Rise of AI Virtual Chat 2020 · Berlin

NEUSTAAT: Digitizing Government

Thomas Heilmann · Member of the German Bundestag (CDU)

At a Rise of AI Virtual Chat in 2020, Thomas Heilmann, member of the German Bundestag, discusses his book NEUSTAAT with host Fabian Westerheide. Heilmann describes NEUSTAAT as more than 100 concrete reform proposals for digitizing and modernizing German government, developed over a year and a half of research by a working group that traveled to China and South Korea to study what makes societies more innovative. He argues the German government proved surprisingly fast and effective during the Corona crisis when focused on a single topic, and that the pandemic forced schools, courts and parliament to adopt digital tools that existing law already allowed but no one had executed. He proposes a state-backed retirement fund invested globally by an independent agency, university investment funds modeled on MIT, and European Investment Bank backing for startup IPOs to address Europe's lack of late-stage funding and exits. He also outlines a "future lobby" to represent not-yet-existing industries in lawmaking, data auditors who would certify how companies use personal data, and a risk-based approach to AI regulation, arguing that clear rules, not the absence of regulation, help businesses invest with confidence.

Key takeaways

  • Heilmann's working group researched innovative states in China and South Korea before writing NEUSTAAT.
  • Three NEUSTAAT proposals were already folded into Germany's Corona economic stimulus package.
  • He proposes the European Investment Bank anchor-invest in European startup IPOs to fix weak exit options.
  • He wants licensed "data auditors" to certify how companies use personal data instead of minimizing data collection.
  • He argues AI regulation should be risk-based and clear, since uncertainty deters startup investment more than strict rules.

Detailed notes

NEUSTAAT: a reform agenda from a year of research

Heilmann explains that the NEUSTAAT project began a year and a half before the talk, when a working group set out to find how to bring more innovation into Germany and Europe. After nearly a year of research, including trips to China and South Korea, the group concluded that a well-functioning state is a key condition for innovation and set modernization as a central task for the Bundestag session starting in 2021, with a discussion period through the end of 2020 and execution from late 2021. The book covers education, startup funding, the retirement system and administrative efficiency, and proposes over 100 ideas, including an annual 32-billion-euro public retirement fund, a "future agency," a blockchain-based euro, school curricula covering economy, IT and social behavior, and a unified app store for public services. Heilmann compares the ambition to the Prussian reforms after Napoleon's conquests, arguing similarly radical change is needed now.

Corona as a forced digitization test

Heilmann says the pandemic moved most political meetings online and forced an enormous volume of laws to be processed under time pressure, run partly from his home office. He notes the German government reacted faster than expected, and argues the system works well in a crisis focused on one topic but is slow when many issues compete for attention. As an example, 2.9 million students moved to online study almost overnight, something that six months earlier would have been called a ten-year project; many teachers had no computer before the crisis. Three NEUSTAAT proposals, he says, are already part of the government's Corona stimulus package: modernizing public registers, a notification tool, and an online public-services gazette.

Funding startups and a new retirement fund

Heilmann attributes Europe's startup funding gap partly to the near-absence of pension-fund capital, unlike the US where pension funds are the largest source of venture money, and to weak exit options beyond acquisition by Google, Facebook, Amazon or Microsoft. He proposes that the European Investment Bank anchor-invest in European tech IPOs as a long-term minority shareholder for roughly five years, and that universities run co-investment funds alongside private investors, modeled on MIT, to improve the transfer of research into companies. On pensions, he proposes an independent, Bundesbank-observed agency investing part of income globally with only minority, non-board stakes, citing a failed early-20th-century German pension fund that lost its assets after investing in World War One bonds as a cautionary precedent.

A "future lobby" and skepticism on Gaia-X

Heilmann argues that existing companies are skilled at lobbying and getting heard in parliamentary hearings, while businesses and technologies that do not yet exist have no one to represent them. He cites e-fuels as an example: because no company producing them existed when an environmental law was written, e-fuels' CO2-neutral properties are not counted in current balance sheets. He proposes a foundation-style "future lobby" to advocate for not-yet-existing industries during lawmaking. On Gaia-X, he supports the goal of a European cloud standard with stronger data protection and lower cost than AWS, but says it is currently "a little over-engineered," with too many participants who lack technical understanding, risking delay.

Data sovereignty through data auditors

Heilmann says Germany is at the beginning of digitalization, not the end, and expects data volumes to keep exploding as computing power grows. He argues against Germany's traditional principle of minimizing data collection ("Datensparsamkeit"), proposing instead data sovereignty: companies that profile personal data would need certification from a licensed "data auditor," modeled on financial auditors, who has full access to a company's data use and can revoke the license for misuse. He argues this system would have to apply to Facebook, Google, Amazon and Alibaba if they want to operate in Europe, and separately describes an earlier conversation about a public data marketplace where audited companies could exchange data rather than one company owning it alone.

