Rise of AI Conference 2024 · Berlin

Welcome & State of AI 2024

Fabian Westerheide · CEO and Partner at Rise of AI and AI.Fund

At Rise of AI 2024, Fabian Westerheide, CEO and Partner at Rise of AI and AI.Fund, opens the eighth edition of the conference with a review of the AI market and a call to action for German and European policy. He reports a hard cap of 300 onsite attendees with an overbooked waiting list and 1,600 livestream viewers from over 50 nations. He describes 2024 as the year of generative AI, with billions in new funding flowing mostly into foundation models even as the broader VC market declined, and names Nvidia and Microsoft as the year's biggest winners. He argues the US-Europe gap is widening and that 95 percent of global users rely on OpenAI, while China quietly built over 100 foundation models in six months. He uses the talk to launch his book on the state of AI, written partly with AI assistance, and lays out policy demands: a digital government, tax reform that favors labor less than investment, incentives for AI adoption, sovereign European foundation models, reinvestment by the super-rich, and AI and coding education starting in kindergarten.

Key takeaways

  • Rise of AI 2024 capped onsite attendance at 300 with an overbooked waiting list, plus 1,600 livestream viewers from over 50 nations.
  • Westerheide calls 2024 the year of generative AI, with most new funding flowing into foundation models while the wider VC market fell.
  • He says the US-Europe AI gap is widening, with 95 percent of global users on OpenAI and China producing over 100 foundation models in six months.
  • He launched his book on the state of AI, partly written with ChatGPT, including an AI-generated closing page and glossary.
  • He calls for a digital German government, tax reform favoring labor less than investment, sovereign EU foundation models and AI education from kindergarten.

Detailed notes

Opening: an ecosystem eight years in the making

Westerheide welcomes the audience, noting a hard cap of 300 onsite attendees with an overbooked waiting list, and says the conference now draws more policymakers, regional delegations (from Bavaria and elsewhere) and media than in prior years, though still no German TV. He points to the second German AI Months initiative, which has grown from about 70 events last year to 80-90 this year, and says the livestream reaches 1,600 viewers across more than 50 nations, which he reads as evidence that Germany's AI reputation abroad is stronger than domestic self-criticism suggests.

State of the AI market: the year of gen AI

Westerheide calls the past year the year of generative AI, with billions in new funding flowing mostly into foundation models and large language models even as the overall VC market declined. He stresses that AI is more than chatbots and that roughly 90 percent of founders work with AI outside the generative AI spotlight. He names Nvidia and Microsoft, active in foundation-model M&A, as the year's biggest financial winners, and notes growing government investment, citing Italy and Saudi Arabia (around 40 billion) against a handful of billions in Germany. He also notes more AI regulation globally, contrasting China's strict rules and social-credit-based definition of "trustworthy AI" with the EU AI Act, which he says will take effect the following year.

The widening US-China-Europe gap

Westerheide says the US lead over Europe is accelerating rather than closing, describing the gap as growing from "0 to 4" to "0 to 8" in a soccer metaphor. He notes 95 percent of global AI users rely on OpenAI, with almost all major foundation models originating in the US. He says China, though publicly quieter and somewhat politically defocused, produced over 100 foundation models within six months after building in mandatory censorship, compared to about five or six in Europe. He warns that foundation models trained on politically skewed data risk trapping users in ideological bubbles, and proposes a "Western Union for AI" to pool European values, talent and data. He argues Europe's bottleneck is funding and scaling, not talent, since innovation and startups are global.

Ten years of Rise of AI and the new book

Westerheide recaps the conference's evolution from a Singularity meetup, through a roughly 1,000-person, four-stage "mass education" phase until 2019, a pandemic-era virtual period with as few as 20 attendees, and a deliberate post-2022 choice to cap growth around 200-300 attendees and scale by quality rather than size. He announces the public release of his book on the state of AI, written mostly by humans but including an AI-generated glossary and a final page written by ChatGPT from the prompt "you are the voice for all AI." The book's subtitle sits between dystopia and utopia, and includes a chapter on Europe called "Ready Player Germany."

