Rise of AI Virtual Chat 2020 · Berlin

The European Data Strategy

Damian Boeselager · Member of the European Parliament (Volt / Greens-EFA)

In this Rise of AI Virtual Chat from 2020, Fabian Westerheide interviews Damian Boeselager, Member of the European Parliament for Volt and member of the Greens/EFA group and the budget committee, about the European Union's data strategy and its relationship to AI regulation. Boeselager recounts co-founding the pan-European party Volt in 2017 in response to Brexit, Trump's election and rising nationalist parties, and explains why Volt joined the Greens group in the European Parliament to gain committee seats, including the budget committee. The two then discuss the EU's AI white paper, led by Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, and the separate data strategy pushed by Commissioner Thierry Breton, who argued the EU needs a data strategy because algorithms cannot be trained without data. Boeselager explains the EU's proposed risk-based framework for regulating AI by how much it infringes fundamental rights, the tension between European sovereignty (data security, control of critical infrastructure) and competitiveness (relying on more advanced US cloud providers), and how the EUR 750 billion Covid recovery fund could be spent on digital and green transformation with minimum spending thresholds Boeselager is pushing for.

Key takeaways

  • Boeselager co-founded the pan-European party Volt in 2017 after Brexit and Trump's election, and joined the Greens/EFA group in the European Parliament because an independent MEP has no influence.
  • The EU pursued an AI strategy under Commissioner Margrethe Vestager (a risk-based framework tied to fundamental rights) separately from a data strategy under Commissioner Thierry Breton, who argued data must come first to train algorithms.
  • GDPR cost Volt half its subscribers due to compliance uncertainty and legal costs, but Boeselager still calls its core data-ownership principle a genuine European success.
  • Boeselager argues EU policy conflates sovereignty (data security, control of critical infrastructure) with competitiveness (needing US cloud providers, who currently lead technologically), and that these require different solutions.
  • He is pushing for minimum spending thresholds, at least 25 percent each on digital, green and resilience projects, within national plans for the EU's EUR 750 billion recovery fund.

Detailed notes

Founding Volt and joining the European Parliament's Greens group

Boeselager describes co-founding Volt in 2017 with an Italian collaborator, prompted by Brexit, Trump's election, the resignation of Italy's Renzi over a constitutional referendum, and the AfD entering the German parliament, which he recalls as around 90 seats. Volt built a Ruby on Rails platform to connect new members instantly with local representatives, prioritizing a positive onboarding experience. Registering a European party required registering separately in each country, ranging from about 60 signatures in Germany to 5,000 in Portugal and 150,000 notarized signatures in Italy, which Volt could not meet. After winning a seat in the 2019 European Parliament election, Boeselager says an independent MEP is 'irrelevant' without a parliamentary group, so Volt negotiated committee seats and joined the Greens/EFA group, which let Boeselager join the constitution, migration/asylum and industry committees, and later secure a seat on the budget committee, which handles the EU's Recovery and Resilience Facility.

Separate AI and data strategies, and a risk-based regulatory framework

Boeselager explains the European Commission's AI white paper, driven by Executive Vice-President Margrethe Vestager, proposes regulating AI according to how far it infringes fundamental rights, on a five-level scale, with the strictest regulation reserved for the highest-risk uses such as autonomous weapons systems and HR selection processes. The separate EU data strategy, pushed by Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton, reflects his view that a data strategy must come first because algorithms cannot be trained without data. Boeselager says the AI white paper drew 168 pages of consultation feedback and that a workable framework would need graduated responses below the top tier, for example licensing requirements or mandated transparency about training data, rather than only banning the highest-risk category.

GDPR's costs for startups versus its data-ownership success

Boeselager recalls that Volt lost half its subscriber base when GDPR took effect because unclear compliance requirements and legal costs (he cites a lawyer quoting EUR 6,000 a day) can seriously harm an under-resourced organization. He argues future AI regulation must avoid similarly harming small businesses, for instance through free legal guidance, but calls GDPR's core principle, that individuals own their data, a real success that has shaped privacy standards across Europe and internationally.

Sovereignty versus competitiveness in cloud and critical infrastructure

The two discuss whether the EU data strategy amounts to building a closed 'digital fortress.' Boeselager says the white paper mixes two distinct goals, sovereignty (data security against actors like US government access under the Cloud Act, cyberattacks, and control of critical infrastructure) and competitiveness, and argues that small European companies digitizing today still need to work with Google, Amazon or Alibaba because European providers lag technologically. His preferred fix for US companies is not exclusion but requiring them to pay fair taxes locally, comply with EU privacy law, and guarantee (potentially via splitting off a legal entity) that data physically stored in the EU is not accessible to foreign governments; Boeselager says such data-residency solutions (for example hosting in Frankfurt) are already technically offered by major cloud providers. He also argues the EU should mandate interoperability between cloud providers, especially for core infrastructure-as-a-service offerings, to prevent lock-in and preserve competition.

Regional strategies and the EUR 750 billion recovery fund

Asked whether all EU member states share the same view on data, Boeselager says most countries currently lack a clear data or AI strategy, making EU-level coordination important to avoid fragmented national rules; he cites Sweden's regionalized approach, for example focusing the Groningen area on healthcare data with public funding, legal clinics staffed by GDPR lawyers, and networking support, as a model he wants replicated in Europe. On the EUR 750 billion Covid recovery package, financed through EU-level bonds and distributed mainly via the Recovery and Resilience Facility, member states submit national plans that the Commission approves; Boeselager says current rules are not strict enough and he is pushing for minimum spending thresholds of at least 25% each on digital transformation, green transformation and resilience (including healthcare) within national plans.

