Rise of AI Conference 2024 · Berlin

Europe’s AI Dilemma: Catching Up or Leading the Way?

Kai Zenner, Martina Silov, Anna Christmann, Stefanie Söhnchen

At Rise of AI 2024, a panel moderated by Stefanie Soehnchen (PIABO Communications) with Anna Christmann (German Bundestag, federal coordinator for aerospace and commissioner for startups and the digital economy), Martina Silov (president of CroAI) and Kai Zenner (policy adviser, European Parliament) discusses whether Europe is leading or falling behind in AI. All three agree Europe is neither leading nor left behind: the AI Act laid regulatory groundwork, but attention must now shift to applying AI across sectors, with more investment, open data and talent. Christmann calls for a 'European Tech Deal' alongside the Green Deal. Silov argues Europe has the scientific talent but lacks business, marketing and management culture, and a tolerance for startup failure, pointing to Croatia's own unicorns built despite a small market. Zenner says Brussels still works in policy silos, that the AI Act's European ethical principles are 'hidden' in the text rather than stated upfront, and cites the underfunded AI Lighthouse initiative as an example of good ideas failing on investment and national rivalry over its location. The panel closes on the need for larger, braver private and public investment and stronger cross-border European hubs.

Key takeaways

  • Anna Christmann calls for a 'European Tech Deal' to follow the Green Deal, shifting focus from AI Act regulation to applying AI across sectors.
  • Martina Silov argues Europe has scientific talent but lacks business, marketing and management culture, plus tolerance for startup failure.
  • Kai Zenner says Europe's AI ethical principles were successfully exported to the OECD and UNESCO but remain 'hidden' inside the AI Act's text rather than stated upfront.
  • The EU's AI Lighthouse initiative, meant to become a CERN-like AI hub, was undercut by an 800,000-euro budget and years of disagreement over its location.
  • Christmann cites Bosch's investment in Aleph Alpha as an early example of German industry backing a domestic AI startup, alongside a roughly 175 billion euro future fund.

Detailed notes

Where Europe stands: not leading, not left behind

All three panelists open by rejecting a binary answer. Christmann says Europe is not leading but also not left behind, having spent recent years building the AI Act as regulatory groundwork; the task now is to move to application across sectors, including public administration, which requires investment, more open data platforms and talent. She proposes a 'European Tech Deal' to follow the European Green Deal. Zenner calls the AI Act's result 'mixed feeling': it will help trustworthiness and safety but does not by itself address the risk of Europe falling behind, and needs secondary legislation plus complementary investment programs, including synergies with the Green Deal such as using AI to save energy.

What leadership would actually look like

Christmann cites regular AI use by about 30 percent of German companies versus roughly 40 percent internationally, and says leadership would mean a more active startup scene able to scale into companies with worldwide impact, helped by the European Tech Champions Initiative for venture capital and a genuinely unified digital single market. Silov describes leadership more concretely: everyday devices and services being European-made, the way US products dominate American daily life. She argues Europe has the talent but lacks the business, marketing and management culture that turns science into companies, and a cultural tolerance for startup failure, contrasting this with Croatia, a country of 3.8 million that produced globally leading products such as Rimac cars and Infobip because of a 'hunger for success' born of a harder economic history.

Silos, risk aversion and digital skills

Zenner names three problems in Brussels: policy silos where good initiatives are not connected and sometimes undercut each other; risk aversion and a habit of waiting for the state to act, which he says is now improving in Germany through initiatives involving a technical university and the Applied AI Institute and public-private partnerships including AI Act regulatory sandboxes; and a long-standing gap in digital skills that undermines Europe's broader digital ambitions. Christmann links Germany's hardware and engineering strength to the need for equal strength in AI software, and describes the government's 'startup factories' competition, which funds ecosystems around universities to help researchers found companies from their own research.

