I stopped with following question this one which is not leaving me can a I be dangerous for humankind and now you can choose who wants to start with this one answering it you guys know my opinion yes absolutely how something as simple as you know AI doubters could steal all our resources so that's a concern right there okay we know your theory we've heard it let's take outside of this theory without the Dow we see it a little deep learning and so for what is a scenario I mean I Stephen Hawking is warning for it Elon Musk was warning Bill Gates these are very smart successful people have a lot of insights and they say AI is the biggest threat for humankind that's why they invest into a to understand it better I still try to understand why where is the threat coming out well I mean if you if you look at it as I think in the previous talk we have this three piece right so process and products and and one of
the threats that is actually upcoming and not just by super intelligence right is the is the the thing around process process automation process intelligence right so we are taking a serious amount of people out of this process is going forward in the next five years and this will have some severe challenges on our society right and the question is how you deal with that rather than okay maybe they're in twenty thirty years some type of super intelligence and it's becoming this Terminator thing right these threats so to say that emerge from the shift in a leverage model that is upcoming already ongoing other ones that are going to impact us I agree everything technology companies today have the the big challenge that they have to deal with the with the with the outcome of what has been done in the 80s in Hollywood and so typically when people think about artificial intelligence and that at the moment many people are talking about artificial intelligence and sometimes they don't they're not talking about artificial intelligence they
may talk about subsets of artificial intelligence that's the grand old the grand big scheme artificial intelligence and I think technology has just solved a tiny fraction of this we also saw this in the in the talk from the DFK AI from the German Research Institute for artificial intelligence there are many unsolved challenges many of the challenges to model intelligence human intelligence have not even be able to and have not been able to be modeled at all yet even not not even not even so soft solved it's a very open question and I think for very specific applications when we saw some of the examples on chess or NGO or computer games or image recognition yes some of the technology has surpassed what human a human brain can do but they only do it for a very specific small and an encapsulated task and the challenge will be and that's the same for every technology it's a tool artificial intelligence machine learning is a tool and you can use many tools in a good sense or
in a bad sense and I think it's up to companies that use these tools to use them in a responsible way and at some point there may be even questions where you have to ask should a technology be used in every single way and that's actually not a new problem we see this in many industries you see this in medicine and think about genetics and how you I apply some of the medical advances do you want to do you want to use some of you do not want to use them there's there may be some ethical questions there may be some discriminant questions so there's a lot of questions that I asked so you know I I have a question for your working for Google and my view Google is the potential Skynet out there Google has the most potential to blow up the world because they're currently the most resources and the most data dedicated to AI so how does Google preventing it that even have good intentions because the guys who invented sky
and I had a good intentions to in all the movies that they're AI won't end up in a negative we're harming humankind so you know we we take a very optimistic view of things and we also take a we take a very very transparent approach so first of all we share most of our most of our work is shared so all of our research work is shared all of our all of the technology can can be accessed through programming interfaces and we also engage in very deep conversations with the industry so just one and a half years ago we we create we were part of a consortium creation coffee the Alliance for artificial intelligence where we partner with on all technology partners such as Microsoft Facebook Apple Amazon and many others to discuss some of the challenging questions that come with the development of new technologies and machine learning and artificial intelligence because a lot of questions are not answered yet so there's a lot of open there's a lot of open questions and I
think you need to be actively engaging in conversations to to start debating some of these questions how you deal with them so Microsoft published Twitter bought a while ago which was used by the crowd of their to train it and it turns six you know it was I think chauvinistic so it didn't like women in the end and it was pretty racism because the internet is not morally always correct because when people can hide yes they have the thing is which saw as an example if the crowd is educating in AI how it can turn and in my slides I mentioned that we can choose it whatever American or Chinese system in our mind one day or at home banku spoke I like a story about a a kid again that we need to raise and so what are ways that we can make sure that the systems which are out there is it Dow or within Google or KPMG is running them out that they represent the values first of the nation which we
are or the cultural barrier but also as as humans so that the act in our interest but also that they act in interest of the people this is where the user I mean I think it's absolutely an interesting question and involves a lot down to some classical old-school means of having your processes right and having your controls in place right so as said I mean the good ol turn it inside-out right so if you train an AI just with bogus data it will just learn bogus results right and you can actually train this to do bad things because it's actually not intelligent right so that and that's the point so I think actually I'm gonna strongly disagree with this I think we can all hug and sing Kumbaya and say we're going to make safe ai's but wishing doesn't make a true folks all the takes is one person anywhere some kid in rural Canada whatever to build an AI that runs out there on some decentralized substrates that you can't turn off that starts
