welcome to the next rise of AI virtual chat today with Robin Henson and the topic of immolated minds uploading hyphenating highly fascinating so as usual please introduce yourself just share your LinkedIn profile what you do where your base just say hello please everyone else on LinkedIn if you want to we know from each episode that that you make new context okay um but I want to come directly to the topic and this is the book the age of M by Robin Hanson I have it here I have it for a while because he was supposed to give a talk here in Berlin and then he did a ritual and then I joined and I purchased the book before um let me give some quotes from the book and what this is about and what we speak today about first imagine trillions of emulated Minds living in their own cities which I call very high density server farms so in trillion emulated minds somewhere in the cloud see them as focused workaholics and we have either
robotic bodies or our virtual with our torus augmented reality virtual realities of like this imagine that their brains run up to a thousand times faster or slower then the human brain is working on a constant level depending on the resources the emulated mind has imagined a whole new society of uploads emerging building clients which are either religious or pro open source imagine a system of total surveillance and I don't know how this meant and we will ask him this imagine a system where the economy is doubling every month because of the high high high productivity of these immolated mites and quote from the Tech Talk our guest today gave is first humans must retire and another one immolated minds are the new elite this talk today it's a dream for everyone who's at the post humanism into artificial intelligence or into transhumanism I mean this book here is one of the Bible's of transhumanism out there the community loves it or discussing it but it's very important there if we're already there with books other
books who have focused on this topic to of assimilating a human mind or uploading a mind one is the series out of kaboom yes so check it out if you don't know it's it's on Netflix I thing but it's also book the other one is from Neil Stevenson fall dodged to hell the idea we're rich guys uploaded it is awakening and building a new world another one I like also very much is punch the Apple II which means you don't die anymore but it's a German word and wait everyone who used to live is living again but just virtru and another one which is good on this is the whole series by willem hurtling about a eyes and AI is involving and i will come to this and as once Robin is here and Robin talks about immolated Minds a lot of books speak about the same system society involving if the eye is taking over so this is very very close to it um then for let's see for a second here so if
you google Robin you find plenty of content about him I like his web page because it has this beautiful 19th style he had plenty of essays there about policies and politics and new to system forms but also about you know AI uploading the great filter nanotech you can talk with him for hours about everything um so all he already shared his Ted link there and you can watch it afterwards so I would say this is the best moment to welcome him on stage here's the audio then the video welcome hey I'm here yes we are here um I like to start the first question outside of the topic how did Kona change your lifestyle if it did well I'm a professor so we went to online classes which meant I wasn't going into the classroom my master got a bit and of course I've been home pretty much all the time but that's the standard changing lifestyle most of us have so I still kept my job of course and I got to keep doing
it which is different than many people I feel lucky but it wasn't as big a change as for most people I think okay and just outside of the topic you just published a paper about automation in jobs which is an interesting finding you shared the paper I think this in the chat is it won't go into this for now but you are also still into the AI and future predictions so you think a lot about how the world will be I like to think about the future I'm also just like to be opportunistic I look to look for neglected things where other people aren't doing them and where I can make a contribution and jump on and add a little something ok so I will ask you a couple of questions the audience please ask questions to also look at the pulse and check them out we will speak mainly about the theory of the book and the assumption is that you can create either full digital copy of human mind or take out functions
let's speak a little bit about the basis there your assumption the what's the technology behind it you're building your world on right so the key idea of the book is to take a standard assumption that's been common and futurism in fiction state the assumption and then us build the entire book on that assumption that is to try to work out in detail what would actually happen given that assumption it's a proof of concept showing that we could do a lot more futurism than we've done so far we could take various assumptions and work out their consequences in great detail we haven't done much of that and I'd like people to do more so my key assumption is this idea of an upload or a brain emulation again it's well discussed in order to make precise I tried to pick a version of it that was as simple as possible and the most conservative and so the idea is you take an individual human ring and you scan it in fine spatial and chemical detail to
see exactly which kinds of cells are we're connected to what and then you have computer models of how each kind of cell works which take input signals turn it into changes of state and output signals and then you have a scan of a particular brain mm-hmm where you see where all of this and you have a model of each cell so you could put that together to make a model of the whole brain which enough computer hardware and if you have a good enough scan and good models of each cell then you will have a good enough model of the whole thing in the sense of input-output it will when we send the same sort of signals in and we'll get the same sort of signals out in the same sort of change so that means you could hook it up to artificial eyes ears hands and mouth and then it would act just like the original person would in the same situation and then it will diverge over time only because it lives in
a different world so there that's the key assumption is it's it's not exactly the same as the original human only differing in how it differs so it's not a copy of me like it's not me or is it me just an iteration so when the subject of uploads has come up traditionally people have gotten obsessed with that question and several others and in fact so obsessed they haven't asked the question what would this world look like so I decided to set those questions to sign and say let's just get on with figure out what this world looks like so is it me is it not me I'm not sure there is an answer to that they will think it's them but who knows is it conscious is it not conscious I didn't mean this is it so this purse of this immolated - will believe its itself so it won't think it's just a copy of me and also in your book you said you won't upload everyone you will just take what the hundred
