Rise of AI Summit 2020 · Berlin · Society & Strategy Day | Future Space

Now That AI Is Here, What Do We Do With It

Chris Boos · CEO, Arago AG

At the Rise of AI Summit 2020, Chris Boos, CEO of Arago AG, argues that AI has already arrived and the real question is what to do with it. He opens by noting that capital markets value three Silicon Valley platform companies more highly than Germany's entire publicly listed industrial economy, that revenue per employee is far higher at a company like Apple than at Volkswagen, and that employees' contribution to actual productivity has been declining for decades, evidence that the industrial era, built on standardization and economies of scale, has run its course. He estimates that with today's technology 80 percent of current work can already be automated, using implicit and explicit knowledge held in data to let machines find individual solutions rather than standardized processes. Boos gives four predictions: society must act now on environmental, populist and industrial-disruption pressures; the current adversarial system of politics, economy and society must give way to a knowledge economy; AI is already being applied in agriculture, medicine, education and mobility, but only in small steps; and Europe's own path should be humanism, distinct from US efficiency and Chinese cohesion. He closes by urging companies to stop running pilots, since the technology already works, and instead change their mindset to let AI act.

Key takeaways

  • Boos says three Silicon Valley platform companies outweigh Germany's entire listed industrial economy in market capitalization.
  • He estimates 80 percent of today's work can already be automated with existing AI technology.
  • He warns e-mobility threatens 400,000 German car-industry jobs while AI investment has not kept pace.
  • He argues Europe's own AI path should be humanism, distinct from US efficiency and Chinese cohesion.
  • He says AI adoption is a mindset problem, not a technology problem, since pilots already prove it works.

Detailed notes

Why the industrial model has run its course

Boos argues capital markets have already priced in the shift: three platform companies out of Silicon Valley carry more market capitalization than Germany's entire publicly listed economy, and comparing revenue per employee at Apple and Volkswagen tells the same story. The contribution of employee time to actual productivity has been declining for decades. He frames this as the end of a roughly 150-to-200-year industrial era built on standardizing, consolidating and analyzing work to justify mass production, the model Henry Ford summed up with "you can have any color as long as it's black." AI, in his view, does something different: using the implicit and explicit knowledge collected in data pools, it can find an individual solution for every individual problem instead of standardizing, and can be applied to almost everything except language and true innovation. He states that 80 percent of what is done today can be automated with existing technology, and dismisses corporate 20-to-30-year adoption plans, noting the iPhone spread across the population in under a year.

Four predictions for the shift to a knowledge economy

First, Boos says if society does not act now there is no future: resource consumption is unsustainable, populism is rising because the system is destabilizing, e-mobility threatens 400,000 jobs in the car industry while AI investment lags, and the COVID-19 response was effectively run by Google and Apple rather than governments. Second, the current system, in which politics, economy and society pull against each other, has been stable for decades but depended on an industrial system that has ended; the needed switch is to a knowledge economy where machines handle most jobs and people focus on new ideas and interaction, a societal rather than technical change. Third, technology is already the solution in small ways: roughly ten percent of farms use AI-guided drones and livestock algorithms, medicine uses AI-enabled minimally invasive procedures, and mobility is shifting toward AI-enabled models beyond individual car ownership; schooling, designed to produce uniform factory workers, needs to shift toward lifelong learning that keeps children's natural curiosity alive.

Europe's own path: humanism over efficiency or cohesion

Boos argues that if Europe wants its own way with AI it should be humanism, distinct from an American model built around efficiency and profit and a Chinese model built around social cohesion. A humanist approach fits AI development, he says, because humans generate the implicit and explicit data the systems need, and it produces a society where curiosity outranks security and facts outrank belief. He adds that this kind of change is only possible in a society with either nothing left to lose or, as in Europe today despite the crisis, absolute abundance.

Stop proving the technology works

Boos says organizations must stop running pilots, tests and proofs of concept meant only to show AI works, because it already does; the real question is whether a company can let go of control and let a machine find its own efficient solution rather than run a predefined process. He criticizes managers who avoid risk because their career survives even if the company fails, and argues the pandemic is the moment to act decisively rather than take baby steps, since the advantage of owning today's knowledge, data and technological power disappears once it is shared or surpassed by others.

