Rise of AI Conference 2024 · Berlin · Applied AI Stage

Shaping the Future: Unleashing the Potential for AI Startups Worldwide

Sabine Wiesmüller · Director, AI Competence Center, Start2 Group

At Rise of AI 2024 in Berlin, Sabine Wiesmüller, Director of the AI Competence Center at Start2 Group, argues that European AI startups need to define global niches and expand into other regions rather than trying to mimic the United States. She outlines Europe's structural weaknesses: relatively low global AI market share, weak research-to-application transfer, startups that stay too small for one region, roughly 75% of European exits going to non-European buyers, and a persistent gap in late-stage investment. She then takes the audience through opportunity hubs around the world, including Boston and Sao Paulo in the Americas, Singapore, Beijing and Bangalore in Asia, and manufacturing and fintech growth in Chile and Brazil, citing statistics on elite AI talent shifting from the US toward India and China between 2019 and roughly 2022. She closes with market trends such as agentic AI, specialized large language model applications, and AI-driven drug discovery, and advises startups and corporates to treat ecosystems, regulatory differences and AI adoption strategically rather than defensively.

Key takeaways

  • Roughly 75% of European startup exits go to buyers outside Europe, which Wiesmüller ties to a persistent gap in late-stage investment.
  • The share of elite AI researchers based in the US fell from about 60% to 42% between 2019 and roughly 2022, with China rising to 28% and Europe at 12%.
  • German SMEs remain hesitant to pool even anonymized data, limiting their ability to train models like predictive maintenance systems that need negative cases.
  • Foxconn invested $700 million in AI chip manufacturing in Jalisco, Mexico, partly to reduce dependence on China.
  • Brazilian manufacturers using AI have cut average downtime by 25%, and Latin America's AI market is projected to grow 28.5% to $10 billion by 2030.

Detailed notes

Europe's structural gaps

Wiesmüller argues that Europe needs to take the driver's seat in AI rather than mimic the US, and identifies where Start2 Group, which helps startups scale globally through legal entities in Europe, the US and Asia, sees Europe falling short. She says Europe's global AI market share is limited partly because research is not transferred into application effectively, and once startups do mature, they often fail to expand beyond one regional market. She cites that roughly 75% of European startup exits go to buyers outside Europe, a trend she says is tied to a persistent gap in late-stage investment, since venture capital remains scarce after COVID and most VCs focus on their existing portfolios rather than new bets.

Regional opportunities in the Americas

Wiesmüller highlights Boston as the leading US biotech hub, noting the FDA currently has shorter approval times for life science solutions than the EU. She contrasts Silicon Valley's heavy investment and close ecosystem collaboration, including data pooling, with what she describes as more siloed thinking in Germany, particularly among SMEs reluctant to share even anonymized data needed to train predictive maintenance models on negative cases. She names Sao Paulo as a major fintech hub she says surprised her, with banks and governments among the clients, climate-affected regions as growing markets for clean-tech AI solutions, and Chile, where a client construction firm shows a Silicon Valley-oriented mindset comparable in maturity to European SMEs.

Asia: Singapore, Beijing and Bangalore

Wiesmüller describes Singapore as one of the region's largest AI investors, with expedited patent processes supporting faster application of research, and cites Nvidia's heavy investment across Asia, including plans for a supercomputer in Japan and India. She names Beijing for its focus on facial recognition and deep learning, noting China has broad application and large datasets but not always high data quality. She highlights Bangalore, sometimes called India's Silicon Valley, for strong ecosystem-wide data sharing and Reliance Jio's partnership with Nvidia.

Talent migration and funding trends

Wiesmüller presents figures showing the share of top 2%-tier AI researchers originating from the US fell from 35% in 2019 to 28% three years later, converging with India and China, while the share of such researchers working in the US fell from about 60% to 42% over the same period, with China at 28% and Europe at 12%. She notes that Chinese firms such as Baidu, Alibaba and ByteDance released large language models the prior year, creating talent pools startups can leverage. On funding, she says US VCs increasingly favor existing portfolio companies, and that in Latin America about 47% of investment goes to Brazil, mostly Sao Paulo, while Foxconn's $700 million investment in Jalisco, Mexico, in AI chip manufacturing illustrates a push for supply-chain independence from China.

