I will introduce them in due time but I just want to you know to give you a brief Roundup of what the topic actually entails and and why I think it was so important also and it's interesting in a sense so I'm kind of very excited about this panel we do have very distinguished guests here I'm very happy about that and as I said like I am working on AI and democracy and intersecting with security in terms of that I work with the information space I try to understand what is a mobilization potential what actually makes people take the way they do and why do they go or do things that they don't want to do and that also is important in terms of strategic manipulation and information space and that's the intersection in a way so just to give you a heads up a disclosure although I'm not an expert in Ai and defense there are some intersections and now I want to introduce and I'm going to start with uh Dr OA Franke
she is a senior policy officer at the European Council of relations and the areas of focus include German and European security and defense the future of warfare and the impact of new technologies such as drones Artificial Intelligence on geopolitics and warfare Dr fanka has published widely on these and other topics and is regularly appears as a commentator in the media she and that's how I know her is the co-host of the zva podcast a German language podcast on security and defense which I can highly recommend thank you for being here then we have Ivan hofa here she's a lawyer and an essayist with a long it career that started in 1999 and in 2020 she co-founded 21 strategies and is its current CEO and 21 strategies transforms how organizations make strategic and tactical decisions under uncertainty and the company provides NextGen artificial intelligence for both the defense and the com the commercial domains she is also a regular on the media and she makes numerous comments about technological impacts of AI and also is the
author of several books she has been awarded the 53rd tooto award for her commitment to democracy has been awarded an honorary professorship for digitization and Society of the B of the uh at the Bon rine Zeke University of applied sciences and she has been awarded as a top 50 AIC CEO of 2021 by the US magazine technology innovators and currently she also holds a roles as a representative for Germany at the NATO's data and artificial intelligence review board welcome and uh last but definitely not least and my dining partner yesterday as well we have uh General M feta no sorry Lieutenant General Mel feta and since 20 2019 he has been the head of the Cyber information technology department and is also the Chief Information officer at the Federal Ministry of Defense he has a long and distinguished career and that started in 1982 when he joined the Air Force and Lieutenant General feta was employed at various levels in staff units and in various assignments in the Federal Ministry of Defense throughout his career
in 2017 he became the first Chief of Staff of the newly established cyber and information space command of the buness faere and later on he has also performed the duties of Deputy inspector of cyber and information space so as I said the topic is a big one and I wondered like how can I actually frame this conversation because it's a big conversation to have I don't know how you know 45 minutes we're not up let's see how we can solve the problems here so I thought the framing of this questions should be something like not focusing on problems but really looking at the vision how can Germany not only keep up in the world where the future of warfare is already here as we're seeing in neighboring conf conflict in countries but and here's the big but how can we actually thrive in this new paradigm because we should not only be keeping up that should not be our goal it's a minimum it should be how can we actually thrive in it sounds funny
I know we're back uh let's say we're not the big players right now but that's not the point point of the discussion discussion is really kind of coming up with a call to action what is necessary to fulfill this Vision in my opinion and uh I have a I have a little bit of a how do you say I want to apply the moonshot method to this panel it's not going to be a classical panel in a way that I'm just going to ask questions and expect answers but I really want to try out and see if uh I'm just going to explain how it works so I'm going to ask everybody for the current state of qu in a sense um of the major challenges but also what is working especially well in terms of their expertise and the Second Step will be kind of trying to Define goals for Germany in each expertise and because we're talking AI it would be in two years and in five years because we know that the
current revolution of uh I don't know systems is in my opinion every 3 to six weeks in a way and the final section would be try to come up with actual tactics goals and plans of how to make these goals a reality how do we become that and it's actually a fun game in a way because uh the moonshot method is a problem solving approach that was kind of first pitched by JFK in his speech in 1962 when he said by the end of the decade we're going to be on the moon and everybody just laughed at him but it set a goal and they made it happen so this is actually what I try to do kind of come up with a way of setting a goal and see how we can make this happen and not only focus on on challenges and risks it's also a way of coming of of getting away from thinking incrementally only you know making big steps in a way so I'm going to start with the status