to accumulate wealth and you can't turn it on so it's much more than just a tool it's a company with rights if you want it to be and these are this is dangerous territory I don't have an answer in the near term of what to do I hope we can have laws that slow this down but to say that you know we're going to be open and hug and have transparent API that's that's more on it really is in my view we can use that help slow it down but that's definitely not the long-term solution it's there like a potential squish sir Killswitch do we have any potential to turn it off and yet all you need is one person to build an AI without a kill switch and then doesn't matter right like we have to get half these mirages at the kumbaya mirage right well my opinion that of course AI can affect our society and we could make a lot of mistakes and what you mentioned I think could be an error
or or made intentionally but what I would like to say is that all these fears that there will be a doom day there will be some super intelligent AI some high immersion out of all this work it would be so much more intelligent inhuman that would rule human race or even decided they don't need human that's basically impossible that's a sort of fantasy science fiction fantasy but if you look into the numbers that's not possible and the reason is that fundamental behind this whole thing is the idea that that AI can explode an explosion of AI is that at some point you have like a computer with a may I and it becomes so smart that it can improve itself it has access to Internet all the information it becomes modern smart and smarter and every time its exponential process and in every cycle even much smarter and then soon enough it just bushes by our entire zoom and it right there and then it's in comparison to Isaac like us to an end or
a fly that's mathematically impossible because intelligence cannot be just it's not a result of of some accumulated energy that just needs to be really all intelligence that we have we have seen all this example is a result of intensive interaction with environment and getting feedback and learning and there is no other way there's no way to become intelligent without learning from the world in getting in our feedback and to get in our feedback you have to do enough interaction so the world has to react to it so there is no just impossible to build something so smart in such rapid period of time so there never will be explosion and I explosion and this follows by the way from some basic theorems of machine learning so all the ideas that is in the AI could explore they're just not based on understanding really how I'm going to finally agree that - I really think we don't need a super intelligence in this way it can be a very mundane AI technologies that we had today
or 10 years ago if it starts to human resources and have this exponential growth in terms of resources that is super dangerous right and you know we could have another conversation about you know whether you can manifest dynamical systems that are intelligent in some way whether or not that can live in things other than question blood meatbags and we're sure we disagree there but it does we don't need to go to that right now I'm saying like with today's technology with nothing magical at all we should be worried today so the one of the most dangerous things of the world are viruses and bacteria they killed millions of millions of people over centuries so it's not a sophisticated intelligence it's not a lion yes it's not a dolphin it's not even n and they kill you alone I really recommend the books by William heartening because he goes through all these steps she sews it speaks about a google-like company who was developing an NLP AI which is creating self-awareness so the typical ways it's
coming out there but then he also speaks about the system that a kid is writing on a blockchain and virus which is attacking systems taking the source code optimising with the source code and it's iterating all the time until it's growing exponential so from a virus intelligence forms is coming too so we're certainly in two of them um but I want to come to a different point more about the consequences and you mentioned this before so who Baha javi and I have no clue if I'm pronouncing right he spoke in his book humidors about the youth less class artificial intelligence robotics automation they will create a useless class of humans so a class of humans he says which will not be needed anymore it's not that the unemployed they are unemployable so my question a is do you see this will happen that we will have a whole class of people we don't need for society anymore and if so what do you do what do we do with them how can we find a
solution that ever wanted valuable for society which does not mean it has to work we start with you I'm I think I wouldn't go to the point that they will be useless group of people right I think it's a way that people have to do different right a lot of stuff that we today do in front and back offices by today can be replaced and it's happening right your usual insurance agents that takes phone calls fills our form nobody needs that in the future right so the question is the question is how do you embrace that similar like you've done with the introduction of factory lines and Andres digitalization going forward right so we need to present a leverage model and that also means you need a different educational system because we collapse you have to do a higher quality work and to actually be and remain relevant because I don't think finding an economic model where still everybody gets some type of money on the bank doesn't solve the problem because people need to
do something right so they just sit at home they go nuts but what can you do which does not mean you have to go out and get a salary what else can be there like for you for example alright maybe it's not about there it's not about money but having something meaningful to do right so I mean there must maybe shift but still you always need something that is tangible for you to do regardless of the payment that you receive right so just fixing the the salary problem doesn't really address so you want to keep people busy all right I mean I mean one one I forgot would did the quote right today it's like if you can describe what you were doing you're in thread of being replaced and that's why I like what I do because I can't describe what I'm doing but yeah but it's reality right and I think needs to be checkered now essentially actually in the educational systems and going forward and so I I think I agree to
