Rise of AI Virtual Chat 2020 · Berlin

Open Innovation for AI Adoption

Marcel ‘Otto’ Yon · Founder and CEO of the German Armed Forces digital innovation unit

In this Rise of AI Virtual Chat from September 2020, host Fabian Westerheide talks with Marcel 'Otto' Yon, who spent his last four years as founder and CEO of the German Armed Forces' digital innovation unit and earlier built companies in facial recognition, later used in German passports, and in image recognition for cancer detection. Drawing on roughly 50 corporate and military innovation units he has studied, Yon lays out five traits of the successful ones: a focus on execution rather than ideas, direct reporting to the CEO, positioning as an internal competitor to the core business, room to grow instead of an early handoff, and mixed teams of insiders and outside entrepreneurs. The conversation covers why German organizations move slowly compared with the US, citing accountability culture and business-to-government sales cycles of around ten years, why diversity in leadership means more than gender, how his unit built trust with soldiers, startups and allied militaries, the personal backlash he faced, and his view that AI's exponential growth will leave organizations too little time to adapt once the curve turns steep.

Key takeaways

  • Yon says the most successful innovation units report directly to the CEO and act as an internal competitor to the core business.
  • He argues large organizations must shift from 'critical mass' to 'critical initiative' since size now slows them down.
  • He says his military innovation unit reached 40 percent women, showing gender diversity is achievable even in conservative settings.
  • He attributes Germany's roughly ten-year B2G technology sales cycle partly to a culture that rewards avoiding mistakes over achieving results.
  • He warns exponential AI adoption can look flat for years before crossing an acceptance threshold too quickly for large organizations to adapt.

Detailed notes

Five traits of successful innovation units

Yon says that after analyzing military innovation units across the Western world and about 50 corporate ones, five recurring themes separate the successful from the struggling: the unit's value lies in execution rather than ideation; the most successful units report directly to the CEO rather than to a CIO, CFO or lower management; disruptive units work best when positioned as an internal competitor to the core business rather than in harmony with it; projects should be allowed to grow into new core activities instead of being handed off early, since early handoffs tend to fail; and the strongest teams mix people from inside the organization with experienced outside serial entrepreneurs. He illustrates the reporting point with Walmart, which failed at digital transformation three times before succeeding on a fourth attempt once the CEO appointed a co-CEO dedicated to digital, and with the US Air Force, where a digital-innovation leader was promoted to deputy CIO of an organization larger than the entire German military.

From critical mass to critical initiative

Yon argues that large organizations need a cultural shift from what used to be an advantage, critical mass, to what he calls critical initiative, since size now makes organizations slower rather than stronger. He says most C-suites reflect the business as it has been rather than as it needs to be in ten years, and calls for more entrepreneurial diversity in leadership rather than boards composed only of people who know how to run the existing business. As an example of rapid cultural change, he cites Singapore's military and defense procurement organization, which moved a culture program from a small pilot area into finance, legal and other core functions and showed organization-wide effects within roughly four to five years. Westerheide adds his own experience advising a roughly one-billion-euro German family business, telling its leadership that Alibaba offers a comparable solution for free and could displace them within five years without their noticing.

Diversity beyond gender

Yon says his own military innovation unit reached 40 percent women, showing gender diversity is achievable even in a conservative environment, but argues diversity must extend further: to career background, since a startup founder who scaled a company from nothing brings broader functional experience than a corporate manager who has only ever run one function at increasing scale, and to psychological makeup, balancing cautious risk-managers with pioneers willing to step into the unknown. He notes that shareholder-appointed board members show little diversity in Germany, and argues that more diverse boards would cascade into more diverse C-suites and, in turn, into the wider organization.

Why the US and UK move faster

Comparing examples such as JPMorgan hiring machine learning experts at scale after the financial crisis against a struggling Deutsche Bank, Yon attributes the gap partly to accountability culture: American executives are held accountable for moving things forward, while German culture tends to hold people accountable mainly for not making mistakes. He describes business-to-business purchasing decisions taking two to three years in Germany versus six to twelve months in the US, and business-to-government decisions taking around ten years in Germany, citing his own facial-recognition company's decade-long wait for significant government revenue despite strong early interest after September 11. He also contrasts Germany's tendency to subsidize AI research and technology directly with US and UK approaches that fund demand for results, such as subsidizing police departments to adopt new technology, arguing this pulls solutions toward real use rather than pushing untested technology.

Building the German Armed Forces innovation unit

Yon describes building a team of officers and soldiers, including people from cyber special-forces backgrounds, alongside serial entrepreneurs from the startup world, and says every one of roughly 80 projects the unit initiated directly involved troops at the operating level. He says startups, contrary to expectations, were highly willing to work with the military once they understood its scope extended to healthcare, logistics and administration, not only weapons, and that partnerships with allied militaries' innovation units in the US, France, the Netherlands, Singapore and Israel were marked by openness despite slow official diplomatic channels. He credits a deliberate change-communication strategy, including a bottom-up community of change-makers that grew to around 10,000 members, with employee representatives becoming among the movement's strongest supporters rather than resistors.

