i'm happy to welcome a dear and frequent guest of the rise of ai conference and when i whenever i think about this man um i really feel his mission so he um is really in for freeing human potential through ai and he's really committed to create more room and space for creativity for human potential through ai so here is this combination of analytics and technology and warm heart and a real interest for humans help me to welcome Chris Boos again on stage thank you chris for joining us thank you i heard some investors also talk about you and they said you have billion potential that's received as a compliment probably but chris is always you might know that a consultant to the german government to the german chancellor and i know that you think a lot about uh implementation of ai versus only piloting and showcasing is that yeah we're going to talk about that in a minute we will talk about that in a minute anyway right so then stage is yours chris um
and the speech is ai is happening now deal with it or die that sounds promising it has to have some titles so you actually start up appearing um thank you for having me i am not having any slides i i have been on stages so much and i noticed that you don't pay attention when there are slides i think what i'm going to say is important so we have to pay attention um i want to start out with a topic of sovereignty and digital sovereignty because in times of crisis which we've now had first with a pandemic then a war maybe next economic crisis and all this stuff coming up determining who is talking um we need to understand like how can we work and sovereignty consists of two parts right it's the ability to execute which basically means either your own or your control then you have you're able to execute and the second one is your ability to know things which is education and retention and as we've just very impressively seen we
seem to have good people and good education but our retention is absolutely dramatically crap right so these two components executing and knowing are kind of important for sovereignty then we look in europe we look at sovereignty and we say like well we're all doing okay but there is a big difference between digital sovereignty and industrial sovereignty and we have industrial sovereignty right we're fine all even though we don't own many uh raw materials we have made contracts and supply chains and so on industrial sovereignty is all about raw materials process and supply chain digital sovereignty is all about intellectual property software and data and these things are completely different from what we see in industrial sovereignty and this is why we have a hard time dealing with it right in digital sovereignty the players who play for digital sovereignty they aim to own the users the end users and the developers they aim to own the ip because they buy companies not to own their revenue but to own their international property and these kind
of things so we have to rethink completely how we think of our ability to control our own fate and i'm not saying that we should be aiming for article meaning that we are isolated that we're protectionists and all of that i think that's complete crap i believe that globalization is actually a peacekeeping mechanism for all of us and whoever said this didn't work because there's war now in in europe is totally wrong right we've had the longest period of peace ever it worked we just shouldn't abandon it so let's go from there what are the what are the key technologies that we need the key ingredients that we need in order to create digital sovereignty well first of all anything digital consumes energy we need to deal with energy and i'm talking about the production of energy the transport of energy and the storage of energy and to be honest we're not good at that in europe completely if you look at power plants right the patent packages for building all types of power plants
they used to be owned by siemens and hitachi now they're owned by google so energy doesn't seem to be something that we're very strong at and yeah are there many jokes about how germans would love to have wind energy as long as it's not in their house right so and and so on so um we're just not good at this the second one is hardware right and hardware consists of three pieces there is the ability to compute the ability to store and bandwidth so compute power storage power bandwidth power we are not good at that either the best thing that we can probably do is bandwidth because once we set our ass to it we kind of uh get 5g working and i'm saying this right because it's a con constant complaint everywhere funklish everywhere dead spots in in germany and in the whole of europe but if you look at this right i i spend a lot of time in the valley like every other call doesn't go through you have to try two
or three times every month there's a brown out in san francisco on electricity yet this is where supposedly all the innovation is happening believe me the innovation is not tied to bandwidth or electricity um but if you want digital sovereignty you need to control energy and the hardware part we're not very good at that um if we want to be good at it and and we've just heard this uh from hands right is if you want to be good at it this means very large investments actually something that politics likes to do politics doesn't like to give out small grants million pieces of something they they love to make a billion euro announcement why because that actually makes the news and this is the fuel that politicians live on and so on right so we we actually love infrastructure projects but then we're discussing infrastructure projects for example a european cloud provider let's let's compete with amazon today and then it turns out you need about 100 euro 100 billion euro investment in order to
catch up with amazon right now in its current state and then i hit my head against the wall right because um it doesn't make sense to catch up with amazon right now you're wasting 100 billion euros and they will move on at the same time if you want to catch up with amazon that's a three to five year project because there's a three to five year turnover of all the hardware in the big data centers and if you want to really build compute infrastructure you need to invest now into the hardware that is there in five years and not try and build a cloud provider with the current technology because that is just too expensive and you can be you can be drowned out in the you can be drowned out in the market very easily so if you really want to catch up with these type of infrastructures that build on hardware and energy which we're not good at you need to start investing into the future of these type of things now then
comes something that we actually are good at which is apis the germans are good at standardizing everything right the dean deutsche industrinom is everywhere globally and germans love their standards and apis are type of standards we defined a lot of them in the open source world a lot of the apache projects take their api from europe and that is excellent because having apis and not just proprietary stuff that comes out because no one else can offer the service having common apis means that we can actually turn from one service to the other for reasons on sovereignty for re commercial reasons and so on we can do that we're good at apis all right so now we have three pieces that we're not very good at we have the energy with the hardware we have the compute for the infrastructure to do it we're not very good at it apis we start being good at and then there's two big key technologies that drive the entire system which is artificial intelligence and security and security the