Policy calls to action

Westerheide lists demands for German and European policy: a digital government and administration that becomes the first large purchaser of AI software; state reform and a fairer tax system, noting he pays about 1.5 percent tax on investment income versus up to 60 percent on employment income; tax incentives for companies integrating AI; sovereign European foundation models trained on local language and culture, running on European clouds; reinvestment by the super-rich of earnings above 100 million a year into healthcare, education and technology; and education reform starting in kindergarten, including at least one foreign and one computer language, to prepare roughly 20 million people to work with AI over the next decade. He also cites a Norwegian case where TikTok's server energy demand reportedly constrained munitions production, arguing for energy-efficient, sustainability-focused "industrial AI" as Europe's niche.

Quotes

AI is more than just gen AI, AI is more than just a chatbot.

Fabian Westerheide

We don't want to grow by size, just by quality, every year.

Fabian Westerheide

The innovation itself is global and the talents are global, especially here in Europe we have a lot of good talents, so we don't have a bottleneck of talents, we just have a bottleneck of funding.

Fabian Westerheide

Questions answered in this talk

How many people attended Rise of AI 2024 and its livestream?

According to Fabian Westerheide at Rise of AI 2024, onsite attendance was capped at 300 with an overbooked waiting list, while the livestream drew 1,600 viewers across more than 50 nations.

Where did AI funding go in 2024 according to Fabian Westerheide?

Fabian Westerheide said at Rise of AI 2024 that most new AI funding went into foundation models and generative AI, that Nvidia and Microsoft were the year's biggest financial winners, and that the AI market grew even as the broader VC market declined.

What policy changes does Fabian Westerheide want for AI in Germany?

At Rise of AI 2024, Fabian Westerheide called for a digital government that becomes an early AI software purchaser, tax reform that no longer favors investment income over labor income, sovereign European foundation models, reinvestment by the super-rich, and AI and coding education starting in kindergarten.

Mentioned

European AI Act, generative AI boom, foundation models, social credit system, digital government, sovereign European AI infrastructure, industrial AI / green AI, Ready Player Germany

Keep exploring

More from Fabian Westerheide

More from Rise of AI Conference 2024

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 3,989 words

Show the full transcript

yes I wanted to start with Berlin greeting you first those who are here um we had a heart cap at 300 people over booked um long waiting list so you made it I told you buy early enough people didn't believe me like I didn't believe you so L I tell you every year H so don't forget it um we have enough of seats you're standing now but we have enough of seats later on the other stage and around and I'm I'm happy I mean we're doing this now for eight years building an ecosystem for AI Germany Europe and worldwide and you are part of it you are the researchers you are the founders you are the investors they they tend to hide by the way uh you have the software Engineers the developers we have more policy makers than ever means politics finally got the topic last year a little bit slow and we have a large number of hubs that's a very German thing yes you have like Cay a and we have a

whole delegation from Bavaria here today we have a delegation from EPI and for years I lobbied for this the first delegation we ever had was from China and now we have Regional delegations which I think is very important because in Germany we're very fragmented and we need we need to meet at least once in a year and we have a lot of media at this time also for8 years almost no media uh we have hles blood here F set Z do site I think aler wanted to come by BBC interestingly only foring TV is here no German TV so no target show yet I think we have too much good news for this H uh technical team can you please give me my slides and my timer good a second I want to agree everyone for Germany as an ecosystem we have again the second year of the German AI months DOA konad and I think last year we had 70 events now stopped counting we are at 80 or 90 events so it's a

good initiative which is picking up uh we have a lot of federal Ministries doing events a lot of hubs Regional very strong again in the South also strong here in Berlin but outside of Berlin there's nothing and uh NV is strong with it I always look at Hamburg because Hamburg is not strong yet the nordics are a little bit slow still um a lot of universities using this to make their own a events uh IAS finally getting it and we need them because it's about local education I'm still waiting for my slides and next one is I want to welcome the world because we have 1,600 people in the streams live H some of them will watch it later some of them you know um will watch the replays over 50 Nations and I just it's pretty ugly because cgp could not export it correctly for me so I had to handra it myself but these are roughly the Nations which are in the streams and we know they're interested to understand what we are