Q&A highlights

Asked whether requiring US firms to split into separate EU legal entities could push American companies to reward users who sign up directly with the US service instead, Boeselager says he hesitates to jump straight to mandating a corporate split; his hope is that US companies find technical and contractual ways, verifiable through monitoring that no data packages leave EU soil, to guarantee data independence from US government access without full entity separation. He adds that he is skeptical of government attempts to build a wholly separate European Amazon-, Google- or Facebook-equivalent from scratch, calling that idea a source of nervousness given his private-sector background.

Quotes

The barriers to entry and democracy are extremely high in many countries.

Damian Boeselager

How would you train your algorithm if you don't have the data to do that?

Damian Boeselager

Questions answered in this talk

Why did the EU develop a separate data strategy alongside its AI white paper?

According to Damian Boeselager in this Rise of AI Virtual Chat, Commissioner Thierry Breton pushed for a dedicated data strategy because, in his view, algorithms cannot be trained without data, making data policy foundational to AI policy.

How does the EU's proposed AI regulation classify risk?

According to Damian Boeselager, the European Commission's AI white paper proposes a five-level scale based on how much an AI application infringes fundamental rights, with the strictest rules reserved for the highest-risk category, such as autonomous weapons systems and HR selection processes.

Does the European Union want to build its own separate cloud and internet ecosystem?

According to Damian Boeselager, the EU's data strategy raises the question of a 'digital fortress,' but he is skeptical of governments trying to replicate providers like Amazon or Google from scratch, and argues small European companies still need US cloud providers to digitize competitively today.

Mentioned

EU data strategy, AI white paper, GDPR, risk-based AI regulation, Recovery and Resilience Facility, Cloud Act, digital sovereignty, cloud interoperability

Keep exploring

More from Damian Boeselager

More from Rise of AI Virtual Chat 2020

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 11,336 words

Show the full transcript

good morning good afternoon we are live again with our Rise of AI virtual chat and that is episode 13. um before we start i point out that in the chat you can introduce yourself you can share uh you can share your linkedin profile what you do where you're based um i just have to switch the screen here for a second else uh i see myself with a with a slight lag second is we have created some polls um asking your opinion about what you think who owns the data how an ecosystem should look like i will read out the results of the polls later uh towards the end as usual you can ask questions use the questions um feature which here we have in the in here in the app at swap card i will um collect the questions and we'll ask the darmian in between so topic today is the european yes i'm a citizen of europe as many of us are the data strategy they have and the ai white paper they have

published just before corona hit us and that's why we never really discussed it and just giving you an example we all know the app tick truck by now tick tock is an instagram story feature from china which is very popular especially among young people and they say well they take the picture of you the facial profiling all the data this is going to china they will work with this so india start to ban this very successful app so you can imagine that um china has already banned a lot of european or american apps europe will one day say well google maps doesn't work anymore or google search doesn't work you know facebook we can't it has to be european facebook it has to be your uh you know european google search india is doing this so we have a trend here that the open internet which we have and it's wonderful it's closing and damian who's our guest today he is one of the best people to speak about this second european union has decided

to have 750 billion restructuring fund for the corona crisis etc and damian who's our guest today he is part of the budget committee so he has some insights there too and he's fighting for having a green digital unsustainable investment into our future and not spending the money on something which is a waste so as i said the guest is damien burzelaga um he grew up in frankfurt he went to the army which i think is something positive and then he started philosophy and economy and after his bachelor he worked for mckinsey i think two or three years then returned to study his master and i think public public administration here in business and um in new york and there he was a little bit involved in hillary clinton's campaign he um experienced the brexit then and he experienced the um the trump not disaster but the trump i think it's just a note in history and from there he was getting involved into political movement and to make sure he will talk tell us more

he started his own party which is vault in 2017 and two years later it was one of the it's the first pan-european party which means it's a party for all of europe he was elected member of the parliament and well i think that's enough for now let me bring him online hello damian hi thanks for the invitation wonderful so um i've briefly touched it you started your own party with a couple of other people so you are not only the founder for party but also member of parliament i think these are two cool things and thank you my question there's how do you start a party because we discussed this for a company you have a business plan and funding but when you never learn business schools how to start a party or political movement it's a very good question i didn't know it either um i think i mean we fell a bit into it you touched upon it you know like we went in in 2016 and fall there and we had all

these news coming in i mean brexit had just happened as you said trump was getting elected in italy actually elgenzi had to resign over constitutional referendum which was quite a big point for this friend of mine the italian guy andrea who was really also a driving force of this um and also in le pen in france was getting very strong i don't know if you remember but she was like ramping up her campaign at the end exactly and and it was also the year before uh the rfd went into the german parliament with 18 seats i think 90 in the beginning but then they lost two or something like this so that i mean like the time you can imagine was completely uh politicized and i think we all remember that and there was other puts of europe so i see you were with the shared citizens of europe i mean there was a lot of that a lot of flag waving i think for the first time actually with european banks um and we

were thinking you know like what do we do about this are we going to just you know maybe think about another think tank so we can bring in good ideas should we um i mean what can we do should we go with pulse of europe on the streets and we thought actually if the issue is in politics we should really go into politics but that was you know like the the abstract idea of the exactly go to the core of the problem and then we realize that nobody wants to go into politics party sounds boring and i mean if it's not an actual party but like a political party it's a career i i mean i'm a member of a party out there i have started with 14 i have seen all the processes and it takes either luck or a very special character trait a lot of waiting until you get a position the position you have i would have to wait 20 to 30 years until all the people in line either resign

or die yeah and that's i mean not a very interesting prospect for people who i guess want to want to get active and that was i think also one of the the issues that i realized more and more that i hope we can solve a bit with boyle is that people are just not attracted to go into politics at all i mean as you said like there's no you know it's not a career dream for many uh people to to do that and i think it's sad because in the end still parties put people on lists and lists are getting elected and it will be the people in the end you know who who run our governments and who who sit in the bundestag and the parliament and all other parliament so you are alone in the parliament for your party um that's correct which is by the way a good success to you know enter the parliament on the first attempt so congratulations to this we've seen it similar with the pirates and then