quo and I'm going to start with M fet because I introduced you the last and uh yeah so yesterday we talked a bit about the bundas faere and about the capability to wage war about as you called it about rebuilding infrastructure and everything so my first question would be really um what is the current status quo of the buir in general the first and then the second would be how is the Bund currently using AI applications actually because it's not about only using Tech or just buying capabilities but what are the priorities for further AI integration as well okay thank you so we I have 37 minutes to to describe the state of p no first of all thank you very much for for having me here uh great pleasure I would like to start and give a little bit of context you know two years ago when Russia started its unprovoked war against uh Ukraine German Chancellor Cole stated that we had a Titan vendor turning point in history and actually this Titan vendor
insecurity policy comes at a time when we're right in the midst of a Titan vendor in technology the former chairman of the US Chiefs of Staff General Millie stated in last October that and I quote we are witnessing a seismic change in the character of War largely driven by Tech and of I think he's perfectly all right with this and even when you look at the war in Ukraine which is not the blueprint for the bundes future capability planning but even if you look there you see there are almost ubiquitous availability of sensors 24/7 you are surrounded by sensors you're surrounded by UNM aerial vehicle cr-based vehicle Maritime vehicles um you are faced with lering ammunition with uh ammunition that comes at incredible High Velocity um so this has huge implications for the armed forces and for our concepts of operation for our Doctrine our training our equipment and our mindset and not to forget space and cyber which play an increasingly important role in Warfare and this has huge implications for us and uh
coming to AI as a pervasive and thereby decisive technology is at the Forefront of where we have to keep up and Pace what are we doing in this uh very Spectrum uh three years ago we implemented what we call the digitization platform for the bundes what does it mean uh historically the bunders procured IT services like we procured tanks aircraft carriers uh not probably not aircraft carriers let's say frigs um and fighter jets this doesn't sound very agile and very smart and it wasn't very agile and very smart so we are reorganizing the system we've uh clustered our it in nine clustered we used the NATO C3 taxonomy so there is a cluster for enterprise resource planning a cluster for it infrastructure a cluster for community in of Interest services and we also have a cluster called analytics and simulations where would he would like to deploy our Ai and IU Services uh that we provide to the war fighter and the idea is then if a war fighter has a special need we will
look into those clusters so to see we will look in our web shop and try to build a solution using standardized scalable secure IT services which are then provided so that we have a system based on an architecture which is easily also or which can be be further developed rather more easily than than we did in the past coming to AI what's going on currently quite a lot is going on I would like to focus on on the military Edge so not on what's going on in admin yes we will have a military style jet GPT hopefully by the end of this year but but my focus is on on on the on the edge on the war fighting capabilities and there we are currently um having a couple of projects out on the run one is called the digitized battlefield where we using pattern recognition object object recognition sensor and data fusion um to to support this Mantra that we have that we would that we need to have information superiority which will then
hopefully translate into Superior command and control and then end up in Superior effect if we have this triangle we will be able to to provide escalation dominance and and thereby deterrence to to any aggressor so digitized Battlefield is one huge Endeavor it's also in the digitization strategy of the federal government uh the second one just to give you one example is an uh AI laboratory for our electronic intelligence people so pattern recognition U animaly uh detection and the third one that I could use is the common operational picture that we are introducing for the cyan information domain uh where we bringing um standardized and unstandardized data together try to Fusion those data and and try to to to become or to get ahead of the of the event so to to be able to uh prepare for an event rather than to react afterwards so in a nutshell quite a lot going on currently so that would be forecasting basically now that's interesting that's something thing I also do um okay thank you so much
I will have followup questions soon uh I will turn to Ivan H now because as I mean we we will mention Ukraine a lot of times I guess today because it is uh it's a case study in a way um very maab told but in a way it is for us to see what is going on actually right now because over there the advancements in artificial intelligence continue to reshape the future of warfare and we can actually see in real time the deployment of emerging Tech combined with traditional monetary hardware and how it looks like um but what I know and what I've read about is that private companies have a very large role to play in this and um in this conflict and then the future warfare so I'm going to ask I mean we know that the industry matters in a way when it comes to providing Hightech and support to the military and um Mr feta was just talking about the information superiority in battle and how important this is right so
data is needed that is collected by Hardware manufacturers and they can turn that to make uh turn can only make operationally manageable with software obviously so and after that defense manfacturers and startups have to use interfaces with each other right to communicate everything so my question to you would be what is the status quo of the German defense ecosystem right now um that comprises military government and Industry in terms of interfaces and their effectiveness to communicate how does it actually work what are the challenges in the B not sure if I actually answering your question now but I I want to give a direct answer to General feder um but let's start with an anecdote and it takes us back to the Year 1997 uh my today's CTO back then was around 30 years old was working for Sean defense Electronics however it was called um and he was in a very exclusive Club of few young people who were building back then the first artificial intelligence system for defense and it was the year