up here in Germany because our reputation in Germany is better than we think yes we like to self criticize ourself we're not fast enough not eager enough you know but outside they respect us I think we do good quality we are process orientated so the global world has a better picture of us and that's why they're tuning in from a lot of Nations this is 1,600 um and then state of the AI where are we standing I mean I don't need to educate you what AI is we we have done this uh we are far ahead no still not there where I wanted to talk about I remember a talk by Hans uite years ago about super intelligence not There Yet the whole AGI discussion is again there but it's not there yet um still it was an amazing year for us we had billions of new funding pouring into the market billions um by the way most of it went into Foundation models lmm and generative AI so we have an ongoing AI boom

especially geni boom I would call the last year was the AI the year of the genis as AI people we are thankful for this for the attention it brought us to the market still I always like to say AI is more than just geni AI is more than just a chatbot and I would say 90% of the founders work with AI which is outside of the scope and sometimes you only get with some investors for the hype your Capital but the good investors they understand your verticals and they will invest you even if you don't have the bus wordss on your slides second um it's a gold rush um total amount of startups is Skyrock it's great the whole VC Market went down the AI Market went up so growing against the trend Global and um also we have more governments now increasing and governments I didn't have on my my map for example Italy announced a couple of billions Saudi Arabia I think wants to invest 40 billions I mean it's strategic smart for

them but 40 billions sign ific number um here in Germany we're currently at a handful of billions overall if we are doing it and now they come in hopefully also investing into Europe and to build it but uh we had Schmid tuba last year who who did good advertising for this they bought him um next what happened in the last year is we have more rules China has the strictest AI rules and we I had a good discussion yesterday already about how China is interpretating trustworthy and reliable and accept that the social credit system is part of this for them it's a transparent AI we don't like social credit system here um so the rules on paper are the same but the interpretation is highly different and this will come to us too we have the European AI Act a handful of you have been involved and lobbying for it and changing it it will come in place I think next year business for some of you hazle for the others and uh I would

say the money makers had a good year and for me the money makers were mainly two big Winners Nvidia largely I mean everyone knew we need gpus everyone had stocks who knew this before hopefully you still hold them um was a great year for NVIDIA and the rest of the world just wanted to flow the money in where is it going lowest level infrastructure means more will come there will be more service providers more AI companies all this de will grow step by step and this is just the first wave pouring in and the second is we have uh Microsoft and I highly respect them because they doing really smart things out there um especially in the m&a space I think they are have bought stakes and almost all Foundation models um again the Americans ruling the world or how do I say are the Americans ruling alone when I started researching 2016 about startups and Global comparison the Americans were ahead of us and I would say the C the acceleration in the US

is still faster and even fast getting faster so the difference is increasing we don't I mean we follow we do something but they do it significant faster in an accelerating curve so the difference will just increase um sure there's a still opportunity for us but it's like you know last year was 0 to four if you want to have a metaphor from from soccer now it feels like 0 to8 yeah or we have one goal um still woring what to do second we all use American software and models right I mean who is using ALB Alpha mainly in everyday use some maybe use Mistral but if you look for the users Global 95% use openi and even the companies are still using openi or Enterprise versions I mean we have Europeans two Europeans I can mention but most models they all in the US and we use them because they write better software they are smarter and we all know it more data more users better systems it's accelerating and then we have Zep hiter

who just announced he will kill open AI um maybe a little bit too early I invited him to he says he's not ready yet he wants to come next year huh um so my viewers us will stay Number One China will stay number two and they are just quiet and if someone is quiet means me they are focused they had a lot of bold ambition silicon Road Etc I think they're a little bit politically defocused at the moment but they're still performing whenever you talk with people in China they had within half a year over 100 Foundation models it took them a little bit because they had to be censored first you know you can't have an uncertain system but still it took them half a year and they what have 100 200 models we still have like five six year in Europe um then we have increasing activities Japan Canada UK as I said Saudi Arabia so we compete with them in the good terms and I personally believe we need to build like

