Rise of AI Conference 2024 · Berlin · Applied AI Stage

The Strategic Importance of AI Ethics

Sarah J. Becker · Partner at Deloitte

At Rise of AI 2024 in Berlin, Dr. Sarah J. Becker, Partner at Deloitte, argues that AI ethics is a strategic enabler rather than a compliance afterthought. Opening with a personal story about a panic attack on a flight, she describes how people accept transformative technologies without questioning them until something forces reflection, and how new technologies tend to produce polarized reactions, either overestimating their potential or fearing humans will be overrun. She presents survey data showing that 79% of decision-makers already using generative AI report ethical concerns, yet only one in five companies has an ethical framework in place. Drawing on a study of AI ethics guidelines, she shows transparency as the most cited value worldwide, with explainability more prominent in Europe and fairness more prominent in East Asia. She warns that many organizations are currently swinging from early AI experimentation toward heavy control through compliance, legal and security functions, which raises the barrier to innovation. Her closing message is that ethics cannot be delegated and needs real resources, not just guideline documents.

Key takeaways

  • 79% of decision-makers already using generative AI report ethical concerns, but only one in five companies has an ethical framework in place.
  • Becker distinguishes visible concerns like hallucination and data privacy from a deeper iceberg of fears about jobs, inequality and loss of control.
  • Her guideline study finds transparency the top AI ethics value worldwide, present in 93% of the European guidelines studied.
  • Explainability is comparatively more emphasized in European guidelines, while fairness is comparatively more emphasized in East Asia, notably China.
  • She warns companies are currently swinging from AI experimentation toward compliance-driven control, which raises the barrier to innovation.

Detailed notes

Why new technologies produce polarized reactions

Becker opens with a personal anecdote about having a panic attack on a flight to Boston in 2016, which made her realize she had never rationally questioned the technologies that let her live as a frequent traveler. She uses this to argue that when a new technology has the power to transform how people live, reactions tend to polarize between those who overestimate its potential and those who fear humans will be overrun. She states that AI is one of those technologies and is here to stay, so organizations do not have the option of staying in a polarized stance; they have to build strategies that balance innovation and control, which she says is harder in practice than it sounds.

The ethics gap: survey data and the iceberg of concerns

She cites a finding that 79% of decision-makers in companies already using generative AI report having ethical concerns, while only one in five companies has an ethical framework in place to manage them. The most commonly cited concerns are hallucination, bias and data privacy, but a deeper study across an international company uncovers a larger 'iceberg' of concerns: fear of job displacement, fear of growing inequality, racism, surveillance and loss of human control over machine decision-making. She argues hallucination is largely a technical, solvable problem tied to data quality and trustworthy AI, while data privacy and intellectual property are often regulatory rather than purely ethical questions, depending on the industry.

Which values guide AI ethics, in Europe and globally

Drawing on a study of AI and digital ethics guidelines, Becker reports that transparency appears in 93% of European guidelines, alongside beneficence, explainability, autonomy, responsibility and security, values she notes also underpin the pillars of the EU AI Act. Comparing Europe with two other global regions, she finds transparency, accountability and security consistently at the top everywhere, but explainability is comparatively more emphasized in Europe, while fairness is comparatively more emphasized in East Asia, particularly China, where she links it to acceptance of social scoring systems. She warns that shared top-line values can mask real differences in what each value actually means in context.

From guideline word to working practice

Using beneficence as an example, Becker describes how a value moves from a dictionary definition into a corporate setting: first a stated commitment to the value, then measures and metrics, supported processes and KPIs, and people made responsible for it, so that employees doing the actual work understand what the value means for their tools, questions and products, not just a statement on a corporate website. She observes that companies are currently swinging toward control, with cybersecurity, compliance and legal functions taking over AI governance after initial exploration phases, which raises the barrier for innovation even as the pressure to keep pace continues.

Closing message

Becker concludes that ethics cannot be delegated: leaders can assign responsibility for it, but if it is sidelined it becomes a barrier to successful transformation. She calls on organizations to give ethics real resources and budget, not just a symbolic seat at the table, arguing that companies which invest seriously in an ethical tech mindset are further along in their AI transformation than those that have not, and that this requires bridging accountable leadership with the people who create value day to day.

