hello everyone welcome back to the rise of ai 2020 here at the hybrid area i hope you had a nice lunch break we definitely had and welcome you all back with a lot of energy for this afternoon we will talk mainly about ai strategy and we have a lot of very interesting speakers for that and at the end at 5 00 am we have our accenture humanity competition so please stay tuned for that and now coming up and you remember before the lunch break we were talking about german regulation ai what politicians could do so what is very interesting obviously is the european level of that and damien burzelaga from the european parliament and vault i think it's a movement they called it but maybe damian can explain it later he will explain us about what the ai regulatory framework on european level is and could be so also taking a look into the future and what i like very much about damien is that he's a true democrat fighting for legal migration and fair
and fast european asylum system and ensuring that the eu works for all via budgetary stability measures and we have a competitive and innovative european union so coming up now damian and please give him a warm welcome thank you thank you very much for the kind introduction and yeah i mean i work on a range of issues as you have said um some of them like in regards to migration i also work on the recovery package that is currently being discussed and stopped by two countries which i won't mention in this very moment and i'll come to that later but maybe quickly as a couple of words of introduction and then a bit of an overview of what's going on on the european level from a regulatory perspective and maybe some three key and very simple theses um on what we should do and why the european level is important for ai regulation so first of all to myself i mean as you said like i uh three or four years ago i founded a movement
or party it's both so i don't really mind which one you choose um with an italian friend and with a french friend and the idea was to say that on the big topic of our topics of our time be it migration but also um ai and digitization or climate change and so on we do need european solutions but we don't have european parties and so we said how about we build the first european european party and obviously if you think about that with the two friends most other people think that you're quite crazy and which was also happening to us but somehow we managed to do this and run for the european parliamentary elections and out of um seven or eight countries and one one seat out of germany which is the one i'm sitting on and then and basically in the european parliament i work on the special committee for ai that was recently founded i work on the industrial policy committee working on all topics digitization and and i work in a range
of other committees that i won't bother you with right now and maybe one which is important is also the budget committee because i work there and this brings me to my maybe to the introduction so what happened since i joined parliament is that very quickly um the new commission was put into place and um one person that was there to oh sure to be there from the beginning was margaret westage that you all know and she very quickly proposed an ai strategy then much later actually half a year later almost um the commissioner greton was proposed by the french government after the european parliament me included uh kicked out uh macron's previous candidate and so um gretel came jerry breton came as the french pick and he did something very smart which is add a data strategy to the whole package of madame message with the ai strategy and why is that smart i think um i mean you all know this but if you regulate ai that's that's very good and i think they
can we can discuss about how to best do that but you should always understand that if you don't have the right regulation or strategy of how to share data you will you won't have any you know data to train your algorithms on and so my own the thought process actually led me to put a lot more emphasis on industrial data on mixed data sets and and focus a bit on how to ensure that we have enough data to actually train our algorithms and so i was quite happy when you came forward with that i mean you we could talk about um what kind of ai regulation um for west sega is doing i mean she what she's basically proposing from the beginning is to say look we should categorize something that is high risk and something that is low risk when we talk about ai high risk for example would be an autonomous uh data um sorry an autonomous weapon system based on an ai um and low risk would be for example your spotify
proposed list or your you know favorite uh yeah favorite songs based on your spotify history um obviously where regulation might not be as relevant because your fundamental rights are not as infringed upon and so this is a process that she's now like an idea that she's now putting more and more into place and it's trying to define what a high risk data like high-risk algorithms are and i think the general approach makes sense and we will see some things coming in in that direction soon and on the data strategy by breton we're still waiting a bit more in detail the idea is to somehow create european data spaces so that in specific industries you create rules that would allow companies but also the public sector to share more data and i can answer some questions on that if you're interested in that um now to to my thesis i think the first thing and here i do differ quite substantially from door to bear who spoke earlier the first thing the first thesis i have
is that european makes sense and we should focus really on european regulation rather than national fragmentation i would call it and the reason for that is that you all know we already have you know quite a complex internal market in the european union and if we destroy or further fragment the digital common market if you want with a national regulation that really strongly infringes on upon the the your chance to train your algorithm with european data and i think we run into a huge problem and we weaken the anyways already you know difficult european marketplace for european competitors even more so the first really important point here for me is that we need to have this european common internal digital market if you want and we should be very careful with coming up with national legislation or regulations concerning ai um just because it will further complexify i don't know if that's the word um the the work of of our european startups and and yeah anyways innovators when it comes to a so that's