European identity, metrics of success, and where talent goes

Asked whether a shared European identity can overcome national fragmentation, Silov questions what should even be measured: research output and universities, where she says Europe already excels, or globally known companies and unicorns, where she says Europe has few success stories and is instead training a workforce that often migrates to the US. Zenner responds that Europe's high-level ethical AI principles were successfully exported into frameworks at the OECD and UNESCO, but that his push to state the 'European way of AI' explicitly at the start of the AI Act failed; the principles remain hidden inside high-risk obligations. Christmann argues Europe needs magnet research-and-business hubs comparable to CERN or EMBL Heidelberg, citing early examples like Cyber Valley in Tuebingen and the ELLIS initiative, though none has yet reached that level of global pull.

The money problem and closing remarks

Pressed on why breakthroughs are not happening despite talent, money and regulation being partly in place, Zenner cites the EU's AI Lighthouse initiative, intended to become a CERN-like AI hub, which received only 800,000 euros in funding and was delayed for years by member states disagreeing over its location. He also notes German companies broadly welcomed AI Act regulation as providing a needed framework, despite complaints about incoherent, overlapping EU laws elsewhere. Christmann points to Germany's roughly 175 billion euro future fund and to Aleph Alpha's investment from Bosch as an early example of German industry backing a German AI startup, while stressing public money alone cannot close the investment gap with the US and China. Silov closes by urging Europe to be braver about betting large sums, tens or hundreds of millions, on individual companies rather than spreading modest amounts thinly.

Quotes

We're neither, we're not leading and we're not left behind.

Stefanie Soehnchen

We don't have the business people, we don't have good management in a tech world, we don't have PR and marketing.

Martina Silov

Europe should be brave enough to say, okay, this guy or this girl or this company is worth putting money in, not 10 millions, not 50 million, I'm talking about big money.

Martina Silov

Questions answered in this talk

Is Europe leading or falling behind in AI?

According to the panel at Rise of AI 2024, Europe is neither leading nor left behind: it built strong AI Act regulation but now needs to accelerate investment, talent development and real-world application to close the gap with the US and China.

Why did the EU's AI Lighthouse initiative fail to gain traction?

According to Kai Zenner at Rise of AI 2024, the AI Lighthouse, meant to be a CERN-like European AI hub, received only 800,000 euros in funding and stalled for years because member states could not agree on where to locate it.

What does Europe need besides regulation to compete in AI?

According to the panelists at Rise of AI 2024, Europe needs larger and braver investment, more open data, stronger digital skills, and a business and marketing culture that can turn research talent into globally competitive companies, alongside its existing AI Act framework.

Mentioned

EU AI Act, European Tech Deal, AI Lighthouse initiative, startup factories, regulatory sandboxes, digital single market, digital skills gap

Keep exploring

More from Kai Zenner

More from Rise of AI Conference 2024

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 7,066 words

Show the full transcript

so a warm welcome to everybody in the room I'm really happy you're joining us for this really interesting discussion with our experts h and a warm welcome to everybody uh joining in the live stream listening to us here so my name is Stephanie zunin like you already heard I work for Pabo Communications Europe's biggest Tech communication agency and I'll be moderating this session right now first I'm going to introduce the panelists to you and then I'm going to ask them to give us a brief statement about our topic about the European dilemma whether we are leading in the topic of AI or if we are being left behind that is what we want to uh talk about now right so let me give you a brief introduction I hope my microphone works again because I want to hand this off to you I am always optimistic I can speak very loudly there no problem okay whatever let's do this so first we start with the ladies I'm going to start with Dr anak Chrisman she

has been a member of the uh German bundist talk since 2017 and she's carved a niche for herself in the areas of technology and Innovation policy as specifically in the areas of digital economy and Aerospace she's the federal government coordinator for German Aerospace and also the commissioner for digital economy and startups now I have to do this right uh she has a p pivotal position in Germany's technology policymaking and AI regulation and also does significant contributions in integrating Advanced Technologies into the national economy she's a vital member in the German bundist Tag's onet commission called K intelligence where she is instrumental in shaping the AI policy advoc advocating for the deployment of AI in alignment with ethical standards and societal goals please welcome Dr Anna Christman all right the next lady on the panel that I would like to welcome is Martina Zillo she is the president of the Croatian Association of artificial intelligence and she is her mission to Foster meaningful collaborations within the technology ecosystem of Croatia under her leadership a hero project

