So dear friends, the next um keynote speaker is uh how can I say when you was uh when you were uh involved in the AI Act at the European Union uh you certainly were in contact with him. I think that even and what I think exceptional about our next keynote speaker is that even if you don't agree with him on certain parts of legislation, stuff like that, he has always an open ear and listens to your opinion. And this is something that sometimes I think uh you don't get very much in in in politics in there. He uh is a member of the European uh parliament. He is involved in any kind of uh digital policies, the AI Act uh and and everything else.
And uh his um office chief Kite also a good friend of this organizations is there. He was also always very helpful with information and stuff like that. Please welcome on stage Axelos feeling dank. So thanks a lot for the invitation and um also listening to me for your patience. So in politics it's not very easy to come forward and even if I'm involved in some legislation at the end I'm not they're never satisfied because you have to do compromises and these compromises are not only for the good and uh that's why I'm um sometimes really not satisfied but urgent action is needed right now and don't be too much irritated so I'm representative of the city oo but I'm asking for revolution and anarchy in this direction otherwise I can't see how we will survive at the end so six years ago I would have told you oh we have only five years left for this window of opportunity to um became more independent and and doing something on our own but now we are
facing even more critical uh challenges in the uh European Union and so we have fragmented digital markets, insufficient investments, we are undermining so far our sovereignty and also undermining the competitiveness. And so what we need is a totally rethinking of our uh strategy and if we have a strategy in place and uh to think about how we can still play a role in the digital world. So we have two polls more than less in in Asia and North America and so on and uh how might it look like how we might come forward with a kind of our own way forward what we are seeing now um I'm coming a bit to these geopolitics now the big techs are getting a backing politically in a way where you it seems to be you you do not have boundaries from limits any longer.
So is just a kind of an supporting everything what they are doing and thinking probably in cash dimensions in um manipulation in power dimension but not in value dimensions and here we are coming to this question do we still want to have values in place and from my um yeah own conviction I would say Europe has a good chance in coming forward if we are connecting values to technology but we need to do this in on a fast track um we we need to be faster than other regions in the world I don't know if this is possible but this theoretically would be a kind of a good way forward um how we can come to this um situation of course at First, we also should think about our processes and proceedings um in a democratic uh government or democratic um process with a fragmented political situation and getting more and more instability in all of these.
So um I would say we need to think about how we can be better as a democratic legislator. Um I I would like to dream of a solution in saying within 3 months we should have a kind of a um answer to new or upcoming problems to give them a frame not a detailed regulation or something like this more a frame where we can say if you're in the frame everything is okay if you're outside the frame you will face some troubles and this is something where I would say but our um what is needed that we are faster because we are seeing the big tech has a lot of money they are flexible in their decisions.
um autocratic states uh they have a lot of money. they are flexible in their decisions and we in Europe making a paper, discussing, consultating, then discussing again and then we have a um voting on it and then we try to execute and sometimes execution of ideas is not really very fast and here we need to have a totally from my point of view a different system for it. Um even if we are thinking about of uh digitalization of uh administrations what would be a step forward already um then I would say please don't put all these tech guys into a kind of a hierarchy then you won't come forward um let them do what they need to do and then you come or they will create a kind of a result what might then be satisfied.
But if you are bringing them oh yes you have to talk to them and then to this ministry or to to that guy and so on. This is taking too much time and here we are coming to another problem. I would always say politicians or the um politicians in office right now uh especially especially the national ones and I don't want to insult someone but here we are seeing they are still sticking to the thinking of the last century they are thinking in their national dimensions and not going beyond this and I still would say Europe has only a kind of a chance if we are changing the thinking if we are creating um or joining our forces in Europe otherwise no single member state can't do this any longer so we have to um join the forces and then also having probably European projects making out of it where we can merge some companies together without any restrictions is just following one idea and then trying to come forward and executing this idea in
a way where we can um have a more uh positive outcome or to expect a more positive outcome. So, but this is something then we need probably to have European projects. But I can already see the discussions. Oh, where about the workplaces where we would like to um split the taxes and and whatever it is. But we need to overcome these situation even here. I would say probably because of this extreme transformation we are into we should give up or suspend let's say suspend for seven or more years some of our um laws or jurisdictions or whatever in saying we do not need a kind if we are putting uh some companies together. So merging companies and having a kind of a joint project that we are not asking ourself if this is market dominated dominating or not.
No, we need to come forward. Secondly, subsidizers or public procurement. uh this is also something if you would like to win these let's say digital race or the transformation then we can't move forward like with all these things what we are always doing it doesn't make sense because we are too slow we are too complicated um and even crossber in the European Union it's even more complicated and this is something what we need to overcome we should have a kind of joint teams um on this level of companies and then trying to focus on the results and and um transforming uh what we have in mind what might be a good idea. So this is something where I would say is a kind of a precondition.