most of what you said I think that technology in the history of mankind has always through technology has created jobs that are more fulfilling but a safer there are more fun you know that reduce work time if you create if you compare the workload that a typical person has today to what they used to do like 100 years ago that has reduced as well so I think the trend will will continue and the question will be are we on an exponential curve and if you're on an exponential curve you can look up upwards everything looks looks pretty vertical if you look if you look downwards everything looks fairly or horizontal so the thing is how do you how do you deal with that and I think in some jobs yes there will be in some job categories yes there will be job losses and the question will be how do you how do you Reese kill people how do you how do you motivate them to find a new job and this process in itself
is also nothing that we haven't seen before you know just in November on on Weekly magazine HP girl in Germany we saw the cover page with an industry robots and the worker and the title was called you fired so in your technology replacing a typical worker interestingly 737 years ago in 73 there was a fairly similar cover on the same magazine with exactly the same situation so the model hasn't changed you know the robot looked a little little more in cheek bender in November 2016 1 but the the question hasn't changed and in the meantime in those 37 years many jobs that were killed if you want to use that that negative words from 73 to today has been generated my job your job maybe all of you Oliver Chisholm probably the majority of the jobs that you all are doing today had not been invented in 1973 so if we look forward to say what is what is the checking out what's technology going to do with my job in the next 10 years
what is machine learning going to do with my job you know many people will have to say we don't know because the jobs have not been invented yet so we saw in one of the talks we saw some jobs that will be created through in like in an a classification threat in China or UX designers so some of these jobs that haven't been haven't been invented just a few years ago so there will be dramatic changes on the workforce but I really feel that the the constant need for education as rescaling people is going to be fundamental to make people happy and keep them in a job that is fulfilling and find and find new things for them I'm optimistic your lesson is caught what I'm going to be expanding on and that is fulfilling think about Maslow's hierarchy of needs right how many people have jobs where it's actually hitting the top level of self fulfillment of their full potential right so many jobs are the mundane ones just around you know basic survival
etc right so I think as a goal we should try to say what you know can we maximize the number of people that actually get to be fully fulfilled and and at the same time make sure that obviously therefore feed themselves and jobs are one potential path but it's sort of a means to an end so I think actually that there's potentially other ways where AI and and blocking both our automation technologies automating the leaf nodes automating the internal mechanics where that can actually bring massive efficiencies to society right think about like how health care is administered and other government programs where the government is like 25 or 50 percent of the GDP this could probably be one tenth or one twentieth the cost if you go fully electronic etc Estonia is a wonderful example of this so and imagine we have other efficiencies that are squeezed out then overall this is actually money that's existing an ecosystem that could actually be directed towards people to just kind of do what they want you know
future Stockard charts are track economies etc they don't have work per se you can do a job if you want so you know I'm sympathetic with ideas of universal basic income I don't know if it's a full solution but it's cool and that is I can show on for example 3x entrepreneurship so if people have ubi there's actually a 300% increase in the amount of companies being started so people go for things that are so fulfilling I think this is a near term and it can extend to to sort of the crazier singularity of scenarios - it's all around a fulfillment of the self as well as the civilization so before I ask you so from here and your self fulfilling and finding your passion and sharing it for you both I heard getting your job which is not existing I say this on purpose because in the English language is not precise in German you say boof which is coming from the wolf phone which means you do not take a job you take
something but you really like to do because you feel you want to fulfill this and the German language is a little bit more precise they they say well this is much up or this is my blue phone yes and there you already have two so now to you thank you so at first I agree with all that but I think there's a bigger umbrella to reach that and even make it better and that is that we will have to improve our democracy historically with with the development of civilization with the development of technology with development of regions of a society also the Democrat democracy tended to improve in the society there's some variations of course but generally does educate and democracy what we have today is not the end of the story it's a technology as you if you wish something that also can be improved can be done better even in combination with the video technology that we have it internet and AI and so on we can make much better decisions quicker decisions
people can vote quickly there's no reason to go to polls really today anymore and we can improve democracy in a such way that all these unemployed before all these people who may not be able to find a job may not want more they want one they may want to do sports or do art or do something else did they have a voice in the society such that they organize all together with all the different interests society that works well for everybody we don't have to date today's it democracy is pretty good but it's not really enough for that new for that new economical situation that they see so I think we will need to improve the democracy that will somehow greater pressures improve democracy become maybe you know there may be short period of social unrest has just been looking historic I'm not looking at the seeing it but historically looking at how things have involved a short period of social investment thinks of okay let's do it that way and then we'll have a