Market trends and closing advice

Wiesmüller points to agentic AI and multimodal AI as cutting-edge US trends, and argues large language models still offer opportunity through specialization for specific industries and regulations, contrary to the impression in Germany that the space is already saturated. She cites AI-driven drug discovery with shorter US approval times, Brazilian fintechs such as Nubank applying AI more aggressively than European banks, and Brazilian manufacturers cutting downtime by 25% on average through AI, with Latin America's AI market projected to grow 28.5% to $10 billion by 2030. She closes with three takeaways: seek out ecosystems that offer money, talent, knowledge and clients; recognize that markets differ in maturity, regulation and client needs, for example Brazil's more permissive fintech nudging rules; and treat AI adoption as essential for every company in a data-driven economy.

Questions answered in this talk

Why do so many European AI startups fail to scale globally?

According to Sabine Wiesmüller at Rise of AI 2024, European startups often stay tied to one regional client base instead of expanding market to market, and about 75% of exits go to non-European buyers because of a persistent gap in late-stage investment.

How has the geography of top AI talent changed in recent years?

Wiesmüller cites data showing the share of the world's top 2% AI researchers working in the US fell from about 60% in 2019 to 42% roughly three years later, with China rising to 28% and Europe at 12%, alongside a similar shift in researchers' countries of origin.

Which emerging markets does Wiesmüller highlight for AI startups?

She points to Boston and Sao Paulo in the Americas, Singapore, Beijing and Bangalore in Asia, and Chile and Brazil for manufacturing and fintech, noting strengths such as Singapore's expedited patent processes and Brazil's fast-growing fintech sector.

Mentioned

AI Act, Agentic AI, Multimodal AI, Late-stage investment gap, Data pooling, AI-driven drug discovery, Elite AI researcher migration

Keep exploring

More from Rise of AI Conference 2024

More on Enterprise AI & Adoption

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 4,275 words

Show the full transcript

yeah thank you um it is my pleasure to welcome you here in our session I'm going to take you on a very wild ride um around the globe actually focusing more so on business opportunities than technical um experience for now um we will cover everything from Mexico to Singapore to India and whatever you name it so that's why I have a few notes Here with Statistics in case they don't come to mind immediately so bear with me on that um shaping the future um we have heard about it today again and again Europe really needs to come back on the driver's seat um instead of following the us trying to mimic what's happening there um so I think for us it's really instrumental to Define niches where we can really land on the market and then being very strategic about where we want to go why do we want to go there which applications do we see in which Market which support system is already there so that's what we will focus on today okay

that was one too fast um start two group um very briefly why am I here talking about this today so start two group is a company that helps startups um scale around the globe initially um our Focus were German startups so we were focused on bringing them to Silicon Valley um to Asia Etc so you name it but by now we have three legal entities one in Asia one in the US um and one over here in Europe and I'm leading our AI Department in Europe so inbound and outbound services so startups coming to Europe but also startups that from Europe want to leverage other markets um and with that um you will also be able to see that we focus on um ecosystems around the globe and then are active Partners within those ecosystems so we can talk about investment Etc I'm also very happy to take questions afterwards if we have time if not you can you know catch me over coffee and um ask me whatever or if you have an interest

in a specific or Market let me know and I'm happy to connect you with our colleagues on site in this specific country all right before we begin um because I have a lot of examples with me but I want to make sure it's also tailored to who you are um do we have startups in the room first and foremost one two very good I'm very happy to help you let me know what you're interested in do we have corporates also you will see other corporates are investing heavily so pick up Pace um VC's public sector what VC okay and public sector all right so that gives me a bit of an idea who I'm having here in front of me I know we have a virtual audience as well from Academia and other places so I try and really make sure I cover um a lot of it but as you can see it's quite diverse already so context Europe we already heard that today we have a few characteristics here positive and negative that

we really have to take into account one is the market share in AI um we do have great research um but the market share we do have on a global market is not the biggest um one of the reasons therefore is that we we are not as well in bringing Research into transfer and application and once we do have it in form of product our um startups tend to not become that mature in global comparison meaning we really need them to go from Market to Market to Market right so it's not enough to have one client base and maybe have the D region so maybe you know consider other markets and once you have that potential of scaling that's when you really are in a global comparison a mature company so but once we have the mature companies another problem we see is that 75% roughly of the companies we have in Europe do exit but the buyers of those companies are not inside Europe and that I think is a huge problem um we