best humans write well well they'll be there'll be a big selection but we should probably get to that in a minute but Sir so basically when the emulation wakes up when you turn it on the last thing it remembers is being human you'll have to convince it it's no longer the human because that's what it remembers and that's what it feels like because that's what would happen to you here you have exactly the same right so from the emulations point of view it sees itself as just a continuity it's the same person continued but of course we don't have to agree with that more commonly m's will copy themselves so the copying of a human to become an m' is only the first step after that ms will often make copies of themselves and then they will have to deal with those copies and which of them are who and so I talk in the book about how they would come to terms with that they would be okay with it and they would be
used to it because that's what helps them get along in their world okay in the part of assumption so we assume that this technology works I'm fine with this because a lot of other books do this - it would be an emulated mind which knows it's an immolated mind after a while and as this new specious unused class of intelligence run where do you see the difference that this is not AI because I would describe it SEI instinct what you could say it's a clap you could just say the class of all artificial lines is all AI but in that vast space there's enormous range of possibilities this is one narrow subset in that space but it's a subset that's especially likely to actually happen and it's a subset for which we can actually say a lot more about what the consequences are we've been around people for a long time and we know a lot of things about people in human minds and so once we have a world of emulated human minds we
can say that a lot about what that world is like much more than we can say about this the abstract space of AI because the abstract space of I there's all these different possible Minds could be ok so I take the audience now mind on the journey because this for podcast this is for live show this is for everyone we can upload our brains we have immolated minds and now you discuss a new book physics economics organization so thoughts so so logic like right so well let me finish off on the assumptions the key assumptions so first of all I say early once we have emulations we'll be able to make them but not understand that very well mm-hmm we will have succeeded in putting these copies together but they're enormously complicated spaghetti code and we won't know how to edit them we won't be able to take someone to music on someone else's sports ability and Christmas vacation memory move them around to change them you'll just be able to turn it on turn
it off run it fast run it slow make a copy delete it those are the things you can do initially and now eventually we would have more capabilities but I still thought there was an interesting story to tell with those limited capabilities at the beginning and the other piece assumptions I'm making is that all of our usual theories in most areas continue to be true including in social science and economics so but many people in futurism hope that our ordinary economic world of firms and capital and profit and interest rates that's all some temporary thing that will all go away when some new future things show up and I'm definitely not assuming that I'm assuming that most of the big social structures we've seen over thin the world for many centuries are relatively permanent features that will continue and so I assume the the world continues with those large familiar social structures of Nations and law and firms and labor and requirement war for a while because I mean if humans retire it might you
know society my calls but I've lost you this later so what one other key assumption is I'm not trying to tell you the entire future but I'm just trying to tell you about the age of them in which similar amount to change would happen then during the entire industrial era or the entire farming era or the entire foraging air before the farming here those are the main three errors before the age of M foragers farmers industry in that progression of foragers farmer industry M s what we've seen as growth rates have greatly sped up each time and so the time scale has been compressed even though in each era we have seen a similar number of humans so this next era fit follows this progression could see a similar number of total humans maybe a trillion in some sense or more but it would be compressed into maybe one or two years and then the dur which something else happens and I'm not going to tell you so I'm only trying to tell you about
the age about I understand and I had him with Chris post last week a week and he discussed similar he call it the age of knowledge worker of knowledge yes it's similar he just wants to humans to be this not an emulated mind the first question why why should we do it like what are the percent benefits floss okay machines I am an economist and we economists are in the habit of predicting what will happen and then even if nobody wants it okay our economic analysis doesn't predict that people want what happens okay what we predict is that each little thing each person does is what they want but the net effect of all the things that everybody does doesn't necessarily have to be something anybody wants so I'm predicting what will happen first and foremost and then I have some comments about what's good or bad but my priority is just to predict what's most likely to happen if we did the least to avoid it okay so go ahead and decide we hate
it and go out way out of our way trying real hard to prevent it that's possible but first you should guess should look at what's likely to happen if you don't try to prevent it in order to decide whether you want to do that okay so since ela must come to Nora link and Ava's are working on brain machine interfaces we know that this even small trend is emerging and this will grow and swing it's likely to happen we discussed if it happens what's that so let's go to the what then and I keep with the book about you call it physics so if it's like scaling infrastructure appearance right and death and let's start with the easy one like how can we envision how this world will look like okay so you have a brain and then you live in the world around you which is in some sense in your brain but you know it feels like you're in the world so you're in a room right now I'm in a river we
see paint on the wall we see some decorations on the wall behind the paint there are pipes and struts and things like that we abstractly know they're there but we don't care about them much what we care about is the room as it seems as it appears to us so in the world of emulations they will actually be in computers of course just like you are actually in your brain those computers will be sitting in server racks and server farms if you like but from their point of view they will be living in virtual reality they will be living in a reality that is as real to them as yours is to you but it's reality that they can then construct and change as they like so it's very cheap for the virtuality to be gorgeous and beautiful luxurious you never need to feel pain disease grime wonderful any of those things but the world they know is our is artificial but just like you know the world your room is artificial that paint wasn't
naturally there you put the paint there so that you would like the way looked and that's the kind of world they live it now so some of them do physical jobs and so for those physical jobs they have to have a realistic sense of their physical world so some sometimes they you know take off their virtual reality blinders and they see the physical world they're in and then it's more harsh and functional they see the server racks they see that big cooling pipes they see the power plants they see the big girders they see that their city is primarily a big set of physical in structure the sort of thing you can see behind your walls if you looked at it a little bit it but they don't usually choose to see it because you don't usually choose to look behind your walls no no I I mean I I don't know this is the ground truth or this is the ground simulation I like a discussion like Elon also have liked to have more