of the uh midterm upgrade of the aex system NATO nea3 which is the aex is the Airborne warning and control system and it's actually doing exactly what you have described General uh you collect data from multiple non-comm transable data sources you fuse them into a overall situational picture recognized air picture it was called back then um and what I actually see is now being like 25 years older than I was uh then I see that uh not much has moved since then so we are still dealing and this is not actually what should I say it's not only a it's not a f it's um it's like I see this also in other countries so the major Target of applying artificial intelligence and defense is of course uh domination uh information superiority by using all types of data of course we have different types of data today also we have open source data which we can also fuse with uh with military data so the operational picture the situational awareness is where we actually stand
now when my today's CTO was presenting that solution that ax solution almost 30 years ago to a group of generals one General after the presentation turned around to his peers and he said but gentlemen AR don't don't we all agree that all that counts is steal at the battlefield still at the battlefield and we were upset of course because my CTO said hey uh what is he talking about of course the information dominance is the thing of the future but today looking at Ukraine uh I think that we did wrong to that General because obviously sort of was right all that counts is still at the battlefield now two Lessons Learned From that anecdote the first one is um where where we stand today is we basically stand where we already stood 25 years ago and seeing young startups entering the scene uh I recognize that they tried to solve problems which we solved already 20 years ago so we it's it's our um so of responsibility leadership responsibility to teach them uh to get
faster to the point because we have the knowledge we only need to dig it out again so this is the one thing and the second thing is whoever is entering the scene of uh military AI or defense AI as a startup and this also points actually to the investors probably has to be aware that at a certain point in time he will have to go physical with the artificial intelligence I have information dominance yeah I have steel at the battlefield there and if I compare these two then I really wonder in the worst case which of the system is stronger and I fear it is not information dominance that's um that's a difficult question to answer I would say uh simply because we see the effect as you say of of missing ammunition missing um we call this embedded Ai and in the end it is in fact what you say it is AI uh sort of integrated with with platforms which can be weapon systems or which can be the other type of platforms
logistical platforms whatsoever but the artificial intelligence will probably no it will not stay in the information space and in the cyers space it will go out into the real life it will contribute to what in the civilian uh sphere we call ambient intelligence it will be everywhere and this also means will be integrated with the platforms yes thank you um now we're turning over to you Mrs fanka uh so I'm going to I know we talked about this digitized strategy right now but I still want to talk about the missing AI strategy in military so it is a fact that Germany hasn't defined one um strategy harnessing AI for milary applications and I'm saying this because the US and China has and we're not even talking the biggest players we're talking also France and the Netherlands have as well an AI and Military strategy in and I think this would or this in general like a strategy depending on how the implementation works um it defines it's a foundation defines principles and especially now in
the military and in the defense sector the limits also of the human machine interaction so as a scholar in defense I'm asking you um what is the role like you have been studying the role of analyzing potential impacts of emerging Tech of a I of drones specifically I know that cyber capabilities so what is your assessment on how emerging technology is used and integrated into the military organizations of the bundes fair what is The Good the Bad and the Ugly as they say is it working is it not working because we've heard one side but I would just like to hear her side as well in a sense um that's a very diffic difficult question for an outsider really um so first of all thanks of all thanks a lot for for having me here um so I put it this way what we've seen um over the last two plus years in particular but even before that not everybody was necessarily paying as much attention is that the bonus V unfortunately was underfunded um
significantly for decades and underfunding doesn't just mean that there's not enough of certain things which was the case but also that you know new things wasn't weren't necessarily looked at um there there was no room basically to to to try out things um and so what we're doing now since not just since the Tien and let's be fair I mean you know defense budgets have been rising at least since 2014 Russia's annexation of of of primier but still what we're basically are doing now um in Germany is trying to rebuild everything at the same time and that is what is so difficult and this is why on the one hand I could sit here and say the Buon is clearly not doing enough on Artificial Intelligence on um on drones on you know many kind of new newish capabilities which is kind of true but the reason for that is not that they don't want to and not even I would say that they haven't understood that this is important I mean we have someone