Q&A highlights

Asked how change happens when many people are comfortable staying put, Boos says society, not just individuals, must respond to failed attempts with encouragement rather than mockery, citing Germany's corona-app debate as a case where data protection was prioritized over health data collection under public pressure. Asked about creativity, he distinguishes artist-type creativity (swimming against the stream), engineering-type creativity (combining unlikely components, which he says Germany and France do well), and pioneer-type creativity (people who need risk), arguing society currently channels pioneers into extreme sports instead of honoring them inside companies. Asked for a wish for future leaders, he says he hopes leaders rediscover solidarity and accept that short-term egotism can never outweigh the benefits of working together as social animals.

Quotes

The technology works, that's not the question. The question is, are you able to make the change to actually let AI work for you?

Chris Boos

No one ever got fired for hiring IBM.

Chris Boos

We've got to move now. Right now we own the knowledge, right now we have the data, right now we have the technological power.

Chris Boos

Questions answered in this talk

What path should Europe take with AI according to Chris Boos?

According to Chris Boos at the Rise of AI Summit 2020, Europe's own path should be humanism, distinct from an American model centered on efficiency and profit and a Chinese model centered on social cohesion.

How much of today's work can already be automated with AI?

According to Chris Boos at the Rise of AI Summit 2020, about 80 percent of current work can already be automated using existing AI technology.

Why does Chris Boos say companies should stop running AI pilots and proofs of concept?

According to Chris Boos at the Rise of AI Summit 2020, the technology already works, so pilots only prove what is already known; the real challenge is a mindset change that lets a company give up control of predefined processes and let AI find its own solutions.

Mentioned

implicit and explicit knowledge, knowledge graphs, robotic process automation, knowledge economy, automation

Keep exploring

More from Chris Boos

More from Rise of AI Summit 2020

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 4,504 words

Show the full transcript

yes that's right you're a few you have to clap louder and longer thank you very much i'm very happy now to welcome another dear friend of the summit he studied computer science in zurich and darmstadt and over 20 years ago he founded his company ago to push the boundaries of artificial intelligence arago runs hero europe's leading ai platform that promises to automate anything advising chancellor merkel as part of the digital council is something that has not been automated yet and has to be done in person by our speaker himself which is probably for the better give it up for Chris Boos everyone so i think i'm going to listen to this talk from hans about five times again because uh him talking about hybrid ai and implicit and explicit knowledge and knowledge graphs is exactly what i've been working on for the last 25 years and most of the time i've been laughed at and now it's hot awesome and also the part about the corona up very funny um if it weren't so sad

but i i've come to talk to you a little bit about like the forward-looking part of ai so i think we can we can say ai is just here like can we conclude it it's here period we don't have to discuss it it's coming and blah blah but what the do we do with it now like what do we do with it and that's a question so let's very briefly look at the past and i'm saying that we've been hitting the wall with our systems long before the pandemic came the capital markets valued uh innovation in silicon valley much better than the industry in germany three platform companies are more capitalized or have more market cap than the entire german publicly listed economy together i mean that says it all the future is in a different economic and technical model and industrial production is the past but we can also see this in macro numbers right revenue per employee i mean if you compare apple and volkswagen that's just sad um but the the real

number is this right our the contribution of time spent by employees to actual productivity that is going down for ten tens of years um and it is nothing that just came around the corner boop and appeared quickly and this is where we're coming from and then ai comes on onto the market and where are we there right digitization most people still think that digitization has anything to do with pattern matching and predictions yeah ai can do that but that's not the point right the point is that we are at the end of the industrial era i mean depending which part of history you're looking at that has started 150 200 years ago um but and we have done extremely well on industrialization but that's coming to an end we came from self-sufficiency agriculture 70 of us were farmers right and we came to um taylorizing work meaning that we have specialized people doing specialized things and then we invented the steam machine and enhanced our force and were able to multiply ourselves and what we

really did was we cater to economies of scale like everything that we did was basically the economies of scale where we try to analyze stuff standardize consolidate and then we are we could justify building a factory or a process or something else in order to get there and the whole point was to allow to build an assembly line to build a factory so we could mass produce cheaper no one said it nicer than henry ford right you can have any color as long as it's black by the way this is how marketing was invented we had to convince people that whatever we were able to produce is what they wanted so but that's not what ai needs right ai can do automation right what we call automation now is stupid robots running a stupid script um and if we look at the story of rpa robotic process automation right they are scripts guys scripts were like any computer person on a post did a script that was not a big deal how do i get