Backlash and the future of AI adoption

Yon says pushing disruptive change in the German military brought anonymous hostile letters and personal, even family-directed attacks, which he attributes to a small number of people he calls saboteurs, criticizing the public sector's inability to remove them once identified; he cites a prior guest, Chris Boos, as suffering similar public backlash after funding a Corona app personally. Looking at AI's trajectory, Yon says the underlying technology, capital availability and mainstream acceptance of startups have all changed since earlier AI cycles, and warns that exponential technologies are especially dangerous for large organizations because the curve can look flat for years before crossing an acceptance threshold within one or two years, too fast for slow organizations to adapt. He expects the next five years to be pivotal, says AI adoption is held back mainly by a lack of innovation culture rather than by the technology itself, and predicts German corporations will either adopt a more entrepreneurial culture and lead, or be overtaken by new startups.

Quotes

Being an entrepreneur is like being in a boxing fight with endless rounds, and all you can do is take the beating and get up again, because there is no way of giving up.

Marcel "Otto" Yon

In the old days critical mass was an advantage in itself. Today it's a disadvantage because it makes me slower, so I need to move my organization to critical initiative.

Marcel "Otto" Yon

Alibaba is running, by the way, the same solution, is offering for free, and they can crush you in five years and you won't even see it coming.

Fabian Westerheide

Questions answered in this talk

What makes a corporate or military innovation unit successful?

According to Marcel "Otto" Yon at Rise of AI in 2020, drawing on around 50 corporate and military innovation units, the most successful ones focus on execution over ideation, report directly to the CEO, act as an internal competitor to the core business, are allowed to grow rather than being handed off early, and combine insiders with outside serial entrepreneurs.

Why is business-to-government technology procurement so much slower in Germany than in the US?

According to Marcel "Otto" Yon at Rise of AI in 2020, B2G purchasing decisions in Germany take around ten years compared with six to twelve months in the US, which he attributes to a public-sector culture that holds people accountable for avoiding mistakes rather than for achieving results, and to splitting decision-making authority from responsibility for outcomes.

How did the German Armed Forces build its digital innovation unit?

According to Marcel "Otto" Yon at Rise of AI in 2020, as its founder and CEO, the unit succeeded by mixing soldiers, cyber-special-forces personnel and serial entrepreneurs, involving troops directly in all roughly 80 projects, partnering openly with allied militaries' innovation units, and building a bottom-up community of change-makers that grew to about 10,000 members.

Mentioned

drawing on around 50 corporate and military innovation units

Keep exploring

More from Rise of AI Virtual Chat 2020

More on Defense & Security

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 9,730 words

Show the full transcript

welcome we are live again my name is fabian westerheight an entrepreneur and investor with a passion for artificial intelligence this is the rise of ai virtual chat a series of conversations with interesting people from the fields of ai and technology to learn to understand and adapt ai um this is episode 18 and you will be here live you maybe will watch the replay or you will listen to the podcast one day soon also this is the last episode probably for this year because we will take a break to focus on the hybrid summit which we have upcoming here in berlin and virtual in november soon also this is a unique addition because we have a co-host called or named kaipak and kai park is i would say a loyal partner of ours and i know what means loyal because during coroner we had a lot of struggle a lot of problems and you learned who's your friend and who isn't your friend and kaipak was loyal to us they have a very motivated and smart

team there we are thankful for them and this is a way of giving back this thank you too what is kaipak doing well they have or they are building a network to drive ai adoption in germany they do publications they do events they are building huge ai server park and infrastructure park outside of berlin which will be hopefully coming in the next couple of years but they also currently already run an innovation platform where you match ai startups and business and public entities so their mission is to increase ai adoption and this leads to the topic today our topic today is chances and challenges with open innovation and i take germany as an example but this is speaking for all of europe we have an old industry just taking the ducks the largest 30 companies of germany they have an average age of 110 years merck 300 years old tusenko 200 years old siemens 160 years old companies like deliver your telecom infineon are among the youngest just imagine telecom is like the third youngest

company or fourth youngest company which we have in the darks so very young company in contrast also we all have seen it during corona that germany is not digital yet schools education failed it failed public services failed we all know the tools out there it didn't work if you want to go in front of court setting up a zoom call with your judge didn't work because they didn't have a computer with a webcam all this i say europe is dying but very slowly since the first world war and we are too big to fail the future isn't here the future might be china it might be the united states but it's here not for a while why is that and how can we turn this around well for this i have invited marcel otto yeon as our guest today he's a serial entrepreneur and he was doing ai before it was already cool so his first company in the 2000s was doing face recognition and everyone who has a passport his technology is in every

passport there which is in germany and other european countries i mean he his company invented the technology to have your face inside a passport and other services his second company was doing image recognition for cancer detection and just to give you an example how he did it well he was running both companies here in germany but he ipo them in usa and australia so again invention germany management germany but the growth the market the adaption outside of europe um he's also the founders of eo germany entrepreneurs organization eo europe he was a part of the eo global eo is a network of entrepreneurs i've been myself part of it for a couple of years i can highly recommend to you if you're an entrepreneur check out entrepreneurs organization because it helps you a lot to not be alone if you have a lot of trouble as an entrepreneur you always have up and downs eo is a very very good tool and network to support you and then the last four years he was the

