Rise of AI Conference 2019 · Berlin

The State of AI in 2019

Fabian Westerheide · Founder Rise of AI & Managing Partner Asgard

At Rise of AI 2019 in Berlin, founder Fabian Westerheide opens the conference with an overview of the state of AI. He recalls that the event started five years earlier as a small meetup called The Singularity Is Near in a Berlin hackerspace and has grown to about 800 attendees. Drawing on an AI Index study he worked on with Stanford University, he ranks the United States first globally, citing its research universities and large tech companies, and China second, noting a focused national strategy, abundant data and roughly 130 billion US dollars invested in AI. He argues Europe lags behind, lacking a coherent political agenda, large digital companies, enough startups and capital, despite strong research institutions such as DFKI and Max Planck. He describes AI becoming political, citing France's national strategy and a less concrete German one, and becoming big business, with the conference's own exhibition space growing. He argues most companies are not ready for AI because they have not digitized their data, and that deep learning, while not over, has stopped surprising researchers. He closes with open questions on ethics, bias and AGI, and announces the next conference date.

Key takeaways

  • Westerheide says Rise of AI grew from a roughly 50-person Berlin meetup five years earlier to about 800 attendees in 2019.
  • He ranks the United States first in AI globally and China second, citing about 130 billion US dollars China has invested in AI.
  • He argues Europe lacks a coherent AI political agenda and enough startups and capital, despite strong research institutions such as DFKI and Max Planck.
  • He argues most companies are not ready for AI because they have not yet digitized their data and processes.
  • He cites about 21,000 AI companies founded in the last five years, estimating roughly 10,000 are not purely marketing-driven.

Detailed notes

From a Berlin meetup to an 800-person conference

Westerheide recalls starting the event five years earlier as a meetup called The Singularity Is Near, held in a Berlin hackerspace, after reading a book by that name and finding AI was not yet discussed as a coherent theme. Attendance grew from an initial 50 people with a long waiting list to 170, then 300, then 600 last year, and about 800 this year. He tells the audience that working in AI now, whether running a company or applying it inside one, positions them at the right time in a field short of talent, capital and service providers.

The AI Index: the US, China and a lagging Europe

Building on an earlier study, Westerheide says he worked with Stanford University this year on an AI Index that scores nations on politics, industry, data, researchers, talent, startups and capital. He places the United States first, citing its large tech companies, top universities such as MIT and Stanford, and capital, despite weak federal AI politics. He ranks China second, pointing to a focused national strategy, a strong ecosystem, abundant data, more startups than Europe, and roughly 130 billion US dollars invested in AI, though he says China still needs to hire European researchers. He says Europe lags: no European company ranks among the world's 50 largest digital companies, data protection law makes working with data harder, and there are not enough startups or capital, even though research institutions such as DFKI and Max Planck are strong. He frames Rise of AI itself as an attempt to build a European AI ecosystem and a bridge for Asian and American companies.

AI becomes political and big business

Westerheide says AI only became a political topic in the past year, pointing to France's national AI strategy and a less concrete German government strategy, and argues that once an issue becomes political it tends to stay relevant for years as it trickles down to local governments. He also describes AI becoming big business, noting that the conference's own exhibition space had to expand after turning companies away the previous year, and describes an emerging value chain from chip makers to infrastructure platforms to vertical applications.

"AI is not the answer" and deep learning's plateau

He argues AI is not the answer to every problem, since most companies have not yet digitized their data and processes and need a broader strategy before adding AI on top. On the recurring question of whether deep learning is over, he says it is not, but concedes researchers are struggling to produce new surprises and are mostly gaining incremental improvements; he adds that existing deep learning techniques alone could keep companies busy solving problems for another ten years, and points to the conference's AI Evolution Stage as the place to discuss what might come after deep learning.

A new generation of AI companies and open questions

Westerheide cites about 21,000 AI companies founded in the last five years, estimating that once purely marketing-driven ones are excluded, roughly 10,000 remain; he names the Chinese AI company Squirrel AI, which he says raised about 130 million US dollars, and Starmind among companies invited to the conference. He lists open questions the conference will address: how to get talent and data, whether to build AI in-house or acquire startups, how Europe should respond to US and Chinese competition, and questions of bias and ethics in AI decision-making. He mentions an ongoing disagreement with his wife over whether AI should have emotions, arguing that AI used in healthcare and hospitality may need to sense how people feel. He closes by announcing the next Rise of AI conference for May 13 and 14, and by outlining the day's stages: a political Future Stage on the US, China and Europe, a later panel with members of the German AI Commission, a visionary stage with science-fiction authors and transhumanists, the hands-on Applied AI Stage, the research-focused AI Evolution Stage, and the Unicorn Stage for growth-stage companies.