from the from the bonus sitting here but that there are so many gaps that need to be filled that you kind of need to make choices right and you will never do everything um uh at the same time and so we have the 100 billion special fund for example and you look at on what's being spent and a lot of it is I mean the F35 is certainly not kind of old Tech and an old um aircraft but it is a man aircraft it's not you know a Ai and and and and and autonomy so to speak um or or helicopters or or things like that and I don't want to say that this is wrong because at this point we're really need more of everything but at the same time it is I think still true that we aren't really you know kind of laser focused on on new capabilities and um and Ai and and these kind of things so it is it is a mixed it is a mixed picture but you
know to to be kind of fair to the organization um it would be too easy to just say they're not doing enough which again is partly true but there's a reason why one sentence maybe on the kind of military AI strategy bit I mean this has always become a a running gag right the the the the France has had a military eye strategy for for many years in other countries as well and and Germany hasn't really and at this point I want to say I mean yes a military ey strategy would be kind of nice and useful but in the end a strategy is just a um a thought expert effort sorry that was what I was looking for so it's it's it's a kind of effort to think things through which is useful but the strategy you know kind of writing stuff down doesn't make it happen and so we I think we've almost gone beyond the point where we need to write things down and we already need to be doing them and
luckily I do know that within the buus V you know people are thinking about this there is thought there is a task force drone there is lots of a lots of things um but I'm you know to kind of put it bluntly I'm kind of over the military AI strategy bit like this was something I would have been useful five years ago and two years ago and at this point we just need to kind of move forward Mr F you wanted to respond yeah probably not respond but but add a bit context concerning the The 100 billion extra budget but Rica said is is very a very good example for for the awareness in Germany with regard to military efforts there was much talk about the F35 there was much talk about the heavy transport helicopter did the Army get enough tanks and do we get enough riets what most people oversaw that out of this 100 billion Euro package 21 billion euros will go into digitization and command and control because this is really
sorry to say what the hits the fan if we are not able to to lead our forces we are blind and then we have a leop 2 excellent main battle tank which is not a digital note on a connected battlefield but which is 70 tons of steel with a pretty good Cannon but that's that's it and that's not the effect that we would like to generate so we really have to speed up and we're doing this in providing the the command and control it infrastructure to be able in a couple of years time to participate in what they call multi-domain operations with regard to strategy um as far as I know even in the Frank language there is uh the the vocabulary uh Lam concept so I guess we must be very careful not to avoid that the Germans are world champions in writing Concepts and strategies rather than delivering capability to the war fighter and if you ask me I'm pretty much more in favor of delivering capability to the war fighter and not
100% goldplated solution but a 40% solution that he gets tomorrow or in in a year's time rather other than having the best strategy in the world and no capability to deliver to the soldiers who are in need of this sorry to say thank you do you want to respond to please as well on the one hand I absolutely agree with you General uh nevertheless I felt uh that it's helpful if you work towards a very stringent option portfolio portfolio of options that you have and an agile portfolio of options you come and set up uh your ultimate objective where you want to be in five years and then like let's say like an investment manager would do it you sit together every I don't know three months or half year or every year and then you actually align the your portfolio with what has actually happened right so you need to have a certain agility and your portfolio brings you on the best path towards your ultimate goal but there might happen a lot of
things that are unexpected events and exceptions and then all of a sudden you find yourself at a certain stop and then you need to make a decision where do you bet your funds on uh Next Step so that has always helped us in it in our it or innovation management a great deal just implementing a an a portfolio option which we by the way also measure from a financial perspective so we give every option that we have there also a price tag is or or a price so we we we calculate the option value so that we know okay when I take 100 million in my hands today and I invest it now on my op to my optimal path uh then this is sort of like an option that I buy me to get then to the ultimate goal and if you very stringently uh manage it like this uh the the probability that you pursue and to get further with your high path is very high so I think we can agree on
we should have had an AI strategy in the military five years ago but in general it is a useful tool you know to be stringent on your path to your vision or your goals uh we're heading on to the second section defining the Visions for the shortterm two years and the longterm five years um I think I'm I'm not sure if it's necessary but I just you know going to re like uh repeat what I meant with the Visions in in itself it's about setting extremely ambitious and Visionary goals it's about tackling seemingly impossible challenges and marshalling resources and efforts and even if success seems uncertain or distant doesn't really matter it's about setting a vision and to reframe to rephrase the the question that I asked to really thrive in this new paradigm because that's the goal not keeping up um yes and I want to start with you of I hope that is okay H yeah thanks a lot um I had to chuckle a little bit when you said shortterm two years