was launched um where they reached over 50 schools with over 50 mentors and 2,500 students she has been pivotal in organizing numerous meetups across Croatia educating the public about the potential of artificial intelligence making it more accessible to everyone she's launched vibrant take communities in Zagreb fostering the collaboration among Engineers Educators artists journalists and Technology enthusiasts she holds an influential position in the AI community and she's promoting techn Technologic iCal optimism which is I think an interesting also addition to the to the panel of looking at all the regulation things we heard before welcome with me Martina zom thank you and last but not least we have Ka Zenna who is the head of office and digital policy adviser in the European Parliament he has made his career in politics law international regulations grounded in strong academic Foundations at universities in Europe with a focus on security studies and European law as working in the European Parliament he has been instrumental in shaping digital legislation and policy namely the European AI Act that we've already

heard so much about today uh he has taken a leading role in navigating this um digital legislation and policy advising with a very strong advocacy for ethical AI standards that align with privacy security and governance principles he also holds several highlevel advisory roles including positions with the oecd's network of experts and the United Nations expert group this allows him to influence global digital policy particularly in the integration of AI technologies that support European digital sovereignty and Innovation welcome with me kaena thank you and now I asked all of the panelists to pre prepare a short two three sentence statements of what they feel about this European dilemma Where Do We Stand from their perspective are we leading are we falling behind uh what is their view on this we're going to start in the order of my introduction so FR Chrisman I'm GNA hand you the microphone yeah thank you so much very happy to be here and actually I I already matched the color of the day I think um so uh according to

the question I think we're we're definitely not leading in Europe I mean that's what we have to be clear about because otherwise we won't be aware of what still to do to uh be uh one of the one most important regions for AI in the future I'd say um so we are also not left behind I think we have many opportunities and that is for us a important task that we have to do now in Europe because several the last years we really worked very hardly on the AI Act on on like the fundament uh for many activities that we have already in Europe and that we want to see more in future but now is really the time to concentrate on the application on really the actual use of AI in all the different sectors uh also in public administration and I think that is the task that we have to do now and what is needed is quite clear Investments so that is also a political task we need data more open data

more data platforms where we can share it um and we need the talents and I think that is what is needed to be done I personally suggested there therefore that we now after the European green deal we also need a European Tech deal to really bring all these things together and be a very attractive place for the development of AI and let me just end by saying it's it's really and no reason to say uh okay it's over uh but there's lots of reason to say now is the time to really um accelerate our activities because we have already many of these things we have talent we have excellent research at the University we have startups and more and more and we have all the question of AI and Industry which is a huge opportunity but no question we need to accelerate to make use of all these opportunities so hopeful but not to late but still a lot of hard work in front of us first of all thank you for the lovely introduction

next time my mom asks me what I actually do I will just give her your number and you will explain uh so hello everyone uh before I go to my statement I would just like to tell you a bit more about myself like introduction how I ended up in this field so uh back then when I joined CI I was the first employee I was an intern there and my first task was to actually do research about AI uh in Croatia and then I was thinking like there's AI in Croatia but during that research I found out that Croatia is one of the leading countries in the world and Europe by the number of unicorns per capita we have so many uh startups scabs even though our actually one of our biggest exits is AI startup that was sold for half a billion dollars last year to Google and it's one number one otech application in the world so I was like this is so cool there are so many interesting fun smart creative people

in ctia I want to be a part of this world um from the first employee I ended up being executive director and running couple of European projects having couple of full-time employees the association grow to more than couple of thousands of community members more than 400 official members uh we have five to six events a year and then I switch my full-time job to M smithz which is an AI startup that is creating an AI platform for multi-agent system and in my NGO role and in my startup role I realized I was always scared but I'm not a scientist I'm not an engineer um I don't have an official AI background and then I realized that those same scientists and Engineers created Silicon Valley and they're not able to do that in Europe and it's not because we are we have been talking about a lot about Talent it's not about Talent we have the talent we don't have the other side of the story we don't have business people we don't have good Management