it's the you know they came up very fast and then they entered and you're part of the green fraction yes if i can say yeah exactly i mean just maybe to to to make the uh the connection between the beginning and and now and i mean how to build a party or a movement was quite an interesting thing to to experience like what we did we basically just posted hey do you want to join our movement and build up this tech infrastructure in the back that would instantly you know bring people in and then we would do integrity management first so community management and i would call community interaction and what platform did you use by the way to to to involve them that they feel they are part of something i mean it can't be physical all the time so we looked at the range of platforms and for different things i mean we in the end we had a volunteer at some point who was a very good coach he's a very good

coder and he built us the ruby on rails database and that would allow us to basically manage the people who are coming in and instantly contact them and connect them with the local responsible person so basically you you register you instantly get an email from the you know your local representative saying hi i'm i don't know max do you wanna like chat and talk about this and i think that what was something that was also very important for me from the beginning is like the user experience of being in a party should be positive you know you should feel like hey actually they they want me they're not just saying like yeah line up as you said you know at the end and then let's see what comes out of it but like you should instantly have somehow the feeling of like cool that they're well organized they the time matters for them like you know i have a email by the person instantly i have a phone call set up digitally very soon and

so like this was i think kind of important for us where was this um this this point that you between an idea and then you are what's the moment where you said you can't go back anymore where this idea was so real that it's like okay now i have to execute this the at least until we win or not win and then we see what happens i mean this was like it's like taking it it's not it's more than taking a job you know which you can cancel it you started the movement i think for me that point came um i mean one year in my master's so like half a year after world started i would say um i had to decide whether i uh changed my plans and leave the us for the second year and go back to berlin to finish basically my second year of my master in berlin which was possible in a partnering university but which was not my dream you know i lived in berlin for seven years

before i just wanted to be in new york and like experience my life there and like it was my dream you know two years new york would like i just had made all my friends and so on but um then like also the italian guy and they said like you know it's nice to start a european movement out of the us but like you can't you can't grow it you can't really mean it and build it and so i think the moment when i decided to go back to berlin um was the moment when it was clear to me that this is going to be a real thing okay and then because i i you you we have to get used to this i jump from question to question so speed or purpose i have a long list for you um and then this movement became a party you how do you by the way register a party and then in every country because you told me you can't be a european party you still

have to be a local party at the end yeah because under the european treaties european parties are actually foreseen but we didn't really implement them so they are these like technically they are european parties but they're not allowed to run on national local regional levels so they're not really and they're also not allowed to run for the uk with elections so it doesn't really make sense that is something a bit different from what we understand for our party and so yeah we had to basically register legally in all the different countries um i mean before the elections we did it in eight countries and so we ran out of eight countries for the european parliament elections now we have around 16 i think i would have to check and how this works is very different in germany it's quite simple you need around 60 people and then you can um basically yeah go and register at the bundesvara light at the electoral office if you want um and then you can get registered as a

as a friend of basically a party and then you can run for elections but in other countries it's it's different in portugal we needed 5 000 signatures to be able to be a party and um to register for the european parliament elections was also very different like in in italy we couldn't run because we would have needed 150 000 signatures given in front of a notary and just to get an idea it would mean that you get you know like a notary on the piazza and like a lot of different cities you dragged this person to that's very good friendly by the way i'm very corona unfriendly yeah but it's i mean also it's very innovation unfriendly so the barriers to entry and democracy are extremely high in many countries and i think it's something that we actually have to change because i think new ideas are good and just the the ideals for the existing parties that they have to perform well or otherwise there will be you know new ideas coming up i

think this is important and these new ideas cannot be just driven by money and power but just by you know by people who actually want to do it i like the summary uh the bears to entry democracy are way too high especially for this let's take a jump and now you got elected now you're a member of the parliament you're on your own but you joined the fraction of the green parties um just for curiosity why this fraction because green is on one hand super futuristic and on the other hand it's very often associated with not digital with not innovation friendly especially in germany so what i realized quite early on before even the elections is that in the european parliament you're irrelevant if you're not part of a faction yeah and in my movement there were many people who said let's just be independent you know we just do our thing we're not the same as the others we're an actual european party so let's not be in any faction and then i said

look the issue is if we do that we cannot deliver on any of the promises we made you know like none of the electoral promises we will be able to deliver on because we will be irrelevant and that was the first discussion we had with everyone across europe so but people understood that quite fast and then i mean who do you join yeah there's the epp which is the basically the conservatives um european people's party and they have people like orban in their ranks as we know yeah so the cdu and auburn's party fidesh sit together in this party so we were like ah this is you know this is the old past that's like really not what we want at all this is entire european party's party and so on then the social democrats i mean they also have quite uh weird parties among them and also a bit like the the past for us in a in a in a way so they were didn't really fit to us and then there's the

far left and the far right and both were not really interesting for us yeah and then there's uh exactly the liberals and the greens and with both i negotiated um very clearly saying like okay look we want uh certain committees so we can do what we want to do first one is the constitution committee so i can actually change europe and its constitution which is basically the main issue that void is about fixing the eu because there's a lot of stuff that we could talk about that's not working so well and the second one being um i want to work on migration and asylum so i want to be an interior committee and the third one being i want to work for sustainable and digital and competitive economy and therefore i wanted to be in the industry committee and this was where my demands you know like give me these three committees and i'll join you liberals or agree and so the liberals were a bit unclear to be honest in how to do that

and also i would have been um how do you say that in the hierarchy below the ftp in a way because the nikola bear would have been this my spokesperson in that group and the mood like anyways that would have been a fact so the hurricane is a little bit more flatter with the green ones so you don't have to report the sub one you can you're directly exactly in the greens i'm basically seen as my own delegation and so i'm allowed to basically be part of all the delegation leadership meetings and did you get those three because you told me you're also in the budget committee which is a very important one so that's a good point i got the three and so we voted across europe and basically i joined the greens and then i saw that there's an empty seat in the budget committee that i could potentially get and so i was then back then with johannes he was one of my advisors and he said like budget that's where the