Risk-based AI regulation and early standards

Heilmann argues AI needs regulation proportional to potential harm, for example stricter rules for AI controlling car brakes than for lower-risk logistics systems, with the same data-auditor structure assessing risk. Asked how startups can absorb the compliance burden, he says "the answer can't be no regulation, the answer must be clear regulation," because clarity, even if strict, lets founders plan and raise investment, unlike uncertainty. He draws a parallel to Germany's early 220-volt electrical standard and argues Europe should set AI standards early, citing the GSM mobile standard as a precedent, warning that without an early standard a single company could build a monopoly. In closing, he expects the reforms to shift power and wealth, compares public resistance to the backlash Ludwig Erhard faced over 1948 price liberalization, and says his personal goal for 2021 is to see the modernization agenda adopted by the governing coalition, regardless of his own role in it.

Quotes

The answer can't be no regulation, the answer must be clear regulation.

Thomas Heilmann

We have to realize that we are at the beginning of the digitalization, not at the end.

Thomas Heilmann

One of the key conditions is that you have a well-functioning state.

Thomas Heilmann

Questions answered in this talk

What is NEUSTAAT and what does it propose?

According to Thomas Heilmann at a Rise of AI Virtual Chat in 2020, NEUSTAAT is his book proposing over 100 reforms to modernize the German state, covering education, startup funding, a public retirement fund, administrative digitization and infrastructure.

Why did German schools and government move online so quickly during Corona?

Thomas Heilmann explains that the legal basis for remote schooling and digital government processes already existed but had never been executed; the crisis forced 2.9 million students and much of parliament online almost overnight, something previously estimated to take a decade.

How does Thomas Heilmann propose regulating AI in Europe?

Heilmann proposes a risk-based approach where the potential damage of an AI application determines the level of regulation, assessed by licensed data auditors, arguing that clear rules help businesses invest even if the rules are strict.

Mentioned

NEUSTAAT, data sovereignty, data auditor, future lobby, blockchain-based euro, risk-based AI regulation, public retirement fund

Keep exploring

More from Rise of AI Virtual Chat 2020

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 8,567 words

Show the full transcript

welcome to the next rise virtual chat my name is Farley investor Ida entrepreneur and investor with a passion for artificial intelligence this episode today is with Tomas Hyman he's intrapreneur his business angel and his full-time policy maker so he's politician he is member of the German parliament and he has published a new book called noise start which is suggesting over 100 radical reforms how Germany and Europe could arrive in the 21st century and I'd like to read this book is about education about venture capital funding about blockchain use about AI so something we really want to execute so enjoy the following one our Q&A enjoy the interview I'm having within it will be likely discussion it is something which is much needed so follow on welcome good morning good afternoon welcome to the next rise of AI virtual chat episode today with our special guest - musk I'm an entrepreneur member of the German parliament and we will speak about his new book um first as usual please introduce yourself share your LinkedIn profile where

your base what you do use this a little bit to connect and meet people as usual the amount of people is increasing and then it's high and then towards the end everyone is going and is continuing to do something else um and therefore directly to come into the topic I would like to introduce Thomas and he is an entrepreneur of origin I would describe him as entrepreneur and politician so he founded in the 90s a marketing agency called Delta design and he then bought another company in diffusion at the end the brand still exists is called chosen friends which is one of the most successful largest event agencies which we have in Jeremy which is today owned by another corporation so in the 90s he was doing marketing also digital marketing and he started to become a business angel he invested in to sing he messengered a Facebook and many other things we only talk about the successful deals never about losing money and he invested in real estate he has a lot of property

over in Berlin where he is now living he's originally from Dortmund and I think this is important in 2000 he became internet kind of a delegate for the CDU the German Christian Democratic Union which is the largest German party which was half Angela Merkel is you know is from the city and he already in 2000 he was dead appointed to be charged for the Internet which was early from today then a couple of years later he became senator here in the city of Berlin for I think I fought the law and you say in German for Braja shots so and as protection as usual elections back and forth and the Vova right he left the Senate and then through let's say successful campaign he was able to become a member in the German parliament and there I got to know him and since he's a member of the German parliament one reason is he initiated like blockchain groups so within the German parliament he wanted to make blockchain legal blockchain technologies legal so we all