in a tech world we don't have PR and marketing who will be able to explain what the tech world is actually doing and I think we can always go back AI Act is going to be responsible for startups leaving the Europe and of course there will be a lot of consequences and a lot of good things but I think we have to go step back and think about what can we do as communities and what can we how can we merge these two worlds that are really really not together at least in Europe and how can we work together because when I my startup is right now in Miami when I go to Miami I can create 10 deals in 10 days if I go from Croatia to Berlin or to Paris or to war wherever I wouldn't be able to do that in a year so so I think that's one of the things that we have to uh worry because regarding the ACT there's nothing to do anymore so more doing and less

talking it sounds like oh we we are still solving the microphone problem we're just going to share sisterly we're GNA do that okay right so more more doing and less talking it sounds like just getting getting it done henna what do you think yes so it's a good question and much has been already said so I will really focus on the European angle and um we made a lot of prep work and also the um I commission or cat Commission in the Bund did I think amazing work and underlined where we are lacking behind where there are problems where there are opportunities and so on and so on and because of that the European Commission in the end made um with the European AI Act um an attempt to yeah fill a little bit in international Gap because back then it was really not a lot happening in regulatory terms a lot of international organizations were working on it but on National or Regional level it was not really the case and we wanted to

yeah create a second brusset effect um similar to the gdpr that basically there are um good um rules here that are copy pasted around the world which would give our um companies a Competitive Edge now if we are looking in the end product the AI Act I think it's a little bit a mixed feeling um so we did a little bit a lot of good work there there are um good principles it will definitely help to improve the trustworthiness the safety of the AI Act but did or does the AI Act really address this threat of being left behind I think at the moment actually not and therefore and what Anna was saying I would agree a lot and I'm really happy I'm now here for the third time and um actually the narrative here also changed a lot it was this focus on regulation regulation but now everyone is talking about okay regulation cannot be everything what is missing and therefore also on the European um side we are now talking about okay the

AI Act needs to be much more clear it's very vague so definitely secondary legislation is missing but we also need to complement it with Innovation with investment programs with also connecting AI to other fields we have the green deal there are lot of potential synergies by using AI to save energy and so on and so on so what hopefully is coming with the next European commission and with that I'm stopping my intro is a more comprehensive way of using AI for a better future thank you very much to all of you I think we got a good impression on where you stand on this I would like to open up the the discussion by saying what would it actually look like to lead because the question is are we leading or are we left behind and you basically said we're neither we're not leading and we're not left behind but I would like to understand from your perspective what would it look like if Europe was leading would it mean we had more companies doing

this would it mean we had like we were the most famous for it or had the most Publications we heard from the Minister that we have so and so many startups registered like what would a world where we are the leaders actually look like I mean if you look at the numbers um you can see in Germany for instance right now um 30% of the companies use AI on a regularity basis and uh on a regular basis and uh compared to the rest of the world there it's 40% so we see we are like in the use of AI in the fields um and the different sectors we are now under um the um score of of many other countries so I think um to be a leader we need really to apply AI in many more fields in many more sectors it needs to be more standard and to see um when we would be a leader that would mean that we would have an even more active startup scene in this area I'd

say and there what is what I said we see really some startups coming up in the sector I mean there are already a lot but what they need is more money to really scale up more um that is uh one thing that we are addressing really with some public funds also and for example the European Tech Champions initiative which is an initiative to have more venture capital in Europe especially for technological fields and um this is the gap that we see so a lot is happening but there is often missing missing the step to really get to a scale up a large company that has worldwide impact and there also in Europe we often have the problem that we have like all the different countries so everyone looks at the own market and um there is often not the attempt being a global leader from the beginning and this is also um I think something that has to change uh companies that start in um Germany needs to have like the global market in their

