Rise of AI Conference 2017 · Berlin

Exciting Entities from the Future

At Rise of AI 2017 in Berlin, Ronnie Vuine argues that today's AI does not yet exist as popularly imagined and is, in his words, a fantasy, and explores why that fantasy is nonetheless what makes AI exciting. He says the field has gotten very good at pattern recognition and, in his own company's work, at reinforcement learning that links pattern recognition to acting systems, but that no one has any idea how to build the actual thinking that would take context, culture and long-term deliberation into account, and that this gap cannot be closed by scaling neural networks with more data. He traces this excitement to science fiction, telling the story of 1920s writer and rocket pioneer Max Valier, whose fictional hero anticipates the atomic bomb and who later dies testing real rocket engines, a lineage he connects to Wernher von Braun and the postwar American space program. He then reads a passage from William Gibson's Neuromancer to show how literature intensifies technological fantasies, arguing Gibson did not predict the future but helped create it, and closes with a quote from Mark Fisher on fiction and reality merging.

Key takeaways

  • Vuine argues that today's AI is not the thinking AI of popular imagination; current systems do pattern recognition and reinforcement learning but nothing that plans or reasons with context.
  • He says scaling neural networks with more data will not close this gap, because pattern recognizers are not thinkers.
  • He connects AI's excitement to a class of technologies, including rocketry and VR, that promise to free people from a specific human limitation.
  • He uses Max Valier's life, from writing a 1919 rocket novel to dying in a 1930 rocket engine test, to trace a direct line from science fiction to the American space program.
  • He argues William Gibson's Neuromancer did not predict AI's future but helped intensify and create the fantasy that drives people toward it.

Detailed notes

Why AI does not yet exist

Vuine opens by noting that despite the conference's name, there are no AIs in the room: AI, in the strong sense, has not been figured out. He says current systems are very good at pattern recognition (classifying pixels as "giraffe") and, in the reinforcement learning his own company works on, at connecting pattern recognition to systems that act and improve from feedback. What is missing is the "little black box" that would actually think: taking context and cultural background into account, making long-winded plans, setting a strategy aside for years and later returning to it. Nobody today knows what to put in that box, and he stresses that this cannot be solved by scaling, by throwing more data at neural networks, because they are pattern recognizers, not thinkers.

AI as science-fiction fantasy

Vuine argues that this gap between the AI that exists and the AI people imagine is not a weakness but precisely what makes AI exciting, because it has lived as a fantasy in science fiction for a long time. He frames a class of technologies, including AI, space travel and VR, as distinct because each promises to free people from a specific limitation of the human condition, such as being bound to the ground or to a single body, and science fiction gives these possibilities a compelling narrative pull that he calls "the globe."

Max Valier: from rocket fiction to rocket death

He tells the story of Max Valier, a science-fiction writer born in Boston in 1895 who published a science-fiction novel in 1919 (the title is unclear in the recording), whose hero builds flying technologies and, angered by rejection, destroys the earth with a device resembling an atomic bomb. Ten years later, in Germany, the same Valier is building real rocket engine prototypes and testing whether they can generate enough lift for orbit; he dies in 1930 in a test explosion, becoming, in Vuine's telling, the first person killed by spaceflight technology before it existed. Vuine draws a line from Valier's rocket-mail pitch to a young Wernher von Braun, who later built the V-2 ("Aggregat 4") for the Nazis and whose team was subsequently brought to the US to help start the American space program, a direct lineage from 1920s fiction to modern rocketry.

William Gibson's Neuromancer and "the globe"

To show how literature intensifies a technology's excitement beyond its physical constraints, Vuine reads a passage from Gibson's Neuromancer describing a character experiencing another person's full sensory input through a device. He notes the novel is highly sexualized and written, in his reading, for adolescent boys, but argues this is exactly Gibson's method: connecting real technological possibilities to what excites people to intensify the experience of AI and VR in fiction. He points out Gibson foresaw advanced AI but not the cell phone, concluding Gibson was not a prophet predicting the future but someone who helped create it by making certain technological fantasies impossible to let go of.