simulations like parallel universe and so for its right it's very interesting in this place I imagined that one day a lot of humans will be in the VR like full-time because they are cheaper than living here now the idea of a simulation is where you don't know you're in a simulation and that would be rare formulations they would usually know it they would be happy in control of but they still would choose it that way just like you could live in a world where you'd see through your walls and see the beams and stand wires and everything but you don't choose that usually because you don't want to see that and therefore they will suddenly not want to see that stuff so I jumped here but how can imagine interacting with them because you you put them into labor work there they are supposed to work and take over tasks which we don't want to do a we can't do and they do it better so what can we imagine it example well we will
have contact with them or not seen them but they are select let's just go back to the basics of we said we're gonna predict a world that isn't necessary what anybody wants why does it happen so the key idea is that these emulations are cheaper than humans right and they can do pretty much anything humans can do because they are human minds right and they are selected to be the best so the emulation economy is a competitive capitalist economy and it selects from all humans to scan and workers the few best the last few hundred best and it makes billions and trillions of copies of those through few hundred best humans SMS and most of the rest of humanity can become an emulation if they want but they'll kind of have to pay their way now humans start out owning all the wealth in this world so humans on average are rich they're they're basically the rich capitalists of this world who sit behind luxuriously leisurely work not working and taking all the income that
their capital returns way this one doesn't work today because 1% of capital you know 90% of capital is owned by a very small minority and if you will play this it means the richest people have a copy of themselves working for them and the rest would either die all we had that conditional basically well it's probably even the poorest humans can probably afford to make an emulation copy of themselves but it's only the best so in the poorest people not only the best will get paid by others to make the copy but it's making the copies cheap enough you can just pay for it yourself but you can't make billions of copies you could just make one copy maybe so you could yourself choose to move into the emulation world live a life of leisure there you could probably live more comfortably there if you believe that's you but many humans will say no that's not me I don't want to become an emulation and for them then there's the issue is they've lost their
job how do they survive so I recommend that people will for tuning now and then require some sort of insurance or sharing arrangements so that they don't starve when they lose their job that's there's plenty of warning there's plenty of time ahead to get prepared but we should prepare but it's best prepared you could be rich so if this Akane doubles every month your wealth doubles every month even a small nest egg over a relatively modest time grows to be large I think the biggest thing that humans should be worried about is that this age of them only last year or two and I don't tell you what comes next so you have very little long-term security in terms of can you last a long time comfortably because this whole age only lasts a short time so do they have rights civil rights human barrettes corporate brides and Geauga rights isn't a legal entity or what is this legal like because lawyers want to notice and government to again my method is to go for
each area of life in the civilization go to our standard academic literature on that topic and ask what is our best simple predictions that this literature has for this case of emulation so if we go to the literature on rights what we find is rights are not strongly predicted by the basic structure of each world for example we could have slaves slaves in our world today that's logically possible it's not prevented by the nature of our world therefore it's not obvious that any other world couldn't have slaves but we can say some things about where those stronger pressures are so I teach law and economics and that's all about how we choose laws including rights and we have a lot of ways to talk about which rights are efficient versus otherwise so for any particular world there's two main factors that predict that world one is what is efficient that is what does what just makes more together total and the other is what do people want such that they get what they want now
if you look at our ancestors a thousand years ago and longer in the farming era they were living near subsistence that is they were mostly pretty poor and in a subsistence world people mostly do what it takes to survive that's so it's relatively easy to predict what they do because what they do doesn't depend that much on what they want well before you do what you have to do regardless of what you want or you don't exist so we are now in this unusual era today we're rich so Labrecque what we do and you have to know a lot more about what we want to find out what we will do so we want rights and so we have rights mm-hmm even if they're not efficient the age of M is an error that returns more to this historical tradition of being people be poor and near living near subsistence and so that actually makes it easier for me to predict things about the age of M if the age of M was rich who
then would not know what they wanted and so we didn't know what they would do but because they're poor I can predict at least what the poor ants do but again what will help we will treat them because this comes to death it's my copy my immolate mi the owner will they own themselves is it like a software estimate present world so when we see humans like us mixed together with the emulations the humans are rich and the emulations or not but the emulations are the vast majority of this new economy and the humilation czar on the side relatively marginal so we can predict that this em economy will do the things that are efficient in the sense of that allow the economy to function and be productive and then on the margin the humans can have whatever rights they want if they can afford them so humans may well look on these ms and disapprove and see that and not think of them as illegitimate but the emulations will see themselves as legitimate and
therefore warm so I mean war will happen regardless in almost any world that we can imagine I won't predict a lack of war but I would predict that war isn't endemic and in all the time happening just like even the shore like paddles or so would tend to be more cyber world the human infrastructure like the cell phones everything is just run on the simulated mines so from the point of view for the MS actually ends live in a world where wages are near subsistence and so it turns out there isn't that much advantage in owning slaves in that world so ok our distant ancestors when there were in a world where labor was scarce and land was plentiful mm-hmm then wages were high and there was a point to owning slaves but when labor was plentiful of land was scarce then wages was false a subsistence level and so if you owned a slave you had to pay to feed them which is about much is you'd have to pay a free worker anyway