back i don't know anyway so the the point of artificial intelligence is that with the implicit and explicit knowledge collected in our data pools we can have a machine find an individual solution for every individual problem we no longer need to standardize and consolidate and analyze and so on the eye will do this for us and this can be applied to literally everything everything probably that is not language because language is still much too hard and everything that is not innovation meaning that actually would get any model to its catastrophic failure mode and people can be passionate about and say yeah but i still want to try it but 80 of what we do today can be done by machines with today's technology when i get this across to ceos and i talk to people then the usual reaction is yeah okay seems to make sense but let's make a 20-year plan or a 30-year plan and i just don't get this i mean there's no reason why there should be a 30-year plan since

the electrification of things nothing no new technology took 20 or 30 years to actually go exponential and be spread throughout the population at an exponential rate with the iphone it was less than a year so no this is not like a lot of people have been trying to slow this down and all this discussion that we have on uh worrying about machines that can take over and so on i very much agree right this is like worrying about the overpopulation of mars like we're not there we don't understand self how can we build a machine we're engineers we build things we understand right so we don't build a machine that has a self this is not the problem the problem is that this is happening very quickly and whoever makes it happen has a huge economic benefit and if you don't make it happen you are simply screwed and if you want to compare this it took us 150 years of industrial revolution to get from zero percent automation to 29 automation and even a

conservative an old-fashioned entity like the world economic forum tells us that only seven years will have an increase to of another 20 in automation like that is amazing so i'd like to walk out and say like give you four thesis or four predictions that i want to make what happens so the first one is if we don't act now for some reason these slides keep on moving by themselves right so um the the simple point is if we don't act now there simply is no future and i always find it very funny when people talk about environmental protection it sounds like there's an environment it has nothing to do with us all these people are delusional right the planet can live without us we can't live without the planet in its current state it's our total self-interest to protect the planet this is nothing to do with tree huggers or esoterics we need the planet to work otherwise we just disappear and if we look at those numbers right we're consuming the planet at a

fantastic rate and we should probably stop doing that if you look at populism and what is happening here in terms of people opinionated people coming out with totally irrational opinions this is an old problem only it is on the rise it's showing our system is not stable anymore because you can outright lie and there's still thirty percent of people who will actually vote for you or help you or whatever this is crazy in a an educated country like germany you have people who've gone to university and they step out in the street and tell us that bill gates is drinking children's blood hello like 50 years ago you've put these people in a mental institution populism works there is an attack on our core industries just e-mobility threatens 400 000 jobs in the car industry and the investment of ai is increasing but it's not increasing as it should be which is a bit dangerous what is very interesting is um the health system right we're digitizing a lot of people actually believe that in

the health system we can use ai and they would be happy to be have an ai doctor and right at this point we hand off the first big initiative on health which is covid is not run by governments it's not run by legitimized people it's run by google and apple maybe because governments can't do it it's pretty sad and then we have trade people are complaining that our inner cities are dying and all you get there is food stands and then the epidemic comes and all the food stands close um and basically there's nothing nothing left of wholesale commerce and all we can do is help these people jump on the bandwagon of google and have their online shops that's not google's fault that's our fault for not transf transforming or not going ahead and helping these guys to adopt technologies like ai to bring out the best they can because if they could automate everything service from person to person cannot be automated simply because we like interacting with our own species so i

hope i made the point the first thesis is that we're pretty if we don't do anything the second one is that our system that we currently have right the system where politics has to be angry with society and economy economy has to be sad at people and politics and people are unhappy with politics and economy all this leads to a very stable system right everybody pulling at the two others means that we have a stable center and this has worked for us for 70 years now well actually we're only running it like this for 30 years or 40 years but it has created a fantastically stable system and this is great like this is the world this is the reality we're living in the problem is that our system our industrial system has come to an end the ball of stability is now on the top of the pyramid and if we keep pulling at each other the ball will roll down on whoever sides pulls hard as next what we need is a switch

to actually have everybody work together so we come to a knowledge economy to a new type of system where implicit explicit knowledge is given to machines machine do most of the jobs people can focus on what their best which is coming up with new stuff and interacting with other people this is the biggest change ever it's not a technical change it's not a research change it is a society change and if society changes politics changes the funny thing is that the ones that are very focused on profit they are going first third prediction technology is the solution right if we look at ai in agriculture like 10 of our farms are already using drones and that that is out there they are using artificial intelligence algorithms to feed their livestock to make sure that we don't over use antibiotics and all these things weather predictions with extreme weather winds coming up all these things are ai algorithms this is applied we're already using it it's the same with the medical field right we can now

