Rise of AI Conference 2016 · Berlin

Human Coexistence with Machines

At Rise of AI 2016 in Berlin, host Fabian Westerheide opens the event's second edition with a status update on artificial intelligence and its effect on humans. He notes the event grew from 20 attendees to about 150 in two editions, and announces he has just become the coordinator for AI at the German Startup Association, inviting AI companies to reach out for policy-level representation. He argues machine learning and AI have existed since the 1950s-70s but improved sharply through more processing power, deeper neural networks, better natural language and image recognition, and the rise of big data and the internet. He lists tasks where narrow AI already matches or beats humans, from games, drones and cars to writing emails, trading stocks, detecting fraud, and instant medical diagnosis. Drawing on roughly 250 audience answers to what makes humans unique, he argues traits like creativity or planning are already replicated by machines, while consciousness, emotions and ethics remain unsolved. He closes with a "wealth index" showing rising lifespan and wealth and falling working hours since industrialization, concluding AI should not be feared.

Key takeaways

  • Westerheide had just become AI coordinator for the German Startup Association and invited AI companies to reach out.
  • Neural networks grew from roughly one layer in the 1960s-70s to about a thousand layers by 2016.
  • He lists instant medical diagnosis and supply-chain optimization as emerging strengths of narrow AI in 2016.
  • An audience survey of 250 answers found consciousness, emotions and ethics as the traits AI had not replicated.
  • Global wealth rose about 600 percent and lifespan about 150 percent since the Industrial Revolution, per his wealth index.

Detailed notes

Opening and a new AI policy role

Westerheide welcomes the audience to the second Rise of AI, noting growth from 20 attendees at the first edition to about 150 at this one, with an expectation of 300 next time. He introduces himself as running a venture capital firm focused on AI in Berlin and organizing Rise of AI twice a year together with his wife Veronica from Pandora Events. He announces that he has just become the coordinator for artificial intelligence at the German Startup Association, inviting AI companies and anyone interested in discussing AI at a policy and economic level to contact him, describing the role as working toward the path to singularity.

The state of AI in 2016

Westerheide frames the "gaffa economy" of Google, Amazon, Apple and Facebook as driving progress, and notes machine learning has existed since the 1950s-70s through repeated AI winters, but neural networks that once had one layer now have a thousand, enabled by more processing power. He points to progress in natural language processing and visual and audio recognition, citing Google's cat-picture recognition as an example, and to the rise of big data as corporations collected data and needed machine learning to use it. He credits the internet as a precondition for the current wave, noting rising AI startup funding and corporations acquiring AI teams.

What narrow AI already does better than humans

Westerheide describes today's AI as narrow but already superior to humans at specific trained tasks. Examples include beating humans at Go, chess and card games, flying drones and driving cars, organizing meetings and booking travel, writing songs and drawing pictures, trading most stock market volume, detecting financial fraud, writing personalized sales emails and handling customer support, and diagnosing illness faster than many doctors. He also describes AI optimizing complex production and supply-chain processes that previously required decades of human experience, and notes machines work continuously without striking or needing breaks.

What makes humans unique

Westerheide shares results from asking the audience what makes humans unique, having collected over 250 answers. He groups traits like creativity, taste, critical thinking, visionary thinking and long-term planning as already replicated by machines in non-human ways, citing Netflix's content recommendation and production decisions as an example. What remains unsolved, he says, are conscience, compassion, emotions, greed, love, hate, ethics, morality, humor, curiosity and insecurity, none of which he had seen any startup attempt to solve. He concludes that feeling, not work, is what defines human uniqueness.

The human wealth index

Westerheide presents a "human wealth index" showing little change for 2.5 million years of hunter-gatherer life until the Industrial Revolution, when machine use accelerated human wellbeing. He cites a 150 percent increase in lifespan over the past 150 years, a 600 percent increase in global wealth, and a drop in average working hours from 75 hours per week in 19th-century France to roughly 35-40 today. He concludes that embracing technology produced these gains and that AI should be approached the same way, to live longer, be more intelligent, and have more free time.

Quotes

We don't have to fear AI, we take AI to live longer, to be more intelligent, to be more happy, to have more free time.

Fabian Westerheide

AI is better than we humans are in a very specific task, once they are trained.

Fabian Westerheide

Feeling, I think, is being unique. Having emotions is unique.

Fabian Westerheide

Questions answered in this talk

What tasks could AI already do better than humans in 2016?

According to Fabian Westerheide at Rise of AI 2016, AI already beat humans at games like Go and chess, flew drones, drove cars, traded most stock market volume, detected fraud, wrote emails, and diagnosed illness faster than many doctors.

What did Rise of AI attendees say makes humans unique compared to machines?

Fabian Westerheide reports that out of over 250 audience answers, traits like creativity and planning were considered already replicated by machines, while consciousness, emotions, ethics and morality remained unsolved.

How has technology changed human wealth and working hours historically?

Fabian Westerheide cites a roughly 150 percent increase in human lifespan and 600 percent increase in global wealth since the Industrial Revolution, alongside a drop in average working hours from about 75 per week in 19th-century France to roughly 35-40 today.