money is decided you know that's where actual politics are being made like if we can get it let's let's get in and so we got it and we from the beginning took um responsibility for fire so basically an instrument of the european union that is called the eurozone budget is something that my core presented saying that hey we don't only need you know the ecb the european central bank to react to all these crises that are happening by lowering the interest rate but we also need to invest money by an instrument of fiscal policy if you want and that's something i worked on and that also explains why later on i'm now in this role that you mentioned the beginning of being really in the core of the recovery i already feel we could have a whole talk about europe and how to work there i have so many questions like how is it different but we have and i promised the audience to talk a little bit about data and ai today too so

um let's jump first in the question about the importance of data and the example i thought about like ownership of data plays a role for example i have a i drive a car who owe the data which is produced who is the owner is it the car producer the operating system of the car the car driver the car owner the insurance company the infrastructure one you know and there's so many parties involved and like where are we legally for example standing today and what is there so let's talk a little bit about data yeah just maybe as a little disclaimer yeah so since i'm part of the industrial policy committee i'm especially interested in industrial data and yeah also obviously that connects to what you're saying which is also you know if you're in the car is it there's also a relation to a personal data i guess you know like very often it goes back to that but my my first primary um objective is to understand how we can increase data sharing within

the industrial sector if you want with like not a direct focus on personal data so what we that's fine industrial data is it's less privacy issue it's a little bit it's easier so for me data is part the most important part of the ecosystem which we have it's like capital which you need for capitalism it's like oil we need as an energy source i mean it's involved everywhere but it's still how do you say still abstract what i realized is the european union came out very late within data strategy in contrast to china united states or obama etc they were a significant earlier israel there were earlier european union has no ai strategy yet just the white papers so what i read is the data strategy is the core thing and ai is just the application on top and that's how they view it some others say ai is the core thing and data feeds into it they see difference so what's your view on the importance of data versus ai and what is the

core like what is the master plan of you your european commission behind this yeah so i mean i think the easy answer is it's all connected you know like how would you train your algorithm if you don't have the data to do that so that's the bit i think the view i have um just to trace it back a bit in in history so the new i mean when i entered parliament i was that was july 2nd last year and then the whole process started off getting a commission together and where basically then from the line finally came out and from the beginning it was pretty clear that manga investor we all know because she starts suing google and apple and now actually just lost some cases of that but anyways um she she was clear that she would be there and she was already starting to work a bit um on an ai and white paper as you said and then switch position so she got more power if you want so she's still

the commissioner for competition but she's also now she got like increased in her rank and is now executive vice president for europe in the digital age so you or you're fit for the digital act so that's basically she's like i have to switch i think for this um there we go so now we speak about this human and just remember this because i have a very nice one for the end it's an analogy to star wars so everyone out there can look for how this looks in star wars yeah i mean i would be so happy it would be in star wars you know like when you float in the uh so she's like the if you want the top top digitization person in the eu so she started with her finally because i always said we don't have a vision and we didn't have leadership for this so it means someone who has the willpower to do something took responsibility finally yes i think so and she's strong i mean honestly she's good she's

smart she's she's fast and she has a strong vision so i think yeah i hope that she can push you know our slow eu to do some some good stuff there but then so my course sent in a woman first um as a commissioner and said like i want this person to be the commissioner for the internal market um and the parliament basically stopped her because she had some yeah like income issues as a mep before blah blah it doesn't really matter but so um the interior market commissioner was coming in quite late and then the guy is called thierry breton and he's a french guy sent by macron basically and he said when he came i have industry experience i have data experience i believe we don't only need an ai strategy but we also need this data strategy so it's really i think up to him that we have this now which is really cool because i agree with him as i said in the beginning how are you going to train your

algorithm if you don't have the data right so and in the white paper maybe just to to quickly summarize what's in there for the ai strategy um basically western says you know we need some there is a perceived lack of regulation for ai and i don't want all the member states like france germany and swedenborough to regulate that themselves and then we have again like this destruction of the digital common market if you want and it makes it hard for startups for smes for like big companies to understand what the ai regulation is in each of the different markets and will stop us from innovating but i want a common framework and the framework she proposed is very simple it's basically let's regulate a.i based on the infringements on my fun on fundamental rights yeah so like level one to five and they only want to regulate the highest level which has a certain risk level which is not exact exactly and but personally i think the idea makes sense you know you say my

spotif so if my spotify account discriminates me and sends me only country music i mean that's not really going against my fundamental rights you know it's a bit annoying but like uh you know it's a faulty algorithm but i don't i mean but if the algorithm would select you based on your gender or your race profile in a interview process maybe exactly and that's where you go up the ladder of fundamental rights you know i would say at the top we have autonomous weapon systems um i guess who would do that or like interstitial you know decisions being made by a heights or something like that and then a bit further but still i think in the highest category as you said is hr processes hr selection process but this is a good question because i'm i'm involved in the bdi which is the largest industry lobbying group here in germany in the how we react and they want they had a one question what do you define because no one wants to be in

level five everyone wants to build below let's imagine hr process is level five on the same level like automotive weapons from the class that means a lot of startups out there whoever works with hr they are now under a new set of regulations and this will be a very interesting discussion do you have some perception if europe will give clearer guidelines or if we have to figure this out on ourselves with we i mean on national level so the white paper um is basically an invitation for consultation it basically means i think that there's something that we need to look at here's an idea what the direction could be and now hundreds of recommendations i think it was 168 just long i mean a lot of people sent feedback to this and i think this is by the way a beautiful process not perfect it's not digital enough but i think it's great to ask for feedback and build this in so everyone can lobby it doesn't matter how big they are i fully agree

