and now we have the panel the first panel coming up there will be also a second panel but now this panel will be about can ai heal the world and it's a close in closely interlinked topic of course um when tanya is has an injury obviously so can we help thanks all right well tanya will introduce her panel guests herself and after the panel there will be the lunch break so let's enjoy our first panel is it on yes um i'm tanya and i'm a futurist um as a futurist you need to be have the worst perspectives on the world and i try this best to also work in really diverse areas so i'm the vice chair of the association of professional futurists i really want to bring future thinking into the world and believe organizations people and politics will be better by applying future thinking also we created a company called futures to all where we believe that organization needs to take on responsibilities in shaping desirable futures then we have a future space
community where we believe individuals can best work together in bringing their images of the future and exchange in order to create better futures and last time or last thing is that i do also consult the eu commission on how can we bring future thinking into policy and iron i and get knowledge from researchers all over the world together when i say i'm a futurist though many people believe that we bring the crystal ball and tell you how the future will come be but it's actually in the opposite end my skill is to facilitate conversations of the future and enable people to think about the risks but also the chances and opportunities in creating desirable futures so i'm very happy to be here today and to lead the panel on this ai solve the world one second and with me we have three amazing people who will bring different perspectives from politics entrepreneurship and foundation so on my left i welcome mario brandenburg he is the parliamentary state secretary for the federal ministry of education and
research and also the spokesman of the committee digital agenda on the study commission of artificial artificial intelligence then in the middle we have daria sohara founding partner of the world fund backing entrepreneurs building climate tech for a regeneration world and she's also a co-founder of one e9 a digital think tank for futures optimists and techies on on the very right hand side here it's janet widget the cfo of build a scale they build and scale ai first companies through incubation and financing co-founding to co-founding organizations she's also working with ea campus berlin where she's the co-founder not for for not-for-profit space for research and collaboration of over 60 ai projects so i want to start this panel today since we heard now a lot about the risks of it what are some chances of ai and what are some especially biggest positive impacts that ai could be and are there some projects out there where these panelists are also working on to see this positive impact so i start to my left with mario where
did you see the positive impacts of ii and der great and so hello everybody first of all um i guess there are many positive aspects and i basically like the running order that we just listened is ai evil in 10 minutes later it should just fix the world so basically it already shows what we expect from ai so therefore the positive things the positive objects we will see will still be in pattern recognition optimization when it comes to climate change and being the political guy on stage um doing basically database decisions not letting the machine decide as karla explained it but really focus on data which basically in my daily political life i would say is still rare to have it like real database and have a real view on the things and therefore i think it can really give us some some clarity and a view on many things to just make better decisions so it's not really like whatever gpd3 or framework so it will be the full thing in using ai in
a supply chain or in the supply chain of decision making thank you daria what's your perspective on this well you know the title of our panel today is if i can save the world well the answer is definitely no um but it does you know it is one of the core technologies and to address the climate change so i'm a founder of world fund we are the biggest european climate tech we see so we invest as you said in transformative technologies in ai is definitely one of them and i want to point out maybe you know kind of three biggest areas where ai has a very positive or could be have a very positive impact and all these three areas are the biggest emitting industries in terms of co2 and that's fallow first so food and agriculture and land use and just um kind of to point out one example for example one example for example it's also a great start is a kind of a range of um companies satellite companies today who use
satellite data and reach it with a kind of infrared data for example and use a kind of a layer ai to be able to a um you know analyze and optimize the agriculture for example to be able to prevent crop diseases uh several pathogens coming up so kind of we were safe on that part but also wildfires which is one of the biggest issues given the climate temperature rise and there is a company called aurora tech from munich so i'm also from munich i'm going to promote munich a lot today being in berlin on the stage so aurora tech a fantastic company so to do exactly the same and then of course if we talk about you know a human so save you know save the planet is also saving us we talked about it today yesterday you know we it kind of we eat so much crap like and this crap is killing us but every single one of us in a different way right so ai can actually tell us and and learn