have minimal invasive procedures and so on all these examples that come out here these are applications of ai but they're tiny steps we need to encourage these guys to make the next big step that is out there and one of the most crucial points this also applies to learning like our current school system was invented so people wouldn't go crazy when they had to work in a factory that was the schooling we're getting and that we could eventually make engineers out of some now we need to make a scientist and a curious person and a self-responsible person and a person that wants to do something out of everybody but how we're doing this in our current system right we walk children we take them from kindergarten to primary school to secondary school to university and everything there is catered towards making people uniform and then when they get out of there we as companies go and like fantastic little guy how about you start thinking outside the box what we need is lifelong learning and

we need to make this attractive to people every little child is born as a little scientist how do we keep this alive this curiosity and of course um it's ai or technology is a driver of mobility it's not just self-driving cars it's not just fleet management but it is the change in model like why does everybody need a car everybody just wants to go from a to b not just in cities but also in rural areas and of course this is enabled by ai algorithms and the new type of work where we're getting more collaborative and where we're working together and where we're actually jumping on a bandwagon to make sure that we don't cater to people who are process compliant and do the same and the same and the same and the same thing over and over again are you surprised that these guys have more fun doing their hobbies than having their jobs what we need to foster is people's creativity and their ability to solve a new problem every day and their

interest in actually solving these problems every day so having looked at this and hopefully i've said that ai is about getting done the question is where does europe stand on this right if europe wants to find its own way it should be humanism it should be a human way like in america the goal is efficiency everything has to submit to progress uh profit in china it's cohesion like we don't want individuals we want a cohesive society that's what the system is if europe really wants its own way we have to cater to humans and that fits very well because the humans create the implicit and un explicit data that we need to progress ai systems like if you really want that that's what we do but this creates a difference a type of society right this creates a society where curiosity and the other where community the many outrank the one where curiosity actually outranks security where facts are more important than belief and where thinking is more important than feeling and i think this

is absolutely essential these type of systems can only be implemented or this type of change can only be implemented in a society where there's nothing left to lose or where there's over abundance we are still despite the crisis in a society where there is absolute over abundance we can do this and we can see that it's extremely profitable and we can see that we can take our development on from here this is important so if we look at this to me the really important thing and i'd like to spend a couple of minutes on this one huh i wanted to is if we want to implement ai we have to stop doing pilots tests proof of concepts and all these things that are only there to show that the technology works the technology works like pick the one that you like best but the technology works that's not the question the question is are you able to make the change to actually let ai work for you can you let go or do you have

to be a control freak about it i mean if you just want a predefined process to run you don't need an ai you've got to let the machine find an efficient solution then you need an ai but that's a total change in mindset halto in german like this is important if you can't let that go you will always end up with prototypes we have fantastic scientists they do basic research and we have whipped them into shape so that they don't try to do end solutions they only do prototypes that is increasingly sad to see because they could do fantastic solutions that could be scaled out quickly and could have tremendous success for the typical middle stunt company for big companies for startup companies it doesn't really matter so stop doing that don't don't go don't try proving a technology that works because it already works it's your mind that you need to work on and for that look at improving that's what we're very good at get the next two percent out of it but

also look at improving the improvement like making a big step going from producing cars to running a car fleet going from selling drills to selling holes these old examples they're now old examples but there's so few people thank you but there are so few people who who actually attach to this so the point that i'm trying to make is we've got to move now right now we own the knowledge right now we have the data right now we have the technological power and we have the ability to do it once we sell the knowledge once we're out ranked in research all of that is gone the point is we've got to act now and we've got to act decisively not baby steps not trials and the pandemic is a fantastic point in time to do this because no one would have predicted a breakdown in business models as has happened now i have met a few ceos who said if i do nothing now the company might go bust but my career is unharmed and

this is like saying no one ever got fired for hiring ibm ibm is a great tech company you could hire them anytime but the point now is we pay managers large salaries so they're able to make risky decisions it's a time for decision making right now and most of those decisions should include ai as the driving force thank you very much hey this has not happened before i'm one a minute early thank you chris i was surprised as well uh yes please feel free to ask questions dear audience um obviously chris you made a very good point right you said the tech already works you have you don't have to prove that uh work on these um work on the edge cases right be be innovative but you also talked about how we make people or we create minds and persons who are not innovative right who are not courageous enough to do it otherwise they would be doing it already so how do you think should this change come about without the few or