so there wasn't much of an advantage to owning slaves so we can say that the ends living a subsistence society where there's not much point to owning slaves there's not much point to enslaving them so if they are more productive they see themselves as free you'd probably make them free just so they could see themselves as as free and be more productive so that would be my best guess it's not a strong prediction it's just to say this isn't the kind of world where slavery gains you much where it doesn't you know there's not much point in owning it's like so humans may not that doesn't mean the humans will grant them all rights in their head of thinking they're good but from the emulations point of view they will have whatever freedoms are necessary to make their society productive because that's what allows the humans to be rich okay so Thomas brought the book the quantum chief and then he speaks about uploaded Minds to who first become very very like floating servers in
the in the universe and they have a lot of iterations and improvements and send out their own iterations in the world and then in the story you meet like version 1.5 and version 2.3 and something like this and it's a hierarchy level but the goal is eternal life is this because you speak about death and this could be over very fast let's speak about timing okay so first of all the there's the moment when emulations become possible and a key assumption my analysis which we didn't mention is at that moment we don't have really strong AI of other sorts okay okay that is at that moment humans are still valuable and so the emulations that swap in for them are also valuable if the human nations if the humans weren't valuable at the moment you can make a mess then the m's wouldn't be valuable either probably because the whatever you were using instead would still be valuable so the first moment emulations are possible they swap in for the humans they start doing all
the jobs that humans were doing before mm-hmm ai is still a thing on the side but not powerful enough to replace the MS over time of course AI will improve and then we could think in the long run which I've done a fair bit up of eventually when AI competes with them is who wins where but we can be more confident than initially there'll be this big explosion in using MS and then there'll be this effort to improve them so it's harder to predict how fast that effort to improve them will will go but I can be more confident there'll be this initial era where you don't improve them much but you make a lot of them and so that's what my age of M book is mainly about is about this era where you can make them you make a lot and then you can again make copies you can run them faster run them slow you can put them all sorts of different environments but they are black boxes spaghetti code you you
can make what I call tweaks you can make some minor modifications maybe like drugs basically for us you can throw in some equivalent of chemicals that change their mood or make them more active or sleepy or things like that but you can't reorganize their minds that much and therefore my book is about that now I do have some things to say about what happens after that but I just want to clearly distinguish the age of M which is about this era where we don't change them very much should the eras afterwards where they get modified more and then then compete more which they are then we speak about the time after the age of M towards the end let's look at first and how will the ecosystem look like I mean not everyone has read your book and how can they imagine like doubling their company month so what I haven't told them is that ends will concentrate into a small number of very dense cities so we get most of our value amount of
concentrating into cities but we don't all come into one big city on the earth and the reason is that as our cities get bigger they have congestion travel and traffic gets more of a problem mm-hm and but with emulations when they are in the city they can meet with each other without actually moving they just send the virtual reality signals about how they are moving in the room say and then how their face is changing and things like that kind of like where we're doing here and so they don't actually have to move to near each other in order to interact and that allows their cities to be much bigger so they have less traffic congestion costs and therefore they have more what we call it la more Asian economies the gains from concentrating together and so they together into one big city or a half dozen big cities but not thousands like we do today and so that means their physical presence is concentrated in a small number of places on the earth they
are not spread across the entire earth because they don't want to be of course just like humans today we are actually pretty concentrated in a smaller number of places so so even as the emulations of becoming a big deal the humans are spread out more on the rest of the earth and the emulations aren't taking over the space from the humans because the emulations don't want that space so much the emulations will want the places where they get the raw materials and the places where they get energy the places when they dump their trash and dump their raw heat those are the places that are influenced by the MS but the rest of the earth initially isn't of interest to them now of course eventually the MS would take over the whole earth if we go over long-term growth rates but not in the first year or two which is what I'm focused on okay so um there is in real currently the trend that server Parks who are historical outside of cities and that
they will have a lot of location of people living around it because first for business you have a short latency so you want to be close to the hub and second because they produce so much heat does heat excuse to energize the environment around so in some areas this will happen that people will live there where the cloud is like where the service are closer to being to the source so the emulation cities will soon be so large that humans won't want to be near them won't be able to survive near them they will not be friendly for humans so a problem is that the very first places to make the emulation cities will naturally be in the first data centers which are somewhat near human concentrations so initially the first M cities will be near human cities because they will grow out of the first data centers but then there will be a conflict as they try to go larger they would then be displacing those human cities and that will be sort of
the initial conflict of pushing away the humans away from where the humans were your immolated mines are the owning property assets or is this owned by the original giver of the brain upload initially humans on everything but humans will find it useful to allow MS to own things just like even my humans own slaves actually slaves own things yes the slaves were allowed to collect their own income and this period wather and freedom by dr. Andreas right so the emulations we'll still own some things and it turns out that that their growth rate of what they own will be faster than the growth rate of a human's own so over time their fraction of the economy will grow and that's just because they're near the center of activity so already today we have what we call an agency cost a private company owned by the people who run it get higher rates of return than a public company or owned by people who aren't involved and that's the humans for this case what humans are