perspective and um there is some work to do and there Europe can help uh if it really works together very well if you have also like the digital um one digital Market in Europe that would help and um if we um achieve that we have really the money that can be invested in these fields I think these are just two factors and I mentioned also data and um uh compute power is also a question and there is also a lot work to do so it's money and mindset What I Hear here and this is also something Martina that you basically said that you know we had don't have business people we don't have marketing people like the the spirits that we maybe see from the bigger players that give them this Advantage do you agree yeah that's how but how if we are the leaders and how the world looks like uh it's really simple when you're open your bag and you take your phone or you take your laptop is made in EU when

you open that laptop and you when you open that uh phone whatever uh and you open that uh service it's European apps it's European Services it's European technology it's European uh best case practices that's the world how world looks like from American perspect perspective for example that's their world because they're using their own products I I don't know what's the last time that I used European product maybe that sounds almost impossible from but that's the RO of when you're leading in certain sector yeah do you you think it's possible absolutely how we have I I really believe that we have the talent I think we need to shift from our mentality that we have to change it and that we have to be more open for example in other parts of the world when you fail once as as a startup or you fail twice it's completely okay if you fail second time in Europe you're a loser so I think we have to first of all switch our mentality in that case but on

other hand Europe has the best quality of life and that's really when you're not hungry hungry for Success it's really hard to create new generation of leaders we had the same problem like in Croatia but you had that really hard history so you created the leaders that are capable in a country of 3.8 million people create the best world product so remat cars are the best world product info is the leading at a company in their field uh photomat was a leading company because people were hungry for Success so I think that's really necessary for one nation to develop the best products do you feel that on a European level that there is this hunger because what we the the criticism that we've heard today as well is that there is um a fear and uh this takes a bit like almost we've got nothing to lose kind of attitude what you just described yeah is there anything like that actually happening sorry no um no that's definitely a point that is being discussed quite

a lot in in Brussels um I would say even in this commission under fond um there were good steps so there was definitely a much more strategic um out viw it was also um a good focus on things where we are strong and trying basically to there become leaders there was not this attempt from the last commission um to make our own browser our own platform because we all know that this is really a challenge and probably not possible so there I think we are indeed um on a good way and maybe we are able based on on the things that are not working and a good assessment to really push them forward maybe to complement the points that have been said because I support basically everything um three things that um again right now in Brussels at least are major problems um again I touched up on it already we are working really in silos there are a lot of good initiatives but they are not connected and this is just extremely harmful and

um is leading often to situations that we are doing in one area one things that is then basically pushing us back again in another area and so on then um an Point um it was mentioned already about us being risk adverse waiting for this State and so on there I see at least here in Germany now um huge changes with t Technical University Applied Ai and so on they are probably here also um Schwartz family there are now really initiatives that are um not waiting for the government to interfere but doing it themsel or public private Partnerships some that is also in the AI Act with regulatory sandboxes this I think is also a really good as step forward if we manage uh to concentrate more here then connect all of our silos better and then finally address digital skills because I'm already feeling old with 38 now because um since I'm at school there's talk about let's improve our digital skills let's work on literacy but without catching up there finally um I think

yeah all of our ambition in the digital field will not be possible to achieve I would like to invite the German perspective is there a German hunger as much as a German angst to to rock this I'd say yes and maybe what we need to understand better is that for the challenges that we have right now and of course uh one is the geopolitical uh challenge that we have of course but the other is the like not new climate Challenge and I think there is a lot of hunger for finding solutions for these challenges and when we look at especially new companies onethird of some tackles uh like uh greenhouse gases in a way and uh climate in a way and actually we need to understand that all these kind of challenges we only will find the solutions to them if we have also like the technologies that are needed and AI is for many of them a crucial technology um so if we stay with being a champion in um like hardware and Engineering