founder and ceo of the german armed forces innovation unit and he was trying and he achieved it but he didn't close it because it's ongoing process to help one of the largest institutions in germany the armed forces to become innovative and i would say let's welcome him here hi hey fabian how are you doing oh i'm i'm doing great uh the prep talk we had before we didn't stop talking and i think this is always a great indication that this will be a very interesting talk today um first question for you you said 2021 will be hard year for innovation because a lot of corporations will for the upcoming recession cut down on innovation innovation hubs etc you said that isn't good tell us why innovation units is something good for for companies and um how you see this development the next years yes and and you know maybe to put that in perspective my comment is based on the experience out of the 2000 uh burst of the the bubble when we saw quite

a few corporates close their um corporate venture capital units you know they at the time it was the big hype end of the 90s to create corporate venture capital activities which i believe was a great idea a lot of companies however in the in the aftermath of the crisis just closed the units down and i think we we may be seeing something similar happening happening to all these innovation units um why because i'm so so these these corporate innovation units are not always doing well why aren't they not always doing well in the eyes of the um corporation it's because it was in the in the past couple of years very hard for them to get out of the pilot phase of the kind of prototyping ideation kind of face and i mean of course my recommendation is is different my recommendation would be to keep and rather strengthen these activities and i have i have visited over the last couple of years so many of these units and i find they have done a

terrific job but very often the corporation could improve significantly the way they interact with them so it will be interesting to see how that develops actually so from market perspective all these innovation units i mean there was a saying they are more accelerators than startups in berlin from market perspective from startup perspective it was very hard to work with them because they didn't have budget they didn't have the right people but from internal perspective they may be useful so what is your experience what worked what's what is a good example of an innovation unit and what is their task to internally so from from analyzing all the military innovation units in the western world and about 50 corporate innovation units i saw maybe five themes reoccur for those that were particularly successful the first one was when the corporate leadership understands that the key benefit the startup ecosystem is bringing is not ideation but it's actually execution so so you know that's the real strength it's not about having the idea it's about making it

happening the second theme is the question who does the innovation unit report to so we have seen that the most successful ones are reporting directly to the organization's ceo and those that are struggling tend to be reporting to the cio or to the cfo or to the second level management or somebody else in the organization and the truth is if you really want to be disruptive then there's only the senior senior management the ceo that can help you um you know achieve that disruption the third theme we have seen is is a very interesting topic and that's the question of what is what is the relationship and the expectation towards the other core the core business and what i've seen is that those units that were meant to be competitors to the existing business with the most successful ones so a lot of organizations want to do this in harmony if you really want out of the box disruptive innovation your innovation unit must be a competitor to the existing business and and particularly in

germany we like to think that competitive competition is something bad um and of course we we don't want them to stab knives in their backs but competition is actually something very creative and it's very natural i mean everything is competition out there absolutely and and also behind competition there's another concept and that is that is the idea that there is not one truth there are several ways how to be successful there's several ways how to establish business models and if you don't allow this diversity you you you're um you know you'll be confined to one truth um the fourth the fourth um theme that we have observed is the question of handing over of the innovation project so there seems to be this idea that innovation units are there to create an idea maybe test it and then hand it over as soon as possible to the core business and we we see this fail all the time and so the better version is to let the innovation unit grow and ultimately become a new

um a new core activity and the four that apparently the fifth driver was one of the team so we have seen that the most successful innovation units managed to create a mixed team of both people from the organization from the core business but also that are able to attract experienced serial entrepreneurs from the outside world and and i think this is also a very underestimated point it's you know we would like to be to stay in our comfort zone by saying oh it's so important to know the organization but i think it's important that we have people that bring outside experience but also that have that you know they don't know that it cannot be done in the organization that that source to speak lack the respect of the status quo so i summit it's exec learning from execution it's ceo focus it's internal competition it's growing it and it's mixed teams um just example walmart for example they tried to go digital for four attempts they started it did it three times they did

it internally and integrated it too fast and it was killed by politics internal only the fourth time it worked because the ceo appointed a co-ceo who was doing only virtual digital absolutely and let me give you another example the us air force did something like that so they have my uh my great friend and and colleague lauren klausenberger who was responsible of the digital innovation activities and who just got promoted to be the deputy cio of the us air force which you know let's remind us is larger than the entire german military and and so this is another great example where an entrepreneur has moved into the core and into the very senior leadership of one of the traditional organizations okay and i think this is exactly the right forward um i i had similar learnings when we talked with ollie baiting who's head of ai at siemens he said like everything has to be co level the ceo needs the reporting and then you need the execution power to integrate everything but you need

to do it in the business unit itself etc how can so it's so critical that the ceo needs to get this and then we speak about where do we have in germany an entrepreneurial ceo like running a large company where do we have this mindset already like any company comes in your mind where you say oh they do it right currently i i'm not aware of any and and i think this is uh the question behind that is even broader than that let's look at the sea level of our largest corporations so um i tend to think that the sea level ought to be looking into the future of the business where the business should be in 10 years from now so in in my thinking the sea level should reflect the business that we want to have in 10 years from now however when you look at our largest automotive businesses banks and so forth you see very successful people there they're great people some of them i know personally they're absolutely smart people

but they they are representatives of the old way of doing business now we all know that our car companies our banks are not going to be like this anymore in five years from now so and i'm not saying that the c level boards should be composed out of um startup entrepreneurs exclusively but i'm i'm saying that there should be uh if if you want a more entrepreneurial business if you want to move to fintech if you want to move to auto autonomous driving there ought to be a certain diversity of the entrepreneurial skill in the c-level suite because let's remind ourselves in there are 100 000 other people in the organization that know how to run the existing business it's not about running the existing business it's about preparing the business for the future well that's interesting because i i follow this discussion we both agree it's a question of culture and leadership and a lot of newspapers from manager magazine who are shareholder focus let's say say no the ceo is appointed to run