and i think the i mean the direction is right you know whether the five categories are the right ones and whether we should differentiate more um is is a good question and we also should see you know if we have five categories what kind of regulation do we put next to it because i don't think you should only regulate the highest one but you could say the highest one i forbid if it's autonomous weapon systems if the second one the second highest if there were more categories is something you say like i only allow this for licensed licensed algorithms yeah so you need to get a license to be able to do that that could be i mean that's a typical way to regulate you know if it's a high risk kind of environment and then you could go down saying like here at least you have to have transparency on the algorithm it's like on the data set that is underlying it so that you can see it's not discriminatory and so on and

you can go down the list until no regulation whatsoever in the virtual chat with a member of the german parliament thomas Heilmann we discussed this he proposed i called due diligence so you have at a certain level you have a due diligence process like you have it with data to do and with your with your balance sheet etc end of the year and that gives you maybe a license or not and that means if you're classified somewhere there there will be a process either it's register only or you're free or you have to actively need a license for this that also could mean that for example google on facebook could maybe apply for a license means they come under even more stricter european law to be controlled i think when it comes to um algorithms and ai that would be the case then yeah i think that's exactly the idea that you um try to create a framework which is precise enough but still simple enough for everyone to understand are you involved a little

bit in this do you have influence so um the ai strategy is still in a very early phase as you said it's in consultation phase and we have to see what kind of regulation comes out of it but i could imagine so i mean you have different committees in the european parliament so for example there's the jurisdiction like yeah the uae committee which works on all things legal if you want um and then there is the interior market committee and i think and and the legal committee which is the interior security committee if you want so they all will have a role in this and the industrial policy committee which i'm part of um will have a role too we'll have a role too but it's again it's more about you know how do you help industry to to to get to a place where they can use ai more how do you help industry to get to a place where they you know share data more so it's less on the the regulatory framework

just asking because i want that startups on you know under certain size are not regulated because it's too much hassle if you start an air company you have to pull out pages of pages before so this is a critical thing um can i say one thing to this because i mean just when we started boiled yeah like i think midway um the gdpr kicked in and so we lost uh half of our subscription base um because i mean like i tried to call in a gpr lawyer at that time and he said like yeah it's just 6 000 a day it's fine and i mean we had absolutely no money so i do know how shitty for a small startup kind of organization um unclear uh you know regulation is you know like it's really bad it really it can destroy your business model and it can really harm you because you don't have the funds to you know afford these lawyers that uh exactly that goes back to the green fields kind of um

or green forest um but it really can really harm you and so i think whatever kind of regulation is being put out there we need to make sure that it doesn't have these harming effects because it's explained extremely clearly and you get free legal advice or something like this but on the other hand gdpr is quite a success for me because it just instantiated the the rule that basically you own your data that's i mean it's just it's a simple philosophy but i think it is there and that is a huge success that actually has had effects all across europe because we have united kind of way to look at it but also across the world in terms of privacy standards and so i think we have to somehow if we regulate take the good sides of like you know putting something like you own your data in there but without uh having these um yeah this huge unclarity about what this regulation means for small business this leads me to the polls on the

one hand please fill out the poll because i asked you who's owning the data and then um this leads me to the the background i have here which is means for me it's all about an ecosystem and you know i just purchased a lot of wood so i'm playing with this ecosystem idea too and we humans are always just trying to regulate everything but at the end it needs to nurture itself and grow so i for me the role of government is to build an ecosystem let's say for ai so let's say provide the framework the funding the infrastructure and then provide everything which is needed but it has to grow in itself as we i think the government should not start companies yes it should own them and should not regularly build them it should help them to grow and protect them from outside from everything which could harm them because they are too small so which comes to me my feeling from reading the data strategy is that euro wants to build its

own ecosystem which means it's a digital fortress or walled garden or however you want to describe it but it will be closer to you what your not us yet but china is doing means that's our internet that's our data our cloud space our infrastructure our rules if you play here you play after our rules and is this just my interpretation or do you see this too i see this too and here's also where i disagree to an extent with like what's being done so if you look at the data strategy i think they very clearly state the issues you know like we need to have i mean a lot of companies are not sharing data there's a mentality issue there is like and also like a collection of data issues there's a standardization issue there's a certificate i mean there's many issues that are well defined in this data strategy but when it comes to solutions first of all it makes me a bit nervous maybe because of my my background in private sector consulting

where everything needs to be you know boxes but um it's not clear how the solutions are connected to the issues that are being mentioned and it's the first thing that makes me a bit nervous but okay it's forgivable but the the bigger issue is that i think the question of sovereignty and competitiveness are mixed you know is it about european competitiveness or is it about european sovereignty and there are different concepts yeah so if you talk about sovereignty you talk about security of your data and so you talk about maybe third con third party actors could be countries like the s with the you know cloud act and so on being able to like take your data so that could be something that you are afraid of and then you would have to shield yourself against that and there could be regulations to do that they could be the question of cyber security attacks and and yeah basically hacking of your data um and all these issues of or like you could be talking about

your critical infrastructure you know you define the internet as a critical infrastructure and you feel that you need to physically safeguard you know this infrastructure to an extent and shield it off but these are questions of um they don't they don't go hand in hand with competitiveness because you're basically saying i need a fortress as you said i need to be i have a certain level of authority of autonomous like like with water electricity so internet should be like those three like air which we can't limit that much and that should be either an ownership of regulated european country companies or state-owned maybe like some water pipes on all the systems this or like the roads in some countries exactly and you're saying exactly the right thing you know like for these topics of critical infrastructure we you know we kick our crew away and we you know we're careful and we want to be like yeah everything in european hands because we don't trust the outside world but i think this narrative is also