my uh like very first strong thesis and i think we should really do that um one way that i try to fight for this and this is just a bracket maybe to open it is that um in the european recovery fund so this is roughly the 750 billion euros that um the eu is now trying to borrow in the financial markets and then put out there as an investment package in all european countries i fought for um something which is called a 20 digital target meaning that 20 percent and calculated that's 135 billion euros um of of my the specific instrument i'm working on should be spent on the digital transformation and i hope we can use this money to really ensure that we that we do the next step when it comes to digital transformation the second big thesis i want to make is that we should really clearly differentiate between sovereignty and competitiveness and and that's a point where i i think it's really important to look into this in the past the
european union but also a lot of the national levels including germany focus a lot on digital sovereignty and strategic autonomy if you want so two notions that somehow seem to imply that it's really important that you know we safeguard our own industry we use our own um yeah suppliers we really try to buy local if you want when it comes to digital um and i think at some point that does contrast with the idea of ensuring that the european market is competitive that our industry is competitive and that we win if you want in the global competition when it comes to digitization and the transformation digital transformation um so to just give you one example i i know i mean you all know this but there's also um initiatives out of germany and with together with other european countries to for example go in or build something like a federated cloud infrastructure for europe so that we have a nash or like a european cloud service provider set federated out of national um european cloud
service providers and i mean that's one approach and i'm not so convinced of it because we're somehow trying with the public sector to build um something like a competitor if you want a european competitor to do to somehow get into the cloud market which we know is very much um owned by uh by the big three um us companies and i think my approach here would always be to say look we on the one side we want all our smes and startups and so on and begin industry to move into the cloud and to be able to use all these great tools and to be able to be more competitive and train the ai on on the other side we somehow tell them yeah but don't use the american ones because they're evil and they will take your data away and i think my approach here would be very different and that would be to be very very strong on market regulation and competition law so that we have the tools and we give the
tools to the european union in that case again for western to ensure that the cloud market doesn't concentrate further that there are ways of ensuring interoperability that cloud service providers um you know need to offer the apis so that you can transfer your your data from one cloud to the to the next if transferable services or comparable services exist so all this for me it's a bit of a philosophical question but i think rather than trying to you know force the european competitor or european industry to use european providers i think we should just enforce it everybody who acts on european soil and you know who provides european companies with cloud service in that example should be held to minimum standard and that also means that data if if companies want that cannot be transferred for example outside to to other countries and we know the whole complication with the cloud act in that regard but i think to be strong on that to be strong on the standards on the equal playing field on
the on fighting concentration in markets in digital markets i think that's in digital infrastructures i think that's really important but i don't think it makes sense that the state if i can say that builds um service offerings that try to compete with what we have there um the last big thesis is also a bit shape for my own uh experience and that is to be concrete and to be tangible in the regulation that we set forward and not to complexify if you want again the regulatory framework too much but to somehow help and enable rather than to to set too many boundaries and that comes from the personal experience that i'm a big fan of gdpr i think gdpr really managed to set a global standard when it comes to data privacy and data ownership and i think we should really see this as a best practice of how to ensure that european standards work and how to ensure that basically we build a trust-based and the rules-based kind of digital space that will then
emanate if you wanted to different in different markets like the us and china so i think that's a really a positive example and but personally when building volt the gdpr came into place and really halved our whole followership um because we just had to you know recertify everyone and ensure that we have the audit trail and i don't know what in place to be able to send emails to our follower base and so i think the issue here was not that the regulation came into place and that we set the global standard but the issue was that um many of the smaller industries and the smaller businesses and startups are often overwhelmed with the regulation of this coming and that i mean i know that the commission also tried and that the countries tried to explain how gdpr worked that there is a transition period and so on but i don't think it's enough and i think we need to when we write these kinds of regulation really have a focus on helping um smaller
businesses in innovative businesses to to you know understand these rules and see that they're simple and that they're easy to apply because if we don't do that again i think we harm our industries and we should make sure especially if we said european regulation that that we take this into account and for me i mean that also means that if we think about digitization about ai about how to you know first even collect data how to change the mindset of people to to go into the digitization process to then at the end be able to use ai and i think we should think about the tangible and concrete ways of how to make that work and i'm very open to discuss this with you because i think it's really a core issue of how to do good regulation is to to ensure that it's uh you know that we think it out of the perspective of the startups and of the smes in that context so for example i think if you think about digitization
and ai i think we should not only think about the regulatory um focus only but we should also put a strong focus on the whole question of what kind of incentives can we set what kind of money can we make available and here in this context i want to mention that i looked also and and went to sweden to look at their ai strategy and which is very much built on regional clusters and regional uh focus areas and i think it's something where we can learn from if you try to actually regionally bring together um the in i mean like the local i don't know what production company with the local university um with maybe some local electricity um production company or whatever so that you create local use cases and and then you discuss okay what kind of data are you uh producing how could we use that to potentially you know lower energy um costs and be more energy efficient in a certain way so i think to really focus on local or