us how to you know how to optimize our own nutrition um in a way so i'm i'm wearing this thing i think there are some of you who know that so i'm trying to for example um so with that i'm trying with the sensor i'm trying to monitor my glucose levels but then you know to have some someone to run a level say like okay and so what then then i learned and then to optimize that for me i think that's very powerful and that cannot be happening today and maybe because i'm talking already so long just the second part is like build environment we can use the eye to actually create new designs new materials like cement cement is responsible for almost eight percent of co2 emissions worldwide could be a politician actually i'm working on it thank you so much and you janet you're working to scale ai companies and also to foster their collaboration and we heard earlier in the talks that collaborations will be one of the key things in order
to create better ai and make it happen so how do you see this positive impact exactly yeah also a very warm welcome from from my end and also a great job fabian and veronica putting it all together thank you so much for having me here um it's really nice i think before i um say something about the collaboration point i was very inspired when far beyond told me about the the panel that is called can i heal the world because in the end we work with ai on a daily basis and the reason why we have opened or where we started an ai ventures to deal with mirantix is because we believe that ai is a general purpose technology and it actually can have a very very positive impact on the world and cancels and many different challenges but where i then want to come to the collaboration point is it's not ai alone that can shape challenges and by that i mean yes and there's other factors that we need to save the world
but most importantly when we're narrowing it down to ai and the ai space the algorithms itself they will not heal anything and we need processes we need products that are ni enabled because in the end the user will not use the product because it's an ai product the user will use the product because it solves a problem or a topic or a task he or she wants to be doing and i think that's an actual challenge we have to solve it's a big one because also internet itself doesn't help or doesn't bring us anything and we have to actually work in order to collaborate uh with different stakeholder groups with different um people that work on ai its researchers its corporate partners who know all of their processes products in and out it's a talent it's the startups who can then really think of novel things to really put together all the different factors um to make sure that we do not only create ai but actually uh make sure that there is products and
processes ai enabled that then um solve um these these actual um challenges not only um in incremental but then actually in a disruptive way and that can only be done um by collaboration that's um a continuous um question and also approach that we face um and have chosen admirations and also at the ai campus is that you have to work together with everyone in germany in berlin and europe and a very diverse group in order to make this happen and this is also why we believe in in conferences like this uh where i don't want to only see startups but i want to see people from from from from policymaking i want to see people and from from from corporates and all from different fields and then also bring them together on spaces like that the one we have on the ai campus thank you so much uh besides collaboration we also heard that we need more curiosity versus the security uh daria are you working with a lot of entrepreneurs and trying um to
fix and come up with some climate change technologies in order to solve that so how do you see those entrepreneurs working and and fostering their curiosity in comparison to the security they're taking on while developing that's not new technologies that's a good question i think an entrepreneur posse is a curious person um and is driven to you know kind of solve the problem uh he him or her um has in mind um not trying to be politically correct now but i don't think that you know if you if you are a founder in whatever in whatever space in germany you have to be ready to break some security rules mario you're you're in the department yeah and working with education and research so what do you see what kind of ecosystem or what we see in the education or others what do we need to enforce do more entrepreneurship maybe social entrepreneurship from that perspective so i guess i i didn't hear the last sentence there was like a noise something like um no just
i mean there's probably some some truth to it but but um to answer your question um the curiosity you mentioned um is something which is probably not a kpi in the political system to be honest and therefore it sometimes feels for entrepreneurs or people who want to change something that this is not really welcomed so um seeing it now i mean i moved into politics now it's five years ago so i i was a tech person believe me i had a life so but now i'm on the other side and and i can basically feel how hard it is to teach and explain that system that there is a value in trying not only in in regulating and bringing something really like in into order but just in letting it happen so this curiosity or just playing for the sake of playing it's important and this is something we somehow have to make possible in germany this is i guess why all these agencies pop up why regulatory sandboxes pop up so these are all