higher level of Baron a level of democracy people decide even these unemployed will have stronger say in how the wealth will be distributed that's been created from all this AI and that's my my vision and hope that is going to work that way so I just had an idea I asked everyone please to stand up if you get if you have a task where you get paid for it yes if you have anything you do like a job or something and you get a seller where you get paid for it please stand up for a minute um it's late with goods move a little bit all right well it appears maybe can sit or who's not getting paid at that time some people have no I don't want to go this way it's it's fine so everyone who if you would not get paid anymore you would go and do it and no one pays you anymore sit down if you would not do it if you would not continue to do it I mean
no you don't get money and you still would you do the same thing you do every day if you would not get money for this if you love a job keeps that yes but you still have enough money for living no the thing is very could you could be automated what we had here so those who are standing they are the lucky ones oh they're the lucky ones because I have found something they they would do without the money because they do it with all the passion and love they get paid for it on top of it and this is what I experienced with entrepreneurs for example and that's why I believe if people would not have the basic needs anymore depending on the job they would find more happiness about what they did so this was an experiment for us to see thank you so because I have an idea where I want to go with this and I took it from all your talks and Martin Spindler he mentioned this term I want
to speak about socialism and capitalism in the combination of technology I was asked on panel or on owners and the talk dead or otherwise the people who own the algorithms they get rich let's take the shareholder in the Amazon it's the shares of Google or Facebook one so four they get rich because these algorithms earn a lot of money Facebook is the largest media company of the world with a very very much smaller percentage of employees than all the media companies used to have before so I mean Facebook and the other media companies are generating more revenue more earnings but with less employees so working for a company is not benefiting to society the same as it used to be because less people earn salaries so less people pay taxes and less people s-something to consume so more money is distributed what we call the top 1% I'm a venture capitalist on purpose because I wanted to be part of this yes that's why I do it one reason um but how do you see
this movement that these who own the algorithms they generate the money and they are not even Dow you know they are not even run by themselves still that people own it versus that we're on the other hand with left people who earn something and that this will and we have seen this Piketty world and the 21st capital that the gap is increasing again the only reason why the gap was done was second world war because of the world war the rich lost a lot of property and production and so forth so the gap is increasing the rich are getting richer and the rest stay and one reason is technology leads to monopolies monopolies I want fewer people so what is what are your thoughts to this point so two comments first I hope that we will start an optimistic part of the discussion or after this question but I don't see the sir it's been there is the topic so far and because I think that I really think there's a lot of opportunity in
all these technologies and there's a lot of good for society and if you are venture capitals and venture capitalists you will also know that for startups today it has become very easy to join the game and to join us generate revenues in fact many of the startups hopefully some of this success start of Xibalba will get into your portfolio are running on hardware that is provided by Microsoft or Amazon or our company they run program into interfaces for their for the proper their for the applications that run on on any of these of these players technology it has become so incredibly easy to create a company we can have an idea today at this on this panel and we can have a website set up payment systems not using any any of our own engineers just by using programming interfaces and you know after the second glass of wine tonight we can have a website our table products up and running this wasn't possible 20 years ago so it has to come incredibly easy to
create something on the internet and it has dramatically leverage leverage the playing field everybody can contribute in any anybody can use the same technology that the biggies the big companies like us are providing so there's great examples Israel there's a great startup here in Berlin I am who created photo software right so they have and they have a love and passion for photography so they created machine learning algorithms that in the beginning were based on Google photos machine learning algorithms so they used our programming interfaces but they said that's not enough for us we want to be better than Google photos who wants to be better than Google we want to beat the big guys so they added their own secret sauce and they creative creativity factors and beauty factors so now their software can detect whether a photo is beautiful or or creative and yes that combined technology is for the moment better than than weird and we love this we love this because it also challenges us to get better as well and
what I'm trying to say about that it is is it is not true that only the big guys can can win anybody can win and this is a fantastic fantastic development of the technology developments of the last 25 years and I've seen this personally in my in my business life I know when I started my professional career I was working for a publishing company and when we tried to set up the first website it was terrible because we had to order machines physical machines and they had in Sun Microsystems they at three months delivery time so but it's fine the idea was finished so that we could say well now have the budget we now can hit the hit the let's go switch it took three months for the machines to arrive then we had to get administrators to set up the system for by the time the the website was actually up and running you know probably four or five months would pass and in the example that I just described we can do