Quotes

Ethics cannot be delegated.

Sarah J. Becker

AI is one of those technologies and it is here to stay.

Sarah J. Becker

Give ethics a seat on a table.

Sarah J. Becker

Questions answered in this talk

How many companies have an ethical framework for AI?

According to Dr. Sarah J. Becker at Rise of AI 2024, 79% of decision-makers in companies already using generative AI report having ethical concerns, but only one in five of those companies has an ethical framework in place to manage them.

What is the difference between visible and hidden AI ethics concerns?

According to Dr. Sarah J. Becker at Rise of AI 2024, the most cited concerns are hallucination, bias and data privacy, but deeper research reveals a larger set of hidden concerns including fear of job displacement, inequality, racism, surveillance and loss of human control over machines.

Which AI ethics value is most emphasized around the world?

According to Dr. Sarah J. Becker at Rise of AI 2024, transparency is the most cited value across AI ethics guidelines worldwide, appearing in 93% of the European guidelines her study reviewed, with explainability more prominent in Europe and fairness more prominent in East Asia.

Mentioned

AI ethics framework, trustworthy AI, hallucination, data privacy, transparency, explainability, fairness, beneficence, social scoring, generative AI

Keep exploring

More from Rise of AI Conference 2024

More on Enterprise AI & Adoption

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 3,022 words

Show the full transcript

yeah let's talk about digital ethics but let's talk about the Strategic importance of it ethics can be an enabler and when if we get these things right it can really help us for our transformation um no no no so okay the video is not working it's no problem so I used to be a frequent traveler I thought you know I'm a global Citizen and this was my my I have satellite homes everywhere across the globe and um yes of course this airplane it helped me to realize this kind of lifestyle and uh I've really been a lot of times in the airplane as a lot of you maybe too and um 2016 I was just sitting there I had just had my first daughter and I had a panic attack in an airplane well I was sweating and I was like oh my God I will die I was flying to Boston and I really I mean you can laugh about it now but I really felt it and I'm not I don't know panic

attacks so this was for me really you know I was in this plane and then I was trying I was thinking and I was like okay no no I just read something the risk of dying by entering a plane is nearly zero there is just no risk but I was thinking like okay this thing is flying in the air is not possible and I was in this circle so before that I had never really somehow rationally questioned this transforming technology I mean what kind of Technologies come together in an airplane I had never really thought about it it is convenient in our life it is just there and it helps us um it helps us a lot so what well what what is happening in general if we have a newent technology that has the power or ability TR to transform um the way how we live we tend to have a polarized um um um a polarized opinion on that so you have those who say okay they the group that overestimates the potential

of this technology and on the other hand those who say okay you human it is over so we going to get we are about to get over rolled these are the two polarized um tendencies that you can find but the thing is if we all agree here AI is one of those Technologies and it is here to stay it's already clear it is here to stay so what does that mean for organizations so what are how we going to handle this thing so there's not really this option of not you know being in this polarized mode so AI for good in a ter in a ter in a definition that you can see here for organizations if we are optimizing the positive impact it could mean that we have an impact on growth we have efficiency gains value creation competitive Advantage you will here find just very core economic optimization things that companies have to take care of to be sustainable so if we get it right we have the potential um to have all

these gains and be better than others and the dystopian scenario that is possible for organizations because they are there people are going to work that every day is okay let's a let's use AI for not bad meaning we might not be the Pioneers we might not move forward as much we don't believe in it but let's take care we have no harmful use let's make a transform a responsible transformation let's mitigate the risk and um let's take care of protection of data so I would just want us being from okay this is it could be polarized organizations don't really have the option you know we can speak about polarized opinions they cannot really build strategies on polarized opinions so they kind of have to find a middle way um but if we look again and I I'm I'm stressing this again if we look into society if if we look into the media we still find two scenarios that are kind of extreme for Europe we have on the one hand the Wild West it's