um without being also a champion on the software side the AI side that won't work that well but we need to bring these two things together and I think there is a hunger for doing actually exactly this one and then there are companies that are already on their way to doing this and I think that would also be like the European maybe uh way of really pushing AI solutions to really find the solutions that also help solving our problems because I don't see so much the need to really like have the next Consumer oriented uh big AI uh personal data company uh whatever I think that is also might be relevant uh for for some um sectors but in the end the European way could really be to bring these two things together that's what I mentioned like being bringing the green deal together with a tech deal I think that would be the European way to go and that is what many people are motivated um by to really solve these kind of challenges

and I think that that could be a push that really uh brings us forward and maybe to mention to link this a little bit to how can we support this umom was mentioned um and what I said earlier that we have already a very high expertise in research in many of these fields um we really want to help to bring them into application into real companies and that's why we started the startup factories competition um where there's just a first round of applications running right now now and there is the idea to really build these kind of ecosystems around universities to bring investors there to um really motivate students researchers to uh really found a company uh from their developments at the University and we've seen that it's really needed to bring public research closer to private Capital to make an a successful ecosystem that leads into more startups that's why it's called startup factories it should produce startups in the end and I think this is the lack that we often see and these

is just one example of concrete programs how we can help to really um make the things happen in reality so we heard from several um standpoints that something like a more European identity on what we should do could be helpful but at the same time we have very different countries in Europe and we have nationalistic Tendencies almost everywhere I would like to understand do you all agree that this European mentality could have that we should break up silos how can we do that I understand that maybe Martina you are not entirely convinced that this could happen because of the fragmented um count so maybe we can look into is a European identity really the solution here yeah I think we have to you had a great intro about let's define success but I think we also have to ask ourselves like what do we measure if we don't measure C customer uh how do you put it customers relationship or customer AI or whatever uh what do we measure like if we're not building companies

that will sell Ai and eventually grow to unicorns or even bigger and leading big tech companies and so on what do we measure are we measuring just the input that we had or the products that we see on universities on Research centers or so on because if we are measuring that I think Europe is amazing place we are creating a great Workforce for next Silicon Valley we're doing a great job then because we already have great scientists great experts we are missing the business part we are not I I don't remember the last time I heard great story from Europe that not just Europeans know like the rest of the world knows about that startup and that unicorn we are missing that regarding the institutions and everyone else I know a bunch of people who left uh Europe to work in us as a researchers as a scientists and so on so we are now practically creating a Europe as a place for Workforce that is going to be just moving to us which is

even worse so I think we have to Define okay if we're going to be the leading in AI what does that mean are we going to be leading in research or are we going to be leading in the number of company that are going to produce and create AI that is going to be used uh worldwide I think you want to yeah yes um yeah on that part it's a little bit sad because um there is actually in Europe again based on the prep work in member states but also in our highlevel expert group Etc PP a strong framework of ethical um guidelines for AI and so on where actually all different member states were able to agree on of course we have for example very different views on privacy in Germany very important in Spain if you make there um a poll not that many people would probably say it has at least the same um importance than in Germany but again on AI we were able to agree on those principles those principles

we were actually as Europeans also able to place and further develop in international organizations like the oecd um that was very um early there and leading worldwide the process but also so in UNESCO and so on the European approach was very successful and we were able to make it kind of a global global framework um and I think this we really should build on unfortunately the commission um again was not really good in after presenting the AI Act clarifying that for example those principles are now in the highrisk obligations for example on human oversight which is one principle or in data governance I actually three principles hidden um and this we criticized and also um our colleagues from other political groups in the process and we wanted actually to add another chapter in the AI Act to really write at the beginning this is the European way of AI now we don't have it it's hidden in the recital but I think this is something that now maybe the European Union and also um the

member states can maybe focus on to allow us to to better explain a story and to really Implement those uh principles that we have in technical standards in guidelines and so on because going back to your first question there I really believe um that it could create a Competitive Edge because then we have trustworthy AI that is WR in principle ABCDE EF but again so far the substance is not really there I know you want to say something but I want to give you a provocative statement that Germany is building the Workforce of the Silicon Valley uh over here to to see what what you think about that I mean I think it's it's quite simple people go there where they think it's most interesting and most leading and where they meet the most interesting people to work with and right now some of them might decide that that is elsewhere and not in Europe where to meet uh these kind of people that are working like cut on on The Cutting Edge technology uh