the current business and to save the business model and this is what the shareholder wants so we could argue first the shareholder do the mistake that they don't appoint a visionary on because they are too greedy to invest in the future and they rather want to cash or milk the cow as long as possible second question there or argument is that how can then middle management or management innovate because if it's all depending on the co this is highly frustrating and that could lead to them oh i don't have to do anything because the co doesn't do it then i don't do it either well let's be clear about one thing because there's this funny thing about us humans we always point to another person when something doesn't work okay so middle management points to sea level sea level points to management and and so forth the truth is of course that every you know every single person in the entire organization has a contribution uh to make when it's about the cultural transition so

i've had a lot of these discussions with i would call this senior middle management uh people who are responsible for 5000 people a billion in revenues etc and um you know they they very often tell me oh i can't do this and that because you know my bosses wouldn't allow me to structure our organization as such and this is something we hear particularly in the military um and and that is true of course but at the same time it's also true that these senior middle managers have quite a lot of you know decision power within their own organization and when you ask their employees they will kind of say the same things about their boss so so it's it's something that affects us all as leaders and and it's probably the most difficult thing in the in the world but having said that we have seen these examples where it has been able to transition to a different kind of culture and i think this is what we need to bear in mind it's a

cultural transition from critical mass to critical initiative the in in the old days critical mass was an advantage in itself today it's a disadvantage because it makes me slower so i need to move my organization to what i call critical initiative so how do we create an organization where everybody assumes responsibility takes initiative but without incurring too many risks so that's always the the hard part how do i balance good governance and initiative um before you ask the question i would like to ask how do you do it i mean you you told us what's important what's a success factor but let's assume because this is about innovation how do we get more innovation the ideas are out there scouting them not a problem i mean startups are very exposed but how do i start i mean how do how can i change the culture from the old way we used to do business which is shareholder focus to i'm willing to disrupt my own business and build a business model which is lasting for

the next generation yes well what's what's interesting is that in most organizations the team the people actually have a good feeling about what doesn't work now the difficulty is um they only know a certain fraction of the problem so it's very difficult you need to be extraordinarily smart to be able from your portion of the slice you know to be able to draft a recommendation to senior management on how to change the entire system so i think as leaders what what has worked very well is we need to enable and encourage a discussion so the starting point is always something where an employee is not with frustration in the room that's the starting point but that's when the real work starts and as leaders we can play an in incredible support by moderating that discussion because one we have the experience of analyzing complex problems and secondly we have the um the overview of the entire organization so it's a question of moderation of this of of this frustration i would say and to encourage

conflict and you know constructive conflict and to work together on on solutions and the organizations that have implemented that have actually been successful in a very very short time frame i think you can initiate trend transitions within months you have examples yes um so one one organization that i've been following closely which i find extremely interesting is the singapore military or defense ministry procurement organization so this is we're talking here about the most conservative kind of organization the military procurement organization and they have embarked on an extremely interesting program to change the culture and i have not seen in any military in the world um a program that was so well thought through and so much focused on on culture anywhere else and they have introduced it of course only in a small area but they have now moved in in the like project management area they have now moved it to the core to the finance people to the legal people to etc to all this right and um so we are now talking

the fourth year of this transition and i think we are seeing right now the pivotal effect it has and and so an organization of something like 5000 employees is is um showing immediate effects after six months and has changed the entire organization after something like four or five years so that that is kind of the speed you can develop to change a large organization so i i take it it can change even in public entities who are set who can't so there's hope we could turn around germany in our industries in five years if there would be the willingness now they have the question how do you generate this sense of understanding example i was talking about ai for a large german company you know one billion revenue middlestand and all the innovation people who invited me like yeah great we need this and all the ceos like very old white guys like my father did this this way my grandfather did this way i will do it this way we don't change anything bam

i told them hey alibaba is running by the way the same solution is offering for free and they can crush you in five years and you won't even see it coming listen to me they don't they don't they believe everything which worked in the past will work in the future we both know disruption isn't this way how can you ex how do you get this into the mind that history is not linear yeah so i mean let's bear in mind that this corporate transition transition of culture is probably one of the most complex things around so there is certainly no silver bullet and there is no you know one one fits all kind of solution um what i found as a recurring pattern is is the question whether you focus on advancing your offerings or whether you focus on technology so particularly in germany we like to to focus on technology so we we so a typical organization would say oh we want to have more ai so you have a very modern thinking ceo

that will say oh we want to have more ai in in reality for the organization it's it's you know it shouldn't be a driver whether there is more or less ai the driver should be is our solution better or not and and so you know the the other experience is it's incredibly easy to build the technical solution it's actually very easy it's much more difficult to to create the change of business model and let's remind ourselves a disruptive technology always comes with a disruption in business model and market and and all this otherwise it wouldn't be disruptive so and this is what we're struggling about it's not about building the disruptive technology it's about all the other things that need to happen so so this is a good idea to focus on the on the on the business side of things um the the other aspect here of course has to do with i mean you you indicated that the traditional the wisdom it's what brought us here what made us successful over the last