a Western Union for AI where we aggregate our values we exchange talents we work on the data levels um because we all know if you look for example at Trump and Trump has his own lmm because all these lmms all these Foundation they political biased they're mostly on the left liberal Spectrum for American views so in Germany they would be more in the right CDU level h and just imagine you have an lmm which is just trained like Twitter Croc on anti-semitic and racial stuff and you only get your own stuff all the time and it's repeating your own bubble and this will happen so the people in their light right or left bubbles will only get content from their AI generated Bubbles and this is something we have to take a look at this Innovation is accelerating by the way this is from um AI index nesto the author he's here today so he will go into in detail um Innovation is everywhere so not the Americans are bringing out the Innovation The Innovation

itself is global and the talents are Global especially here in Europe we have a lot of good talents so we don't have a bottleneck of talents we just have a bottleneck of I call it funding and accelerating the right companies startups are Global we have a lot of abundance of startups everywhere still all the capital most of it is American and the m&a activities are strong I know it's the wrong audience but I appeal to more German companies buying startups yes because it's refurbishing the system if you spend 200 million for a startup 190 million are going back to the system after Texas maybe um um to refinance it and we saw this with study foots set Etc this money was like 10 times 100 times reinvested over and over again so we are doing rise ofi quite for a while still two years for anniversary and I like to recap on it because it meant we started as a Meetup talking about Singularity still way ahead but this was our first thoughts and then

until 2019 I call it it was mass education almost a thousand people four stages and parallel it was a lot of um tuxedo uh suit people with ties yeah Consultants who wanted to be educated and it changed in 2019 we had all the analysts there today all the Partners came so we still have the Consultants but today we have the boss and not the the ones to be educated today it's a business for them and I like this um 2020 we had to go virtual that's why we have a live stream today which I like a lot and I remember um we had the first lockdown and the second lockdown and we had like capacity of 20 people there so 10 people sitting in the audience and 10 people exchanging all the time and then 20 2020 2 we came back with a new system limited it to the size of first 200 300 people we don't want to grow by size just by quality every year and for over 10 years we do this

now we um connect I spoke with thousands of you as speakers as guests over the year I collected a lot of thoughts of you and this all worked for 10 years in my brain and I try to summarize this in one book so today is the official public release of my book called and it's hybrid work so everything no most of this is written by humans if you get the book some parts are written by CDP for example the glossar and it's written there and I have an EEG there the last page was written by an AI too I gave CHP the pro prompt you are the voice for all Ai and you're shaping the image we have of you for decades do something out of this and then you have to get the book to to look what what the AI is telling us or telling you how it sees itself for us um the title itself is a little bit ambitious and first I wanted to add a question mark there because I'm

not sure if we will become a k AI Nation one day still that's why the subtitle is between dystopia here in Utopia because I can't decide I think we are somewhere in the middle in between and I I personally like to go for extremes um I will introduce AI you can skip the first chapter but it's good to read I will go in depth my view on the American and Chinese systems especially I traveled plenty of time to China and if you if you want to live in 1984 real time go there experience it and they have beautiful programs like Skynet they're really call their program Skynet I don't know I don't sorry I I the marketing agency would have N I would never call a system Skynet nevertheless so if you want to experience Skynet it's coming from China it's already out there um I will go into analysis what we in Europe are doing and what we're not doing that's why the chapter is called Ready Player Germany question mark yeah sure you

know um it's a nerd joke yeah but I like the VR and the metaverse and this will come real too but this is a different stage um so you can get it from now on today on Amazon but we also have some printed X over there I have a pen with me so if you want to have a signature I'm around and I will sign it for you if you get uh a printed version there or it's ebook too yeah um since I've wrote it with you yes it's your thoughts in it I have a nice uh reading list in the back also some Germans who wrote about this and some of our speakers are in the book too uh plenty of our guests are in the book too um please read it if you want to do me a favor recommend it on Amazon because for the AI algorithm so it's trending better yeah we need it um but honestly I've wrote it so you can give it to your boss or to your

clients to tell them you haven't get got it yet read it and then we talk again so it's more like a sales instrument for you to educate people that they take this serious um last year during the dinner one member of the parliament told me give me 16 copies yeah for all the 160 minist we have they have to read this and that's how why I wrote it both of it uh it's um and as I said the Easter egg is on the last page good I have a timer so I have a couple of call to actions and they are not for today they are for tomorrow and afterward words so first we need a digital State we heavily I repeat this every year until we arrive at least in Web 2.0 for for the government but we need a digital government we need a digital Administration and this Administration should be the first purchaser of AI software later not yet because if you don't have the infrastructure below if you don't have the