hopefully many who listen to your speech and say right i'll just get up and do it but i think for every one of those there's maybe a thousand people who say ah i'm not sure if he's right i'm quite cozy where i am so i mean hans made the perfect point right um he described the german angst very well and unfortunately it's not just german acts it's european angst now right we've infected everybody with this seemingly um i think that we have to on a public side become more open to change if people try something and they fail our reaction shouldn't be laugh at them and maybe kick them a little more our reaction should be thank you for trying right that's i would say that's the biggest thing and if you look at also examples from hans the the corona app where we put data protection before health and and data protection was so important that we didn't collect data and now everybody's crying for data um if i had been a politician i

would have made exactly the same decision with the public pressure that that came right the point is this public pressure should have not been there we ourselves have to come into a position where we think like at least one step ahead right and not just in the here now and i think this is important it's not it is not something that we can ask of someone else to do it is something that each and every one of us needs to think is um yeah do i respect people who try something new because something new otherwise we're going the economy is going to go down massively if there are no people who try something new right and will i accept a change will i accept that solidarity comes from me too it means i have to give something so the whole society can profit and i eventually profit more and things like this so it's a very personal thing and i think we've lived in in a space for a very long time where the only

question was what can i get like my question would be like if i give this what can i get right how do you stay on your toes and on the bones in your own company how do you use the creative can you make sure that everyone that you employ is like a creative type of person uh comfortable living on the edge or how do you deal with that not everybody needs to be a super creative person right when we talk about creativity it's not only the big ideas and i mean in in my company you have the the fortune or misfortune of having a crazy person like me there who who has many big ideas but the the point is that the value of creativity has to be given even to the small creatives i think there's three types of creativity one is the artist type of creativity right the person who's willing to swim against the stream this is what we typically call the big ideas right someone who says i want blue paintings

everybody goes no blue paintings suck you say i still love blue paintings right and and you can say like i want data everybody goes no data can you can't have data and you say i still want data and you're going to build something great the second type of creativity is the engineering type of creativity and i think in germany we have lots of that and i think in europe in france i've seen fantastic engineers these are people who are who take components from unlikely sources um or unlikely combinations and bring them together and create a solution that people go like what wow um these are type of engineering creativity and i think what we totally undermined is the pioneers right the pioneers the people who need more risk to be happy in the olden days these people walked on ships um today a few pioneers uh building rockets the most we can see a huge increase in extreme sports right people climbing mountains without ropes and stuff like this because they need the kick it

would be but the problem is we don't honor pioneers in society meaning that they do these extreme sports rather than contributing to society we've got to get those pioneers back into companies and say like do it take the risk take the risk of a fall but we think you're do you're cool at least we should say they're cool and and is is what you think of like a a call going out to the individuals for change or do you envision something like i think elizabeth warren in in the u.s talked about big structural change like engineered by politicians maybe like more on a global scale what kind of change do you have in mind when you talk about these things well if you look at the us it's very polarized right so trump isn't the problem is the result of a problem and this polarization is is uh because these humanistic principles like completely went out the window which is sad um and we shouldn't let that happen uh i i believe it's it's a

very individualistic thing the question is do we as individuals believe that you fare better being an egotistical egocentric person or you do do you fare better being a community oriented social animal everything in evolution points towards the latter right but we behave towards the former right yes i agree i do have a question here from the other daniel who's helping us out a lot today what are your vicious wishes for the leaders of a better tomorrow from your perspective of changing the status quo as powerfully as possible oh um look i always you can have any wish you know it's free probably it's also inconsequential but it's free um i hope it's not inconsequential right so i hope so too i would wish that we rediscover solidarity and that leaders that we have no matter if they are left or right um accept that we're social animals and that the short-term benefits of egotism can never outweigh what we get if we work together all right thank you very much maybe one last question because

i was quite curious you were talking about different kinds of creativity the artistic and the engineering creativity where do you see yourself like i would guess in between but i'm not sure yeah probably i mean i'm stubborn so i i go against the stream for a long time and this is why i like kansas talk so much where he said uh implicit and explicit knowledge have to be combined otherwise it can't be applied properly to industry only two years ago i said this and there were a bunch of pure machine learning guys sitting at the table and they go like and where's the ai in this right now it's hot right so it's really the ability to to swim against the stream for a bit but i'm also an engineer like last night i went to bed at three o'clock because we were running large simulations and it's interesting right and i'm very glad to have you as uh as vigorous and as awake as we uh i saw and heard you today thank you

very much thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.