the same thing today at no cost and by the way if the at the model scale if you get enough users for your for your idea for your app or your website energy just add more space to your Amazon Cloud storage or Google where you we care about entrepreneurship it's easier and cheaper to be an entrepreneur today I absolutely agree asking who is an entrepreneur in this room just raise your hand okay and who believes it's easier to be an entrepreneur today than it was let's say 15 years ago and I agreed it yes by the way statistic is if you're one of the first 100 employees of Google you earn 99 percent more likelihood that you earned it that you get to be a millionaire than when you're CEO of your own company so and statistics is interesting if you join a tech company early it's less risk with more return by the way so it's with our loaded into the inner ship is a lot of self-fulfillment so the thing is not everyone
can be an entrepreneur it's easier today but not everyone has I see I I look at some of you of the year and we do 10 investments I would say 90 investments getting better or lentil companies get money from others but 9 team let's say magic percent of the team's will never reach a point that they get funding by investor yeah but you also know as a venture capital company that this isn't int I equals tomb right so if you look if you look at this conference today where they're in entrepreneurs and yes most startups fail probably this is a good thing because it stimulates the entire ecosystem but it's not only those few people that get lucky to create a startup that is super successful and gets a great exit it's an entire ecosystem right so you have people that run event spaces like this there's people that drive food trucks there's an entire industry next to the startup the startup ecosystem so for every everyone job in the high-tech industry which agreed is
well paid there's probably four or five jobs in adjacent industries so you know the entire system is driving the economy in a very very positive sense and there's many studies that prove exactly that so okay it's not only a few people that French is because I think there's one other positive thing that's happening so just to give an example of something that's negative right now you know well like a several hundred years ago the corporation was invented right and at the time the the investors and maybe the founders who had owned all the shares right and that would benefit them that it wouldn't benefit the employees who wouldn't benefit the community that's using the product or whatever right but especially with the rise of the nineties and even before and stock options became really a big thing and then the employees would be able to share in the benefits the winnings of the of the corporation and this was great because it align the incentives of the overall of everyone in the company right but
the loser the users have still been the losers right obviously this quotes like you know if you aren't paying then you are the product and this is actually a problem with some of the existing models that are out there right and yes there's other ecosystems that emerge but if I'm a user of Facebook then Facebook is making a lot of money off of me now what's exciting is that we went from people the top owning everything to having the employees having the stock options but now think there's a whole new trend with from the world of watching of tokenized ecosystems and what this means is that the users get tokens as well so as this ecosystem grows in value not just the founders of it and not just the people building the tools of the infrastructure but actually the users themselves are getting a value it's a positive sum game a rising tide that was so booked and this is really wonderful because then you know in some next-gen Facebook or Google or otherwise as
that thing takes off and grows the users the adopters are actually sharing in the benefits of rawl so it's a broader spread of the wealth across more and I think that's super exciting and it's a self-fulfilling prophecy so it's a would look in the history book yeah what I tried translating my words it's a mixture between capitalism ownership and by the intrapreneur and leadership at intrapreneurs in combination was a form of socialism because everyone else is an owner to everyone else is participating in their product if you don't like technology you don't even need a company like everyone has tokens in this ecosystem but you know some of the early people like grant more tokens but as you come along like more and more people get token so everyone gets to participate and what I do with these tokens what can you do it becomes the currency for services so probably the most modern recent example is etherium right so they raised twenty million dollars two years ago now that's the nine billion dollar ecosystem
and not only have the founders and initial developers been benefiting from this but everyone's been building apps on top as well as the users and the performance of the ecosystem everyone so there's been a big rise in the overall wealth and what's cool is they're taking that money and they're reinvesting it to build so this community is growing growing growing and it's the sort of flywheel of nine billion dollars and what is the you always have to put I mean if we take money today it's just a way of exchanging energy yes you work you get cash for it you give it to someone else and he invested cash tobago into to make a bread in the cell into the bread what is then the form of energy you put in how do you gain these tokens I mean what I have to do to get a token so you can trade it there are exchanges so like the main token in a theory mechanical ether you know in Bitcoin Bitcoin etc and there are
third party exchanges that you can go and exchange either for dollars or Euros and you still need to have a job to get dollars to trade them in to control them but that stuff one way but there's other ways you can earn it so there's other ecosystem things like steam boat and so on where when you do a blog post you get seen tokens and then you can exchange these Steam tokens for ether or for dollars or whatever so basically there's proof of human work that you actually get rewards in return this is super valuable and actually points to a sort of a rewiring of society at a fundamental level that actually is much more inclusive of everyone on an economic level and it ties together super well with AI and what not to as you might imagine so danke how do you and if I may have to say this you're one year I mean we're all very Western people here special yes and we spoke about this you were also on a system