Fiction as sorcery

Vuine closes by describing what people in the room, and AI practitioners generally, are doing as a form of sorcery: using signs and symbols, science-fiction fantasies, capital and hard work to try to make an imagined future real. He ends with a quote from the late theorist Mark Fisher, from "Flatline Constructs," on fiction forming a "resonant contact" with the world rather than merely paralleling it.

Quotes

We won't scale our way out of this ignorance.

Ronnie Vuine

He didn't foresee the future, he created it.

Ronnie Vuine

Questions answered in this talk

Why does Ronnie Vuine say AI does not yet exist?

According to Ronnie Vuine at Rise of AI 2017, current systems can do pattern recognition and reinforcement learning but no one knows how to build the component that would actually think, taking context and culture into account, and this cannot be fixed by scaling neural networks with more data.

What does Max Valier's story have to do with AI hype?

According to Ronnie Vuine at Rise of AI 2017, Max Valier wrote a 1919 science-fiction novel featuring a bomb-like superweapon, then became a real rocket engineer and died testing rocket engines in 1930, illustrating how science-fiction fantasy can pull people toward genuinely dangerous, difficult technological pursuits, in a line that runs to the American space program.

How does William Gibson's Neuromancer relate to excitement about AI, according to Ronnie Vuine?

According to Ronnie Vuine at Rise of AI 2017, Gibson used real technological possibilities and intense, sexualized narrative to make AI and virtual reality feel exciting, and in doing so helped create rather than merely predict the fantasies that now drive people to work on these technologies.

Mentioned

Pattern recognition, Reinforcement learning, Science fiction, Neuromancer, Rocketry

Keep exploring

More from Ronnie Vuine

More from Rise of AI Conference 2017

More on AGI & Future of Intelligence

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 2,632 words

Show the full transcript

I am going to address the question of why is talking about the ice so exciting you all came to a conference called rise of AI and things that rise usually are exciting in some form I mean I can't think of many things that rise into this AI and there's could fool you maybe or populism but that's about it so AI obviously is exciting however you will notice that there aren't any AI is in the room look around doesn't look like AI is something that's done we haven't figured it out inclusive of an amaz book certainly made a point about how hard it is just now and how far away we are from property and the true sense of the word so in technology usually the rule is demo or get the out and it doesn't seem to be the case when talking about AI so I says today today AI would that would be my take doesn't exist it's fantasy we have made great progress in pattern recognition that's you know we input a bunch

of pixels and we get some categorization out of it here's a bunch of pixel this is a giraffe that's something we have gotten very good at over the course of the last couple years let's keep learning and we've also gotten very good at what my company does reinforcement learning which is connecting some form of pattern recognition to some form of system that acts based on the data that comes in from the pattern recognition system and uses the results of the action to improve the pattern recognizer recognition in the first place the important thing to notice all of this is almost instant so in the middle between these perceiving and acting systems there should be a little black box that does the actual thinking and nobody today has any idea what to put in there we haven't figured this out computers today can't think that would mean take into account context take into account you know a cultural background make a long-winded plan due deliberation make a strategy that maybe you set aside and after two

years just from internal driven is you come back to the strategy and see you see it through so none of this today exists and it's also important to note that we won't scale our way out of this ignorance we can't just throw more and more interesting data at neural networks and then suddenly magically your networks will start to think that's not what they're made for their pattern recognizers so today AI isn't there is just not there it is very much a fantasy and it is a fantasy that has been around for a very long time in science fiction and I'd like to make the case in this talk that this precisely and at the very best sense of the word is what makes it exciting this is something that sets AI apart from other technologies that you know we are getting good at recently because science fiction isn't just a random pastime something we enjoy when we're young and then we give up on it and there's no consequences so here's a science fiction writer