Another precondition is of course the infrastructure. It's money and is cyber security also. This has to be installed at first or need to be done and then we can come forward and then creating this new vision with courage and also political with a political strategy and then we can or we have to reinvent ourselves economically, socially, politically and and uh to secure our position somehow even I wouldn't say as a kind of a global leader in digital issues but I would say we we need to come forward just to survive in a way and this requires probably the so-called third way um so this means for me also building a kind of a sovereign digital infrastructure and what we are discussing also with opensource and privacy preserving techn technologies but this would contain and this is what we are discussing already on the European level level a bit Euro stack something so India is doing this Europe can do this also and um that's why I would say this might be a step forward to
be more independent or to come to a more sovereign situation in Europe and otherwise if you are all saying no no no no way please I'm still open for for um other ways forward, but we need now a way forward. And um if you're looking to the geopolitical situation, um we we might be held hostage by our partners overseas somehow. If a weird president is dreaming in that night about a new idea like this then we um do not have a wonderful future any longer. So therefore we need to make ourselves more independent. So then also driving um investment strategy for AI. I would say robotics is something where we should concentrate on bio biotech where we are leading still but I do not know how long we might do this if we are not working on this and also quantum computing.
So this is something where I would say we should have this as a general goal and this is the minimum what we can do. We can think about other issues but this would be something where I would say um we we need to concentrate on. So then we need to eliminating also regulatory fragmentation to create a seamless digital single market. The digital single market should be our goal for the future that we are not fragmenting ourselves in this direction. Modernizing also the GDPR is something to enable more innovation friendly data flows and harmonized uh compliance. Um here I can elaborate a lot on GDPR. Um, of course, I have been a part of this negotiation at that time, but 2016, I haven't totally not convinced that this is the piece we need right now.
Not um meaning I'm not in favor of data protection, but how we are doing this here, especially in Germany, this destroying more than less the possibility to have access to quality data. what we need in a in a datadriven world. So, and um also we we need also to regulate digital spaces to prevent disinformation of course hold platforms accountable and uh ensure algorith algorithm um transparency and so this is what we should have in mind. So therefore theoretically we should have these headlines in strengthening industrial policy for digital sovereignity and and global competitiveness, creating a digital single market, shaping geopolitics in the digital sphere, building also a digital state across the industries and enhancing digital skills for competitive Europe.
These are the ideas and in trying to come forward of course we need to elaborate on these and probably we need to be radical in these um ideas itself. So I mentioned already Euro stack. This might be something what brings us forward um with this uh European digital infrastructure and software applications in public procurement might also help. So we do not have to die in beauty if we are changing or can change some of these elements. So it doesn't make sense if we are just sticking to this what we are um knowing since decades and uh so that's why I would say a totally change not totally but a change has to take place um we need this unified and also ambitious strategy for Europe's uh technological leadership if I may say so but uh it's it's needed and we um need to overcome this fragmentation in the digital single market.
So if I'm referring to AI, I'm not the biggest fan of the AI Act. When we evaluated the result, we find out 32 points in favor and 32 point points against. So that's why um even here I would say h it's not the best way forward especially with this kind of new technology where we where what is so fundament and and where we need to play a role in this. So still I would say the AI Act itself is um somehow risking or hampering uh competitiveness in a way of the European AI ecosystem. Um but also therefore we need probably additional steps to overcome these very complicated piece of legislation. Um at first we are asking for as an EP group in this direction um for harmonized technical standards.
The idea behind has been if we have created a standard and if you are taking these on board then you should go or should be able to go directly to the market. This would be something what we have had in mind. Um legal certainty. So if you're looking to the AI Act right now, you will find oh legal uncertainty some strange definitions where you do not know really what does this mean in practical dimensions. So there we said oh we need these guidelines first and said and second also these kind of code of practice what is now on the table and we are still discussing the idea behind has been so everyone who is fulfilling these and signing this uh code of practice then go to the market and realize your idea and templates and so on.
So it's um something what is necessary how we can simplify the access to the market if you have wonderful ideas in place and uh here also we need to think about and probably we have to take more risks instead of once again dying in beauty. So then we try to now to try to avoid these legal overlaps. Um there was a kind of a pressure at the end of last Monday to come to an end in these negotiations and negotiations in these dimensions means we do not have a government. We do not have an opposition on the European level. So therefore these at that time seven uh different political groups need to come to a kind of a majority through compromises.
This means sometimes what you're reading is not always logical. So that's why we um had to compromise and then on this institutional level also we need to compromise and Germany and France at the very end came with some ideas what I personally would consider totally idiotic but for face saving reasons we need to take some of these on board so that's why um we have here some elements in it where we can improve and uh also these legal overlaps we need to find out. Probably you will better know than we are at the end where the overlaps might be and but please let us know we should come up with more legal certainty at the end.