are also collaborating closely with um politicians and governments in Europe to really solutions for that but that is tied to the last topic I want to talk about which is we really do have a gap for late stage investment so that's really missing and lacking here which is why we then often see those exits to other regions in the world so risk Capital um also after covid still um is yeah scars on the market and most wec's focus on their existing portfolios so all the more reason um for startups to really leverage what's out there and really be open to other markets um because one way or the other you need the data you need to diversify and so I think that's really worth the focus all right um last before we dive in AI knows no borders um for Good For Worse um we've talked about the arms race in AI um the US that really focuses on um Pace when it comes to development but on the other hand side we do have

the potential to find those niches and also leverage those and have sustainable growth which we are focusing on here in the EU also what's shown you know through the AI Act um that's one of the signals that we want to have a different path in Europe which is fine and it can be a USP but we really do need to make sure it is a USP and it becomes a USP because then if we try and mimic large language models from the US you know it just won't add up but again I mean Yas andrulis was here last year they are actually trying to do exactly that they have a niche they have a different type of client um and a different type of Mission and that's what you can do as well with your companies with your startups and also as if we see what you can mimic in your portfolios so let's dive in we will talk about places and talent funding and investment and market trends um and beginning with the places

um Boston for example if we look at the americaas first continues to be a biotech Hub um in the United States others that you have uh San Francisco and San Diego they're also investing heavily um but you do find a lot of Articles right now um that apparently um Boston has still won the race um which is also um one of the reasons why we for example have offices there already for eight years and a lot of colleagues that are actually covering Life Sciences from Boston from that region um one thing that's also um relevant in this case um when it comes to the FDA and the EU the FDA really right now has um shorter approval times um for life science of solutions to be approved um because they invested heavily in resources and staff so compared to you the waiting times right now are actually shorter in the United States um Silicon Valley of course they invest incredible amounts of money in Ai and the AI ecosystem but apart from that you do

have various characteristics like very close collaboration among the ecosystem players um you really do see the knowledge transfer that oftentimes you lack um in Germany we have a lot of Silo thinking still um so that's something I really want to encourage um I've been also working withes in the lake constant region um companies are still hesitant to to work with data pooling even if um the data is anonymized so I really want to encourage companies to make sure um they look for other Solutions because for example predictive maintenance you need negative cases so you can train the AI to avoid those negative cases um mostes have very little negative cases which is good for them but little to train on for the AI so their data pulling really makes sense and we do see that across the globe that players are more open to to Really share and work with their data in comparison to Germany so sa Paulo in Mexico City sa Paulo for me personally was a surprise um I only learned a

year ago that sa Paulo is a huge fintech Hub um so fintech there is really buzzing um a lot of money is being invested there and also Banks and governments um are becoming clients so that's really a place to look out for um climate and clean energy and we will talk about that as well um all basically rule of thumb um countries and Nations and regions that are more affected by climate change tend to have more demand in the market um but not always do they have the resources to really develop the solutions themselves so if you are in the climate clean tech sector or seeking to invest or expand your portfolio or land clients those are really places to to look out for and there's often times even some financial support and lastly Santiago de Chile or Chile in general we have a client there a huge construction firm um compare but we can actually compare it to smmes and the industry over here in Europe um when it comes to their maturity levels

um but the big comparison the mindset um they are really looking towards the Silicon Valley so all those countries and the business owners there are more open more knowledgeable um and they are really trying to leverage AI best they can so again watch out um and learn and focus on them as well all right as I said while trip around the globe now Asia Singapore Beijing and Bangalore those are really names and places you should watch out for for different reasons as I said I'm happy to go into detail or connect you with my partners on site um with Singapore it's one of the hugest players in the region um in terms of investment um gen AI as well um but not only financially and not only from government side but what you also see is on the administrative side of things they are having expedited processes for patents so they're really supporting in the the research but also bringing speed into the application um of those Solutions Beijing again um maybe that's not a

surprise facial recognition um deep learning so there are various industry focus and Fields of application there so if you're planning to invest in um facial recognition might be a place to visit um but apart from that and on a serious note um of course China is one of the big players um there are differences of course um so the US is still stronger when it comes to research and foundational models but China has very broad application and of course a huge data um um access to huge data sets um but something that really is important to keep in mind that doesn't mean that the quality of the data is always good so what we hear from startups that are entering the Chinese market with us um of course data is a great thing but if you can't really use it because the data quality is not sufficient that again will also not be an advantage and then Bangalore um sometimes also referred to as the Silicon Valley in India um huge amounts of money flowing