20 years is not going to make us successful necessarily for the next 20 years so there is kind of a conscious and unconscious bias in any organization and and ultimately when you think about this i think the only way to tackle this is to allowing more diversity in leadershi in in the entire organization but particularly also in leadership so bring people from other sectors bring people from other worlds like bring people in from the military from startup world from academia etc and then you will be able to to um overcome this um you know um inherited wisdom and and all this how and how can we bring because diversity is we all know it sounds easy but it's so hard first you want to have the same qualification i know it we lost the conference and we had in the past people saying hey you don't have a 50 ratio of female speakers and i said like if you give me fifty percent of equal qualified female speakers no problem but the market is like

one to ten they are like so less so it's significant harder the other thing is yes do you mind if i challenge you on this one please oh so we we tend to think that diversity is about gender only and of course this is important and by the way german innovation unit we had 40 percent uh uh women so we're talking at the crossroads of military startup nit and we still managed to have 40 women so it is possible if you really no i agree i agree and but but the the true thing is it's about diversity it's not about gender diversity so let me give you two other examples of of diversity the the size thing that we touched upon our way of thinking about leaders about recruiting is always size matters so the way headhunters and and ceos recruit their team is to look at oh have if you have managed one billion in revenues before you're now ready for one and a half billion if you have managed 20 million revenue startup

you're not ready for some reason for a 2 billion revenue company and and so this is a good example of diversity because i can tell you um that the good startup entrepreneur will bring so many more things to the table because he has actually gone to the difficult pivots of finding these 20 million in revenues which is a completely different task than from managing an existing business and typically startup entrepreneurs are thrown into the cold water so they have seen every single function whereas the middle management and corporations very often have only seen one or two functions they're they're sales people or they're finance people or something and they have much less diversity in the in the corporate functions and skills etc so so i mean this is just an example but there's also diversity at the level of psychology you know we all know there are people that are more cautious that protect us from incurring stupid risk that's very important but we also need people who are who are the pioneers who are

not afraid of taking a step into the unknown so it's about that balance too and um do we have diversity in the in the c-suite no we don't so there's a saying a players hire a players yeah but yeah players don't and a friend of mine he worked for i think red hat uh you know which was he said like the first 1000 people that was fine because there were only eight players in the team around the ceo but then it got bought by a larger corporation they kicked out the a players because they didn't want to share their power and then all the others left the the talents how how can you can we make it that diversity means also i give away power that means i someone that will challenge me someone will question my task that also will mean i have to give a little bit of my budget of my my business models away because he will disrupt it how can we convince people to not stick on their seat on

power because politics is doing the same for years i mean there are no role models out there who really provided diversity and change and even all the leaders which we have our diverse female act very male in their position well at the end of the day that we are in a hierarchical system so so it starts with the it starts with the shareholder and look at the the board of directors they're non-executive boards there's no diversity there there's zero diversity and and some of them yes they have taken on board a few women even on the side of the employees i mean the the vectra they are not even diverse and they should be well that that is a very particular phenomenon in the german um in the german legal system um and and i fully agree the question is you know who's who's you know who do the employees put forward as board members but but um let's put that aside because it's a very special and complex thing there's the other half of

the board members that are being appointed by the shareholders and even there we don't see much diversity and so it really starts there and if if shareholders really want to make sure that their large corporations and their enormous valuable assets make the transition i think they should apport and appoint more diverse board members and then these board members will appoint more diverse c-suite teams and and then that will cascade down into the company and at the end of the day there's no right or wrong here it's you know it's you know let's i want to be very clear about the startup world is not better than the corporate world you know i'm just saying there's good in both and in other words like the military they're good in all these worlds and i think we are we just get more if we are able to include the good of all these worlds and make a best off okay i would like to look for a second on abroad outside of europe for example jp morgan

during the financial crisis they hired right after 1 000 machine learning experts and started to scale and automate a lot deutsche bank they could they honestly suck i mean they don't do well anything innovative there why are the americans over and over again and morgan is an old company able to reinvent them and be adaptive and we don't do it i mean what is what are the advantages the americans have china outside because it's a different younger system but what can we learn from the united states and cultural and leadership and diversity etc and adapt here yes so i think the the examples that you're mentioning go go back to this diversity and to this culture topic we have been discussing so i don't want to expand on that anymore we have covered it but but let me share the experience of an entrepreneur that went into the us and what i what i find is um we're talking here about b2b and b2g so selling to businesses and selling to governments versus selling to

consumers so the sales cycle the time needed to make a purchasing decision by the corporate in in germany in europe is about two to three years for new technology in in the us it's much less it's somewhere between six months and 12 months when we talk about b2g business to government in germany it's around 10 years so that's what it takes um um you know when we invented facial recognition we were at a phase in in particular after september 11 you know we where every single minister of interior in germany wanted our technology where where all the the the people working in the in the engine room wanted our technology and still it took something like 10 years before the first revenues the significant revenues came yeah and and why is that so so there are a couple of drivers here um one driver has to do with the com the willingness to assume responsibility and to be accountable for results and and i think in america we're seeing executives that are held more accountable