from the 1920s this is max Yee he was born in 1895 in Boston and in 1919 he published a science fiction novel in his book called spyridon yucks and this picture of him is from this book itself published so nobody stopped him from making the self-description free version of what excludes plop so that's how he liked to be seen he was a man of wood that's what that was for the ladies right but that's that's not for you and in this book division it looks spiritedness the main character it's a bit like him very talented knows many things and spirit Yann builds a lot of technologies right for instance for flights and he's also good at this philosophy and he falls in love with a girl and she does love him back so it gets very angry and he uses his powers to go to space using rockets and uses a device that is vaguely recognizable as an atomic bomb to destroy the earth because it's so angry so that's that Marx Valley in 1994

you I'm going to read a brief passage from this sorry for those who don't speak any German it's just too nice to skip out on this with an orphan from London four million and a decision and then Fabul has now dearest out on damage cavity Nemo glide a linear decreasing which caused or noon for masters destroyed the vanadium super Solomon Tecna - Liam's crust and getting our eldest really getting in monster Flynn also in close idea about using glances on Stalin column is then current life the tool on the other one design emphasis criticizing installation this very same guy ten years later he's in Germany by now is the founder of a thing called finances all your fault this is 1929 now and he creates prototypes for rocket engines this is the valley which tools bag number six and on the right you can see G also uses to test whether you know rocket engines produce enough lift to get people actually into orbit so that's that's what he's looking for he blows himself up

in 1913 and is considered the first person who dies from spacefaring before he was invented with the successor of Wichitas vehicle or rickshaws wagon see physics the number seven killed him in 1930 what happened before is that when he pitched his scheme of rocket base in base delivery to dodge it I suppose he met a guy called Jonathan Brown and benefit long as there is fascinated by the idea of building rockets and famously a couple years later built aggregate fear better known as hot side which the Nazis used to terrorize most of us in Europe and then he and his people and the Rockets were taken to the US and pretty much kick-started the American space program so there's a direct line if you want a direct causal tradition and line from this mad guy in the 1920s even today's American space technology run by people like in masks so when you when you want to design rockets what what are the ingredients the rocket itself is pretty much shaped by what it's supposed to

do you can't build rockets in any shape you like you can make square you need to take into account all the constraints of Technology and physics and the object that you get out of it is almost fully defined by you know the physical constraints and the constraints of gravity and fuel and whatever you need to do to build rocket engines so that you could consider the universe's contribution to a rocket it needs to look like this if you want to really want one if you a contribution is wanting one and wanting it very badly so badly in fact that you blow yourself up getting there now why are doing period why are people doing this you know why do I blow yourself up for something something like this and my take would be there's a class of technologies that are distinct technical possibilities it doesn't work for things that are just pure fantasy it needs to be doable in a form and those technologies have the distinctive property of freeing us from one specific limitation

of the human condition if realized but these are technologies like slightly that we don't you know we're not bound to the to the ground this was in science fiction all the time this is a technology like rocketry where you can go to space these are technologies like VR where you're not longer bound to you know this bag of weak flesh and you want to experience something visually exciting and fly through a canyon and need to drag this lumpy thing around or technologies like AI where you know this could deliver us from the ever maddening abyss of human stupidity itself if it ever worked and in science fiction these technologies are very prominent but there is more in science fiction there's one additional component that I call the globe this is the the thing that makes you want to turn that page that gets you really excited like a cold fire in the dark you read under your blanket you don't give up on it something that's very specific to good science fiction and with an

almost feverish quality these books and movies make the technologies they present exciting and that's the thing that only literature can do that only language can do just by looking at the technology in the physical constraints you don't get it that's specific to science fiction and to illustrate how this works I'm going to read a passage from William Gibson's Neuromancer I would assume you all know that but again that's so nice and so illustrative that I'm just going to read that to you so the protagonists case is just testing a piece of technology that lets you experience all the sensory inputs that another human being has then he keyed the new switch the abrupt salt into a low flash matrix gone a wave of sound in color she was moving through a crowded Street past stalls lending discount software prices felt pens and sheets of plastic fragments of music from countless speakers smells of urine free monomers perfume patties of frying krill for a few frightened seconds he found he fought helplessly to control her body