which is fine and then long term five years because of course in the military realm you know five years is super short term um when you think about the the Future combet air system for example the French German Spanish aircraft plus aircraft plus combat Cloud plus drone swarms um that is being developed and has been in development for a few years uh we now think that this is going to fly in 2045 and even on that we're not entirely sure so yeah shortterm and long-term are kind of relative terms in um in the military Realm that being said I just came from a conference actually with the with the luffer and we were talking about the fact that there really is a worry that Russia is currently kind of building up its capabilities and might be able to fight a NATO country or invade a NATO country um in the time frame of 3 to 5 years so again you know kind of the shortterm um time frame is important and so fcas won't help
us um won't help us with this um what is what is the the the vision um it's interesting because I'm always someone who says like yes we need more kind of political visions and we need kind of more positive um ideas in politics that being said of course in the defense and security realm that is really tricky right because there are no positive views I mean the positive situation is you build a lot of stuff that you never use like that's the idea you spent a lot of money to develop really cool fancy things that you then never get to use because they did their job in kind of detering everybody from attacking you and so that's the positive Vision um so let's talk about fancy stuff that we want to build in order for never having to use it um so a few things I would highlight and and maybe I think something to understand and I do understand that we don't want to talk about just the challenges but also what we what
we can do but I think it's important to point out one specific challenge when it comes to comes to this question of what should we be looking at what what what should we be investing in I think the problem is that we basically have three levels of levels of uncertainty when it comes to AI in the military realm the first level of uncertainty is that this is a technology that is still developing I mean GP what what would they call that GP gp4 or something um that that open AI just put out they put it out like yesterday right so so we have a development in um on the technological side that is still ongoing and and very fast so we don't quite know where we're going um with this first level of uncertainty second level of uncertainty we don't know then how these capability will translate or be adapted into the military realm because we are not talking about a new tank or a new drone where we kind of know okay this is
the capability AI can literally enable well the full range of of military um capability from Logistics to targeting to data analysis to I don't know what so we we have a level of uncertainty of like what even makes sense what is useful what what can be done what will we invest in etc etc and then third level of uncertainty is how you then use that capability because you know as someone who has spent a lot of time studying past Revolutions in military Affairs so this idea of you get a new technology on the battlefield and somehow it has a revolutionary fundamental impact on the battlefield the one thing the literature the Academia Clinic on is that what matters isn't so much or isn't just the new technology but how you use it the tank was on the battlefield already in 19160 it really became revolutionary if you want to use that term or kind of important relevant in the second world war because of of of how you use it so you have this level
of uncertainty and that makes predicting this um very difficult but nevertheless to to to to try and answer your questions so the thing I would the things I would um try to look at or I want you know the bonus the the B and everybody to look at first would be um swarms swarming capability um so drone swarms but it doesn't have to be in the air it can be on water it can be it can be every anywhere of course we're already doing this I'm not kind of saying stuff that oh my God they have never heard in the in the mod mod um fcas even have a swarm cap has a swarm component but I think this is one of the capabilities that is very relevant and is likely to have a big military impact can be done relatively soon we kind of know how to do this technologically even though it's still kind of um being done so so swarms would be uh would be one the second would be the whole
issue of autonomy and here again you know of course people are already thinking about this but kind of very specifically think about you know what areas we are willing to to automate to kind of um use autonomous systems in what not how do you do this autonomy isn't binary things things aren't either autonomous or not but have autonomous elements so how do you how do we um how do we deal with this and what are the kind of rules and regulations that we want to have I think that's a very important one and then the final one um and this is kind of if you like inspired by the the reports coming out of um out of Israel and Gaza on the use of AI for uh Target recommendations I think what we should be doing now is develop rules and procedures on how to work with AI especially AI recommendations because I mean I don't know to what extent you've seen this but we had these reports I can't judge by the way whether