mostly examples from the us where we say okay they do whatever they can technologically do they just do it and these are if you have been on a main stage these are technology companies driving this Innovation and they just do whatever they can and then you have this fomo group yeah okay Europe is dead we don't have any chance yeah to be come to rise up again um and we in Germany and and and it's often even stricter than in whole Europe but we have this situation that we think we cannot we cannot keep up so what it is that companies organizations have to they have to it's not negotiable they have to build up strategies that um find a balance between Innovation and control now you look at me be like okay this is it this is kind of trivial Innovation and control of course they need to balance it yes it is it is as trivial as it is but how you're going to do this and what it really means is not

as easy believe me that's what I can talk about and work with people every day so what is new and it we we won't find this numbers for other transformative Technologies is that 79% of decision makers in companies already using AI geni um stated that they have ethical concerns when they implement or um work with um Ai and in the same the next question was okay so are you prepared for this and only one in five companies have an ethical framework in place to manage these concerns um they answered this and now you have to ask yourself okay or we ask what are ethical concerns I mean you said you have them but what actually do you think are ethical concerns and again here you can see hallucination bias data privacy if you look at the numbers of what are the most cited ethical concerns it's actually those this is what you can find but we have gone a bit further and ask an international global company all those who are actually experimenting with that

what do you think are ethical concerns and you see there is a lot more under the iceberg and if we now take a closer look for example at those that are discussed majorly on the top like hallucinations what is hallucinations I have talks I don't see my colleague David here we have a lot of talks that hallucinations can can be technologically solved very soon it has to do with dat it has to do with quality it's actually what we say trustworthy AI is how technology can solve and help us in order to cope with these kind of risks or these kind of barriers that people name let's go to data privacy same thing data privacy you see on top and there a lot more that we couldn't show in the graph data privacy and uh intellectual property it depended on in which kind of um industry you are there are a lot of more regulatory um impacts where you say okay this is a legal question it's not an ethical question so we know somehow

it's difficult but we know how to deal with it so the rest what stays there is wild and unstructured and heterogenous it is the impact on the workforce they have fear of job displacement they have people have fear of INE qualities on the other hand racism surveillance but also L loss of machine control the human machine interaction a lot of people we had done even more qualitative qualitative analysis here and we saw that people really when they technology comes into their decision-making they are afraid so I said just one of five companies has an ethical framework to deal with the issues that are coming up and if you look at them you see for the ethic there is just how you're going to tackle those aspects that Define in the end the acceptance the adoption and the success of using AI in a corporate context it's not trival even we know we need to balance Innovation and control so the question is ethics what's the standard do we have a standard for that because when

we have a standard we can kind of use this and help organizations to operationalize it and if you look at these um principles or values this is the discussion ethics is in Academia in society in politics the UI act it was a discussion first place about values and principles and these are those um that could be find um in most of the we have done a study in all those guidelines of of digital and AI ethics these are the values you can find if you take a closer look in Europe 93% transparency what does that mean of all um guidelines 93 of them actually had transparency in them so you can see transparency very important Ben efficiency explainability autonomy responsibility security for those of you who have been in in contact also with the U eui act they have been pillars also for this regulation so these are values that actually are very important for us in Europe and uh we could see this from the guidelines so we are not alone in Europe and

this was something Fabian is not listening to this now but we had discussions about that we are not alone here in Europe so let's take a look we have done the study too for a client and we have done a very intensive study for two other regions in the world what might that be and looked at the also at the most prominent values so again transparency on number one accountability security you can read through this a bit is this really striking is what what's really happening there so does it help if we say okay this is us this is Asia hm it seems kind of homogeneous right so also these values and this is science I mean this is studies that told us okay they have the same values so let's take a closer look transparency obviously the most important value and principle worldwide further explainability in Europe see explainability only in Europe us is they come later you know and the it's not a top six values you will find explainability in us too