which was not Western yes you agreed in the end in Eastern Europe yes so yes you have years of different systems - so how do you see the trend that capitalism is getting stronger because technology is in the hand of less but then we have people like under their knowledge who want to give more free money to those who are not in the system anymore who don't benefit to it like both happens at the same time of you yeah so it's true I had experience of communism to see how this economy works actually my father was enterpreneur within a communism which was a funny thing and of course the capitalism that came afterwards so what would a hell observe is the following that the society as a whole makes best progress when you have such a situation that people don't get too much and change in their in the power whatever power they achieve so if the company gets really big and powerful and has all this position it's sort of an internship position you're
like there but Google it's really hard to shake a Google if you are if you are if you have your you know your little shop in the inner busy street it's your shop your interests you're pretty safe with your business it's really hard to take you out of there for every intrapreneur that's the goal for every startup it's a goal like you either get a salt a bot or you actually find your position but really productive society makes a good balance between between these how strongly you can keep this position and how good chances are for these others down let's call them down they'd want to also go and find positions what was the problem of communism was it you know you had positions they were six they were no block didn't work if you go into capitalism too much to the extreme you would have the same problem if you if you complete the regular size nomen can go up it's just like whoever has the power stays there you will you will turn
off the growth of the society the growth of the economy the quality of life and that was like the case in early capitalism or enduring fatalism and in this in this part so what really makes society rich is this this flow and this flow is possible with this balance you have to have a possibility to go up otherwise there's no motivation there's no incentive there's no but once you get up it shouldn't be too safe because others you should be susceptible to challenge and if society can do this things well then then we haven't just that major is going to go really really really well and that the history the countries they did really well were the times when that really worked well that was after the Second World War as you mentioned you were creating the granite and I mean you think I honestly really artists s because they are there are a lot of trends technology different ones which affect these types of models so you might have those where you say okay
AI is taking our jobs but then you have others like share economy you have basically a know a new appreciation of handcrafted goods around the globe wire platforms like Etsy that gives people a very broad market give based on technology so there's and in these actually let's see how they level out and that's going to be interesting right and also in a being the incredible optimist that I am I really think that there's so many positive effects for society through technology if you think about some of the some of the projects that many companies including ours are experimenting with in the area of medicine if you can treat diseases in a better way just because you crunch very large numbers of data large amounts of data and you find patterns that can help you that can help you determine key fight a disease or can you fight being sick in general you know you can take real big aims at addressing very large you know Humanity challenges that's a really positive effect for our society
if you think about one of the big project that we've been working on that that we believe the society benefited is access to information most our search engine is now providing better access to information so that anybody can find almost anything that is written somewhere on the web that's great we're still working and it's not still not perfect and we're still continue to work on that and there's so many other really positive things you think about sticking in the medicine in the medical area there was some really great research progress on on identifying x-rays with machine learning so now you can now you can help doctors in developing countries you know you may not have enough doctors but you may have sufficient technology so you can take us you can take a scan send the x-rays to some machines through some programming interface and get the diagnose probably as good if not better then you have a doctor on site so you can you can really help address a lot of medical problems worldwide and
there are many many use cases we talked about the self-driving car and one of the talks 93% of accidents a feat of little accidents in worldwide are through human error so if you can bring that number down just because you add some self-driving vehicles whoever produces them whoever owns them whatever business model you run through that independent of whether that's you know a an existing car manufacturer or new players in the market that's a great benefit to society if you can if you can travel in an traffic faster or safer that's fantastic for society and I think there's so many positive use cases that make life also simpler not only safer but that's simpler and you think you think about how you use your mobile phone every day there's so many applications from our company from many other companies that make your life a little easier every day and this is what we are very passionate about I guess we're all agreement we're all in technology field because we believe it's better for humankind I
am purpose so before I give it open to the panel so if it's a question think about it for a second I have two short questions just short answers first do you own bitcoins yes yes I don't know yes yes no okay good for those who own them last year for a percent and increase yes so that in this yeah it's it's in invest it's it's an interesting return depends one you have and whether it's I expect it from you so I'm a questions we talked about the technology will make you healthy living longer the life expectancy of newborn kids today is a hundred years when I asked my grandmother who's still living asked her like what is the biggest things you are happy for for the last eighty six years she said the progress Amit listen all this course all those computers the progress in medicine I'm living already today thirty years longer than I was supposed to when I was born so question is if you can't choose how old would you like