some satellite concepts orbiting around the very stiff regulatory framework because if you can prove that something works you somehow take the you know how should i say the frightening of the people or the regulators in the end that this is okay and and the last sentence to social entrepreneurship and this is why we have zara boone in the in the bmf now as the outfit social entrepreneurship very sexy and catchy title um but that's how it is probably and and she really should make sure um that we are running offers or programs or whatever that this really doesn't fall off the table because normally they are really seen by classical measures like mostly monetary measures or patents or something but really letting stuff happen to come back to that with a good social benefit um then it's just okay to let it be and i guess there is some way to go um in that system to change that thank you janet when you're scaling or looking for companies and startups of that you fund
what are specific applications that you look at where do you see is ai best used for for positive impact i think ai has the potential to have a positive impact and disrupt basically any kind of industry of course admiratix we see it as our job and mission to really solve the biggest challenges that are out there and i think it's then definitely when we come to healthcare we i can have a big impact and one of our portfolio companies they are called avara they're actually active in in breast cancer screening where we are not only tapping into the german market but are also now expanding to latin america and other emerging markets to really make sure that every single woman has access to breast cancer screening and and therefore we can actually detect brands brands breast cancer much earlier and therefore um there is hopefully um not as many uh women that are sadly dying of of that cancer every year um but also um of course on the biotech and um dario honestly mentioned
it before in regards to new materials uh we see now um to what extent we're actually dependent still on on petrochemical materials and and the potential in regards to biomaterials is so big and and that's combined with um computational um technologies that will actually allow us um to for example come up with entirely new biomaterials and in that regard we have our petroleum company called cambrian and they are engineering proteins um so that we can actually um replace um those materials from the slaughterhouse from all those petrochemicals to to basically yeah bring us forward and and create materials that are not only sustainable but and that are performing better and in the end are ideally even more cost efficient thank you we also heard earlier that ai and energy are highly interconnected meaning of course with more and more ai we actually also use more energy streaming is a great opportunity for people for less traveling but we also know that all the video streaming services on social platforms also increase highly the energy consumptions
so my question and this is open for anyone who wants to answer is how do we take on those challenges that come up with using more and more ai technology and maybe replacing human power where human energy might be less and variety friendly politics first oh that's nice um so to be brutally honest i guess this is um a part of the whole serenity discussion so um like there's a topic every year and at the moment everything is about whatever sort of digital or security or whatever serenity and to be honest we are seeing that we are trying to get rid of russian oil but now we are addicted to chinese solar panels so um i'm not sure if this we have to do it so i'm fully behind all these decisions but we have to see it on a long scale and so for sure we celebrate ai we all want ai it comes with energy consumption if this is green energy and we are not getting new let's say problematic friends so far
i think that's that's not the problem but this really is something um the politics has to answer at least from a direction and society then um has to follow or has to say no that's not our way so i wouldn't i wouldn't make it that small just talking about ai that's really a general thing if we want to have all that stuff we really should think about like what is the price to do that um and therefore i guess right now it will need more energy it's good that it's not good but that's the price we pay for understanding more of what we do you like new materials like curing cancer we all want to have that stuff so therefore that's probably well spent energy sorry to the planet at that point but there needs to be a strategy that this stops you know we cannot go on further and this to be honest at least from my perspective we didn't answer it and probably no country on the world really answered how this should
go on if i can add to that i think uh just like as a stat maybe interesting number that um the data centers or the infrastructure including ai in germany has a higher co2 emission number per year then the whole of the flights so we always talk about the aviation but there are like also different different kinds of uh co2 emitters so i think one of this i agree with you um but then kind of i have to i'm trying to be a politician now too but there is also another solution as a midterm maybe long term is quantum right which is more high performance less energy not less energy saving more energy saving kind of enabling completely different use cases and to be run and at a higher efficiency as well maybe just to add here i i think it it's very important to have that conversation on energy consumption also uh it's about continuously optimizing the hardware that is it is used and but in the end it should not prevent us from