they're accurate or not so I'm just going to put them out there um um we had these reports that allegedly Israel is using um AI enabled systems that give recommendations as to what and who to Target in Gaza so either um um uh places and and and houses that that would be the gospel um or individual people lavender these are the two systems again it hasn't been confirmed but it doesn't matter in this case what what has been reported is that it seems that using these systems the IDF is doing everything wrong what do I mean by is that the system seems good enough I can't judge by that but the system seems to be kind of doing its job and giving recommendations and what the IDF allegedly is doing is basically taking these recommend ations and you know throwing bombs on them to put it very blly without any kind of real checking without kind of you know rules and procedures and that is exactly what what people like myself and many others have
been warning of for the last years that that's not a good idea and so kind of putting rules and procedures in place as to how to use these systems which can be good and can be great and again I have no idea whether these Israeli systems are any good or not but that's not the point here um but kind of making sure that if you use them you kind of you and the the people using them understand what these systems can do and cannot do and then use them properly I think that would be um important so that's my vision on anell that's a very important point that you mentioned that I'm also discussing in a foreign policy right it's the decision support to what extent AI can actually Provide support in decision making because it's okay to have an analytical support it's okay to have a virtual assistant at some points but decision what percentage let's say you know of the Intel is from AI who how much time and that's specifically what lavender
said how much time because they said yes we do have a human in the loop but there's a decision- making process of like two seconds I thought when I read the report and I thought it was really disturbing in a way because if you have two seconds um of decision then it's it's human in the loop but not meaningful human control as the term is used right if you just have a human that then presses the button because the AI told them to then you might as well not have the human like there's no point and in fact it's even it's it's even very unfair to that human being which very likely will be kind of lower level military officer that then can't really take any responsibility so so exactly these debates and again you know it's not as if these debates aren't already happening but I think we need to be kind of very clear on kind of putting these procedures in um in place um there are lots of good developments here but
but yeah the long term may be just five years so let's get on with I may on this two so I may on this two second I mean let's let's be fair when it comes to uh especially ballistic missile defense currently the German Patriot system works in a highly automated mode when it comes to missile defense on a frigate we have the rum capability which also works in the defensive play in a highly automated mode you can then now discuss is this autonomous or is it automated um matter of fact when it comes to certain defensive scenarios you don't have the time to have the human desire to see oh do I fire this missile or that missile you have to have a highly automated process and the Man in the loop is the one who trains the system who who does the uh the the checks who says okay this is the algorithm that I apply this is the probability for this but then the system had to work in automatic mode because there
is no chance for human interference if you want to survive a totally different story is when you apply lethal autonomous weapon systems in an offensive mode and there as as what said how much can you trust the the system how how much can you address the result that your AI decision support enabled system provides to you this is a totally different Affair highly ethical but when it comes to defensive Maneuvers especially in ballistic missile defense Hypersonic defense Etc you don't have really the time to discuss but you need a system that works quickly and and where you have this escalation dominance you see it you can assess it it's a threat and you fight it and in Warfare there's always a risk that you have to take so you must be careful how much risk are you willing to take but but some parts of this autonomy discussion are really not in are not taking place in in real world environments but in the Berlin bubble I mean we took I I guess eight years
to decide whether we can carry a bomb on a drone in Germany that's also not really agile well thank you for the contextualizations I'm going to ask and in order to understand how such systems behave uh Germany has something in the hand with which is unique worldwide it is called the defense metaverse you know the working title which is Ghost play so it was actually initiated by your ministry uh in 2020 2021 and it is how do I know it is unique because I'm being approached um at NATO by different nations who say what Germany has a defense metaverse and you can test AI systems in that defense metaverse you can see what they are doing you can see if they behave in an ethical manner or not and then you tweak and twist it and you revise actually your specification before you actually Implement them and go to the real life with a platforms um there is there were already two two demos life Demos in Washington at the dod uh we had uh
30 people sitting there from the dod and also the intelligence services and the CIA man in the end was very stunned that he did not recognize that Germany is working on something like that UK is in demand Sweden is in demand uh Denmark Spain they all coming and ask what you have something like this this is actually something we would also need and can't we together we the Nations that work together at NATO level can't we just try and get there to develop our capabilities the capabilities we miss together with the use of the defense metaverse so it's a huge thing actually that Germany has in the hand and it it differentiates Germany from approximately 30 other countries so a team at Helmut Schmid university called the defense AI Observatory they have uh done 30 Country studies with regard to where are countries with their defense AI from Turkey to I don't know South Korea to Russia also Ukraine and they figured out there is a cluster and the cluster is in ISR intelligence surveillance