dangerous to an extent because i mean um if you talk about competitiveness who like if you're a small company right now and you want to digitize um for example some some part of your manufacturing i mean which kind of competitive google i need amazon cloud these are the first especially alibaba for example the first companies i would recommend you to work with if you're working with data and you know upgrading your your industry and there are no german i can recommend there are non-europeans i can recommend the americans have a huge head start technology wise and i think there you have it the question is if to be able to digitize and to actually share data currently you would recommend people to use these um providers from outside then if you forbid these providers you decrease your digitization that is a problem that's a problem i haven't solved yet for myself too intellectual but the issue is like why do you mind that there is an american provider like i mean google amazon and microsoft

currently providing cloud space my answer taxes if they would pay fair taxes and their fair share what they earn here they are fine i mean it's like we can buy foreign cars too that's not a problem if they comply with regulation and it's a foreign company i don't care i just want that they pay their taxes here because we need the money and what i'm really pissed off is they don't and that's not only their problem that's a lot of other corporations do the same and that's also european you know dublin luxembourg problem and so far and then but i love that you say that because it's you know it's clear you say they should pay the taxes and i want 100 agree and so let's write regulation that makes everyone pay pay their fair share yeah so that's absolutely i'm with you i have another issue you know if the competition is bad um then the prices would increase and people would be locked in with certain job providers for example especially if there's

no interoperable you know way no interoperability between the different providers and then obviously it gets worse when you go from you know infrastructure as a service up to platform as a service and so on but um and that's something i think we should regulate as well i think we should strongly regulate that there has to be interoperability i think all public contracts that are being signed should force cloud service providers to increase interoperability between others so that like it really is just like one you know push on the button and you can go to another api like uh possibility to change your cloud provider and don't lose your data exactly and i mean i've talked to a range of companies and they said you know the core services provided by cloud by the big cloud providers are the same and then yes there are specialized services and obviously you can't ask someone to transfer data and learnings from algorithms and so on to to another let's say technical world where they don't exist because you're

the only one offering that that's fine but at least for the core of of the cloud services i think we need to ensure that there's interoperability and we need to fight for that and this is stuff i i love talking about because this is you know helping businesses reduce transaction costs ensuring that there's no lock in ensuring that you know you have the best service available that there's competition amongst the cloud service providers but what i don't think is fair is to say i don't like american companies because i mean we are so interconnected with the states the fact that we believe that it's okay to you know say i don't like uh us based companies as a whole in general i think it's not it's not the way europe works we always say everyone who adheres to our regulation you said that who pays taxes who um you know supports our privacy laws who is like in line with everything should be able to operate i don't care where you come from i agree

i will continue to use google and amazon because they provide a significant better service and for a better price the second thing which is first but which annoys me it's it's taxes because regulation you can fix privacy issues taxes and second is i hate that the americans are spying on us in that scale it's like they they do it and it's it might be it's assumption easier for them to to use existing american platforms for the political interest like the chinese do it you know the moment i use alibaba i know that this is transparent data and it will feed into my social store and um you know i know it feeds in there whatever i buy and purchase on amazon i assume that it doesn't feed into everything but at least nsa i assume will check it and this pisses me off too that we i feel unprotected i feel like everyone can read me and the european union is not standing clear and saying hey we protect the interests of our citizens at

least that they're not spied on that scale anymore i fully agree i think there is very interesting and due diligence is made by um i mean the commission but also by big companies trying to understand where am i sure that no data package leaves the european soil yeah and that's i think that's a super interesting and a worthy kind of exercise and i mean if that means that some of these companies because they are under the cloud act obliged to give data to the you know the us government then maybe we need to say like look then you need to split the legal entity yeah and then you have to be here and ensure that you are here and can legally ensure that the data doesn't leave um we'll have a european google and european amazon and european facebook maybe and then they will work out how they they say okay but we have one algorithm how do we feed it and so forth but the end they need to i see they need to

split and build and i think the good thing is like i don't think we need to um you know already say what the how they need to do it we just need to tell them you need to do it so if i as a that's very politician yes you have no i don't care how you do it nobody i think it's it's very true because i mean i think for many many services for example spotify um maybe i don't mind if the data maybe that goes a bit back to you know the risk framework that we're doing earlier maybe i don't mind much but especially when it comes to public data or individual data so public sector data that is maybe very secret or like individual data um maybe i want to have the right to say i don't want my data to leave this country and i don't want my company's data i want to be sure that if i save this data in the cloud maybe it's hosted by amazon but the government

or other governments are not able to access it exactly and i mean there are these solutions already offered by google by amazon and by microsoft which say your data is i mean basically physically stored on our servers in frankfurt or somewhere and or you can also say i store my data they have to do that gdpr even though i mean it doesn't say gdpr european data is not allowed to be stored outside of europe so i think um you can basically admit to your data being stored outside but i'm again i'm not like a perfect um expert on gdpr but i think the issue here is more when it comes to gdpr that um if a country is equivalent in their data privacy laws okay we allow this country to take our data as well and that's the the huge battle that the eu and the states currently have on the data shield and the um and the question of whether um is as tough as as gdpr so i think that's a huge political

fight that that will continue to come but i mean just like maybe to to summarize amazon can host your you know you can manage your cloud even though you said you have your own service um where it's safe yeah that that is a feasible technical solution already and very standardized possible so the only thing that we want to ensure is that whatever learnings amazon takes from the data that it manages for you that i mean first obviously doesn't take the data itself and takes it out of your server somewhere else and also that the learnings that can generate from your data is not you know transferred without your consent to um to governments in the uh the us government or other companies in the us i think that's uh so we have one question from the audience um which reads do all european countries have the same understanding of a the importance of data and b furthermore the practical moral view and ownership of data differ from members this leads me to following question a