can use them and I learned he is a prime active guy um he started to include all the stakeholders so I met very interesting disease and users and programmers and people from the Baffin and the buddhist museum the bishops it was able to evolve policies administrations but also operational people all together to work something out which really works so the first time i felt a politician is not thinking intellectual how can you know how to fix a problem he asked the people who are using it what is your problem how can we make it legal how can we solve this he is quick he's fast so he's not a typical politician he's been tripping ER and I like about him he has no ideology yes he I never felt that he's thinking in a box and so my overall message is we need more policymakers like him I have over the next weeks more policymakers here also from the European Parliament all of them have in common they're entrepreneurial they come from the industries and

they really want to change something so and since this is the focused topic today is his new book called noise start for everyone not not speaking English German this is like new government it's a work playing and in this book he analyzes the obvious problems we speak about problems education lack of funding for startups the retirement problem huge mess the whole topic about self-reflection how administration works how it's not efficient enough how it's not digital enough and then we need more infrastructure so good analysis and then he brings out a lot I DS it's I think over hundred ideas a couple of ideas which are still on my mind is 32 billion every year into a prize public retirement fund so we have a new form of investments I think this is very good and we need this he speaks about a future agency he wants to have a blockchain based euro which i think is really cool um he wants that school education already starts with economy IT technology but also behavior manners that

people start learning again how to behave socially and he has a quoted app store for public services I think this is nice to him overall the whole thing is analogy to the crucial reforms of the 18th and 19th centuries so after Napoleon conquered half of the world on Europe and crucial learned well we failed and they started huge reforms and the fun hadn't back and shine that's the way pressure Cheers it was an inspiration and he says we have to be as radical as they are we really need this so his book is bright from his perspective it's not radical there's nothing which I think it's sighs fine no to Otto pian things nothing which is out of the box where you think this is inspiring but it is practical and it is good so I have only one wish please execute this so I will bring him online now then he will introduce himself for a couple of seconds so I can refresh my screen to show you a video they have done crop

causes a little bit not perfect for sharing screens but we will try it so first let me bring to Mars online already good first question for you how did your life or your business life change during Corona especially for making politics well in T Direction is number one is most of the meetings went online we even do now in politics some hybrid meetings meaning you can be there in present or you can be there in person and second the amount of laws we have had to proceed under enormous time pressure was enormous or was huge therefore there's a really funny situation most of it I've done in my private working room which you now see here and I see you know you can close close it this is my my favorite business room in my private home and our four kids said they're all at home obviously and they now experience how many meetings I have because it usually it starts today at eight o'clock and the last one will start at 10 o'clock tonight

so and my computer is now my companion and I think you could adapt good I'm surprised how quick German government was able to react I mean normally they need decades to change something and then within a couple of weeks they really we're ready come did this surprise to you too or did you already have this confidence that Germany could read their fathers they have to we describe it in detail in the book and that the German governmental system is pretty good in crisis if the focus is on only one topic so at this time on corona then then be able to be fast and make bold decisions in the time of year in their normal moods where we have thousands of topics at the same time and have many goals at the same time then can be really slow and many of the projects take forever and then they finally fail and and that has to be changed and okay we'll go do you speak about the book let me show the video which you

translate it English sorry yes for a second I got a I got a the term doesn't work let me we hate you someone told me we you can you can hear us if anyone wants you please in the chat we hate you okay let's play the so if you want to see the movie in a better quality than Fame then then go on ww no start no start with double-a and no are taught yet which is the German version of now so here in the chat on the other side we had later put it there and this German version and I thought just I mean we have made perfectly for that event English subtitles and I got the idea that we that we have at least in small English information on the website listen to so Tomas um why now I have the feeling you said in the vu it's the pre it's the post miracle area which is coming I think everyone is getting a line now plus Corona why not why do you

think this is the right timing to come with this very bold and radical approach how to reform politics honestly part of it is occasional you know this project started a year and a half an hour ago we created a working group inside the city would see a group thinking of how are we gonna get more innovation into Germany and into Europe and and agreed that we will have a long research period so we did did almost a year only research we traveled to China which is South Korea in any other places and we take what makes a society more innovative and and we found out that one of the key conditions is that you have a well-functioning state mm-hm and if you see we're not real function enough so what makes a better function and we said this needs a wheel task for the next parliament session which starts in 21 I mean then we came to ddz that's by the book have a discussion period till the end of 2020 market it on 21

and start executing it at the end of 21 and during the period of research and discussion we came to it the gels pivots as we call it always came after crisis and will be discussed there was no crisis we had a long discussion do we have an environment where people are prepared to change things radically enough and why we discussed it Konoha third and so we have the crisis which is obviously not part of our plan but you even have a chapter about this so it's very recent yes and now we were in the last two months of creating this book and then Conan happens and obviously we talked already world crisis in the book even before and then we say now we have a crisis and it's it's in detail described in the book what the scroll not just for the state we have a you have even an headline called co-owner highlight the detail is even through good German expression for drinking wrinkle taking a Red Bull advertising and the finding of it