to be because we spoke you you mentioned this just a number what coming in your mind if you can choose when you think okay today it's official 150 150 well I guess there's no there's no number I guess unlimited like all I can get unlimited my life has to be fulfilling so it doesn't it doesn't really matter if you have a life that is 200 years or whatever the number is it is not fulfilling so us assuming you always want to live even people who are unhappy most of them until they make it okay you don't know what you actually my grandfather he lived to the age of 94 hit a very fulfilling life many many adventures but but six months before he passed away he was rated in move on and so I they deeply acknowledge when people are ready to move on and I also reconcile though with I don't want to die when I don't want to die so I agree with you I don't know what my number is um I
don't know if I want to live forever but I just don't want to die when I don't want to die so hopefully a thousand maybe ten thousand years I don't know okay ten cells like like in the foundation yeah I mean by better it'll probably be some random crazy intelligence that's just me as origin but it'll be completely different you know okay now we have 150 we don't know yet temp up to the 10,000 so I mean you had hits you want to see your kids and your grandkids are however I'm afraid uh I'm afraid I wouldn't want to live much longer than hand years I have a feeling that due to very property of our own how our intelligence works we the way how we accumulate knowledge we process it differently at lower it older agent it's not because we get all it's because we get smarter and it becomes the last fun over time in in a sense that the time flies faster when you're older and it's neither it's not the reason
for that like we got we don't know how to how to deal with that we have so much more knowledge that we perceive the world differently it's just nothing's happening compared to the little kid like when it discovers in a little toy that's this so immense for their knowledge there's nothing that can impress as much as maybe two it has to be like incredibly great another question for you what if it's about the deltas of information you've already you know graphed most information in the world so every new piece it's a small thing it's only a small piece of information content that you're getting but what if you could keep getting that same large chunks of information content that you got a that's what you would have but you would have to go like explore at the planet to get the same excitement as my daughter gets now it's a very big question that probably deserves a whole conference and I think everybody would probably agree you know if you especially if you if you
take different if the context is important if I ask you now you're young and healthy and everything's fine if you fast-forward 40 years and you're like I know 75 and you know you feel the first signs of ck maybe your answer will be completely differently and you would say okay if someone could give me another five years and fix my knee and my my back and whatever whatever small trouble I have yeah I will take it and I think everybody would also agree that it's fantastic to see you mentioned medical advances it's fantastic to see the medical advances and in the last year's to give you one personal anecdote three years ago my wife was diagnosed with breast cancer and at the time everything science and we were all through this it's also fantastic but at the time she was looking up on the internet well with my specific type of tumor what are the statistics look like right so she's she's very analytical so she couldn't resist to do research and and then you
see numbers and percentages and I said well the good news is look at the statistics you know the statistics are from studies that are five years old the data for the studies there's probably another two to three years old and that even in that time when the statistics are have been created and the research has been created science has advanced so now you know you're done for your treatment if something happens again chances are that medical advancement is much further than it was when whenever the first researchers started working on on your statistics so I think everybody will agree there it's fantastic to see these great examples of medical advancements and many people with the same diagnosis only fifty years ago may have had a different a different outlook in their life so I think everybody is probably very happy about this whether I would answer the question do you want to live forever I probably don't so if you want to have the products were in - I recommend the book by Charles Stross
called axial random it's a pretty good book and within one book you have three generations you come to the point that lies is getting so fast that you can first you have cognitive agents so you can live one more than one life at any moment yet you can multiply your personality and live your whole childhood again with different iterations to figure out what where your parents could have been doing the best job and what schools but so forth so you can within hours you can live centuries of life because it's all in your mind so I agreed that moot time is exponential everything is getting faster more informations so life in ten years can feel more intense than it maybe feels today and life used to be slower 100 years ago and so I agree sometimes it's hard to say I think it's really useful to point out - like you know people can disagree whether or not we will end up on some silicon or silicon substrate but consider professor live ability that we
do right well there is a vast space of possible intelligences right and the intelligence that is a current human intelligence it's only one tiny pinprick in that vast vast vast space right and when we have more flexible substrates then we'll have the opportunity to adapter our intelligence of the shapes of our intelligences too much broader things to merge in and out with AI intelligences whatever whatever we don't really know right so and we have to consider that to beyond like if we say going went on from 100 to 200 years it you know given that we could be exploring different shapes of intelligences then that radically transforms an accelerant oh for example the the protagonist he actually changes himself into a flock of birds for 700 years and then his girlfriend leaves him because he's a birdbrain literally so the point is though like it's potentially like a malleable right and and this of course is just one possible scenario but it's actually put into the an exciting one right well this brings you to