little bit the political i heard that the stock is driving the ai strategy but brothers driving the data strategy which are a little bit different so it's a little bit power play maybe there and then you have all the national states and one some say hey we care about data and others say i don't care that much what is your feeling like how the power plays and how the national levels who's the driver for a stronger sovereign and competitive system versus i don't care so i think in all countries as i see there is a as i said there is a perceived lack of regulation when it comes to ai and also when it comes to data and when it comes to sovereign sovereignty on data um and also competitiveness so i think a lot of countries are currently like building their their strategies in this aspect and that's why i think it's so important that we do it on the european level as i said also because i mean the worst case scenario is

we have diverging routes across europe i think that could really harm all our businesses to a large extent and so i think we really need to make sure that this works well the power play between the commissioners is not so much of an issue because i think they add to each other very well yeah like the ai regulation makes sense the framework that she's putting forward is a risk framework and it makes sense but and the data strategy is much more like okay let's make the data available let's push for that and i think there's some countries which are really running ahead i mean i went to sweden obviously a huge form like a huge forerunner if you want of how to do that well they have a regionalized ai strategy which is something that i'm also pushing for in europe so you basically say um okay we know in groningen we have a healthcare university and we have some healthcare companies so let's make the area of groaning and an ai focus on healthcare

and health data and health sector if you want and push you know what they do is they give money for projects so that companies can come together with universities they do something which i love which is legal clinics so they give you a range of gdpr lawyers and data lawyers so that you have basically the knowledge of what that means and how to implement that and how to share data with each other in a legally combined way and they just make this you know a clear priority and i think this is something competence center so they provide uh access to network a little bit of capital and that's how they attract talent and more capital and companies exactly so i think the yeah and that leads me to the question i mean europe is now spending big big money um 700 billion at 750 billion how do you how how will we in the ai industry at the end can't benefit from this like what are means for europe to really support an ecosystem like

behind me regulation is clear but how can they give financial incentives and what are good means to distribute the money yeah so there's a there's positive and negative news on this yeah so the negative news is that the eu has a program which is called the digital europe and it's a really cool program to push digitization across the eu um but while on the one hand we have like this huge recovery package um with the 750 billion that you said and now set up and i can explain a bit how that will work we also have the seven year budget of the eu and where this digital europe program is in and there they the heads of state cut a lot um in the last meeting that they had in the uh i mean a week ago by the way is this the predecessor or the following after horizon horizon 2020 no horizon has its own um um basically follow-up and that's more for research and yeah innovation europe is its own i mean i

think it's actually a part of horizon i have to check this again sorry um but it's basically its own uh like legislative act um and is really focused on you know pushing for ai for uh digitization and so on um but so there's some negative news on on money being cut currently and we from parliament will try to push it up again and i'm already trying to do that with some other people um but then there is the recovery package and this is the 750 billion and here the majority of the money is giving a given out in a very weird process yeah so um basically europe borrowed 750 billion from the financial markets yeah directly uh secure or will borrow but directly secured um with you budget as a collateral if you wanted who will who will sell the money like who will give us the money is it uh pension funds or a central bank and so i mean like treasuries on the german level like normal uh government bonds if you want

they will be given out i think to a series of buyers in the basically first so germany is giving out bonds and then gives this money to the eu no no so i think it's just i just i want to say it's a similar system as german treasuries work yeah if you want yeah so and now it's only happening on the eu level which obviously has a very high credit rating because you have all the different companies and the insurance you know a factor it's like the euro bond we never wanted to have it is exactly that it's so funny how the uh how the you know debate changed how europon said is not being mentioned anymore right um but it's exactly that i think the the positive thing that comes out of it is that um the idea is to channel this money through instruments in uh in the eu and not just transferred to a member state i think with europe bonds a lot of people thought oh okay now countries can just

indebt themselves further um and just be secured by the eu as a whole and that's something i also don't think is a good idea but what is a good idea is to say we are in a huge pandemic we're in a huge crisis i mean not only do people lose their lives but also the economy is going down um really rapidly and might for a longer period of time and we have to understand that we have to in get out of this together and not only the rich germany you know helping lufthansa and being happy but also the european uh boring 750 billion houses now distributed to companies ngos or is it governments like who's receiving the money and how do you get it okay so basically it's forward then it's by a technical process um pushed into um some programs of the eu budget um and the main new program that is being set up is called the recovery and resilience facility so around 75 percent of the money are being spent via this

and how this works is um there's an allocation key of how much each country can ask for and then they write their national recovery and resilience plan and can just basically write whatever they want into this plan and then they go to the commission and say hey we want this money for this plan do you think that's okay and so far in the regulation there's not so much written and it says you need to your national plan needs to be green and digital but i'm not so trusting in that because if you look in the annex and that's i mean where the legislators work comes in you can see that um they don't really make this criteria very biting yeah so i'm not sure at the moment if a country comes in and says you know i spend one euro on um on digital stuff and one euro on green stuff on greening you know our economies and 98 on a coal industry um that they wouldn't be able to approve it under the current

how the regulation is currently written so what i'm trying to fight for is very simple minimum spending targets so i say there should be three priorities for this european money first is digital second um green transformation and third resilience so that could include healthcare resilience and i mean basically making our administrations more resilient to to shocks and um you should spend at least 25 percent of i mean when you hand in your plan you should show that 25 of your plan is spending on green 25 percenters and resilience 25 so you go in you say they need certain thresholds criterias you have to spend it so you don't spend it just on building tanks because you want to have a defense spending but to make it green sustainable and digital for the future by the way i think this is also what vault stands for right uh digital and sustainable and green like yeah very much i mean that's exactly our line i think we have like this weird element of fixing the eu obviously