data and the process you don't need AI we all know it it's just the tip of the iceberg but still we need government second and um I Lobby for this we need I call a large State reform to bring the government in The Next Century and we need uh I call it a better taxation system because what's for stating if you have a job you pay more taxes than when you do Investments and that's not fair years I just did the math and I learned if I just do the Investments I pay 1.5% tax on this but if I hire myself I pay up to 60% overall that is not fair I think we have a huge penalty on people who work in this country and I think this is something which should be changed second I want that we get more incentives for integration of innovation and I spoke with government Dr anak chrismont for example to give like tax breaks tax relief for companies to integrate Ai and they they all know they

need AI but they need a little bit of push why not subsidize it in a certain way we always know in the long run we benefit and this is the only chance we have upgrading our industry upgrading our economy we need our own Foundation models because this is I call culture B yes it's our language it's our culture and these systems I want that our children's books are written by our own systems and not by American or Chinese systems but I still also want that our industry is running on our clouds on our AIS and we need to do this and we still have the opportunity because this is all about sales it's about being there helping the companies and the Americans they don't do sales here yet I mean you have Amazon yes and you have Google calling you but there's still huge opportunity to do all the sales especially in Germany they don't fly they fly into Berlin but they don't go to hbr that easy or to Heidelberg and that's our opportunities

to local help them to upgrade and this is why we do this event yeah that everyone goes back to his home turf and is helping the the local ecosystems um I want that the and I call them Super Rich taking responsibility with super rich I mean if you make more than 100 million a year you can keep 100 million a year but the rest please reinvest huh you don't have to raise your hands if you make a 100 million um but reinvest um Club the Rome just did the mass and if you have like earnings of 10 billion a year in dividends you don't need 10 billions on your bank account you can invest 99% of this pay back to the ecosystem um invest in health care invest in education invest into technology and we need this most of the assets are in the hands of very few people as I said we are taxed because we work we are taxed heavily if you have a lot of money you are tax less because government

is too afraid or too weak to tackle this but we need this and I'm pretty sure most of the wealthy super wealthy people they entrepreneurs themselves they have built companies themselves we just need to give them hand to be active and to give something back to a society and what I want there is we have to accelate education we have to start in the kindergartens to teach our children how to be responsible with technology and how to learn I always say they have to learn at least one foreign language and one computer language they need to understand how machines work and I'm afraid if I learn that about generation I think Z they only know interfaces they don't know Doss anymore they don't know the terminal anymore how can you fix a machine if you just do drag and drop you have to look in the terminal at least once in a while to see how the engine is running you need to be able to at least read the code and I have some

people here who reeducate them and start to learn Ai and coding even if they are way out of kindergarten today um and we need to educate 20 million people half of the society will work with with AI in the next 10 years they need to know how to use these tools how to get along with them they need our help and then as I always said we need to figure out our niche in Germany in Europe it's not the big AI I call it the industrial Ai and green AI sustainable ai ai for sustainability but our AI should be energy efficient because it takes a lot of energy um and we had this one dialogue I think Norway they couldn't produce munition anymore because Tik Tok servers needed more energy and they had to to do a deal so we have to decide do you want to have Tik Tok or do you want to win a war and they decided for Tik Tok yeah that's something wrong in our society but on the other

hand if you look ocracy and others it's about entertaining the masses so overall it's about collaboration as a nation as an ecosystem to make all this real which we have on paper because our time is running out call to actions for today yeah so today this stage is for the policy makers for the United Nations uh for the German government um and AI in defense as a last topic later you have over there the applied AI stage which will open right after me where you have research scaling ethics security and the European AI Act The Good the Bad and the tiny hope um I want that you go out there you eat you network and I know it and I will sometimes force you to go to the stages we have at 12: p.m.

Al at 12 the first session with meet the policy makers a new format we're trying in the lounges and at 1 p.m. the next one so it's about for 10 to 15 people if you want to have a policy maker face Toof face um shadam host rules no media just do it yeah then you can't complain they didn't listen so I would say Enjoy yes thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.