these distant investors who then don't get as high rate of return on their investments as the m's who do or who are more close to the action so that means that over time ends will grow on a larger growing share of the economy but still initially humans start out owning most everything and therefore they're gaining getting most of the gate ok you have then something you call politics rules and what will be what kind of policies will they have like will we see so I'm not sure I answered your question about time scales and death because I think you were hinting about death before no you just said you don't know it because I do I do know we maybe I do know about death we're about rights so as soon as you are an emulation you are a creature that's in principle immortal because you're stored as a computer file somewhere that can be backed up and restored and so if you had enough resources you could from that point on be immortal if
you had an immortal society to support you of course if the society blows itself up and goes extinct your immortality is ended at that point - so the problem is today houses and cars are in principle immortal that is if we paid enough we could keep our houses and cars going on it definitely but we usually don't so just because MSR in principle immortal doesn't mean they are in practice immortal it'll be a matter of whether they can afford your mortality whether they choose to because it still needs an NG to to run them yes Jimmy needs resources to keep going now animals will have a limited career length because the human mind appears to age even without physical contributions so your brain is a physical thing with physical or you know cells and those cells do age but your brain seems to age in addition to your cells aging just in structure of your brain changing in the way it does by your learning that ages and that tends to make your brain over
time more fragile and harder to learn and harder to adapt and so therefore even emulations will also over time their minds will become a fragile and harder to adapt and that means they would have a limited career length say a century or several centuries subjectively after which they need to be retired and replaced by younger versions themselves I know sir retirees don't have to die however like so I'm like Neil merging with the source code again and part three I think what you really do is just get replaced by a younger version of yourself right it's a little bit like cloning maybe will tell you you're merging but you really not you're just going away and we're being replaced yes it's like heaven okay then they would retire though and these retirees would probably run slow because that's much cheaper and so when you're running slow how long you can live subjectively just depends mainly on the stability of the Somoza interesting personal thing I can tell you and I with let's say one human
Dane I could live a thousand years in my mind that would be running fast that would be the way I roll with you okay but if you run very slow you see it might be only a subjective day in which after which you know the outside world has gone a thousand years but what if the about outside world can't last a thousand years interest peace and prosperity that you don't last the day you see will so I'm feeling that those immolations they will have human traits like great like of course laughs like passions is a criminal or not so I assume that will be first conflict and there will be an enforcement to make sure that even those keep to their own laws how do you see this how is a lot of villains again I'm an economist and I teach law and economics so I'm familiar with our current theories about how we keep the peace in our world and those theories seem plenty sufficient to continue to keep the peace in the emulation
world as best you can that is today we have property things we own and then we make private choices like where did what to wear to work and where to live and who our friends are and then we live in a larger society which has law and governance to handle some larger issues that are harder to handle at the local level and so Emma's would again have property make personal choices but also live in the context of corporations of charities of governance law and all of those things would change somewhat for m's but they don't necessarily have to change enormous lis they their world can continue to function but of course again war is still possible and war probably will eventually happen because we haven't a limited war from our world either if we're has been a very stable feature of our world for a long time you you are very imprecise in between so will immolate Minds control themselves or would humans try to control them because you have a police you have a
legal system all these are still in impact and you want to roll it over you said I think as a practical matter the emulations have to be given a lot of autonomy so even if we look at the case of slavery say in the u.s. South the more complicated the slaves jobs were the more autonomy the slaves had to be given in order to manage those jobs so if you were just in the field picking cotton or something you didn't have much autonomy because there wasn't much autonomy needed but if you were logging or running a shop in the city or even a house slave you were basically given a lot more autonomy and the treated less harshly because we had to trust you to make a lot of choices and we didn't want you really mad at us so the emulations will basically have to be given a lot of autonomy because they're running the emulation world the we humans are just too slow in the distance so I haven't mentioned that on average
I has to make emulations run about a thousand times human speed a thousand times so as I said even two years a whole society could emerge and : right so like in two years in two years of human times these simulations would experience 2,000 years so Roman Empire mortals also we don't need a chef well we can watch it from a distance but it'll be really fast so that's one of the reasons humans just can't control this world very in much detail is it's just going too fast for them then and they don't understand it and they aren't there on the ground experiencing it so for everyone else dodge fought to hell is doing the same it's the speed is varying to human life so either you can be like you can't speed it up or not all the movie here is really good where you have this conflict wait when AI is speeding up so much that it's leaving humankind because she just slow my favorite book is a human life for me it's
like reading a book but only one word per day well so in the age of M these aims themselves with variant speeds because they can and that's probably produces a class distinction they would split into different classes of Em's and the high speed M's were high class high speed M's have all the markings of many of the markings of high status in our world they embody more wealth they know things fresh they win arguments they host meetings and so there becomes this class hierarchy and in fact the retirees are lower class they're expect more like ghosts ghosts are very low class units world they're very slow your world salts all full well because of here - why taking the real world and just making more extreme so the super rich will get super rich or richer because they combine more resources and those left behind if no chance to keep up I have a section on inequality ok talk about inequality in this world so first of all in our world recently we have only
