Rise of AI Conference 2019 · Berlin

Status Quo in Politics and Society, and Why AI Could Be the Game Changer

Mario Brandenburg · Member of German Bundestag

At Rise of AI 2019 in Berlin, Mario Brandenburg, a member of the German Bundestag, describes moving from the IT world into federal politics and finding himself acting as a translator between people in tech, ordinary citizens, and career politicians who, in his view, do not understand technology. He argues that digital politics differs fundamentally from classical industry politics: a state could once simply refuse to build a bridge or road, but it cannot stop technologies like Airbnb or Uber once people demand them, which makes speed the only currency that matters. He proposes three areas for speeding up Germany's AI adoption: building an ecosystem (English as a second administrative language, keeping the country decentralized), unlocking finance (state capital and pension reserves invested in founders rather than bonds, connecting startups, established firms and wealthy family offices), and political commitment (loosening restrictive data rules and telling a positive, visionary story about technology). He closes urging the mostly non-political audience to get politically active.

Key takeaways

  • Brandenburg argues that unlike classical industry politics, digital politics cannot simply block technologies like Airbnb or Uber once people demand them, making speed decisive.
  • He proposes English as a second administrative language in Germany to attract skilled workers without years of bureaucratic language requirements.
  • He describes three disconnected groups: startups with ideas but no cash, established firms with orders but no clarity, and family offices with idle capital.
  • He cites EU data protection rules blocking him from receiving a 23andMe health report as an example of over-applied regulation limiting technology use.
  • He notes that not even 1% of people in Germany are politically active and calls on the audience to get involved rather than just complain.

Detailed notes

A translator between the tech world and politics

Brandenburg describes moving from the IT world into federal politics in Berlin and living outside the capital, in Rheinland-Pfalz, which he says puts him between three worlds: ordinary people who do not follow Silicon Valley disruption talk, Berlin tech and political circles, and classical politicians who, in his experience, do not understand technology. He says this gap is not because politicians resist better regulation, but because digital topics are simply not their normal daily business, and he has positioned himself as a translator between these groups.

Why digital politics needs speed

Brandenburg argues that digital politics differs from classical industry politics: in the past, the state could prevent things it did not want, such as a bridge or a road, simply by not building them. It cannot stop technologies like Airbnb or Uber once people demand them, regardless of political preference. He says this makes speed, not traditional political caution, the only currency that matters, and that speed is neither a typical political nor a typical German attribute, which he says explains why some political decisions look slow even to him as a sitting member of parliament.

Three levers: ecosystem, finance and commitment

Brandenburg groups his proposals for speeding up AI adoption into three areas. On ecosystem, he calls for English as a second administrative language so skilled workers do not need years to learn German bureaucracy, and for keeping Germany decentralized rather than concentrating talent in one city like Berlin. On finance, he argues the state holds large capital reserves that could be invested in founders instead of concrete and state bonds, as some other countries already do with pension funds, and describes three disconnected groups in Germany: startups with ideas but no cash, established mid-sized companies ('Mittelstand') with full order books but uncertainty about the future, and wealthy family offices holding capital that does not return much from a bank; he sees a state role in connecting them. On commitment, he argues Germany over-applies data protection as a blocker, citing that EU rules prevent him from receiving a genetic health report from a company like 23andMe even though he consents to using the service, and that a company like 23andMe could not have been founded in Germany under such rules.

A call for political vision and engagement

Brandenburg argues politicians should be more visionary, offering the example of brain uploading as the kind of positive future story politics should be willing to tell, rather than leaving people to adopt an imported American vision of the future or default to a dystopian one. He notes that since joining the Bundestag's AI committee, ordinary conversations, even with his own mother and while picking up his kids, now regularly turn to AI, which he reads as a sign of real public momentum. He closes by noting that not even 1% of people in Germany are politically active, and urges the audience to join a party or movement and articulate their views rather than only voice frustration with political outcomes afterward.

Quotes

The only valid patterns and the only valid currency is speed.

Mario Brandenburg

We have startups with ideas but without cash, we have the middle stand with full order books but they don't know the future, and we still have family offices with lots of money.