Mentioned

narrow artificial intelligence, artificial general intelligence, singularity, machine learning, natural language processing, wealth index, AI winter

Keep exploring

More from Fabian Westerheide

More from Rise of AI Conference 2016

More on AGI & Future of Intelligence

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 2,732 words

Show the full transcript

good we can start we have a wonderful Full House this is great so I say welcome to rise of AI it's uh the second edition of it I remember we started the first version of it in the cbase with 20 people last time we were 100 now I would say 150 yes this is good next time we already know it it will be a 300 yes exponential growth for this topic too so first of all I would like to introduce myself I'm your host for tonight my name is Fabian uh I I invited all of you most of you and um I run adventure Capital firm based uh here in Berlin for the topic of artificial intelligence I organize together with my wife Veronica um from Pandora events raise of a ey twice in a year um I also like to blog about topic and like to speak about it briefly introduction I will talk I have seven slides for you to prepare you for the topic then we will have two Talks by uh

Trent and Anish and afterwards the speakers will still be around you can start to continue to discuss what you learned uh what you heard Be Inspired just mingle a little bit networking will be open man if you want to tweet please use raise of AI and I hope you all have left your mark on the fingerprint tree yes I think you have all at least considered what opportunities for upgrading will be there for you which you would like to have and maybe some of the talks will give you the opportunities to think about um when they will come um also I would like to announce that for the last two weeks or three weeks now I am the head you call it coordinator for the topic of artificial intelligence for the German startup Association so whoever has here an AI company and would like to be represented we call it lobbying yes or anyone who he would like to discuss the whole Topic in I on the level of economy Society in a more formal

way please send me an email with your wishes with your ideas I just created this position for myself yes to to to Foster the whole ecosystem to Foster the system for AI and I want to bring people together but this it will be more let's say on a policy level working on special topics which could be in our way to the PA of Singularity and with this I would like to start I would like to give you a small status update what AI is today yes where are we standing um the first is and we have to think the gaffa economy so Google Amazon apple and Facebook for this is we have a lot of progress machine learning actually machine learning is around and the whole topic of AI is around since we have computers 50 6070s we have these so-called AI Winters in between so there was always up and downs and they say oh AI is coming now we have it now and it's not there if you read science fiction from the

50s and 60s it's not there yes we don't have a full aware AI yet too but we are on a good path there so machine learning the tools to train machines to learn to teach itself they have been around for a while but they got improved and in combination with processing power today we able to achieve it one example I spoke with a friend about in the 50s they had noon Nets or tried to play with it or in the 60s and 70s but they had one layer today they have a thousand layers so you have way more possibilities with computers to achieve results which you couldn't do it before the second is um we have progress with NLP so natural language processing and visual and audio recognition so machines are today better to understand what we humans want from them to understand how we write uh if we speak if we have pictures yes best examples with Google and the cat pictures so machines are today able to understand us way better which helps

us a lot with a human machine Comm communication the next is very important is data mining Big Data Co especially corporations and a lot of internet companies started to collect data in the last decade and now need machine learning to make sense out of this data so a lot of companies out there are datadriven and need AI or AI tools to figure out what can we do with this data and to implement this so without these data there was no need for machine learning and no need for AI so far and then have the internet the internet hasn't been around 30 years ago and without the internet no one would be here today because I invited every one of you viral yes um also we wouldn't have the means of AI today so where did this lead to well we had more startups starting AI companies meant more money went in more money went more people thought AI is cool and started next AI company and we saw a lot of progress in a in

M1A so whoever hasn't started an a company yet you should it's very good timing now and from the larger corporations who didn't buy an uh an AI team yet they should because the big ones over there they buy a lot of in the AI space and very a lot of good teams are gone so what does it mean well I would sum it up that AI is very good at specific tasks today yes this is status quo today AI is awesome at playing games better than we are we all saw it how they beat go and if you saw the game live or later on YouTube it's pretty amazing to see the commentary chess was done our card games was done AI is able to fly drones way better than we are uh drive cars yes I mean we have elements of this in Tesla and uh Google and diamler and so forth trucks boats planes but also organize meetings yes um book your plane tickets um shop online so whenever you had a person

assistant in the past today you could use software tools for this we call them AI you could use chatbots and so far um this is the one level the other one AI is able to write songs draw pictures um trade stocks most of the stocks traded out there most of the volume on stock trading is done by machines not by humans anymore yes we have robot advisor and so for who are starting using AI to manage your wealth or the both of let's say people who have more money than we have detect fraud yes especially in the financial industry AI has been there for a very long time write emails so whenever you get an email today most likely it was written by AI there are companies who just press a button and they say well please write an email to this person and the software is taking all the data from the net there is creating super personalized email about the weather and where you're living and the friends you have and is writing