doing something because if if i'm a company and i want to deploy some rather like elementary models i can do it on the cloud and yes that also uses energy consumption somewhere and in the in in the centers of google a lot of amazon but that is a start and and there are still so many companies out there that don't do anything that have hardware that is also producing or actually consuming a lot of energy but has nothing to do with ai at all just because the hardware is outdated and and the software they're using is not existing and so it's an important discussion to have but let's paralyze things let's start doing something and figure those very important things out along the way by actually learning even more things by by doing multiple things at the same time and just to to at a last note this is why we need a working regulatory framework on a european basis so um for i mean it's easier to host data centers somewhere in sweden or
in the nordics where basically they're just different sources of energy than in germany so um for sure even like we as our federal data centers we try to somehow make them as efficient as possible and some stuff really needs to be hosted here that might be the truth for really some core processes but in general if we would have a working european regulatory framework plus single market um then that's basically the size to work in so as even if i'm not a federal politician here that there's probably nothing germany will fix alone thank you before we further think about how ai can solve a world problems and save the world we also want to think a bit of the opposite as futurists we never talk about the future there's always futures in multiples so we explore everything from the very bad to the best and in between and then also encourage organizations politicians and individuals to take on their preferred future so i want to start with actually question that is way easier to answer
because we get so many images of hollywood of movies and even the news and it is how does ai ruin the world how does it may destroy and i want to give a few examples which is already mentioned earlier for example how do we prevent or what happens if we put our biases into ai because everyone human has biases and the program will put it in but there's also another example with ai and kids for example growing up and listen to smart speakers who have female voices and they give very rude commands to that and to other things so what is really some of the ethics and what happens if this gets out of control so my questions for all of you and we um we start with janet on the side how does ai could ruin the world so what could go wrong i think there's always a lot of things that can go wrong with everything we do and sometimes it takes people to to do mistakes so we we can do better
i think in order to prevent things going wrong going south it's really us all having responsibility in in that regard because um it it it refers to us all and i think in that respect information and and education is very important because you took the example also of those those videos of science fiction videos i mean they're fun to watch that um but they should not make people scared we should have respect i think that's okay but in the end ai is something that everyone should understand to to a certain extent and so that he or she can actually use it for for its purposes and for the good daria how do you see the threats well i think a technology posse is neutral right it's what you do with the technology and it's about the eye or quantum or you know or rockets or whatever it's always the same question that there is always two sides of that so i think the question is rather you know how do we put a framework of
control mechanisms incentives um to put and to kind of have at least rules how to and then i'm back to rules yes the rules are good to kind of to be able to manage that right so um for me it's rather you know it's a question of free regulatory but also in a way that it gives you the flexibility to actually invent and and innovate right um and then and then that's one and then i think the second thing is like what you said that's hollywood movies and stories it's also a lot about the narrative of technology and one of the reasons again where i co-founded the 109 think tank is just because we really truly believe that we'll like as a society not people here but like generally we don't like we lost the vision of wherever we are going right so and then and and i think it's also a role of the politics kind of to create a more positive narrative around where we're going to go and and how technology also
has a positive impact in general um and it applies for as well so first of all i like your intro to say we as futurists never talk about the future we talk about futures and we as regulators never talk about regulation we talk about regulations so i should probably just take that one for further penalties and no but jokes aside um i'm fully on the side that it comes up to what we take out of it for sure there is bias in the data but thank god now we know there's bias and we have proof so it's like shooting the messenger and it's just a mirror so we can be angry at the mirror but we did this obviously the internet was white and halfway racist so thanks to ai that it just showed it to us so i can yell at the result or i can be thankful for the way and it's the same with like the little speakers so my daughter is using them for sure all the time um so actually