been concerned about one very particular kind of inequality about them out of all the kinds of inequality there are we have focused on inequality between the families of a nation at a time so yeah that doesn't include the inequality within families which is actually larger than the inequality between the families of a nation it doesn't mean include the inequalities across nations which is actually larger than the inequality within nations and it doesn't include inequality across time which is actually larger than the inequality at a time mm-hmm and it those those are all usually about financial inequality and they're not focused on inequality and popularity sex appeal wisdom intelligence all sorts of other things so if we just focused on inequality between the families of a nation for the M world that's relatively equal because of the subsistence wages they're basically making similar wages because everybody's making very low wages CIC they can own property and I assume some MS will hire em to run for them and you will have corporations owned and run by
MS so they will be smart so capital will matter less but there will be capital and capital can accumulate into larger inequality over time because of the immortality effect so today one of the things that limits inequality and capital is the drags drags and three generations effect where somebody figures out a way to get rich but they don't pass that habit on to their children are the grandchildren and then they eventually get poor again but because emulations can be immortal then once an emulation finds a habit of mind and style that allows them to get and stay rich then they can keep that going over a longer time so that would produce more inequality of capital but again within a bigger kind of inequality that we don't pay much attention to today but that the m's would pay more attention to is the inequality between clans so you and I safe would go back five generations we asked each of our ancestors five generations ago how many descendants did they have and that will probably
meet quite unequal some of us may have far more descendants now compared than others relative to five generations but we hardly ever talk about we don't care about that that's the kind of inequality and then Em's would have a lot of because again out of all these humans only a few hundred of them are giving rise to most of the MS and so therefore the EM clans are very unequal but individuals within each clan are pretty poor so then from you know our point of view a the question is how much do we care about the kind of inequality they would have a lot of and how much will they care will so I'm because we have two questions there and I will ask them in public and support my last there is will they s6 of course and they reproduce primarily by making copies and so the role of sex and reproduction is cut out and so that's why they will be much more liberal and live in and live-and-let-live about sex because sex
doesn't matter as much directly for their world so our ancestors cared a lot about sex in part because sex was central to reproduction essential sex with centrioles who who grew and who didn't and so they wanted to control that in order to control this central part of their world but for em sexes is a side part in a sense although it's very important psychologically because they are humans who who have all the same feelings that we do about sex but I talk in the book about the mating problem which is that we tend to like pair bonding we have one person to another person and a particular agender matched pair bonding a male to a female and there's no particular reason that the EM economy will want equal numbers of men and women and we serve about genders is there still agenda in the race because it's virtual well again you're right but it's in your head but of course most of your gender is in your head right now I know I have familial
and non-binary at the end and we all somewhere soft but is will there be gender or not or is it absolutely will we have a more tender is in your head but it's real and your real in your head and so they will still have the sort of genders that are in their head and so again we have the assumption we aren't modifying their brains greatly which means we aren't also modifying the gender in their brain greatly which means that they have this inclination toward a mental style of a particular gender and they want to pair bond with someone of the other gender and that means they will that will be a thing they want and that will be frustrated in part because they won't necessarily be equal numbers of genders in their world so in our world we're sort of biologically guaranteed to have roughly equal numbers of males and females and they are not and so I go into in the book into some detail about how they can deal with that so
there's fast-slow pair bonds and there's other sorts of ways they can accommodate that but that would be one of their potential frustrations another frustration is they don't have children the way we do and so their parenting urges will also be somewhat frustrated because again they're making copies instead of having children they will adopt humans then okay first question by Li cleaver and he asked what special interest groups are most likely to oppose yemm's and what rules are they likely to try to pass to preserve the value of their obsolete capital so we're talking about enormous changes absolutely astounding changes so anybody who actually foresaw the changes might well be reluctant to the have them so just like you can imagine someone who is a farmer a thousand years ago and you tell them about the industrial world and they would just cringe and they go you know I like some parts of that but I don't like the rest of it you can imagine talking to foragers a hundred thousand years think about farming and
they would have been reluctant to have large parts of it so just as a matter of habit most everybody will sort of cringe and be reluctant to endorse this world but of course there won't necessarily be a moment when they are asked it would happen gradually over time and so then the question is when would people go out of their way to oppose some particular thing that's happening well interest groups who do who will lose the most like for example church land owners capital owners workforce who do you think will be the initial thing is whoever is being out competed for these jobs so you know emulations will show up first in some industries and some professions and there they will replace the human workers in those jobs just like today Automation often replaces human workers and then those human workers may or may not complain a lot about being displaced similarly humans will dislike being displaced here one of the biggest conflicts I haven't mentioned is that the initial scanning process is likely to
be destructive later on you would be able to scan a human and make an M without destroying the human in the first place but first you would probably be destroying the human brain in order to make the emulation so if somebody chooses to become another nation they are therefore not becoming a human anymore and other people who disapprove may call that murder may call that suicide and try to get at that okay furthermore initially the emulation will want older workers are already skills in their professions at the peak of their professional abilities but after a while the emulation will or will diverge enough from our world that the emulation world will not be interested in the peak lawyer or the peak software engineer in our world they will want younger Minds who are more flexible and able to learn how to deal with the emulation world that means relatively quickly the emulation world will want to scan destructively scan human children to create emulation Minds able to flexibly learn the new memorization jobs and so