when he willed himself into passivity became the passenger behind her eyes the glasses didn't seem to cut down the sunlight at all he wondered if the built-in amps compensated automatically blue alpha numeric swing to the same low in her left peripheral field showing off he thought her body language was disorienting hostile foreign she seemed continually on the verge of colliding with someone but people measured out of her way step sideways made room how you do in case he heard the words and felt her formed him she slid a hand into her jacket a fingertip circling a nipple and the warm silk the sensation made him catch his breath she last but the link was one way he had no way to reply two blocks later she was threading the outskirts of memory lane case kept trying to jerk her eyes toward land box yet with a fuse to find its way he began to find the passivity of the situation irritating the transition to cyberspace when I hit the switch was instantaneous okay so all

of the book is like that it's highly sexualized there's just descriptions of acts of sex of sexuality there's things like what I just read and of course the whole book is about two-way eyes were sort of polar opposite who are very attracted to each other and need to melt to form something and telling you the book is and as William Gibson who stares at a very adolescent book written by a flower Louie immature or sufficiently immature man let's be honest this was you know directed to our sixteen-year-old boys and I know it works I used to be a 16 year old boy by the way there's an interesting 7 it's angle to this I don't know of any female equivalent to these sort of fantasies so there seems to be something that's specifically made about all of this so what she does there is connecting technology that are real Technol attack the technological possibilities to things that are exciting to young boys essentially using pop devices from literature so this there's a section various drugs

the violence anything that gets you excited when you're a 16 year old essentially but he does there is intensify the experience of technology something that you know literature adds to the possibilities are there are super advanced a eyes in Neuromancer and there's the art technology that even lets you experience all the sensory information from different people and people step out of this virtual reality and I pick up a pay phone on the wall and throw in a coin and call each other William Gibson didn't foresee the cell phone and you could ask so what what kind of a profit is he then and this is 30 years old he foresaw AI he didn't foresee cell phones that's for a week and my point would be he couldn't be bothered he wasn't interested just you know technology the less you speak a lot of people because it's not one of those liberating really exciting technologies the book is all about really intensifying experience of AI and VR so he's not a prophet at all he didn't

foresee the future he created it he used what he had available technological possibility and his very large means of intensifying something to create the future that he describes in that book so what seems to be going on is that certain fantasies of technology can be intensified and everyone in every now and then a very talented writer will come along and do that and you know describe how it would be to have a situation where the technology is real and would have undone one of the limitations of being human and destroyed what it meant to be human this is really transformative humanity is not the same when this sort of technology is in place and then once that has happened these ideas are very very hard to get rid of there in the world you can't undo what you did there it once you've intensive at them they're not through yet and they're not just fantasies there's something in between they're in the process of making themselves real like code from the future as a technological

possibility like code from the future being executed on current humans you can't kill those things they're just there everybody wants it to happen these books keep creating young boys of 16 years age who become engineers or entrepreneurs and you know start working on this getting very frustrated because it's actually very hard it's you know even worse than rocket science if you're in AI but it keeps producing us guys so what Gibson does here and what we do all of us in the ER in this room who are excited about AI but certainly all the people who work in AI like myself are doing is actually sorcery it's the manipulation the use of signs and symbols to bring about changes in reality using pretty much anything that we have available and it starts with just capital that we raise if you're that we Rises or if you're entrepreneurs to the fantasies from science fiction and you know just very hard work at that we put in I'm going to leave you with a quote by Mark

Fisher from whom I've gotten most of those of those ideas that's in flatline constructs coughing materialism and cybernetic theory fiction you can still find that in the Internet Archive they took the actual website down when he I think when he died earlier this year but I can still find is on the internet in this cybernetic age of anticipative simulacra fiction is not an image of the world it forms a resume with the world there isn't a parallel evolution of fiction and the world the empirical as such is increasingly the mere playing out of what has already happened virtually in simulation that's it okay let's make it happen

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.