problem is not all the modern stuff that is security by design the problem is that 20 years ago we started putting web servers on dvd players without any security whatsoever and those are now used against us and turned into bots hosts and so on and so forth so security is a difficult problem and that's why i'm starting with this because i actually want to talk more about ai security is a difficult problem because it is turning the world upside down let's look at security from a political space right before if you wanted to be a government player or a nation player on a geopolitical stage and you wanted to be taken absolutely seriously you would have to own nuclear weapons and the physics for doing nuclear weapons is actually fairly easy you can go to amazon you can order the book that oppenheimer uses to onboard new phys physicists into the manhattan project you can read that and you know how to build a nuclear bomb the point is that getting the material and technology
to do that is extremely capital intensive so it is nothing that you can just do because you feel like it this is kept the idea of large wealthy nations or nations that committed a large part of their capital to the topic of mutually assured destruction kept peace for quite a while unfortunately we now do not have just one topic of mutually sure destruction we have three on top of the nuclear arsenal which still exists we have gone to cyber right and cyber is this huge problem because all you need is a few pissed off i.t people who you pay handsomely and then you can build a cyber team that can attack other countries and i literally mean attack in a military sense because if you turn off the energy or water supply for a city like berlin or new york or london or paris or whatever people are truly screwed right people will start dying within weeks so we're not just talking about ransomware i'll get to that in a second right we're talking about
physical attack and actually much better than nuclear weapons right because people die and the infrastructure stays in place and it's extremely cheap if you can build a cyber team let's say out of 20 30 people and you pay each of them 10 million a year right that doesn't even buy you a tank in conventional warfare but you have just entered the state's stage of mutually destruction mutually sure destruction with a very very cheap budget cyber from a political point of view is extremely dangerous and sometimes governments demonstrate this to each other right helsinki airport is one of the places where this is demonstrated quite a lot then someone turns off the lights for five minutes and then turns them back on this is called blinking the lights and it's basically showing look what i can do and if an airport is the sample field think of how many back doors are found in really critical infrastructure that is 20 40 80 100 years old if you look at things like water supply or the electricity
grid second part mutually sure destruction third part is propaganda right in a world where there is absolutely no buffer where reaction has to be instant if you don't react to something as a politician as a decision maker instantly then you're facing a shitstorm right the real point is that there's no time to think so propaganda which in old time used to be an inward bound thing you used to make propaganda to keep your people happy to go to war now propaganda actually turned into a weapon we have three times mutually sure destruction and this is why security is a huge topic the current world leading country in security is israel and israel is fantastic at this because they have been feeling threatened since their creation they have the proper mindset which brings me to the last key technology which is artificial intelligence and artificial intelligence is the key technology to this transformational process and to sovereignty in a new era because artificial intelligence ends the industrial principle the industrial principle is that what we have
been taught if you want to solve a problem well and you want to make good money out of it analyze what's there standardize it so you increase the volume build a process that you're there or consolidate whatever you have and then build the process or the software or whatever is there this usage of economies of scale is what our entire industrial mindset our education our industry and sometimes even our politics in a society are made of if you apply ai to this by the way if you want to have a joke right this is the reason why marketing exists because we have standardized what people get so now we have to market to them why they want it um but let's let's go back to them the the entire point of ai is that ai is able to create an individual solution for each individual problem so you're thinking about ai we're not thinking about a simple pattern matcher or something like that we're thinking about a problem solver and if you no longer need
to standardize consolidate right that is very different that means that the key competency of any company which is now control of process predictability exactness and so on has to go out the window it has to go out the window completely and that means that the key part to all of this is not government funding it's not education unfortunately i would love it to be education it's not research and all of that stuff exists it's the ability to change our mindset and that is extremely difficult because we have to do it to ourselves if we don't we just disappear i have been doing ai for more than 25 years and i very much enjoyed the research period of this and and so on for the past eight years i've been looking at selling ai in the market and my conclusion is that ai is not sellable not because it's not needed not because it can't do good results but because the buyers don't want to change they just don't want to change and if you don't
believe me look at all these ai companies that try to sell ai projects so that i try to sell ai platforms and ai services and so on all of those they sell because there's a huge interest in artificial intelligence but they only sell pilots and pocs and then whenever it comes to rollout there's all types of stupid excuses like enterprise readiness or whatever so that they are not executed and it's because the other end doesn't want to change that is the only reason why automation hasn't gone from industrial type automation to artificial intelligence but gone from industrial type automation to robotic process automation which is nothing but a script and that has been existing for 40 years right so the question is the mindset change and the only thing that works in ai is if companies start applying ai to themselves right if you compare the i.t operations of any international bank to the i.t operations of google there is about a thousand times efficiency at google compared to these it operations that banks and