you can imagine humans being quite opposed to allowing the destructive scan of human children brains in order to create productive humans now you know even if those children agree and their parents agree you could easily imagine other people of jacket next question because we're for currently and we have a little bit like 10 minutes left um Jacob asks do you ever plan to ride en fiction even they they are little stars with no plot just try to show a normal day for an e/m it might help people to understand the world you're predicting it might I've had many people tell me they prefer their fiction futurism in the form of fictions I do I have large files of notes on possible fiction on the other hand it takes people years to learn to get good at writing fiction I'm I'm I'm definitely know that that's a skill of it takes a lot of training and learning to become let's go I have not acquired that skill and so so far I have not done that
I I have sort of large sort of plot things but the details of an engine of a person's day are actually some of the hardest things to predict so I am opportunistically worked in my book to find the things that I could say things about and say things about those things and be quiet about the things I could not speak to so that's part of the problem with fiction you'll still have to make up a bunch of stuff that you can't predict very well but you people want stories they're a good question by Jake he says what I give falls on a new TV show called upload in it people are uploaded after they die it's pretty different from the e/m world because uploads are not copied and they are forbidden to work saying just commenting it it's a great series on a certain level and they are only forbidden to work because of all the logic you are explained because they would be cheaper and more powerful and then they would own property at
the end and will take everything over so I have watched the series mhm uh you know it's pretty in the terms of its 4k and it's set in a pretty environment so my eyes just approve of the visuals yes and the characters are engaging and you know believable characters the clearly the people setting the show just wanted to tell a story about heaven upload is there mechanism to put people in heaven they like a story of a love story between someone who lives in heaven and and a whether it's called dot and fall to hell because this assumption is you want to go to heaven and as hell at the end right so and that book also does the same thing it's really interested in the Heaven and Hell story and so it just arbitrarily cuts off the other our options that would make other things happen now actually in this world of the upload TV show in a competitive arge competitive world somebody somewhere would decide to make trillions of dollars by having these
uploads not be to be allowed to work that would just be a thing that would happen very quickly and then this whole story would change yes so but there's lots of stories that are like that you want to tell a certain story and so you just push aside all the other possibilities so you couldn't you know stick on the one you want okay but in my book I was asking what would actually happen and again so my book is like science fiction except there's no plot and there's no characters and it all makes sense and that last thing is the hard part and that's usually what most people writing fiction don't bother to do because they want to tell an entertaining sorry so I want there to be a genre of people who write things where the focus is on it all making sense and less on making you know some story work okay turning to the last question which we have here from Dave a little bit longer so you Robert you think that
fully conscience self-directed agents will dominate and will be the first true AI these will be perfect simulations of humans while this may be possible adventure to get a perfect copy to get that copy would be very difficult because of the non tribal nature of human biology and especially the brain so wouldn't an Apple project end up with a no amorphic e/m that may be good enough way before any successful upload of any person this e/m might be the best human alike I think he touched what you said under your social beginning right so there's some related questions there one is in essence how simple our brain cells compared to brains so this idea of a neuromorphic AI is to say where we're going to look at the structure of a brain and we're gonna make an AI that has many of the similar structures but not in great detail so the idea is there's some larger structure there that you can see once you can see enough structure that is the key to AI and
if you have that structure you have human level intelligence mm-hmm so that's a claim about the nature of AI and the nature of intelligence so my presumption and position is that there is no single central algorithm that once you have that algorithm boom you have super intelligence all the way there's just lots of little algorithms that you have to accumulate over time at great cost and the more of them you have the smarter your system is and the human brain is just a large collection of those little logarithms yes yeah so under that view there is no Singh overall structure that gives you the neuromorphic AI that lets you replace humans there's just all this messy detail and so in that sense I'd say you know brains are more complicated than brain cells for to make emulations work the main thing you need to have is good enough models of each brain cells now brain cells are enormous ly complicated here but we only need to model the parts of the brain cells that are
relevant for their computation ie for signals into signals out plausibly that's only a small fraction of the brain cells which is true for most other functions that cells do in the body your bone cells your blood cells your you know muscle cells those are very complicated but the key function that they provide the rest of your body is relatively simple so you can replace that function with vastly less complexity than it takes to model that entirely cell and that's plausibly true for self brain cells as well in fact we have many decent models of many kinds of rein cells and that's confirmed with those models the essential function of those cells can be reproduced at a much smaller complexity that it takes to model all the details so question by Lina she asked if I understood you correctly EMS would be aware of the world around them for example the human this cancer is the ancestry and in which scenarios would it make sense that they don't know this for example remain in an informational
restricted environment sure so once simulations are possible that emulations would allow that to happen in order to test and prove their loyalty and to train them so you know today often we read and like stories about extreme scenarios that we hardly ever experience but we like the idea that we are at least somehow trained for those scenarios like a bank robbery because we've seen them at fiction mm-hmm so emulations would symbol it similarly say gee I wonder what will happen in the scream cicero's am I prepared for that am I ready for my trust worthy of that and so they will agree and say okay people around me in the system around me you're allowed to every once in a while SWAT me into a simulation where I don't know it's a simulation but it looks to me like the real world and then you can test me in that situation you can see a my loyal do I freak out do I keep a level head I want that to happen because I want