and saying the utilization will go on or quick on air sue corona and if you see a 2.9 million students now study or everything online and if you would have talked in December six months ago and saying let's study online this the ten years task that you would not have hundred percent and now it was illegal right you have to send your kids to school now you can't couldn't send them to school you had to tear we have changed so much in social time and people see it even works so I think people are much better prepared to change and see the changes needed and and the coming economic crisis will also help us to prepare people and if we take these so-called come into a program which is simply like the Republic governmental response to the crisis where we spent more than a billion euro hmm even three of our suggestions in the book are already part of the package which one and number one the modernization of registers public register mm-hmm notification tool

and as we call it the online sue gongs Gazette which is something like how we get all public services online and this is only gonna change gonna be financed differently and it's technically I'm different and it's all part of the book and now already part of the current governmental I'm in digital I'm digital everything when the crisis came nothing changed from me we're gonna sit ups then I learned that all the laws are already out there like all the courts all the schools they should be remote they should be digital and no one executed on this we needed a crisis to realize that we really needed to turn ization tell me why didn't we do it before like because reasons number one there's some reasons is some loss in not supporting it and we overcame so slow because of the dimension of the crisis first of all every every pupil has the right to be not online to not take part online on and of course which makes schooling different you know if you have

30 people in the class and you say now we don't do online and it's an illegal possibility then how you're gonna do it and this how we overcome because of the crisis and more important you know I got four kids and their teacher we're not prepared to do anything online they even teaches you didn't have a computer at all in a matter bought one and this is a fundamental change in minds of teachers and public service people and they're all extinct I mean I don't have to talk about other people if I talk about my own colleagues in Bundestag we have never ever done in a video call before Corona now we do 80% of sing video : everyone takes part because they know they're out of discussion they out of information flow is they don't hey I can do they all say I'm not a technical guy and it comes to technical I asked my employees it cetera my assistants and they now all experience that they can even sit in a train in

take part which some of them do and then they complain about the bad connection in German trains and that makes a good change in mind therefore the conditions in the preparation of change is to go more digitally I know much better than before okay so we have to see this in the larger context and I got a cut a lot of questions before the talk one was how do we see Germany in genetics hi to your kid by the way with is one of my kids yes yeah it's good it's all knife here it's real and this belongs to a film it's family I mean I'm in my home office to UM within Europe how do you see your reforms being in the larger context of Europe and also do you think if we still can compete with United States and China in terms of your reforms will it give us a head start how do you see the bigger picture all right different questions and the he has asked me something so this is

it's real life and first of all this book's focus on what we could do on the national level in Germany right it clearly states that we need a lot of changes in your to this can't be done by us so what we said is we do what we can change and we don't do a book other people should change it's a different mindset saying this do and that's the focus of the book clearly without our European neighbors we won't succeed and that's very very clear and we analyzed it pretty sure we need to comment European market much stronger than we have we need a very strong euro we get to Europe there's only can can all are done be done only in in and through your but this book doesn't say what can can communities - it doesn't say what cities can do it doesn't say what your concern it can do could do we think what can we do what needs to be changed means politicians but also public administration er now when we

talk about politicians military got this support of many high rank administration guys who's supported and even gave their name many inputs in yes please change change this law and do this differently because I think that's a different approach to saying you know I mean there's so many books saying this and what should be done differently and it always puts the blame to someone else and we said then we don't put someone else responsible we make our shots responsible and that sounds like and that's you know this book is only there for one week but the the public reception is tremendous so I believe that this attitude makes a difference so I read first you have a very good lineup of experts yes a lot of them I know I have read your Amazon reviews which are really good but there's no public awareness it's not that all the talk shows have chunked on it or that all the big news have jumped on it how is it like it's a little bit like underground route

and I think this is not bad this is good for the book but do you ever ease received like like negative feelings about this that people feel a check or saying now I don't want to change I'm comfortable the way I am now number one if this is the marathon and it goes towards the end of 21 so in every marathon you should limit your speed at the beginning energy for the rest second unfortunately this book on exactly at the day when the German coalition negotiated the according to a packet which took us some of the awareness but this you know we planned such a thing three months before and he couldn't know the book is sold out and there will be the news the second edition our flag will be on June 22nd so we're gonna munch it was in two weeks and there will be another newspaper said you know tomorrow the hundreds that will have two pages on it so you know books don't come at one day and then they're over