Then the idea of governance overlaps. So this is something what is probably annoying you all. um the governance in all these direction if this is digital services act, digital market act, data act, data governance act, GDPR and the AI Act is already fragmenting everything and what the one administration is saying the other will probably say the opposite of these and this is something what we need to avoid in the future. an idea would be and this is also something what I would like to propose more to my uh political group to come to a kind of a centralized um governance structure where you have all these legal elements on board digital service act etc etc what I um listed already and then trying to find an interpretation where this is balanced between competition and market situation and also a protecting of the single person and this would be my what I would consider a way forward um instead of confronting you with something what is 150% of data protection then this will won't fit the
um possibility for having kind of a good market situation. So here I think we need to do something the concept of send boxes in this case. I'm I'm already seeing this that France would like to compete with Germany, Belgium with Denmark or whatever. This is not the right dimension any longer. Therefore we are asking for concept of these sand boxes that not everyone is doing the same. um so that we can also prepare for sectoral sandboxes in a way and we have been asking the commission um also to create something like this the easy compliance formemes also here we should more have a kind of a riskbased approach in this because of the size of companies um this might be also something that smaller companies doesn't or don't have to fulfill everything what the big tech is um has to do.
So there might be um also a way forward training data. So we we need to have access to training data or quality data at the end. And here I'm also convinced Europe can play a role if we have something like this in mind where we can uh link values with technology but it has to create a kind of an consequence or result out of it. What is quality and trustworthiness then we might also play a role better role here. But we need to have this access to a quality data and here we are coming to a situation and or an overlapping situation to the GDPR. Um I always had said at that time but haven't gotten the um majority for it but why we are not integrating just a sentence in the GDPR and saying you can use personal data for training your algorithms.
This would be a kind of a legal clear element and um now you might face different interpretations in this direction. But um then also thinking about a kind of a yeah modernization of the GDPR still um I would be rather radical in this in in changing the whole structure instead of everything is forbidden unless you find something what is allowed. Um I would change this in everything is allowed but do not touch the privacy of our citizens. This gives you a totally different approach that everything is possible but I have to take care where I can't go further. Um even I would say the time has come where I would uh yeah turned from data protection to privacy protection.
It might be also hard to define but um it would give you also a kind of a better possibility. So sometimes in Germany as far as I know the data of the pressure of a tire is protected as personal data. I do not understand why and that's why I think we are exaggerating data protection too much so that all machine data seems to be personal data somehow and then you you can't really move forward. So that's why I would say privacy protection is the idea behind and probably we should move forward in this direction and um of course nothing would happen if we do not have the talents and here we need al so our federal system of education might not be very helpful in this regard but um we need to educate our population also in this direction that we um have talents in Europe in all our member states and therefore we need to come forward with a different educational approach and and here I hope that everyone is understanding what to do
even sometimes the last point do we need really penalties all the time so threatening companies, smaller ones uh with penalt penalties means sometimes probably h this risk is too high. We should um probably then not doing this or that. No, we should more activate more initiate and um more motivate also um the ideas of creative digital entrepreneurs. So that's why um I would say please at the end if you have wonderful radical ideas please let me know in which direction we should go. Thanks a lot for your attention. Axel everyone Mr. Of course. Uh just one one two quick questions. Um in the beginning we also talked a little bit about that. Um there was this Paris AI summit and there were it was the announcements the all the announcement were there and uh Frandeline did the announcement of I think of 200 billion in investment.
Yeah. And then uh some some weeks ago I was in Hibbron and then Lutasi from the AI office said, "Yeah, well 100 billion are coming from the national states." Did she tell them the prime ministers and the chancellors and the finance ministers of the national states that she just given out a 100 billion check without asking them? So I don't think so. Um but in indeed we need to think about how we would like to finance or how would like to invest also with private money and thinking also about to change some rules that insuranceances can also um invest in some of these um new ideas and and so on. this is not possible right now in in the US and somewhere they are doing this but so we can have more money probably in the market.
Um this needs also to be changed. Um and I hope that our all financial experts can think about a kind of a program or dimension to attract also private money with a kind of an interest outcome at the end. But um also have some programs in place where we can really have more money in the market and that we can really come forward. But we need a strong will. Yeah. A political will to do so to survive in this digital market and to come forward with priorities. You also said things have to be quicker in in in Europe. So I am now uh involved a little bit in an IPS and an important project of a common European interest.
Um it's called IPS AI. The development of this IPS is 24 months I think. Yeah. And then it's the implementation and stuff like that. I get it's a lot of money. I get it has to be checked and stuff like that. But your former colleague Mr. Teoda once told me that on the political level we agree that it has to go bigger. But when you go to the dieses, the dire generals and and the people working on this I he thinks that this message isn't going along very well. Yeah. Would you agree? Yes. So um I would say the um courage in administrations is not there and also going into the direction of risks and um even I'm asking myself if the national um governments would be able to have a kind of a European dimension in this um that's why it might be tricky but the European um investment for uh banking for the bank for investment EIB uh so might create some programs and can probably do here more than what we have
in mind. So that's why um we we need to contest them all and then you need to contest us all also and then we might come to a situation where we can play a role. Thank you so much Axel for everyone. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. It's done.