to moving things forward in germany we like to help people accountable for not screwing up so so there's a bit of a difference so for example politicians when they do a fall they always have to resign so they can never learn from their mistakes this is something i don't understand because it's like hey you do one mistake you're out of the system so you can't learn so politics is taking this to the extreme you know but but maybe you know that maybe that's an another session and then you you mess up something like the the airport and there's no responsibility now accountability in there and you have sunk billions of it well in in so let's just one comment on the public sector in the public sector we have the concept of sustained kites it's it's the there's no real translation for this in english it's the person that is allowed to make a decision which is distinct from for unfortunate so the responsibility for a result okay but what we love to do in

the german public sector we have the ministry of defense that is or any ministry is the same that is responsible for making the decisions and then you have the layers below who are responsible for delivering a result well that that doesn't work my my mother told me you cannot share responsibility either you're responsible or you're not and and so that this is a very um tricky point and also we love to share this responsibility over many many many people i think there's no way in the german govern a public sector you can make a transition you can introduce a new technology with less than 100 signatures that you would need so we come to the point where we just discussed you said it takes 10 years to get a technology into it which is terrible because i know that our drones which don't fly but if they would fly they would fly on dos i know this from suppliers and this is just an example um so so will this change or is there any

innovation how this process can be reduced from 10 years to maybe three years or yeah this is not scalable so the first question is is it possible and the the unit i i was you know allowed to build in the german military had to address particularly that question is it possible within the legal the very complex legal constraints of the public sector and the very high demands of the public sector to to do a procurement system that is faster and the answer is of course it is so for example we designed a process from ideation to delivery into the hands of the soldiers in three months so it is possible the european procurement law requires you to have a tender out for 30 days it doesn't say three years so it's more a question of organizing the workflow organizing processes etc and what we see here is a debate about um you know the old functional organization was the new cross-functional team but you know we're we're kind of drifting back to the culture question

let's let's go step back a little bit for the the question what works differently in the u.s so so another thing that i witnessed there was the um the focus on the solution rather than the the technology so let's take an example in the subsidies so in germany we like to create public incentive subsidies for artificial intelligence that will say you get subsidies if you do a research project on artificial intelligence what if we did something saying we will give money to the public transport company of a local city that manages to introduce the first autonomous bus so that would be more results or like like the doppler challenge a little bit like giving an incentive for results or in back 20 years ago what what we saw is the there were subsidies in the u.s system that gave money to sheriff departments or to state police and or even federal police to introduce new technologies so it created a market supported the market demand for innovation versus financing a push of technology and there's

a bit of a difference and of course you need both um but in in germany we tend to have only the technology push and it's very important excuse me very german word yes but even the ungervanted foreshown the applied research is extremely tech push oriented and by by giving purchasing demand to the user you you are actually not only pushing for solutions rather than technology but also you're making sure that the products created um are such that somebody can use them and and so i mean you know this is a thinking that is much more um embedded in the in the us or actually australian and to some extent even british culture it's much more results oriented is and i mean we said australians they are entrepreneurs because they built the country the same about the americans the american dream but the british as well and i mean the british are better in ai than we are in terms of startups funding etc and this metrics do they have british have this mindset too being

more result orientated i i i have i mean you know everybody has his own experiences i was allowed to make some very positive experiences in dealing with the british government and british companies and i found there was a very big openness to innovation um which was remarkable and of course let's not forget to mention uh israel as a country which also is of course very innovative and and result-oriented yes um we have a question here from the audience otto do you have examples of european and now it switched my tab of european innovation projects which worked so companies or anything where we can orientate where we say at least it worked once so cooperation which was more innovative or which accepted innovation internal outside something like this so so just to be clear with by innovation projects you're you mean like digital innovation units or you mean any innovation let's let's stay with uh successful uh innovation projects outside of it doesn't have to be digital it has to be successful i mean innovation projects

there's so many in successful innovation projects and let's come back to the german military the german military is is highly innovative if you look at the technologies they use we're just missing a culture of innovation that's that's a bit of a difference here um the you know i mean innovation projects other successful ones of course because i mean germany continues to be one of the leading nations one of the high-tech nations we have produced some of the most amazing products so behind all these great products there are so many successful case studies of innovation but maybe the way i understand this question is more geared towards digital innovation units and and if you ask me do i know one that is perfect the answer is no but i see a lot of good and a lot of in a lot of settings and of course you have to differentiate also between the innovation unit itself most of them are actually quite good have remarkable teams and have great ideas and great projects i i would

say by and large if if these innovation units fail it's more the the opportunity is more on the side to think about how do they interact with the corporate and that's more question of what does the corporate design for them to so for what can they do what they're allowed to do or not and and um and and how are they in the structure of the overall organization and and again they're on both these accounts there's no perfect one but there is enough there is enough um lessons learned you can draw from those that are existing um i i think and there's enough publications out there it has all been written down already that it's actually not that complicated to to craft the right system it's it's more the question whether you have the real willpower to do it in the right way so i have one example which i like it's not perfect by going direction which is this fist mum which is building heating systems and they have launched veto one so they

have an early stage funds they have a larger company builder fund and which is run by the family itself so it's a little bit family office capital too and they really they buy and invest financial and strategic into startups without integrating them but to learn and to adapt this and i think this is a very good approach so i'm a big fan of hey you have to invest into the future technologies without thinking to buy them just that you learn and then you adapt and etc like battlezman was doing this for years and then they stopped it by the way axel springer was doing it and then they stopped it by the way too so i see this waves also coming that they do it and then they stop it yeah and and and it's a great example and you know with the new generation that has taken over um you know uh at fisma um there's a new young leader that is bringing in some of that entrepreneurial culture etc and there are other