right now and therefore I think that is the main task for Europe to show no no we are here the best place of the world to uh develop AI in a way that is uh serving the society and I think that is um the point that we haven't reached yet um but I think there are examples where we have that in other areas um for example that San in G which is a very prominent place for physics everyone knows it people want to go there they are like eager to work with people there and use infrastructure or we have it with a European uh molecular biology laboratory the amble in heidleberg many of you might not know it because you're not in the field but like in their field they are like the top uh top place in the world that is known and where people want to come and actually Al an example both of them for European collaboration because um they are both um financed also by several European States not by the

European Union but by the collaboration of um more than one European State and I think these are examples that we need to see more also in the field of AI there we haven't really reached that we have like some places in Europe that are that well known that people are really so eager to come we have some of them I mean cyber Valley in Tübingen and hbor now a bit Munich so like there are some but we need to see more that really show they bring together the people that right now work on the news Technologies in Ai and I think that is something that Europe can do together and there are actually also initiatives that are trying to do this there's this Ellis initiative um in AI um but they haven't reached the level to be that well known worldwide for the young talents that we want to have here as a Communications expert to me it sounds like Europe has a PR problem so maybe we need to talk about how we can

it's not only more than positioning more in the world that we are actually this place but you wanted to uh respond something to this yeah yeah I have a lot of comments but it's getting interesting so it's fine um I think it's not about leaving to us or any other parts of the world uh because it's a bit more interesting it's not about that because Europe is definitely one of the best places to live I would say 95% of people that I talk to that move there they move because it's something happening in the US and I think something like that can be happening in Europe but we we can't I would say our focus is not to create one more Institute like Institute for biology or Institute for physics an Institute for AI it's not about science anymore like AI is the next like 30 years ago we had tickets the tickets were called internet based on those tickets people created multi-billion Empires and it's not just about science and it's not like scientists

just work there everybody worked there from business to marketing to scientists to engineers and politicians policy makers policy people and so on and something like that it can be created in Europe at least I hope so but if we're going to see AI just as a from the science perspective then we have again the same pattern that we had 30 years ago just to clarify that's not what I was advocating for I I wouldn't say that should be like Research Institute but it should be like a hub um and that is what I mentioned earlier with these startup factories like it it's a combination of both and when you look at the like big companies in the US they are actually both I mean most of the research in AI it's happening in private companies in the us but we don't have these kind of private companies yet that have such a huge uh budget for R&D so there is a public task in bringing the things together and um that's what I meant with

these examples like the examples I mentioned are a little bit more research based that's true but I think for AI it can be done that you um develop more these kind of hubs that have both the research perspective but also um the um startups new companies businesses that are coming from them it is though still quite startling why it's not working like in a breakthrough thing it seems like some money is there Talent is there the hunger is there so what is happening why is it not just um going ah is it that the regulation was missing and we were just waiting for that to tell us what to do so we don't have to be afraid like what like if we have everything then why is it not happening what what would you say well yeah maybe because of Regulation to sad um well your point definitely um so we again I work for a conservative parliamentarian um I'm very industry friendly and we were actually quite surprised that um a lot of companies

to us especially at the end um when we were also a bit afraid like the green said um the AI Act is shut down by certain member states um that many companies were telling us no please we need regulation and especially German ones because uh it was mentioned already um in in Germany there is just this being risk adverse is in our nature and therefore I think it's for many companies and CEOs really important to to have at least a general framework and then hopefully now there are really more and better steps yes you'll comment also sometimes there's maybe too much regulation it's what we see now in the European Union too many laws that are not really coherent that are interfering with each other overlapping with each other and so on but maybe back to your point and also to complement what was being said before um I think Investments is definitely one of the biggest problems that we see all the time also on AI and now my example would be the AI