another question I'm sorry path if AI if you could choose the form of intelligence of AI would it be a dog or a cat I have a dog person doc person I can't decide I like I like cats and dogs frankly I like the personalities of pigs pigs okay I grew up on a pig farm there it's a stock and auto for not the thing is with cats with the discussion with cat owners the question is I do the owner of the cat was the cat the owner of you yes and the same as about AI or do you want the AI to be like your dog always walking behind you and always doing what you want look at the time and know what I didn't do so last minutes and I didn't allow love questions today because I like a TED style so I like it if the speakers speak and the questions will be done outside of it well now I give you the floor if you want to so who wants to
ask something for the panel otherwise it means we're here questionnaire okay please there is a microphone turn it on hello okay um you spoke earlier about meaning that what we do need to be meaningful and that even beyond the point where we might be replaced by technology artificial intelligence there might be something that we could do what do you think also from a psychological perspective happens to us not subjectively but more general when we lose the status of being the tip of the spear because for the last five million years or so we were the biggest and best creation of this planet and we were very aware of it what happens when we don't have that feeling anymore please okay I can try and some of the colors is here so well yes we have been on a top and historically we had a few ego shots as as a nurse PC because a lot longer go we thought we were much more on the top we were like equal to God we were in
the center of the universe in Berlin were we are not in the center on the unit's we were on some sort of Paris ferry then we thought although the the earth is is how did it go first we discovered the dirt was running around the Sun and then we discovered that there was a bigger universe and so on then the evolution comes we're not coming from God like people but we were actually not some distance from from chimpanzee nineteen ninety-eight percent share DNA with then so we have got this hit right and then on the other on the other hand what we have none of us here is on top of everything each of us is is a minority or which term did you use in compared to something else and you're you you know maybe you are break enterpreneur but you probably don't think excellent and so there you look at okay well how well they sing or do something else so we are used to that we're quite used to that and it's
it will really you know it will be a fine we always I like to write the other I mean there are for everyone there's somebody that's smarter typically right so and I think that's somebody that I mean and most people actually would acknowledge to right and the and the other point is if there is something like super intelligence and you accept that it's smarter than yourself I think it's more around who's in control of it right so if you have a super smart system that that can excel your own capabilities that's all fine as long as you're in proper control of it right so the thing can play better Sesame so that has yes I have been impression about this mother than me but I'm pretty sure I'm in control of it right so I don't have any type of sense of threat now here's another anecdote I mean to some degree some of the tools we already using today are the same in the same category right so if we if we were sitting
over a beer or a glass of wine and we would talk about I know in Germany's soccer is very popular we've talked about soccer and you talk about this great player how we scored the second goal in that particular game typically in a typical bar situation it will take probably 45 seconds which we disagree whether it was the second half of the first half of the game where he scored two to nil it would take 45 seconds for any of us to use their mobile phone to find out on any such and as many on any search engine to to find out who actually scored and when when that was so we already have the tools that extend our brains capacity right so it's a tool like a like a calculator 25 years ago we now have different tools and they will advance over time I personally don't believe and this is my personal view not not not necessarily Google's I don't really find it so important when and if and whether singularity will happen
it's important that society deals with a with the challenges and the questions that come around that if technology advances quickly and you know there may be the unspoken Unsinkable thing that single singularity never happens who knows maybe it takes another thousand years maybe it never happens I think we need to be responsible as as end-users as companies as as individuals as society to deal with the progress that technology technological advancements bring this is nothing new we have seen that as many technologies and I think the underlying thing that is true for everything is the ability and the willingness to change change has always been taken place in society not only since we have machine learning and artificial intelligence and Darwin's quote is still true right it's not the strongest species that will survive so it's the one that is most adaptive to change and this is true for companies this is true for end-users this is true for society we will expect to change that's wonderful closing them before we close because it's people are
you know um two last questions and short ones first is can you imagine to leave Earth in your lifetime imagine or in medline and realistic you know first imagine second would you do it so I didn't catch the question can you imagine to leave Earth a lifetime you know we spoke about one way is to conquer space because otherwise we'll get bored or we have to flip my copy flow hmm at least one of my copies well one of them company's good I would love to do it but long back not get it if I could afford ship to moon and back I would look okay yeah I'm adventurous to write and I join you on your trip let's go I think I would be into right leaving aside all the details that come with it maybe a good go back four year olds excited about moving tomorrow's actually so alright it's the Wild West out there yes wooly why not okay then now last question do you believe we live in a simulation I
know high probability and I love that actually if people are trying to scientifically test this right now and seeing if there's computational shortcuts that are being taken at the lowest level so now you don't know right I said no high probability yeah no no no I don't think so no you don't think so well hopefully we won't find it out thank you very much for this yes that's awesome