Mario Brandenburg

Questions answered in this talk

Why does Mario Brandenburg say digital politics differs from classical industry politics?

According to Mario Brandenburg at Rise of AI 2019, in classical industry politics a state could simply refuse to build something it did not want, like a bridge or road, but it cannot stop technologies such as Airbnb or Uber once people demand them, making speed the deciding factor.

What does Mario Brandenburg propose to speed up AI adoption in Germany?

According to Mario Brandenburg at Rise of AI 2019, he proposes English as a second administrative language, keeping Germany decentralized, directing state and pension capital toward founders instead of bonds, connecting startups, established firms and family offices, and loosening data rules that over-block technology use.

Why couldn't a company like 23andMe be founded in Germany, according to Mario Brandenburg?

According to Mario Brandenburg at Rise of AI 2019, EU data protection rules would prevent a company from legally sending back a personal health report based on genetic data, even to a consenting user, which he says would have blocked a service like 23andMe from starting in Germany.

Mentioned

English as second administrative language, data protection regulation, brain-computer interface, political participation

Keep exploring

More from Mario Brandenburg

More from Rise of AI Conference 2019

More on Policy & Regulation

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 1,915 words

Show the full transcript

hello hi yes thanks for giving me the chance to talk ten minutes basically about my findings in the new political world about AI at the political system and basically the way how Germany can be or hopefully can find its way in the race so basically when you change from the let's say the IT world in the political world it somehow feels really like changing worlds and I'm as well not living in Berlin's or not like a Berlin Mitte guy not an urban hipster so I prefer to live in rheinland-pfalz at the German wine street so more the relaxed region and so it's really like three worlds so back home people work in supermarkets bakeries whatever so they don't get the Silicon Valley turtleneck disruption stuff so but they also don't get Berlin in politics and ice-t-- moved into Berlin politics becoming a federal politician and I found out that basically they don't understand tech so all these worlds are somehow drifting apart and I found myself to more or less be the translator in that

world because if we really want to be successful in general and we somehow didn't really really were to successful in digitalization and we wanted to be in the next wave with AI we should better put these worlds together and to make it basically visual why some political discussions or some political loss might not make sense to us it depends whom they have in mind so we are definitely the digital natives or at least the digital immigrants and there are the others so the stuff we discuss might not be the stuff which classical politicians might have in mind so this doesn't mean that they don't want to do better regulation it's just not normal to them or it's just not their daily business and if you do classic or you did classical industry politics all your life my finding is it's a difference to doing digital politics because before politicians or a state could avoid things to happen if they don't want a bridge to be built it's not going to happen if they don't want

a road there it's not going to happen you can hate Airbnb and uber as much as you want it's going to happen because the people demand them the people want to have them and that's a big change in the game so and if we are honest in Germany we love patterns and we love all that stuff the only valid patterns and the only valid currency is speed so that's the only thing rich really really saves you to be honest at the moment and speed is unfortunately not a classical political attribute and sometimes as well not a German attribute and this is why we are somehow on a new playground and this is why some decisions and some discussions look cumbersome even to me now being a part in that area and I just want to change I just want to tell you some things which icing would give us a chance to speed up and in the end I'm more or less fighting for it in Parliament and basically trying to find people to join

so I think if we really really want to speed up and you can put it in three groups that's basically the surroundings or the ecosystem we have to talk about finance and we have to talk about commitment so first thing I think we need English as a second administrative language so if you are bad as data scientists studied in Stanford there's the war for talent the whole world wants to have you why would you start to learn German another three years just to be able to fill in your text form at the end of the year so this is absolutely not what you wanted to do but it has to be possible to live everywhere in Germany and we are in Berlin obviously we do this in English that's fine super I like it I don't live in Berlin but I want to have the data as scientists or whatever to live in line and files as well and we were always strong as a country because we were T centralized so if we would

be a central country like France all the problems basically would come with it so I hope where I fight for it that we can keep somehow our decentralization and get the smart people also to whatever English that works for you name it where our hotspots are the next thing the finance part so we all know that there is not enough capital in the market and the state still sits on tons of capital so why is it not possible to invest basically in the next generation or into the brains of our founders instead of concrete and state bonds so there are other countries who are a bit more brave basically taking whatever pension reserves or pension plans to spend it at least to a certain amount into basically the next generations to help them and this is also a sign if the state does that it might make sense and the lower left side true story my mom was reading newspapers and stuff about AI and she asked me Mario f5k how can I invest in