regional um areas and priorities and have a bit more of a bottom-up approach and allow for funds to be used to have a legal clinic in in these kind of local contexts so that all the legal questions can be clarified i think then we can work our way from use case to use case to actually a digitally transformed society so um i think maybe as a as a closing remark and then i would be very happy to also hear your thoughts on many of these issues and your questions i believe um that sometimes so in general ai is what we should aspire for and the ai transformation is something that will happen but when i talk to all the smes and startups in on a tour around germany but also other countries and when i look at the different ways to regulate i think we really have to understand that companies are on a journey from being almost completely analog to using ai as the core of their business model and for me what i'm
really interested now in is how to in the next digital transformation process which is really about industrial data and making industrial data usable for ai across the european union i think in that process we really need to think very carefully about how we set as i said european standards rather than national fragmentation how we can help um european companies to be competitive on this journey from from the analog to the complete ai integration if you want how we can really understand where the majority of them lie and how we can help them along this way um to make it very concrete and tangible with with use cases and business cases this is a bit the the focus i have i think from the european level we will see quite a lot quite soon as i said when it comes to ai classification high risk low risk uh in the in the way of madam message if you want and i think that's useful to set a bit of a frame but i think when it
comes to the data strategy of and and how to actually enable companies to to share data so that they can move on on on this journey from analog to ai i think that's where we still have to do a lot of thinking and i would be i believe it's really at the beginning of a thought exchange and i would be very happy to hear more from you also now in the q a but also afterwards if you have any thoughts in that direction and that's it that's it from my side i would be very happy to use the remaining time for question and answers cool thanks very much damian i think we have one question from marcus schmidt what's your opinion about gaia x maybe damian you can also explain what gaiax is first for everyone yeah i mentioned that indirectly in my in my speech a bit so gaia x is the idea if i get it correctly but i never fully get it and that's i have tried but i i admit that
um so gayax is the idea of a federated cloud infrastructure so bringing together european cloud service providers um to be able to compete if you want with the american cloud service providers um and yeah basically set up a system of uh european cloud service providers so that that they you know have the same kind of uh like some form of a competitive offer and i think the idea is that especially for public procurement of cloud services um they should be able to to you know join a tender for example if the european commission says we need a new cloud infrastructure for research data or whatever on the european level that that this cloud federated or like federated cloud infrastructure would be able to compete with the with the american ones but um since this is started out of the german industry um ministry i i think i mean i have to still uh you know understand how it actually works i think that's a that's a bit my my question that regard and i as
i said i would rather than trying to build competitors i would try to set extremely clear guidelines of what any cloud service provider in europe has to follow such that um even if i choose amazon web services or whatever google cloud i don't know what azure from microsoft that i'm for sure that you know that i know what i can get um and that i'm sure that my data is secure if that is what i want if that i use i mean whatever kind of offer they that they offer but i i know that it's regulated under european law so i think what i'm trying to say is i think it should be possible for european companies to choose whatever cloud service provider and have a hundred percent trust that the data is secure that the data cannot be transferred to another country or even government for example under the cloud act and that um nobody uses their data in a way that that is not you know proper i think that's for me a
bit the focus i would like rather put cool thanks marcos also had another question how to motivate the big tech players to share their data with smaller players probably referring a bit to the us players yeah i mean here i'm um much more um interested and open yeah because i think um as you probably heard i'm very much on the side of of the startups and the new players the new entrants if you like because i i mean my movement vault is a new entrant into a market a political market and i can see already what kind of barriers of entry exist in in such a setting where you really have a zero-sum game if you want but i i do believe that we have to also you know have a look of how data is uh owned in the different um in the different contexts and i'm i'm a big fan if you have ideas of how to force companies to open up their data spaces i think it's it's an interesting point i
would still go if by default always to competition law so i mean as you know um there's an interesting law case currently running in the us on on you know access to a certain uh market for for amazon and so on or like for amazon competitors and i think we should always try to understand you know where is the competition infringement and can we somehow give the eu commission a bit more power to monitor certain markets advertisement markets and others to to like ensure that but i mean if you think that you know a general law that you have to publish your data unless it's personal data um or has contains any trade secrets or like business secrets i mean i would be very happy to think about it but i just haven't seen a good system yet i think one problem there's also if you don't pay for the product you are the product so who gives away the product data when they can monetize it one thing that i am i always find