Quotes

This industry will be the biggest change we will see in the next decade.

Fabian Westerheide

AI is not the answer to all your problems.

Fabian Westerheide

We don't have a political agenda for this.

Fabian Westerheide

Questions answered in this talk

How has the Rise of AI conference grown since it started?

According to Fabian Westerheide at Rise of AI 2019, the event began five years earlier as a roughly 50-person meetup called The Singularity Is Near in a Berlin hackerspace and grew year by year to about 800 attendees in 2019.

How does Europe compare to the US and China in AI?

According to Fabian Westerheide at Rise of AI 2019, the US leads through its large tech companies, universities and capital, and China ranks second with a focused national strategy and roughly 130 billion US dollars invested, while Europe lags behind with no political agenda, no top-50 digital company and too few startups and capital, despite strong research institutions.

Is deep learning over?

According to Fabian Westerheide at Rise of AI 2019, deep learning is not over, but it has stopped producing dramatic new surprises, and he argues existing deep learning techniques could still keep companies busy solving real problems for about another ten years.

Mentioned

AI Index, cognitive revolution, deep learning, AGI, AI ethics, AI bias, GAFA

Keep exploring

More from Fabian Westerheide

More from Rise of AI Conference 2019

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 3,684 words

Show the full transcript

my name is Hagen Vesta hidin and I'm the one having sent you plenty of emails in the last year yes I bombarded you for a year yes and got over and over more and I'm your host today together with my lovely wife but when I can just show you yourself please for a second yeah so it is it was hard to find the words it's it's so beautiful to see all you hear it is really nice I was asked yesterday how we started and I started five years ago after had read records world the single area is near and I had so many questions and I want to talk about this and AI as a overall theme didn't exist five five to six years ago it worse I researched somewhere in the world spread and I contacted over LinkedIn I've talked to them and I wanted to have more and I I said like I have so many questions I started a meet-up called the singularity is near and we met in Sea Base a

hackerspace in Berlin it was the smell of wheat and the background and loud techno music somewhere there it's typical Berlin and we discuss and it was really weird cool people and they asked me can you do this again but please a little stage I said like sure I made another meet up and we're 50 people and 200 no waiting listens like wow oh crowded we did it again 170 people 300 people last year we were 600 people this year we're 800 people every year we are growing and that means it means so much yes especially if you remember it's like a child you see to grow up and it's wonderful to have you all there so who is here for the first time and who has been here before good yeah because it's wonderful Sookie those who have been here before please be very nice as to all the newcomers we're very open here you can have a conversation with everyone exchange it's a very very great variety of people who have CIO's with entrepreneurs

we have students we of people from 25 nations we speak here English today but you can speak Mandarin if you can do try German everything works here this is supposed to be a number what AI is contributing to the global GDP somewhere all the consultants have done this beautiful numbers what I want to say is this industry will be the biggest change we will see in the next decade the first Industrial Revolution replaced the human body with the machines and enhanced us the second cognitive revolution will help us through place and enhance our brain and this is so much more because you are here you are already at the right time at the right spot that means you're really interested in this topic and if you run a company in the eye space it will be huge if you survive as usual with the startup it will be huge if you're doing AI in your company you will be the key man in the next five to ten years if you want to get into

AI do it because this you should demand for everything we don't have enough talents not enough capital not enough service provider this is a huge huge industry and this is growing we see it everywhere but also means you are ready showing the interest for the right industry for the right mindset and I thought about what do I want to talk about today because I spoke about brain machine interfaces and small mental just before I said like let's talk about the state of the eye how do I appreciate see the state of the eye and just for the technical team upstairs I don't see my my timer I would like to see my timer so I at least as a speaker keep keep the deadline so I last year with Wallenberg are we made a study analyzing where is AI really going off and this year I'm working together with Stanford University on an called AI index and for this I have considered several factors if you look at AI nations what is relevant for us

it has politics its industry its data we need researchers we need talents we need startups and we need capital and the market leader clearly is the United States the unites they have a lot of the gafas they have a lot of existing players they have a lot of great universities from MIT to stand for it they have all the startups they have the capital the politics isn't the best in the United States currently and it won't change for a while but outside of this it is clearly number one and again in the world leading in AI but number two is China and China is coming with a speed which we will have in our talks after me and speaking about they doing amazing because they have a very focused politics on this they have a very strong ecosystem they have abundance of data they don't have so many researchers yes that's why they like to hire European researchers because they know they need this they also have mixed talents so for Europeans great opportunities to