other so-called hidden champions that are amazing amazing companies um so um yeah of course we have these great examples so i would like come to point the back how do we can innovate public entities like the army but also like everything which is public services at the end you say there are 100 people in average involved into signing a technology person purchase at the end that means there isn't the top only there like so many others involved i know it's a culture question but how can we start i mean how can we give some something inside the system like because every one of us is out there and is able to change that this moves in the right direction it's it's it's i feel like overwhelmed by this task and i'm if we're overwhelmed we say i don't do anything and and it is an overwhelming task because it's so big and it's so complex you know the public sector is 45 of the german economy and that's pretty big and and they have a

lot of uh responsibility to deal with and um so so it is complex um having said that is it possible of course um i you know and there are many things we can start at the operating unit level every unit leader can do something to change the culture today and at the same time if we really want to build a greater public administration we also need to start at the political level we need to think about us as voters um and i'll give you an example the the good leadership good governance of the public sector is not a political topic we're never discussing in the political agenda how how do we make better leaders how do we make better entities in the public sector and the excuse is always we're not here for profit we're you know it's a non-profit thing it's the government so you know that's always the excuse to say all these leadership things that tend to come from the corporate world are not relevant to us and and that of course

is not true so so i would say the most important thing is to introduce the question of good governance of good management of professional management of leadership diversity into the political debate okay before we continue i have a quick question there too i will read out the results of the polls i have asked there and i for example asked does your black behind in adapting innovation and the majority of 57 says yes but europe can learn from us china how to be more open towards innovation for society and one third says we will stay behind because we aren't hungry anymore then ask what is the main driver for innovation and they said they shared with you 57 said it's culture and the other third says it's talent um this leads to my question your personal experience being in the army which is for me the nightmare of being modern um what was good what did you achieve and you said like hey i achieved this in this work but also where did you fail because

we all know you couldn't have succeeded in everything where did you get against some boundaries where you said i couldn't push them this didn't work so um before i get into this let me let me rectify one perception the military has phenomenal people that are very entrepreneurial and that is particularly true if we look at the troops in the in the core of the business when the soldiers are in the field when they do the core business it's actually a great organization with great people the the the challenges are more in the let's call it corporate headquarters and in the senior commands and it's it's in the military bureaucracy really both civil civilian and and in uniform um but you know to answer your question more specifically to our unit so first i i think i mean you know we have we have had and have still continued to have uh a phenomenal team there that has done an amazing job and i i don't think that it could have been done any in any

better way in any shorter time the what was particularly successful i believe was the building of the team we built a team of officers and soldiers from from the military particularly from these cyber special forces kind of backgrounds but also from the startup ecosystem we have several serial entrepreneurs in the team etc and i think that that happened in a very short time frame in an extraordinary quality this the second thing is um we managed to implement that every project would have what was done with the user with the troops with a battalion with the with the operating level um so that was very succ so in in 80 projects that we initiated it was always the troop involved we always assumed that we would know what the military needs and so that was highly successful and it worked well and the interaction with the comrades was extremely positive and successful the the third thing that was really successful is the interaction with the startup world and let's remind ourselves that there was an unknown

we some people said startups don't want to have to do anything with the military now in my experience the contrary was true everybody was was very um willing to cooperate with the military and in particular when they understood that the military is not only about weapons it's also about health care about logistics about administration about so many things the the fourth thing that was highly successful is building partnerships and and here partnerships is delivered with the corporate sector but it and the startup ecosystem but in particularly it's it's other military organizations from our allies in the in the u.s and france netherlands singapore uh israel etc and i experienced so much openness so much comradery so much willingness to help among these innovation oriented people now i also witnessed what it means to have official dialogue of cooperation with another country and that was the most bureaucratic processes i've ever witnessed okay um but but in when you strip it down of these um diplomacy and bureaucratic elements cooperation is there and and we we

can be proud to have really great allies um and and i can tell you without the openness to and willingness to share experiences uh we would not have been willing to uh we would not have been able to build this unit so fast and you know in particular with the u.s military um and and the the fifth element was i i think we we were wise to recognize from the beginning that change is about communication so we did a very good change uh communication policy we we um we had the strategy of building a bottom-up community of change makers and so that's a community that to my knowledge today has something like 10 000 members and is growing 10 a month and so that's like the bottom-up rebellion and um and i think that was the right strategy and for example the the unions the employee representatives which in most corporations are difficult to deal with to in these periods of change um in the military where actually the fearest supporters of our movement okay

i time wise that's why i speed a little bit up i know that you also had backlash i mean you're a guy extroverted entrepreneur bold you wear red pants which was a cultural clash and we both know and you know even better you got public really insults i mean they hit you very very ugly private family i mean you had people attacking you and i asked first why in second where was this coming from like who was afraid of you that they had to run propaganda against you well it's i mean people have to know that everyone who tries to make change disruptive change in the german military will get anonymous emails and letters uh from some idiots in the system the i'm convinced till today that it's a very very small number of people who have chosen to take that path of being saboteurs it's it's not the majority not at all i have i'm i'm fine with it why because i have so many great and positive experiences of people encouraging us people