so and so and the second thing is it is hard for the other parties to position on it you hardly can say listen just are the public administration shouldn't be modernized that's a difficult position to have at least in my view okay we claim that area now and that's always in politics and they struggle to find an answer and if you want to be in talk shows and you need a dispute there people say it should be different and I haven't found anyone publicly saying it should be in general different it's like Oh AI panels all the time everyone is FOIA I know and wants no AI we just maybe don't agree how to do that's terrific so going into your book a little bit deeper and you suggest for example that startups and venture capital have a lack of funding which I agree how do you want to overcome this what is your your suggestion that with more funding for entrepreneurship which is needed to build a whole new ecosystem and economy to two

ways number one better the conditions for or three things that is the conditions for startups mmm-hmm second close the gap which we have because we do not have pension funds look in the u.s. the source of the money by far biggest a is pension funds and things do not exist in Germany almost and and if there exists they have a hard time to invest in this offense so take the pension fund opportunity that's the second and the third one and jemima maybe the most important is better the exit possibilities you know if you haven't get a I company most likely is that Google Facebook Amazon or Microsoft's can buy you but any other European company and what we would like to have is get a new start to IPO good start ups out of Europe and find a new segment in a new environment of support and one of the concrete ideas is that the e ib which is a european investment bank is allowed to sign IPOs initial IPOs in Europe from starters and

be one key shareholder for the first whatever five years or so so be a long term investors be a market maker and and usually if you invest in a broader scale if you say it's a vib if there is a start-up IP owing and be always you have to consider it she Simon then they will sign whatever 20 30 40 IPOs the year then then we would like money at the end not with every IPO but in general if you have deep tech IPOs and if you have more in Europe then you have growing companies you have a capital basis so we have some ideas in the book how are we gonna do this sounds a little bit like how I feel in Europe is you have China on the one hand which is very state money driven and you have the United States which is not official getting any state funding they do a lot of research funding and then Europe in between like we have more state capital hopefully in the technology market

than the US but less than China yeah it will be do the research support we do too in Europe and in in German research is not the problem the transfer from the research into companies it's more the problem we got the idea to give the universities a fund to invest I like this like like MIT strings it's false and so they're not allowed to fund them alone they need to have the NASA private investor at the same term so that we down double check but then that would allow us teach you have more startups out of the university of is new technical families and then we have better conditions to fund them and we have better exit conditions and then we have higher value chain in making new companies ok for the live audience today because this will also be a podcast and video cards but for the live audience you can ask questions here if you write them they can be uploaded I can tweet them and then ask to us directly but you

to the next idea you had you call it a future lobby its night I can true for tucán is it like you wanted building for future or is it this is the very inside view of politics if we do it as a law even if you do it very fast like in the cronut we have to have at least one hearing usually we do many we take something about new cars for example then we hear the experts and they're mostly in all existing companies do have a very good system to be here so they have experts who know how they're gonna work when does it happen how to get into such a hearing etc and that's a good thing and iron mental people do you know how it works - so they're part of the earrings - but a company who does not exist that isn't being hurt because they even if they're already there and have three people they don't know how it works they don't have time they're not experts Adana when to

say what to to influence and if there's a concrete example when we make new Environment Protection laws we excluded fuels Brian oh and practical reason is didn't exist at that time it was research and university level but there hasn't been any company who produces a fuels at that time if you now make your balance sheets for environment and you see fuels which are co2 neutral it doesn't count which is completely nonsense the reason why is because no one told the law makers at that time that there is an option what we call lobbying from your perspective yeah it's a lobby if you want to call Lobby no one told us and you know the system man says be measured the outcome of a car mm-hmm but we do not consider the input and it's the input of the car takes as much as pollution out of the environment which comes an hour that's the same amount at the end new tool at the end it doesn't count and this is the future lobby as he

call it mm-hmm she should be my foundation neutral and they should speak out for companies who do not exist already hmm for those businesses for the future and saying listen think about what kind of business could be there and integrated in the law already so the condition in terms of law is better so it's a bit like an expert group thing thing which is giving political advice for topics which are not realized yet so you think lobbying itself is good for the process because it's feeding information into the politics yeah okay you know we would be our only innovation comes always if new information comes at the table okay time so quick next one what is your view on Gaia X it's a very good idea and I very much hope it will work I have a little skeptical that is little over-engineered you know pretty germans yeah so to have a European standard on the cloud will be extremely helpful and there are many new companies even in Berlin with aim in Finland there

are very interesting new services where you could have a you bean based cloud clear European data protection and it would be even cheaper to use instead of using AWS or whatever even half the price okay and if Gaia X would have surprised of using cloud space and have better data protection and would standard you as being only then then I would believe everyone would use it I mean if it can save money you have a better data protection and there's no downside and tonight in mind it takes a little too long it's a little over engineered and too many people inside and do not have a sense of technology behind and therefore there many discussions where I said listen this is not a point because it doesn't work already okay you suggested in your book that part of our income should go into a retirement fund like four percent and then of the normal retirement payments but this is a fund which will invest and it will have loans to repay it and I like