work with them there from significant more startups than we have in Europe and they have capital just as the number China is has already invested in this investing a hundred thirty billion u.s. dollars into AI German government last year five hundred thousand years that's how we do it honestly we in Europe which struggle we don't have a political agenda for this yes every nation has figured out what they want to do but it's not really there we don't have a digital industry it's very weak amongst the 50 largest digital companies that is not a single European we have a lot of data but our laws are making it very hard to work with our data it is really troublesome we have great researchers with the dev ki were phone overview of Max Planck we have great researchers here that's a plus we have a lot of talents telogen people great students a lot of people out there we have not enough startups so please go out there start more and we don't have enough capital

and so that's why I look at people like Christian yes that they are helping us to provide more capital to us so we're in Europe we are lagging behind that is the reason why we do by the way this conference because we won first that Europeans are starting to have more I in this yes we need more and second is we want to be a bridge here for Asian and American companies to come here to do business with us to start businesses here to use our data in Europe and to help us to have a strong ecosystem what else well AI in the last year became political I'm doing AI for a while and I know I talked and talked and no one cared for it last year it became political Macomb announced an AI strategy for Europe you wanted to do it our government here in Germany they can't came up with the strategy for artificial intelligence - it's not really hands-on it's not really executing it's more piece of a paper telling we

want to do something but we don't know what and when still it became political and the good thing is when it becomes political it won't go away because we know politics needs five years to get the hype so it will be there for another couple of years because now it is trickling down to all the demonstrations on the local governments and so forth I feel who the German government is talked several times this year have been several times to the local one Bolinas are not having informal formal discussions about AI so they are starting to think but they need the education they have no clue they just need to learn more about this well second it's it's becoming big business I see this with exhibition I mean we're growing so much that we have to expand the exhibition space and last year because we had to say no to a lot of companies because we didn't have the space anymore and it's in several levels of the chip layers if yes companies like nvd are

producing trips which you need you have the platform's the infrastructures then you have all the verticals on top but it's becoming business step by step we have more and today you you will find and apply the ice stage verticals speaking about this we have a lot of exhibitions having services in the I world and another thing I would like to add is stay a comedy to tell first what I mean is AI is not the answer to all your problems honestly most of your time you haven't digitalized your company yet you're not storing your data you haven't started to digitize your processes you're still in doing a lot of menial work so first you need to figure out yourself what you want to do having a strategy and then AI is like on the top someone said if data is the oil AI is like the petrol or the products all you have on top of this it's like the in Germany they say fade look for this and what's next I was I regularly

get off so deep learning it's over what's coming next and it's true deep learning is it's not over but we're coming to a point with deep learning stop surprising us anymore it's very hard to make new and new surprises with deep learning a lot of researchers they came up at the level saying like okay we can't get another two or three percent but we can't surprise you anymore and this is true the truth is we have so much to do just with deep learning another 10 years you can be busy at your companies solving problems just with existing technologies now imagine this is just one core one way to apply AI at your companies there's so many more ways to apply and more money surprises however we are very open we have a whole stage for this asking the question what will come after deep learning it's called our evolution stage what will be the next algorithm next approach the next platform how we can make machines smarter and then there's a new generation of

companies I speak about 21,000 AI companies being started that last five years 21,000 so if you take out the 60% who's just marketing you still have almost 10,000 AI companies out there and we have I've tried to invite the leading ones of them here we're squirrely I for example who raised I think a hundred thirty million isn't a Chinese AI unicorn with companies like star mind we have AI two eggs with math antics and more all presenting here either with a boost or at the AI evolution stage because they are the next one you looking for a job speak with them first you want to buy a company look at them if you want to have a corporation partner why not because they are showing us what a I can solve what is possible and what is not and then there are so many ants questions and I don't know the answers and this is what we are here to discuss this please I mean you already start with a topic leaders I saw this

was good discussions you will have the brakes they are few brakes but we try to have some brakes for you today yes to to re-energize how can you apply I how do I get the talents how do I train the people how do you get the data where do we invest we do it in-house or do I do I buy a company should our corporate with the startup even they could be dead next year or not what is with the global competition where's your standing and how do we have to handle China United states-israel do we cope for it with them is this a competition or is this a friend the whole topic of a ethics and the moment you work with the eye you're working on machines who are making own decisions that means we're building biased machines in the good way or in the bad way if you train your eyes means they can make something good on the long term or something bad for you plenty of examples how AI can fail

and plenty of example how a I can be good should a I have emotions and thing my wife and I would regularly discuss this in the morning really did we do because she says no a I shouldn't have emotions I say like someone will build emotions into AI because if I doesn't feel like you they won't understand you and if you want to have AI in healthcare and hospitality and so far you want to have AI which is feeling but for you and so something to discuss also will we have a GIS will we have a strong intelligence we have talks about this what happens if we have a strong intelligence so to give you a little bit of overview what you should do today this is their future stage and this is let's say the most political one for until the the lunch this is about it inertia AI West China West Europe where we're standing today then in the after the break we have more the political part with members of parliament here