but it is not very important so explainability if you look at the discussions that are done on explainability we use a lot of energy on explainability in science again in Academia and then what we tend to forget ethics is about not optimizing for V value but having a balance so if you make something totally explainable what happens to your value of literacy for example how you want to educate all those people on explaining them how this explainability what it actually means for them so also the values they have to be in Balance but just just a remark Europe seems to like explainability and then another thing striking fairness and it helps us for one thing fairness only in in in East Asia predominantly China so a social scoring system in the in the um Chinese Society might be absolutely Fair fairness is a value very important it indicates us a bit that okay Sarah can we talk about what fairness means can we not talk about what transparency means it indicates us that these are

values and principles and we need to might need to go deeper just one more example beneficence I pointed this out because it's a very old bioethical value beneficent doing good and in doing good is something that still whatever it means has been present everywhere and we will take a closer look what companies now F challenge face the challenge they face when they say okay we have guidelines because this is the only way to somehow nearly come into the direction of managing ethics and taking care that we behave like this values but we can obviously not work just with the words so this is very it's it's now just a short example beneficent there a definition again we extracted all the definitions what does it mean beneficent and all those um guidelines that we found and it's I wish we had gen when we did the study we didn't so it was a manually scientific work so beneficence has a definition what it is what in this sense it is then when it enters no when

it enters a corporate setup there's something needed commitment you need to commit a value that you want to work with this value and want to ensure this value and this is practically just you say you promote this yeah so this is an easy step you say this is important for us and now and this is very important measures in metrics in order to come to a framework and actively work with those to address the fears we need measures and metrics and we need to measure what we do we need to establish processes supported by relevant kpis and metrics we need to help people responsible for that and we need to make enable action and enable decision making so that someone who is and you had this picture of managing the management and managers those who actually do the work right they don't see the beneficence on the corporate website we promote beneficence in in order to tackle the issues that we had underneath the iceberg we need to make sure that those who do the

work know how beneficent will help them in terms of tools in terms of questions we ask to ensure that we have beneficence in every product to have beneficence in every process and in every action that we that we do and it shows us again and this was just a contribute again to Fabian that the value they are very sensitive to the context of course and they mean something in a certain setup and I think we in Europe here we have a strong value Focus but still organizations need to figure it out for themselves so again I'm coming back to Innovation and control how can we have actually this this balance um because um actually this is this is what is happening out there is more it goes more to what we saw in the beginning than to that and when we are talking to decision makers in companies right now we see that there's a clear focus on control and we have had seen setups where actually people totally like they have gone with some

exploration they have done some stuff and then there's this decision of okay now how to scale how to implement how to get it right how to strategize and then there's this break scenario so what happens is control takes over and we have all those functions within companies that take over and then they have their Frameworks for trustworthy I not that much but we have the seil set up cyber security security protection we have compliance we have legal and they all are asked okay please give us a framework we don't have a framework for everything else but give us a framework so actually the barrier that is what we observe is tending to get very very high for innovation and but at the same time we cannot lose speed so this is actually a situation um that we see within companies so it's um there's actually the need to act now and say change something in the way that we manage our AI transformation so what do what do we want you to take with you

and and uh spread read the words and talk it talk about it with all of your colleagues and everyone who think can have an impact on that ethics can be delegated I know people don't I don't like the word ethics by the way ethics helps me not to do my work have companies for a safe transformation but in the end ethics cannot be delegated if you put it on the side if you don't take care it will be a barrier and it will not have to transform successfully so leaders and people in charge can delegate it and we cannot stop educating on that then if you have realized that give ethics a seat on a table that is just a picture but it means give them resources and money because otherwise you have done nothing and nothing will work so we really need need to mean it and there are a lot of examples where pioneering companies have done that and they are further in the AI transformation than others that haven't done that so

it's in in an invest actually in getting the transformation on and again create an ethical Tech mindset to make ethics an enabler again I have to site you manage the manager managers we have to when we look at our um when we look at the organization we have to fill this gap of people are who are hold accountable in legal terms but also in strategic terms of having a long-term development getting this transformation um that AI is opposed to business models going on and holding accountable for that and those who actually bring the value and are those who are working on that every day so we have to bridge that and you you have to realize for that something has gone a change in the culture and again we have to value that thank you very much

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.