reconnaissance but there are only two countries who are outliers and the one is Germany and the other one is turkey and turkey is betting Almost 100% on full autonomy in weapon systems yeah and so I think that when my vision would be actually in in 5 years that we can deter the adversary with um with technology that that can deter right it does not mean that we have actually this super hper duper technology stuff flying around or driving around which is very vulnerable because it's only I don't know scientific Concepts which are nice to research but don't have any any milit not not any milit but have low military value are very expensive very have very long development cycle so we I want in five years deter the adversary uh to to to to make sure that we can protect Europe and what we all have achieved here in 80 years of Peace time more or less peace time um you're the last one to share your Visions please do so well to quote Helmut
Schmid if you have WIS you should consult your PhD um but um um you know we must be able to bring the bundes into a state of play to be able to participate in multi-domain operations within the next five to six years this is imperative therefore we need to speed up to build all the digital backbone infrastructure that is needed to be able to to sing from this sheet of mus music um and this also includes an AI enabled um methodologies and tools what we're are currently working on is called software defined defense because software defined defense because when when we all have our nice smartphones here in in in the in the audience and and the capability on your smartphone is the application and not the operating system uh and currently we are still too much platform focused and unfortunately Legacy platforms have an IT architecture which make it really difficult to quickly employ or deploy an app uh on a tornado or Euro Fighter typhoon or or some other gear uh therefore we
need to be smart when procuring now on New Gear like fcar like M MGS uh even leopard 28 to to have a sort of application layer on the weapon system so that we can better introduce apps on the system second we have to to build the it backbone that enables us we have to build up test and experimentation structures so in in my vision so to speak uh a a armored infantry battalion has a software update x uh on the platform um in the test and evaluation center we qualify X+ one uh and at the same time in this test and evaluation center our software Engineers are working on X plus2 so that we're in a constant death SEC off cycle that we really get the agility to bring those software apps as quickly as possible to the Warfighter to the front so that's structure and then it's culture its mindset and its people like always you can't introduce digital Solutions against the people you have to take the people with you and and this
is the next effort that we're doing so in in our training uh those digitized Solutions must be an integral part uh we have the privilege of operating to our own universities which provide a lot of capability and a lot of good training to our people so structures will finance people and then we I'm I'm quitting pretty convinced that within the next five to six years we will be making huge progress in in making the bundes able to participate in mdos well thank you you also provided already like the call to action what is needed to uh get to these visions and we don't have time so much but I would ask both of you if you can give me the one thing that you think is necessary to aeve achieve your vision if you if you want to go ahead it doesn't matter you have more time to think about it so so one thing to achieve that vision is that uh we actually have to show in the industry more ambition so we are
very spoiled we were very spoiled from the last 20 20 25 years where we got money from the uh Ministry of defense and it was just a little bit of Maintenance money yeah it was like just to to keep them working a little bit and this mindset is still there and that mindset has to change we need to strive for military objectives we need to give the best support to the uh Ministry of defense and to the Armed Forces to deter the adversary thank you can't come up with one I mean I'm kind of okay so the easy one answer would be an actual s vendor that's maybe too easy what I what I mean by that is that this is such a thing her answer but in the in the way you do we do need a change in in mindset as was just said because I I really do feel especially I guess especially in Germany but anyway it's all in all of Europe we are we don't actually we still don't have
the real sense of urgency that things are changing and changing extremely fast and as you mentioned both in the geopolitical field and the technological field at the same time and so what we need is a realization of that that sense of urgency the money that needs to be put behind that and it's not going to be just the 100 billion fund I'm I'm I'm sorry to say the willingness to work with the private sector like this is this is kind of almost a whole of society effort in a way and I do realize that this is an extremely huge answer because it's like all of these things but yeah that's the best I could come up with because it's not just one thing it's not just money I mean money helps but still it's not just one thing so it's it's all of that a real sighten in thank you thank you all and thank you for kind of going this experiment with me of uh identifying a vision and then coming up with a
call to action although the call to action is still very meta in my opinion but the Visions were interesting in my opinion to see where we actually want to go so thank you all for having for being here and for sharing your knowledge and your expertise