AI so fair question whatever build your own crypto for go ahead mom so that's why is it not possible to do that stuff people are interested in it so why does the state stone give any tax credits or whatever to do that sort of investment instead of whatever he's studying you could futuring or something so we have to be more brave to make it normal for the people to invest and one of the speeches at the moment one guy said somebody has to start the wheel and this is true so the money is there unfortunately but we even have more than money we have three silos we have startups with ideas but without cash we have the middle stand with full order books but they don't know the future and we still have family offices like the Kwan's and the Schwartz with lots of money we don't get money on a bank how wonderful would the world be if these three would interact and that's in my opinion a task of the state to at

least facilitate that so I'm liberal I don't think that the state can do anything better than basically normal people can do but at least it's a job to facilitate that and this brings me to the last part which is commitment so right to use technology it's not meant like in a written law but we have to be more ambitious who of you knows 23andme at the company for example so some of you do basically I can send them my genome so they read my genome and they sent me back my ancestry report and a health report but I'm in Germany I wouldn't get the health report because the European Union actually even protects me so this doesn't make any sense if I'm aware what I want to do if I want to use a technology why it does somebody over protect me and now I'm only basically a user who is annoyed but you could never have started 23andme over here if you're not legally allowed to give back a product so and this is

true for many more things when it comes to data and for many more things we will see in the scope of AI and neural networks deep learning so if we are dead scared and if you only bring data protection up as a blocker it's not going to work and I'm not saying that it's not important to do it but we should not use it as an excuse and politics in general could be more brave and being brave it's not enough it should be visionary as well so I just put it the example of a brain upload because I really really like that idea and we are not that far but politics should give a positive utopia so if we don't do it then we read a copy of utopia from somebody else but it might not be ours the American utopia might be different or we might end up in a dystopia and talking with other brain upload why not how cool would it be sitting there Sunday on a couch there in coffee and

downloading the brain of Barack Obama and reliving his life it's probably better than going to museum staring at the muck which he might have used on a Thursday morning and try to imagine how it would be so and these are things I think politicians should be willing to tell just to tell people there's more and just as an appetizer not that is there but if you believe in such a story and you have to chance to invest in brain computer interfaces for example you might do it if you think about the sidewalk stuff you might not do it and these are the stories politicians should start to tell and should basically start to listen because I really think something is different right now with AI true life example I studied computer science for quite a while I love the lifestyle of a student traveled around so I didn't really have somehow rush or hurry and my mom actually never asked me like how is your java class or how was your whatever with algorithms since

I'm in the Committee for AI every time I pick up my kids I have to talk about AI because she wants to talk people want to talk obviously you're sitting here listening to a politician before I was sitting there listening to you this makes a difference that's not normal so basically that's the momentum where people want to join so and coming back to the guy this morning somebody has to start the wheel and I think there's really really a big momentum for us as politicians to do it and as well for industry if we all tell the stories quite often and let's light basically I know that political decisions are somehow not easy to understand but I basically just want to hold a little mirror in front of you not even 1% in Germany is politically active so if you work in HR you know how big the talent pool is in that case so if only 1% does the decisions for all of us and next time you're basically angry at a decision or

at a statement former politicians then sign up for a party a movement whatever but articulate yourself so it doesn't work out if 99 percent just say that's not how it works and I will at a different way so think about maybe joining that system I never intended to be a federal politician now I'm standing here I had 10 minutes to talk to you 10 seconds left and perfect in time so thanks for listening happy to join the discussion afterwards if you want to send me a message a tweet whatever I'm in any social network you can have I'm the monkey unfortunately from this speech before thanks for listening that's it

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.