she really understands it's a computer so it's not male or women or whatever but when i when i see how these things place where music explains stuff even sometimes she doesn't understand it because wikipedia answers obviously not only for six-year-old people but in the end if i see how i had to back my grandma to buy me a new benjamin bloomfield cassette or whatever and and how information for her is so easy to get maybe as well sometimes the wrong information but in general it's information so if i look at a pure result she has more chances she has more opportunities yes for sure with more danger but still it's more and therefore i guess it's really what you get out of it and i tried to create more positive visions as a politician as basically i just received the task i mean janet mentioned that we organizations need to take on more responsibilities but unfortunately also the past have shown once technology is introduced it is also sometimes misused and it's just off the
list uh leash we saw that with the internet and other things so the question is if is is ai controllable some companies already noticed that they created their own language once they kind of like co-created on that so how do we get companies how do we get humanity to taking on this responsibility and prevent that someone just goes mad with it yeah i mean as a youth daria said it's a lot about frameworks and and you can write that down and i think that's in the regulatory that that's very important because it basically makes us um have one one set of common values but we also have to need we need we need values in every kind of relationship in every kind of company or just like um setup so that um those those things that are actually written down are left and that we're guided by them but they should not only prevent us from using something but motivate us to use something in the right way and to actually uh not like break
us down but but but um just basically show us the path where certain things can can can lead us towards i'd like to contradict myself now i think we can control everything period we can't control you know the human nature we can't control technology at 100 because technology is built and controlled by human nature and i think it's a good thing because someone else will come and break the rules and and kind of and develop a new paradigm and maybe that's a good thing right so um my answer to your question will like we can't make sure it's not possible to make sure that we control everything so i mean therefore we build all these regulatory frameworks as kala referred or the eu does it with security levels or germany or whatever this is i guess the box we are in but ultimately so if you think that society is good then i think the main usage we will see is good it's like with all the other technologies so bad stuff came out but
in the end the good stuff won like gps i mean it was basically done in a military scope to kill somebody now you order pizza and the person shows up thanks to gps so the good case one so it's really like are you under on the on the optimistic or the pessimistic side but saying this is a politician i know it's not enough to be on the optimistic side this is why for sure there have to be regulatory frameworks and there is a difference if we talk about the genome or whatever chatbot um but still picking up your case about tao or the bot who went crazy the good thing is we don't have a general artificial intelligence as of now so we give the freedom this thing is stupid it behaves like we know the problem so and then we can fix it as long as it's not super smart and tries to fool us into something we still have to be thankful for that as oddly as it sounds but most of the
time even the companies came up with the data set and gave it for free to all the researchers and for for sure algorithm watch was mentioned they do a great job so at the moment we we find out what can go wrong so as long as the thing is not in the hollywood stage of doing stuff by itself taking over the internet and avoiding us to switch it off and personally talking to siri 10 minutes per day we are far off that she's controlling the world so basically we can still try to play around like looking at lots of scientists sitting there to play around and find out what could go wrong that people like myself then basically can build a box to operate somehow can i i really like what you said um because the gen there is no general eye yet right and then a lot of narrative coming from the media is like it's already been done and like the robots are out there waiting for us to kill us and then
it's all possible but i think like what we talked before the panel right maybe you can pick up on that like where do we actually stand today and what yeah i can do and and that we spend a lot of time and energy thinking like how to save ourselves from like the evil of the eye um and and maybe the energy is better channeled uh developing the solutions first right yeah i mean we discussed about uh this this famous gap uh because and there is these uh very um ambitious minds out there who want to change something and we have these great visions um to actually use the technology for good and then there is of course many consumer clients but also companies who are 10 20 years back and i think i sometimes find it difficult to discuss challenges when we're like 30 years apart how is that possible and and also it's very hard to then come up with joint solutions and when we hardly do anything to actually close that gap and
and to work together to find the closer together and then um collectively work on solutions that then bring us towards the future yeah so the problem with this dystopian future so that we saw so whenever we see how ai destroys the world it may also leads to that we see in the present more and more information or hints that actually show the fears and the evil so i also want to turn this around acknowledging as mentioned before they're not only good and bad futures there's not autopia and dystopia the many futures in between but i like always to challenge to say how would a preferred future that may balance those threats will look like because by that we have the chance in the presence to see what i call the pockets of hope and to enfoster those so and foster the good examples and not only look towards the threats that then may come true because we're focusing too much on it um so madaria what would you say if you look 10 to 20