the idea of an investment fund question there who would manage this like like who do you work in Norway from an independent foundation he had such a saying in Germany hundred years before or even more wrong before at the end of the nineteenth century and the money and invested it in World War one and that problem so the idea at that time was you know one is a very good investment so we and then you know they're gonna win this war and then the other nations pay us and then we have a nice return interesting mmm that was not a good idea obviously because the pension fund went bankrupt mm-hmm the beginning of the bimah the public and so what we say is it needs to be an independent investor because this money belongs to the pensioner it's their equity it they own it the state is not allowed to decide any of any purpose what we tell them the worst idea would be you know Lufthansa is in trouble you have a there's a

pocket of money with billions of dollars why don't we have them by Lufthansa so we saves this takes payers money and it's a very good investment because left-handers were only a few minutes a few dollar and so if we start doing this one you know it would be the end of the idea so it has to be only minority shares saying they do not become any board seat you know it shouldn't be they shouldn't govern this company they invest hmm secondly which wasn't possible at the end of 19th century it is investing world wild it would be a risk sharing for German pensioners saying this even if German economy doesn't go well but Asian one then we would benefit from it and we do what all wealthy people in the world do is something like to risk sharing and diversity management and then we would say that they need to be a new a new agency doing it which would be independent and should be observed by the German Bundesbank so politics have to stay

away and we wouldn't put it in the Constitution to protect money so I like the idea of having a new fund i I once said we need your one trillion fund which is invested into the future into technologies infrastructure education so everything in this direction they're good because money is currently free it's like plenty out there it's not arriving your my pocket maybe but all the high-level it's with a surplus of money how do you think that switch a little bit to to data because data is crucial I'm very important and we still don't have the data revolution it's like governments and administration of sitting on the data and they don't share it how do you want to change this is it a law or a culture problem boys number one we have to realize that we at the beginning of the digitalization not at the end the rights yeah you know most people think you know everyone has a smartphone so we know digital eyes now we have a virtual conference so all is

done on and so this is not the case and they're very interesting members two years ago we reach the moment that if you spend $2,000 you get the brain power of a mouse so practically stalking if you buy a smartphone like with $4,000 then you get when you get the brain power at the capacity of a mouse 2025 or wigging that's five years to go same amount of money the brain power of the human being another 15 years further you get $4,000 buying power of Z of the human mankind in total you know it won't be the same like the brain but it can could use a lot of data and it will be much cheaper so this will exclude the amount of data you're in this society so we're at the very beginning of the data century and we could do much more with the data so I fully agree but we need to start to open this box this explosion yeah exactly but you know you have to see the dimension of the

issue III know it and most of the choice you know it to talk about politics and people do not know in the majority maybe AI experts do know but they don't for this is like the first step the second step yeah we call it the German Canton spasm cart so original ideas have as little data as possible it is a complete nonsense logic if the amount of data explodes then they sell and we have you have therefore two new lease exist - no laws number one is data sovereignty which is not brand new because you have read about it with maybe before and then we call it dad's org file so what we say is the real crucial point point is not how many data you possess real crucial what you do with it and do your profiling or don t do a profiling and so we find a new solution in saying listen we won when I have hotel auditors as a new profession and as every bigger company needs to have an auditor

every debtor any company use a lot of data needs to have a detail or the truth it's practically with a I automatically will approve its you do not do for fun which is easily to to look into the computer so you may collect the data but you know may not do everything with the brightness specifically if it comes to personal data this is the question about privacy so you want to give free data but you can't profile exactly and only in the limits of the current law and and you know already in the 19th century the concept of auditing has been invented you know it cost a lot of money to come to me said everyone is audited what we said if we do have false balance sheets it dangers the entire society and that the law as a lawyer he's called me neither public believe in the correctness of balance sheet and we need a public believe that people are caring about the data of individuals mm-hm and if it is a public goods

that we believe in it then we need an auditor and you know and we do it like we do it in auditing so it's private auditors who have been a license to do so and they would lose your license if you do something wrong so I'm not I'm not arguing with an office a public office I have an auditor which I pay which will be much faster in much more service-oriented but they do have a job they have to stand that everything is in order if you lose system you know you lose you're alone is to put to collect any data one thing you click get the real point in it that means Facebook is only allowed to act in Europe if they have a date of origin which approves them it would discuss this before you want to approach this way Amazon and Google and Alibaba that they have to comply with European law because they need an audit if they don't audit they can't operate in Europe correctly and that will be a