standing by us that this dwarfs um next to it um but you just have to be aware that unfortunately this happens and the the only the only thing that i i regret or i find sad is that the public sector seems to be incapable of dealing with these saboteurs so in some instances you know who they are but the public sector is incapable of throwing them out um and and we're talking about a handful of people in the entire we know it that one commenter is saying hey this is not right and then 99 don't disagree with him public enough i i mean it's the internet it's a very small voice can be very loud it's yeah it's for the system as such that such a i mean we're not talking about constructive criticism we're not talking we're talking about saboteurs let's remind ourselves and and so unfortunately the system the way the culture is gives them quite an a voice yeah and that's the real problem it's you will never have a large organization

uh with without one subverter it's you know it's unfortunately there are people who choose to take that path but the question is how does the organization deal with them and how does our political system deal with it and you know the entire and this happens that i i know generals that have been treated extremely badly i know i know simple employees that have been treated extremely badly and that's very sad because it's it's killing initiative okay three minutes left and just decide chris bose for example who was at our patrol chat before too he had a similar backlash he wanted to do a corona app he invested millions of his private capital in there and he got attacked so much by some public voices that he was very very painful hurt he'd struggled with this and i know that he suffered under this and he's a good mooded guy but he said like hey i try to do something good and you get a lot of beating because the beating voices are very often higher

in the public sector than the encouraging voices yeah and but hey if you want to be a disruptor if you be an entrepreneur and be prepared for resistance that's the way it is it's the same thing when you're a startup entrepreneur and and actually i think that that is one of the reasons why we should have more startup entrepreneurs in the c-level of corporations and in the public sector because entrepreneurs are so good at dealing with these obstacles i like to say that being entrepreneurs like being in a boxing fight with endless rounds like and all you can do is take the beating and get up again because there is no way of giving up then you're out um so you have seen and let's at the end turn to ai a little bit because you have seen ai coming and going before you have experienced a whole cycle where do you see us in the cycle currently and what is to be expected in the next couple of years because you have experienced it

yes there's so many deja vus here because you know all the great ideas that are out today we had you know they were out there 20 years ago and there were great companies working on them 20 years ago however a couple of things have changed first the technology has made tremendous progress tremendous progress it's amazing what it can do today and secondly there's so much money around and and also the role of startups is very different i mean 20 years ago there were a few crazy people doing startups now it's like mainstream and so i i think the the the speed at which ai is going to develop is going to be so exponential and i think this is why it's so dangerous because that's the whole point about the exponential curve for like years you think it's not working it's not good enough and within a time frame of one or two years the curve will actually go through the the acceptance level the minimum acceptance level and one or two years will be

too short for the large organizations to adapt and this is why exponential technologies are so dangerous for big organizations it's not that they don't understand it or they couldn't cope it it's the change to the organization cannot be done in one year so i mean i i would say if you if you don't start really really really hard i mean it's like 5 to 12 right now um i i think that the next five years will be pivotal in the industry but at the same time you said it's technology it's not the bottleneck it's the culture and it's the adaption for it and um so you say that the hype will not go down for ai like the digital you had before because let's be honest ai disappeared in the knowledge on the awareness of people for wait eight or to five years a lot of researchers said oh i used to do ai and now we called it cognitive science or machine learning because ai was a word we didn't use for 10 years

yeah the so so i mean what is going to why why is it so difficult to implement ai because most ai applications are b2b business broads and and as we discussed earlier decision making process and complexity to be fair is is i mean it's just longer in in b2b and and so um that's why we're not seeing more ai today it's because of the lack of innovation culture in the large organizations um so two things can happen either we'll see um these large organizations change either kovit is going to be the opportunity to really make two change changes to talent diversity and to culture and all this and then the german corporations actually have a tremendous chance because there are world leaders today so if they adopt a more entrepreneurial culture they are unbeatable and the other outcome is that we will see the emergence of more startups and then we'll just beat the corporates i i'm not part of those people who think that the uh western world will go down the drain and

asia's gonna take over um there are some phenomenal people and phenomenal companies in asia and you know there's there should be enough space on this planet for everybody i i think we will more see a shift towards towards uh startups in germany rather than germany going down the drain otto great boards i mean giving us hope we can't do it we can pull it off it takes only five years to change a very large corporation if you want to uh we learned a lot from you i thank you for this i will excuse you now everyone else can stay on the line uh thank you for being here today thank you so much thank you um so that was great there was also a good closing for our series of virtual chat which we end for now it's the first season 18 episodes we had um if you're interested in ai innovation you could check out the kai park because they have a huge database and access to a lot of solutions so if you

think about okay how can i do it how do i get to the core technology how do i find corporations partners kai park is offering you this on the other hand if you have some innovation and you want to get in contact with enterprises and public sectors with state forever kaipak is building the platform and the matchmaking for this um else sign up for the summit if you haven't done it yet we streaming it free it will be like today just with the stage and everything around we use a lot of our learnings from the virtual chats to do an amazing hybrid summit um it was a pleasure i had such great talks i learned so much in those talks and i know i had some really hard conversation partners and i had some really nice conversation partners so i learned also a lot of myself i had growth in the eight us talks you learned a lot we have a platform we recorded everything it was wonderful to have you here i hopefully see

you back to the next season enjoy your day you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.