you a sales email which is over and over improved over the time which is way better than a human could write it and the same is if someone is answering an email especially customer support by now or the next two years it will be done by software by AI there is no human need anymore because at the end it's a human machine machine communication whenever there's a machine in the pathway very likely AI is behind this we also see a lot of progress in instant medical diagnosis so AI is pretty good figing out if you're sick and what you have and way faster than a lot of doctors I'm very interested we have a doctor later speaking here what he thinks about this but also what I saw as an investor in the last time is AI starting to optimize complex processes if you speak about production Cycle Supply Chain manufacturing processes AI is today able to understand what either you have for 20 30 years of work experience and they can solve this in

a couple of hours or a AI is able to solve problems in production Cycles which you couldn't solve before because too much data too complex yes too many factors coming in so what I say is today we have a narrow artificial intelligence already it is there yes we speak about Ai and we have narrow AI that means AI is better than we humans are in a very specific task once they are trained important is to say trained it used to be very expensive and time enduring to train a machine to train a machine to be better than you but today with the internet with all the data and with all the progress and machine learning tools it got very cheap and very easy and very fast to train your machines so today it doesn't Tak years anymore to develop a software which is better than a human in a certain task it can be only a couple of weeks month or days additional these machines doing the jobs 24/7 yes uh never get sick don't

want to go on a strike and yes well don't have lobbying yet um this is my favorite chart wait but why if most of you maybe know the blog if you don't know the blog you really have to check it out um the question for you is do you want to compete do you want to compete on one of these tasks with a machine I say we are here they say we're here there will be an AGI artificial general intelligence somewhere there super intelligence after War I say for some fields for some areas the machine is already better than we humans are and we want this yes we create them um so I asked every one of you and I then I figured out it was you had to answer it yes it wasn't a free one what makes us humans unique maybe you remember uh your own answer you gave us uh I got over 250 answers and I try to sum it up a little bit what makes us humans special what makes

us unique in contrast to machines because machines are better in jobs they are better in a lot of stuff we do because we want them to do so what makes us human the my first answer I saw what this 42 yes okay answers a lot yes and these who who smil no um nothing that was a very common answer why why not I like like this one I he said I'm not sure if we truly are so if you're on the Matrix and if you have the books of dick and you don't know if you are aware not aware and if this is a real word I can't solve this today either yes but then you have maybe a little more philosophical problems than just thinking if we're unique or not um the next cluster was this creativity taste critical thinking Visionary thinking flexibility transer knowledge image uh on long-term planning that is a lot of human stuff there but I put them in the corner here why because machines already solved this but not

in a humanlike way we saw that machines Can Dream they just don't dream like we dream we have machines who are very creative who write songs who draw pictures we have machines who have a taste who can't tell you which is the new trend they can write just check out Netflix yes most of the stuff you're watching Netflix and I has figured out that you have to watch it before you know it and they even started producing it they tell you well this actor with this topic with this theme will be very popular with this target group so they already figure out this out so a lot of this stuff is done by AI too so what's left well what's left is this conscience compassion emotions greed love hate ethics and moral humor Soul and Spirit by the way Soul and Spirit I didn't solve it it was only there once so nothing about belief and religion was there so very special group here curiosity insecurity luck and our DNA and I spoke with a

couple of friends about this and we all couldn't solve this yet for software I didn't see any startups yet to solve this so if you're working on this yes do it the other question is for yourself what does this mean about us there is no job description here I didn't find anything no one said well we work we live we're very good in this and this this job so work is not part of being unique but feel feeling I think is being unique yes having emotions is unique and also interesting is this this is all wired in your DNA this is all part of your biochemistry this is nothing we program or we invent it or we teach this is something you're born with and you're living with and you develop them less so you know especially the emotional reading is very tricky yeah if you have a woman you you have to learn it um this is still something we haven't solved and we don't have a formula for this well and the last

answers I liked is asking this question this taught me that I'm Still Human I'm not a machine I ask you this question means I'm not I'm I'm unique still that's wonderful so my second favorite chart yes is everything blue you see is kind of a human wealth index yes the the the higher it goes the better we humans are there so not hard yes two and half million years we were gatherers and hunt you know went out hunting there and then it it it it got a little bit better and then we have here the point when it started to accelerate it yes when everything took off and the interesting thing is this is Industrial Revolution we started using machines on a large scale and we used them to work less yes we wanted to have more productivity more output um we used them to accelerate us as a humankind but this leaded to us being better off a lot of better off the last 150 years we increased our lifespan by 150% so every

one of you above 30 be happy because 200 years ago you would be dead with a high likelihood also our wealth increased by 600% global especially here in Germany I think it's over a th% and so forth we don't feel it anymore Our Generation doesn't our grandparents felt a lot they they doubled their their wealth every 10 years yes it got a little bit slower but still we we have more money we have more access to technology knowledge we can buy more things because everything got cheaper yes so we all have honestly very very good life and then we work less yes it used to be 75 hours in average in France in the 19th century today in France it's 35 in Germany it's about 35 to 40 so we work less so we have more money we're more healthier and we are spending less time to work so I say this all comes because we use Technologies because we embraced them who accepted it so my message for today is we don't have to

fear I we take AI to live longer to be more intelligent to be more happy to have more free time and these were my last words um as an introduction now

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.