tremendous change because if your agrees on it then would lose a third of their market so they can't not comply you also spoke about when we talked last time about a public marketplace for dejan like everyone who's audited has to fit his data into the system and can receive other data back so that way Google alone own the data anymore alone everyone else could have the same data except me because this opens competition you know if you mean it's not technically difficult to make immune search or to create a new search but to feed the search with enough data that's the difficulty so I'm curious in future if either they will pay a lot of lobbying so this won't happen or if they go so far and make people quiet so this won't happen because I hope that it will happen it's so do i and let's see yeah well you're fine remember what you know politics is always about majority and we fight to get majority for those five years mm-hmm okay and and

for the lion and Festa I also Pro dater pro AI so they want I mean I see a common line there there are many ideas you know even this weekend I will have a call with for the lion to convince her routine to go that road and so European Union wants to regulate the eye and we're still in a I accept here have you looked it a little bit more close into it because you you touch AI in one of your chapters what's your view on regulating a I like is it needed if so what will it be actually at the end well AI is a huge of a bunch of huge opportunities we need to support them but they I could be a danger to so we need to have some protection rules and 15 pages we created the principles of those new rules which in general say we need to have a risk-based approach meaning how likely is that something goes wrong and how much will be the damage if you have an

AI which supports your breaks in a car and this wouldn't work and you miss written by death so you need obviously more regulation if you're logistic is based on age I and the worst case is that the common good is coming a day later to you you know I would say you state should stay waste the damage risk is so small though we don't you don't care but who who will decide what's critically I am what not the the critical issue would be done by by a public institution in general and we would go back to the daily authorities so the data auditor you anyway mm-hmm gives you an approval and saying this is critical you need to have this risk assessment mm-hmm which because you have them if you if you have a if you buy a new company and you put the value of your company into your balance sheet mm-hmm what do you do you call you wanna check and your auditor says you know this is how you're gonna do and

and you would get it extremely quick answer maybe you don't like the answer but you get a quick answer and and that's the same with AI you know you need to have a procedure where you can protect your the information of your business so this your auditor you share everything you your auditor knows everything in your company otherwise he can stamp at the end of seein things and everything is fine and your data on it who knows your business pretty well and has to know and has to know all secrets of your business but he doesn't have to give you an answer and he's responsible by law and if you just do it wrongly he would lose his license ohyeah would go to trial if you just do for something wrong which we have the same but this sounds like more regulation at the same time startups hate this I mean it's killing them from the beginning I'm running a startup venture funded it's regulated all this auditing cause a lot of money if you

only have like two or three people then Corona hits you how do you want to prevent that Google is audited but not all the SMEs out there who don't have the resources for this well it's like they're auditing in a balance sheet I mean if you if your new startup you don't need an auditor for you finance measures and you wouldn't have them but as you grow you need and I think the answer can't be no regulation the answer must be clear regulation because one thing is you don't know what to do you may not like an answer but if you know I have to do that way it make raise your investment instead listen I need to to do more to to comply that then at least he can manage it the worst thing is you don't know what what what is possible and if not that always kills you investment because if you don't know anything listen I can tell you whether it even works then like so what you need is clear

regulation not liberally regulation with these clear regulation and manageable with the regulation and that's the same we have done in the 19th century with the consolidation the Germany was absolutely best in clear regulation we have been the first who regulated electronics so that we have 220 volt etc came very early in Germany and everyone knows it's not 200 it's 220 maybe it's not the best solution I don't know where we have to be very clear conditions and everyone had to meet the conditions and it made the German industry grow because they know what you do you know we have this team in Germany thought it was team on and and even in existed in Russia was culturally but it's a very old institution in Germany and and this made this night in Germany visit was very clear in generation standards but I see there the conflict for example I am in conversation with team for everyone who's not German it's like ISO international it's a standard agency they have no clue about AI they know

that they have to develop a standard for it but they don't know it and honestly no one knows how to do it and then you have China United States or rebuilding EAJA companies and keep doing so we see that without standards they succeed already isn't like a standard and the one hand it's good to build upon but if something is already existing isn't it like running behind you're trying to catch them and slow them down if it's a question of timing yep good examples the best one to my mind is GSM the year in nations made a mobile standard right this mobile standard came very early already in 88 or so ahead of the marker that's very important and we managed not the Motorola standard it's not other states makes the strengthens other company makes the standard yeah whoever is is about to take the mobile transmission standard because it's just ahead of them and then we follow mobile UI and we will be dependent forget that they're in China and forget the Chinese problem