members of the German AI Commission coming discussing what can Germany do to have way I hear and then if you make it until the end because I know you will have system overload at certain time if you make it until the end we have the visionary people with the science fiction authors with the transhumanist we have those who have the bold 550 500 years ideas what AI can do for society and for us then you have to apply the I stage which is over there it's a hands-on one it's it you want to know how to run it's about use cases about verticals about how you can make AI a real at your company then upstairs yes you take the stairs upstairs we have the AI evolution stage we just said it's about research it's about innovation it's about what's coming next is about the crazy ones the new approaches and then we have the a unicorn stage which were two stages this year last year they were together and unicorn stage is all about

the young companies growing becoming unicorns over the next year's you should know them if you haven't downloaded the app please do if you want to it's wonderful from networking it's it's tinder for business well you can swipe it's like beautiful and doesn't have to have bad feelings because I'm swiping left and right all the time yes so you're swiping swiping swiping if someone else swipes you - you haven't matched and it's a business match yeah so they have yo-yo five minutes stand here and meet new people sign up with LinkedIn use the password rise of AI and we asked our community to give us cool t-shirts levels and the winners they got a free ticket they're here and they came up with those and we would let it crowdsource this and we printed those shirts and if your speaker you get your free shirt over there at the VIP counter if not and you want to have one of them 20 years ago there please pay in cash yes I know it's do conference but

please pay in cash and you we have 100 t-shirts for you if you want to have one I think they're cool I haven't decided by the way if you can't read the one on the very left from your side this is intelligence test you will see if you succeed or not and yes I also can announce we will have the next Rise of AI conference because War II signed the contract it will be May 13th and 14th so take out your smartphone lock it in your calendar no excuses yes block it right off the time we will have it two days one day pure conference and the other day will be exhibition plus some conference elements because there's so many great speakers like I want more stages my wife kills me for this but I want more stages because we have so many knowledge to share and these were my words this is now my sign to give it over to Daniel and Daniel will be the mast of the stage the moderator I met

him on a ai' related conference I was a speaker he was a moderator and I liked him right away it connected he has the right energy the right mood the right kind of humor that's why I think thank you welcome Daniel on stage and have a great conference yes thank you actually we met those guys it was Microsoft explained two years ago and I can only return the compliment I liked you right away and when Fabian told me that he was running an AI conference I had not heard about I said like how could that be and he told me the same story he told you that he's been going from very small to very big and now we are here together and I have to tell you for me this is AI week I have spent the last two days at a conference hosted by the German Ministry of business affairs and energy and we have been talking about the state of AI in Germany and rest assured they know that the money they

put into AI is not enough but what kind of money would be enough I think we do not know that yet so I will not leave you just saying I rush that happens if I'm nervous you on stage yes please excuse me because I had so many people this time we are very strict with the times this time Swift breaks so at 10:30 all other stages will be open so you have time you can leave me now or you can stay for the next talk but at 10:30 yes all other stages will open so we have scheduled ten minutes between each talk for you to move around because this was something if you I know there's so much content so now your opportunity to switch yes otherwise stay stay tuned and follow the rest and we want we won't look too too hard and nasty on anybody who's leaving now yes okay fine I know there's so many other contents and it's good to move around so I just give you the opportunity no hard

feeling that's that's like Fabian I brought a number for you okay because I heard a survey Germans were asked like how many of you have any clue about a island how even how many do you even know what AI is do you have an idea how many Germans said yes I know what it is I would say if you ask them to define a I'm one percent knows how to define the I right but I would say 80 percent of people have an idea of AI right okay so 48 percent of all the Germans ask said that they have no idea about AI at all okay and I think this is a I mean normally more people tell you that they have an idea but they don't really have an idea so I think like it is is fair to say that the people that really know their way around AI in Germany although we have many international guests are all right here at a conference they are here they here for years yes we

have for example hunts in the first row who has been a speaker two years ago yes and came all the way from China yes we have a show over here who's a long term guess yes and he brought some friends with him too and here we have the the mother of Manu Sierra in the first row he's eighteen year old and he brought his mother with us with him which i think is really cool I have my whole family is here yes my mother is here my sister is here her boyfriend is here my father is here my mother she doesn't know anything about AI but she's coming every year because she's so proud to see me yes so say hello to them too if you meet them we have some people here oh here for five years in a row and we have eight more minutes to kick off the first talk on this stage so I wish you all a wonderful conference whether I see you here at a future ai stage or

on the other great stages thank you for a beyond for inviting me and I hope I'll see you at AI future Stage two during I will run around if you want to talk to me I will be the guy running around all the time here he has to stop me and I always have five minutes for you what you in seven minutes we will announce young Chui so have a great time so little in a couple of minutes thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.