into the city um a very strong ecosystem and just like I said Bangalore does have um a lot of collaboration on data so there the players are really sharing their data sets and you do see the transfer effects um from having those um collaborations um and for example Reliance shio is a telecommunications company and they just formed a close partnership with Nvidia I saw a lot of um individ in media um people here and they um yeah if you have questions you can ask them directly but Nvidia is investing heavily in Asia so um that's something to keep in mind as well we are slowly waking up to the idea dear that AI is a great thing here in Germany but then again in Asia it's a different game right so keep that in mind um there's a second market and a lot of tendencies that other nations are already investing where we are not even trying to look right now Talent also an interesting topic um so I think I can I can read

the numbers from here so I don't need all the notes I specifically brought for you um so leading countries of origin um when it comes to most elite um AI researchers what does that mean the top two% of their classes so really the best ones in class um and you see it's only a threeyear period and that's something you should really think about so three years in between um the US was leading 35% of the leading AI researchers came from the US in 2019 all of a sudden 3 years later it was 28% and it became um a very equal Market um because then you have have the US India and China almost being at the same level um so what that can show you is that there's a dynamic in the market but also something you can leverage um because having this very broad Talent um Range actually um also allows you to leverage that so we do have um startups that specifically grow their presence in China just so they can leverage um

the experts there and the researchers there and also there keep in mind um large language model um last year there was a big wave of um allowing llms into the market in China so BYO Alibaba um bite dance as well so you do have all those experts in this markets as well and you can leverage on that um maybe a side note um don't become too cozy I mean niic is an example where it might became a bit too cozy but still you can leverage on the existing talet in the markets all right and where they work um as I said three years in between um 2019 almost 60% of the top talent worked um in the US and you see the brain drain um in only three years it changed drastically um so it's only 42% in the US and 28% in China 12% in Europe so you do see we still have a substantial amount in the market also if you compare the sizes of the regions and but still there's a dynamic

in the market then you cannot deny so even for the US where maybe over here we think the US is the one big player even for them I think um it's time to really wake up and make sure that they Define their USP before it's too late all right funding and investment um just like VC over here in Europe and the US it's the same um you do see that VCS are under pressure to really um show revenues um so they do tend to invest more in their portfolio company so it's also not as easy anymore to raise money in the US if you're not a port part of a portfolio already I wouldn't say it's as drastic but I talked to the colleagues over there and they really confirmed this trend um talking to the VCS um so maybe that's something to keep in mind like it's not all golden anymore um on this side either in Brazil or Latin America maybe that's also something um of interest um if you want to race

in Latin America maybe go to sa Paulo directly so you can maybe do the the shortcut um because most of the money 47% actually is invested um in Brazil and then they probably most of it again in sou Paulo and Mexico investment trends that might be interesting in well um we do see a steep increase um in AI related Hardware um so for example foxcon from the United States invested 700 million in halisco which is one of the biggest states in Mexico um in computational hard so meaning also AI chips and chips manufacturing um of course with the agenda to become more independent from China um but they do also leverage on the NAFTA free trade agement um so that is just one example of thinking around you know um or basically doing um no I just lost track what I mean is just think outside the box that's what I wanted to say that was what I was looking for um because you can really work with partners and you won't be able to

do everything on your own but you you need to look for alliances and people that have the same goals all right again Asia um in Singapore um of course the the government is investing heavily I've talked about that already um so smart Nation AI Singapore even the mayor has kpis um so they're really looking to become a leader um and also I mean if I jump to the third Point um The Association of Southeast Asian Nations um has a VC funding of course as well and Singapore provides 60% out of this um amount of money um and again as I said Nvidia um is investing heavily so for example um in Japan they're seeking now to develop a supercomputer same in India um so there you will see the pace picking up as well um due to the fact that there's infrastructure computational power the ecosystem the talent so in Asia you really vote see how things will develop over time and really pick up pace over the next years meaning for us in Europe