as a as an additional thing it has to because the first people already asked for the shirt in the chat and i purchased it on redbubble who wants to just give in citizen of europe and you will get it in your size um i think we should have more of those another question for you because what time is limited we have eight minutes left and florian butch asks following if you legislate the companies that have to split into two entities yes let's say facebook is a google one and uh american one to comply with law and how to ensure that they won't offer different services and as a european consumer will i be obliged to use the service of european company instead of let's say the american part of it maybe u.s companies would reward european customers to sign up directly with them so that they get more data uh that's an interesting thought by the way so google says hey oh google's way better if you use google america and not google germany it's

a super good question that's why i didn't want to jump the gun and say you know we need to split these companies to be able to fulfill the regulation i mean my hope would be that the us understands that it's better to comply um to yeah like some form of eu uh standards when it comes to privacy so that like these companies don't like are not forced to share their data with the fbi um or like the ciao whoever or nsa um but that they actually you know can secure us that they are independent it could also just be sufficient and that they somehow find ways to say look the data is stored in in germany and or in europe and we don't even have access the american government to the data itself as of the technical setup of this because we can actually monitor that there are no data packages leaving um yeah exactly so and my my hope would be that we can come to such a solution where um basically maybe they

can manage data without having the need to um you know actually have access to it from them people here will say hey i need to train the algorithms i need the data for this that will be something tricky to solve but companies will emerge to solve this um i had a thought which i have which i have lost now uh yeah i mean i think it's a good it's a good like the thing is i think we should acknowledge that this is complex um and not and that's why i didn't like the data strategy so much i jumped to the conclusion let's build it all from a german european whatever french perspective we just built our own google we built our own facebook we built our own uh cloud service provider and also with a bit of a status view as the government you know like when the government and you said this earlier when the government thinks that the eu or any government thinks that they can build like an amazon or like amazon

web services or like something like this i just get very nervous you know like the idea of being able to reproduce um a european cloud service provider completely on our own um and make this available for public use it's just something where i where i get a bit nervous from my private sector and maybe then at that aspect also liberal kind of so i summer up a little bit first europe has a huge data market i think it's as some would say it's the oil of the 21st century it's a little bit different than oil but it is a richness which we have which means like saudi arabia emerged with this walls we can use this wealth too it's huge and it's brilliant and we have to use it goodness europe wants to regulate it for protection we still have the unclear questions of sovereignty like protection versus competitiveness where it means open market um you want to just set boundaries so that we don't have too much fragmented regulation at the local level but

on the local level we want to have regional adaption like you gave with the example of sweden so there we still have like in eastern europe which is lagging behind and we have western france germany and the nordics which are a little bit faster um this will still it's still open yes everyone can get involved there um what what else we have to mention there and by the way yes the 750 billion i can't apply for it only my government can apply for it that's a pretty good summary and i mean as always like it's a complex it's um you know the eu is a big big animal but i do believe that it's quite important that we fight also in these big animals and it brings me back to my original point on you know join a political party not the right-wing one as possible but like join a political party to ensure that all these decisions are not only taken by you know people who don't know so much about digital policy and

i mean i'm also like at least i know some you know and no python so at least i have some access to it but but i think it's really important that we understand that these decisions are super important for our future and are being taken in politics by politicians in the star wars background that you that you're currently doing by the imperium or whatever it is and so i think they're emerged after this that's the problem yeah so i think it's really important to get active in politics to make it short bring your expertise and your ideas and then get active oh my i mean history or future it's it's a thing um the european union is the closest which we have to the galactic senate that's because a lot of local member states or planets are there we all know about the strengths and the weaknesses yes we know how it can play out i i give a clear call for hey check out vault it's not don't i don't say vote them but

go out there and check them out because it's one of the precious ideas which we have there on the on the market yes for political activity i say get political active if you're not that's at least vote please always vote and second try to do something because this is too important for us and if we don't get active we can't change anything um well and then i would say any last any call to action from your side no i fully underwrite what you said become part of the galactic senate and help us change this so that basically the european model becomes the the like a positive example of how we can live in a society that is sustainable that is digital and fair and and take out your passport and tr look what's on the top because my passport says european union and then it says bundesliga deutschland so our european union is already it's already there if you say oh no germany's no european union is the most important which we have to protect

and then comes our regional it's berlin or it's frankfort it's paris you know wherever you feel home that's what we have but don't put too much emphasis on your national state because the national state is in between and your opinion is already there we can't see and i tell you brexit the british they will suffer from this and they maybe have earned it and they will come back hopefully because they're part of us i hope they come back to you wonderful um damian i thank you um i have shared your contact details there else um your twitter your webpage and your linkedin profile i will share it with everyone after via email so thank you for coming in you will be there again for the summit which we have 16th and 17th of november then you will talk a little bit more it's half a year how the european market looks like and then we will have also more maybe physical interaction it will be hybrid streaming plus physical being there so i'm looking forward

to this me too thanks a lot for your time thank you um do i want to finish with a galactic empire because it's collected senate ending them and to to let me see if something more optimistic ah yes that's a little bit more optimistic we're still on earth so um that was today about well we spoke a lot of insights about how european union works what they up to i learned a lot i think you learned a lot um i want to point out for the next virtual chat which is next week same time very interesting topic it's dr rick franke who is a polit policy advisor on the european level but it's more an ngo and we speak about the future of warfare so we will speak about what darmian has mentioned about the level of to be regulated services what do we have there how is china united states russia what do they have out there uh how is the law here what can we expect how will war be in future good

news is less less less people die from years to years because of autumn's war we speak about drones so the whole topic will be touched i think this is a topic we do not speak often enough and it's often ignored in germany but if we look for example france that's one of the key pillars of the ai strategy which is national defense and security strategy we germany don't do it but we're here european we are global i think this will be highly interesting so next week you can register as usual with a link which will be shared here in the chat or do you go on rise of ai slash virtual chat register for free i will also announce next week the next four virtual chats which we have i have done the planning until september a lot of interesting will come up too excited we will have 16 in total then and it was a pleasure as you usual i will see you next week have a great day you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.