it's not good if you have one company setting the standard in have Microsoft Office you can't walk around because of a rule because court is law is everyone here probably knows so you need to be quick and early and to be ahead of the market before the market is there you set a standard and on that standard you have one competition and not a monopoly that's something like is easy go if you do not standard you will have single companies building a monopoly like Facebook even if they come out of your yes and B they won't come out of you you have if you still have to run race the winner takes it all you have a a monopoly which we don't want and be the winner is not room that is it's not European so this isn't like the connection and we would like to have it an open market and we would like to have competition on a standard but standard almost by a private person so we're coming to the end we

still have a couple of minutes you have bold vision good reforms if you start to execute them with a majority after the next election and you have the society push through to support this because this is much needed it will shift power and capital how this thing will have political shift powers because always exchanged they're always winners and losers right at the very end if we gonna manage it well there will be a huge increase in wealth on a broader level and that always pays for the current institutions so Western German in evidence were skeptical about Ludwig Erhard and the majority of Germans want to have him step down and when 1851 he took back any limits on the prices on X and it almost made him go out of office hmm but then the people saw that it has a very positive implant and then it changed the entire mood in today's it's yah demócrata vs.

hiss hmm his heritage is even from I've t2 links but sighs they all talk about it I mean it's just common ground because it has been so successful so if think utilization III if we manage it well to the benefit of the people then you know democracy in Europe will stay very healthy and become a museum in Europe to play we want to see how has been in the parched don't even democracy is a danger but they also will be downsides and losers because someone is currently printing producing books like to write in and everything is digital they don't produce books anymore so you accept that industries have to adapt people might lose their job find maybe something else it will be painful I think it will be great they feel yeah people will deal I don't even think that so many people lose their job there were these different things in their job if companies are able to adapt then the the if you have you seen the last 15 years I mean there

have been digitalization already and we have even and demand on jobs and we have too many people there what we do is our education system I have to change and we need to help people to adapt but the free market is pretty strong and helping people you know because is there if you don't get a perfect employee it takes the second best and make you become better I mean this the marketers do it already so if something like this solutions that the products are not coming out of Europe but other Asian then you have unemployment it is just a question of market share do do we have enough market share of the new industries in you yes or no that's it that's a core question I agree we need national European industry we need the Europe's the drops here we need the education to reform the policy-making has to adapt a lot of homework a lot of homework if we can execute 10% of this this is more than before I think this book is

a good approach it's a marathon and I will company with the methergine too and I hopeful more people today to the last question for you how will you person you help where do you see your role in this marathon so 2021 what do you wish I mean I'm trying to be happy if I be reelected into the Parliament the new coalition will be City who lead it and will have on their program for the next four years this pivot and I could control other Parliament that they're gonna be lead II will be M plans and it doesn't really matter whether you know it doesn't look for a title or so but I would be something like you know I will have an important role in controlling it if politics would officially adapt this program mm-hmm then you will be asked that one uses like isn't one of the leader of this or when you will be in this in a circle I did I don't care but that's not the key issue the key issue

is do we get moist art or the modernization of the state as the key tasks for the next period okay my vote and my energy you have for this I call for this for years we need this I'm pretty sure you will find plenty plenty plenty of people who see this too and I think this is good energy and especially in this times everyone is depressed currently they are annoyed I think it's good to have some optimism that even this will change it will change for good to us I thank you thank you and we talk again everyone else can stay for a minute it was a pleasure to have you good bye bye bye what a nice day so everyone else stay for a minute um I think this was a good talk this was a good talk I suppose you have a lot to go over because this is if you read the book there's so much enjoy this so much I can recommend the book even if it's not written fast because

it's written for politicians it's one of the best things I have read also it's very good like design it's modern you feel that the people are motivated behind it what it's still missing is like high level support like you know like political superpower because maybe they won't commit we will see for everyone else next week we have another virtual trek you should join totally different topic no politics we're going to tech because we will speak about quantum machine learning and if you've heard about the bus with quantum machines and machine learning you're like me if you don't know what this is you're like me too I have no clue I have ideas I have bread books and I'm curious but honestly I don't know how to code this I don't even know if this is about quantum and machines or machines in quantum um I have a special guest for this and her name is Claudia puling I'm Claudia pulling she is a she's a tough good woman and she's talking straight which I I

need a sense for his partner she's head of AI machine learning old is at the Deutsche Telekom laboratories so it's a little bit like I would say a German version of Google X so she's doing cool research and she will talk about this research and quantum machine learning is one of her core topics so if you're interested in quantum machine learning and I've said this over and over now join next week again let me see it is 11:00 a.m. next week same method same topic and then we won't stay home stay self enjoy the rest of the day's a little bit rainy here it was a pleasure to have to talk with you and see you again next week bye

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.