Lighthouse it was going in the direction you said to build up another CERN another um yeah Hots spot of AI knowledge um in the European Union what happened the budget was €800,000 with a budget with 800,000 I know or you know much better than me it's of course not possible the second point was typical European Union especially now the last 10 years member states could not agree where this um Lighthouse is located uh France wanted to have it uh in France Germany in Germany and so on and so on and those things are then often leading to a situation that uh there is a good idea but nothing is really happening and again Investments are lacking and so on to be a little bit more positive and was also mentioned already I think um in Germany definitely there are are um public um initiatives there are private initiatives like in Munich like in B wenberg like here the the AI Hub and so on and so on this is already good and I think now

with the AI Act and we see it also in other pieces of EU legislation there's really this strong underlining factor of private partner private Public Partnerships regulatory sandboxes but also those digital Innovation hubs that are already there and I think this indeed would be a really nice way to maybe in the future partner up also address the money problem because then maybe if Bosch zons and other are joining forces like we see now in necos it's maybe really possible to achieve together better things and if the state and the data protection authorities for example in V wenberg are very Innovation friendly are from the beginning included and are kind of helping in the process then I would say we can maybe be much more positive in the future Martina do you want to you look like you want to say something at the same time I want to give you the question of you say you're hoping for it to be possible but what are you waiting for like I'm really positive I mean I'm

living waiting I'm living my dream I live in Europe and we have a company in us we are making money in us and we live here believe me we are we are fine I'm really positive so uh I'm fine uh but I really really believe that we can create Miracles here I really believe that we can have the mentality because we have the talent I think the money I don't I don't think we are uh having the right numbers here mentioned uh and I think Europe should start betting on something that's something that we didn't uh mention Europe should be brave enough to say okay this guy or this girl or this company is worth putting money in not 10 Millions it's not 50 million I'm talking about big money and I think Europe has to have their own Superstar like like uh us has its own China has its own Japan has its own we have to start believing that something will be great and risk it maybe we will lose eventually we will

win but I think that kind of um setup and mindset will help us a lot yeah I I mean the money question I think is very important because we there have just a different situation I mentioned like the budgets that they are working with in the US or in China be it private or state money it's it's just a different dimension and we won't change this like overnight that we uh have to be clear about H but I think we can see some Beginnings I mentioned some of the like public funds that are starting which we Tred with a future fund and we just like announced that we want to uh have 175 billion Euro also in these kind of new technology fields that we invest by different means um but also the private sector is has a role here and I think that is very important industry in Germany and maybe also other parts of Europe is sometimes a little bit hesitating in doing uh Brave Investments I'd say um because we there see

that there's a different tradition and also like um the Pension funds and other are hesit ating and going in these fields that is why we are talking right now from the government also um with Pension funds and others how we can change this that they would invest into venture capital and to like lift this uh budget problem a little to to make make it a little bit better um the beginnings that I see that are positive is of course the example that here I guess everyone knows with Alf Alpha which has um become investments from uh from bos and I think that is an example that is very good because we see its German industry investing into a German startup in that field in a I'd say relevant uh some um and uh that is what we need to see more and some of the um industry companies that are starting doing a little bit more but not all of them some are also backing um going back a little bit now when it's a

little bit more difficult situation so there is really a way to go and what we try is to just uh like make the um framework the best as we can to make it easy to invest and to like f to to push with public money and say okay when you invest we give 50% public money then we double the investment these are things that we are doing already um but we will need also the private sector it's not possible to just do it with public money we have to be very clear about that I think that's a good point to wrap this up uh as a as a conclusion ion of this I think we had some hopeful notes of that a lot of setup is already there lots of minds and ideas and potential and also the uh motivation to do it but there's also a way to go we have new things that can spur us on or hold us back I think we're going to see this summer starting this summer what

what it's going to bring but we also need other players that are maybe still hesitant to come into the mix so thank you all for your contributions for this very interesting Exchange and thank you all for your for listening and uh yes thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.