interesting is the discussion about regulation is usually around b2c products so it's about the end consumer which makes a lot of sense but you mentioned the industry that this one is also very important do you see any need for regulation of ai in industry data place for europe anything where we have to protect our data or actually can even foster more ai or support it with regulation so um i mean you said it correctly for me it's my focus i think we the b2c market is quite defined already to be quite honest and obviously there's things to improve and there's a lot of focus on the digital services act and other regulation that is looking into privacy and so on and i think again if you talk about equal standards when it comes to privacy i think there's still a lot to discuss also with the us and other countries but i think the next big transformation the next big digital transformation where that you can try to be competitive is really when it comes
to industrial data because we hold a lot of this industrial data and we hold it in very decentralized ways because we have a strong middle channel we have smes we have um startups which hold this in this data um and so we need to find ways to somehow allow for data sharing and and data analysis based on all of this industrial data and i think that that will define uh whether we are you know competitive or not in the future so i mean i i'm constantly thinking about what the best ways are to ensure um that we can use this data best and i mean as i said like for me it's really about building incentives for these companies to come from a mindset of what do i care about this data to actually collecting it and then not only thinking oh data is the new goal so i won't share it with anyone but actually thinking about ways how to how to share it with um with others and so that's why i mean
these local use cases for me could be an easy way that i can you know explain to a ceo of an sme and for example byroid where i studied saying like hey um you know how about you sit down with a buyer at university and you also understand a bit you know what kind of data you're producing with them and maybe with the with like two or three other local companies and you think about is it textile ai something that we could potentially think about building together and i think these these very clear um use cases are quite helpful in that regard and since we have five minutes left i may share my perspective there and please give me your thoughts usually the companies we invest in so i'm an investor and the ai companies we invest in they build up this called data mode so a strength of having their own data annotated data trained machine models and they create products out of it so it's based on my annotated label data i don't
want to share it because i don't want anybody else to build a product so wouldn't it be a problem if i have to share it based on regulation because you might kill my usp that i need to build this big company that you actually want to support or am i missing something out here so i mean that's why i said like i haven't found a useful way to force companies to share data you know like i mean that's i think when it comes to competition law that's something we can discuss if you are holding back data that basically blocks entrance uh to even be able to compete with you because you have you hold the data on i don't know the search history or for for restaurants or whatever it is then i think we can discuss it because you're really destroying subsequent markets with your kind of conglomerate model if you want but for other cases it's really hard and i don't have the solution of you know does it make sense to force
you then to to join your annotated data i don't think that that would be currently the way i would take it you know i would rather say as i said how about we set your company or that you invest in in a context with companies that could have similar ai needs you know and you somehow have a chance to um pool your very scarce ai talents and data experts and and and data architecture experts whatever um to bring them into one room with a look as i said local university and then they can discuss a bit you know how can we use this maybe in in different places at the same time but the issue is that um the b2c market i think was much easier to revolutionize um i think when it comes to industrial data it's always very specific data it also needs to be trained in very specific ways and it's not so easy to to ensure that like you know we all proceed on this journey from analog to ai driven
i think that's really a big question mark in my mind i mean i also look very deeply into standardization questions so should you develop more industry standards when it comes to how data is structured to ensure higher data quality to ensure that you know once you decide with another company that you actually want to share your data you don't take a year to somehow make it transferable even but that you that you can almost do that with a with a click um and i think there's some ways that we need to work together with the standardization agencies if you want authorities to to make that happen but i'm maybe to make it very short i'm not yet there that i would say you need to share your data uh right now because then it's it's not thought through yeah i agree with you and i i would i would say regulation could help to share it in a safe way so that people are not stealing the data or misusing the data so i think
that's where you can help a lot those companies because sharing data in industry context is really difficult for startups to build those companies since christmas is coming up i asked that the other two before as well what would be your biggest wish from the european parliament to really support ai frost ai in the future what what is something people should do more yeah i think i said it earlier for me it would really be uh to think european i mean that's in general uh like a message i'm trying to get out there and but i think in this context it's really really important as well if we now run ahead with national regulation especially out of the biggest market in germany and say hey it's a it's a good idea to regulate ai here on our turf then we will run into this game of national regulations everywhere and then i think we have basically seriously harmed our competitiveness versus the big other markets china and the us because we have not taken advantage of
the fact that we have a european union that we have a european framework and regulation that we could try to have all these discussions in but we have decided to be against more nations irrelevant nations and destroyed the competitive edge for our ai businesses be they startups or smes thanks a lot damian and it's great to have somebody like you in the parliament helping all of us thanks for your view and everything and i hope we can support you more in the future thank you very much again happy for ideas via email or any social media at all times cool thank you