no reason to be afraid but you need to leverage it you need to see it as a market you need to see there's Talent there there's money there so how can you really leverage those markets doesn't mean you can incorporate and start your company in Europe but you should do that very strategically and then very quickly set your eye on what you can do and what opportunities you can really um leverage in Asia all right very briefly market trends um so in the US you still see mot model AI but also a gentic AI so AI where there's no human in the loop anymore um those are trends of course that is more on The Cutting Edge side um but still those are topics to look out for um multimodal AI meaning you can have different types of input sources so input output um but this is really something to keep in mind so you could for example have picture analysis um that gives you an output that's written for example a combination um of

various sources um second Point large language models um there again I've talked to my colleagues because over here oftentimes I have the impression that people think like yeah large language models we cannot really do much anymore in this topic because it's already you know the market is set you have those big players in the market like there's no not OPP Unity um there anymore but what we do see in the US is there's actually a huge rise in um new companies that leverage on those llms meaning they specialize the existing llms for specific Industries regarding to certain um regulation types so there is still a market even if you jump on what others already did and here in Germany is more like ah already gone but again you have to develop a leverage mindset maybe let's call it like that growth mindset but we need to Leverage all right and last Point Healthcare um so Aid driven um drug Discovery um so Target identification and validation I've talked about that already so um even approval

times um are shorter over in the US now as compared to the EU so there also opportunities to maybe um go into the US market earlier than you might have had in mind beforehand um so just keep in mind all those differences and different stages the markets are in and the regulatory bodies are in um and just you know carve your own path all right then also Trends in South America again we have Finance I've talked about that already with um sa Paulo um so there you really do see Banks as well leveraging all those new developments over here you know I don't think spaka simin um is applying that much AI yet um on the other hand side in Brazil that's exactly what you see so you have the developers and the products from the market and then also the clients in the market um and names you can have a look at is new bank and finance um so those are really interesting cases to watch out for manufacturing um I've talked about

that already industry-wise it's compared uh it can be compared to Europe or Germany actually but again they are really leveraging on the solutions so they are really using it in the production lines and they really brought down um in an average um the the downtime by 25% so they really do see the success in applying AI already and now last but not least um growth projections um the market will grow 28.5% um is an estimation um meaning 10 billion um by 2030 so if you have something to offer to Latin America might be a good time to go there now and look for clients all right we almost coming to an end last Trend slide um Singapore um apart from the fact that it's investing in Ai and Chen Ai and has expedited patent um processes um it's also emerging as a semiconductor market so manufacturing of of chips as well um so it's really a leading place for money for geni for Hardware infrastructure so really keep a close eye on what's happening in

Singapore and if you're seeking to enter into Asia that should probably be the first place to go to and then you know have a look into the specific markets and see which one is really interesting for you and your product but in terms of relationships ecos ecosystem it would definitely be Singapore second China and India um leading in a adoption I've talked about that Finance manufacturing um if you're active in those Industries and also Logistics um also an interesting place for you to be and emerging hubs um new places in Asia to keep an eye on is Manila qualum and Jakarta in Indonesia um and I will also show you why in a second just in case you didn't have that on the radar those are numbers invested into those cities and places so maybe let that sink in for a second and think about what your companies are investing or you know what our government is investing so there's really something happening over there in Asia and you will see the consequences of that

and if we cannot change the situation apart from what we are ourselves are doing at least try and leverage on what you see out there all right so here we come two and a half minutes left so maybe we can squeeze in one or two questions let's see um key takeaways ecosystems why are we talking so much about the ecosystems because there you have a support system ecosystem means there's money there's other startups there's knowledge in this area there's clients so really look out for where are ecosystems for whatever you're seeking to do think Global um markets have different maturity levels um different client needs different support structures different incentives as well um different regulations for example nuding in Brazil when it comes to fintech is allowed um on a different level that it's allowed over here in Europe so maybe think about going there quickly and leveraging on that as well um unless our regulation changes a little bit um and AI adoption um in my opinion AI needs to be implemented and adopted

in every company and we need to leverage on that um specifically now that we are in a data heavy and datadriven economy um so whoever is anme or or a corporate you need to work with AI and you need to be knowledgeable and own it and really know what it can do um and yeah for everyone else who has a product or who has an interest um make sure it's really tailored to to those companies because the need will arise because if you don't adopt AI I think the journey will be over very quickly um and so what we tend to say because we help the startup Journey um startup Journeys are different um but be strategic be intentional and we will then help you with your journey thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.