the excuse that bank is dealing with sensitive data and is highly regulated and blah that just doesn't fly google is dealing with sensitive data and so on and so forth right this is not an excuse the point is that google has applied its own ai to itself the banks don't have ai that they can exp uh could apply to themselves they try to buy ai of course the organization doesn't want it so they have to do something they do 20 pilots applying ai to yourself is one of the key things that can happen there are successful ai companies out there that take a topic let's say something super simple like i t operations because i stick with that and everybody knows that it's painful dealing with it ops and go from a labor arbitrage model which is something that fueled the entire indian economy to an ai based model and it takes their margin from 20 to 70 percent the customers are still buying exactly the same thing they're buying it outsourcing or process outsourcing
with an sla nothing changes on the market the customers are happy the application of ai is to the insight to the production process so the real question for all of us if we want to apply artificial intelligence and we know that we have the ability to research it we know we have the talent we know we don't have the ability to retain the talent we don't we know we don't have the ability from the bottom up right it means that very few competences we have in this entire chain of sovereignty is security and artificial intelligence and security i'm not sure if we can still catch up but ai we can definitely catch up a because we have the knowledge and b knowledge in terms of ai but we also have the knowledge that can feed ai because european companies tend to not outsource until they've understood something so all the knowledge about how things work today are stored in our economy in our people that is why we're at the table at all at this
point if we want to deal with this if you want to be successful all of you will have to become ambassadors for the mindset change that not an industrial process where you control you exactly know which step the machine is going to do next and so on as we but you look at nai as a problem solver like your neighbor like your friend and it will solve problems for you in a general way and you can't predict the next move look the cool thing about um playing go against alphago was that it made moves that the go player didn't expect if your industry and you try to make ai completely predictable you might as well have written a script or build a process that's the mindset change we all need to go through and that's the critical part i believe that if we offer up funding opportunities our governments will step in i know that there's all these discussions people bring out money and then it's never called for i personally am very much engaged
into education and then we try to for example connect schools to the internet we find out that we write to 16 000 school not even one percent replies right this is not because they're all this is because it is so hard to even allow a school to create an internet connection because you need seven people at the table and no one has time to do this and i know this is true for germany and france um italy has improved a lot there and there and i think that we can learn so much from for example the baltic states how to organize that type of stuff so artificial intelligence either you'll do it you probably have to do it to yourself or you'll die because competing with someone who has a thousand times efficiency on you it's just not possible at all so here's a few suggestions on what we could do about it number one we should accept that an ecosystem is not a nice cuddly thing where everybody does their best and everybody loves
each other and everybody has equal opportunity the working ecosystems that we know like ios and android are built around a quasi monopoly that is going out there and that everybody is joining we should in europe where when we see these ecosystems evolve we we get cramps right we really get stomach aches we need these ecosystems to evolve here as well we'll need someone we'll need to allow someone to actually become that strong to host one of those ecosystems or two maybe the second part is we should turn our absolute desire to be perfectionist from an engineering skill that is done in the basement to something that is demanding for a leadership role right right now if you look at global industry the european the good european industry kind of they're perfect at stuff but they no longer want to be the leaders they no longer want to be the innovators because for innovation you sometimes hit the wall you sometimes get smacked you sometimes have a storm happening on twitter whatever and then it's much
easier to just be in the basement and be perfectionist get out there demand to be leaders the third thing is that we have a society question here we have heard many times today already that in europe were totally able to educate the right people to produce fantastic talent to do great fundamental research people just leave they leave to places where there's a dictatorship in place or they leave to places where you have to if you make that type of money you have to live in a gated community so you're not robbed or your kids don't get shot in school like i think there should be every motivation for people to stay the problem is that there is no societal contract about this so if i can make one suggestion to all of us let's try and get back to a humanistic society where community becomes for self thinking comes for feeling before feeling and actually the question of security is put behind curiosity if we could do that i bet you anything that a lot
of the talent that we have lost would love to come back because that's the type of societies that all these super talents in i.t and software very much enjoy so if you want to not die and get ai into your companies into your life let's try to become more human because that will make the talent come back and it will also accelerate our human ability and look humans are not made to work in an industrial machine i'm sure you've heard that term to be like a cog in a machine who wants that that doesn't make you happy right people need a lot of work for life balance if they have this feeling that they have nothing to contribute and nothing to do people want to contribute ai's can do that for us ai's can take the shitty cog in the machine work from us and can give humans back what they're actually good at and there's two things that humans are really good at one is making other people happy and the second one and
by the way if you don't believe this try it out if you you feel more joy when you give a present to someone than when you receive a present and this is not a dopamine hit this is a much stronger drug this is an endorphin hit the second thing is people love to invent every little kid is born a curious scientist and we spent 13 years or even 15 or 18 or whatever years to get it out of them like you can't put people through schools that were made to not turn people crazy in factories and then after they come out very uniform like expected go say to them now please think outside the box let's stop destroying natural curiosity then we actually have the ability to apply ai to ourselves and have the supply of talent and people and everybody who is hungry for a better future that can come to us this cannot be done by government by the economy this can only be done by you each and every one of you
so please go out there and make the change in mindset happen because otherwise ai is going to eat the world and other other nations and other blogs are going to come out on top of it i think it's worth the try and there's no reason to be afraid of the future in fact there's every reason to love the future that is driven by technology thank you very much