to be trained for those situations and I want to prove to people around me that I am reliable in those situations so they will agree to those simulations and such simulations could also have a number of other purposes that I talked about in the book and so there would be a background rate at which at any one moment you might be in one of these simulations designed for one of these purposes and you would have agreed to that exactly because you want to be tested now of course that means anytime there's an a weird thing going on you think yourself this is probably a simulation then you think well I want to show that I do well in the simulation so let's go do and so you would therefore in a real crisis probably be more reliable and more on on Arden and more planning and reliable because you you were we're all ready for this so I have um asked some polls before to the audience and I would like to read the results
out form minute because not everyone is watching a lot of people are also listening in so I asked should we researched how to create executable digital models of brains so and then should we go for this what you suggested and 66% of the audience here today said yes only one person said no and the rest said like maybe but okay then I shook those copies have certain rhymes and interestingly only 20% said yes like like a legal company 50% sets on the long run they will be like humans no one said no no one said no and 25% said I'm not sure yet I have to decide later and the last question I asked like how will humans and immolated coexist and I asked them a those related minds are the work force for humans the wealth is shared amongst the physical humans 50% said this will the option then another 15% said no I'm elated minds will have their own economy no one said here in the chat that there will be only one
higher form of intelligence and 70% of the audience said we might coexist in a symbiosis so there is a wishful thinking that they will be good for us and we will have better society this brings me to the last point you spoke about the times after the age of M so first let me just comment on that last integration point there is a risk that if the human society is separated too much from the emulation Society that the emulations will say what do we need those humans for let's just go take all their stuff what that's a scenario that many people have been worried about the more integrated the emulations are with the human society using the same structures of politics finance law etc then the more expensive it would be for the emulations to turn and say let's just take all their stuff because everybody wonder who's next I mean that's what happened you know today we could all kill our retirees and take their stuff but we know that would be very disruptive
to our society so I recommend keeping as integration as long and as strongly as possible in order to prevent the scenario where the emulation say they a let's just kill for the humans they're there they're useless right after the age of M is not clear that there's a sudden transition but there'd be a gradual transition in two dimensions one is that other kinds of AI would slowly get more capable mm-hmm and the other is that the emulations and cells have become more modifiable they we would understand them in a deeper levels and be able to make larger more useful changes and then the question is which of those when where and so I've actually done a bit of work in the last year or two on that question and I think I can identify which of them wins where and the key conclusion is the emulations win in a lot of places that is some people have this fear that once you have competition between emulations and AI then the AI just wins and humans
no longer have a place the only way the humans can have a place is not be being more productive somewhere by by being in control and so many people say we must maintain an iron grip of control because if we ever let go we are lost because we'll never win a competition yeah I think that's wrong my assumption is that we will have emulated Minds we will have a eyes we will have uploads or just tweaks of uploads we will have cyborgs androids we will have a huge variety of different forms how intelligence will express itself they call it the new compression explosion yes but even today for example we have a Cambrian explosion of firms but we still have many features that are common across firms we have many ways in which in a competitive environment some features just lose out because they're not so competitive you know and so for example there are many kinds of most animals that ever existed aren't around anymore most plants that ever existed they've been out competed
so it could well be that even though there's a lot of variety that variety will all stay within a certain range of what was the most effective and that's a reasonable fear then about through so for example you know there are just very few firms that allow their employees to anything they want all day you might say well there's a big world and so some firms would be like that but really hardly any furniture like that so well I thank you for this our highly interesting way more I recommend checking out his website because he has written a lot way more so I think thank you for being today here in the show you're most welcome and I talk to you again if someone has a question I have shared his LinkedIn profile on his website just shoot him a message he's active on Twitter I have shared that the Twitter feed profile up too and I say goodbye Robin thank you and everyone else stay in for a minute take a um so for
everyone else still here and that was really nice that was really interesting I honestly this is what I love about the virtual chat I can invite people who write cool books and I could talk to them and you can ask them questions and there was so much fun Wow I'm pushed I pushed if you follow my Instagram stories you know I had a bad week so this is really really cool um next week we had come back to reality but we have here in our show the first time a member of the German parliament it's it's MVB member of the German parliament Tomas halma and Tomas Hammond he is a former intrapreneur he's a business angel yet in visiting sing LinkedIn Facebook so he's coming from the Czech industry and now he's for what now two or three years in the Parliament and he has a radical new book out there he published it this week and he will speak up on his book next week and the thesis is let's assume we can redesign
government and policy making and bureaucracy that it fits to the 21st century how will this look like I have read this book it's very it's good but it's too much to discuss and one I call it he calls noise start I call a pivot the government how we can have a digital state so next week you should join in if you want to learn how you know if you messed up about how politics works your chance to learn how politics could be better and to ask a politician directly online hey by the way this sucks how would you suggest how would you do it and we would talk about AI blockchain decentralized systems everything out in the politics so um that was ah there we go that was the show for today um thank you for coming in I say goodbye to the world you will get the follow-up email in a second I will publish a link of all the books and also an Amazon link of the book of Robin and so you
can purchase them or not it was a joy and goodbye we see again soon bye bye