years into the future and by a chance love to go further so it seems more possible how does a perfect world look like in balance with ai where is it used for and how does humanity support it an easy one why do i start now as i said things first it's easier to destroy the world than to save it but no no sure so you know kind of at world fund we and whatever we do we we do in order to enable like you know the regenerative world in the future so 10 to 20 years from now we um we hope that we still have the world in a way and i think it's not like um and i think it's i i i actively decide every day to stay positive that it's still possible that we use ai or quantum you know fusion technologies and in order to prevent the biggest catastrophe and as like the three areas what i said are probably the biggest kind of in that or even five areas is
like it's follow uh food and ag tech um land use it's energy it's built environment in general it's it's manufacturing and transportation so in in all of these industries we already today have various pieces like already today there are a high use case is happening um and i truly hope that we as a ecosystem where not only the politic there is no silver bullet right so it's it's the politics it's the startups it's it's the research it's uh it's corporates it's real it's all of us that we enable the work europe to be investing more capital to develop transformative tech and build right use cases around that um yeah so in order to look at preferred futures i always ask organizations to look at what are the future challenges that um yeah we may and they might tackle with their skills and that so how can ai then solve one of the the future problems that we have mario should i talk for companies now no i said in general organizations but it can be
the same what might be the the level of support from governments that are needed that organizations can and foster that and so maybe to pick a bit up on the ideal world and and then to blend the answers so over simplified in an ideal world um in 10 years ai would be something like a fridge everybody has it nobody knows how it works and why it's cold in there but there's lots of trust that this thing is good and nothing happens so if we as a government could come up to that level that it's just happening so you can choose where you want it to happen but there is enough trust that you believe nothing is wrong here that would probably the the top line we could achieve so how do we go there within 10 years okay i have to leave now i should start working um how do we go there and then surely it comes back it started with trust and it will entry trust so from a government perspective um it's
the regulatory framework from a research and corporate side it really is the ethics boards and and really living up to that but to be honest as well here to be a bit of the party crusher we as well need products so only with ethic sports we might not really succeed and this is a bit of the problem i see so with all the the good intentions of all the levels of danger so if i'm in a startup and i just have to decide which of the 10 levels of danger i am and the other ones just upload the face sap app and all the kids are doing whatever funny haircuts and we have 10 million new profiles in some chinese ai research lab so that's probably not how it's going to work so we all need to find a way to still be fast enough and give enough freedom but still to be able to give enough trust so right now i'm in the role of the ones who have to give the trust so
they are even for an fdp guy it hurts me but yes there will have to be regulation for sure but still the outcome just cannot be that we remain too slow because we only will succeed with our ethical value if our usp is not we are the most ethical ones we have to have products who prove that we are the most ethical ones and this is a bit of an imbalance at the moment janet how's your preferred world look like with ai looks nice um i think um it's two parts i think when it comes to us having big visions we should look 10 years ahead and be super ambitious our founder always talks in moonshots and i definitely support him um there but the doing needs to be happened right now i can talk about the future i can i can have long talks where i want to be but we actually have to do something today and not only us in the room um but but but everyone and and that starts not
only by building companies and that then goes over to educating and every single person because apart from the sustainability aspect and that we touched upon before we also have another challenge is that our people are getting older and older there is a decrease in in the labor force and therefore we need more automation but we also have to get better in things because i mean we have to be honest uh which is in in some parts human beings are just not good in and then we can actually improve that and and combining that all together and make sure that um today we do a lot of things and that will hopefully then also have a positive impact in the future thank you we have a few minutes left so i also want to invite the audience to ask as a question for the panelists or maybe do a statement of how ai serves the world i just need someone to pick the microphone because i would love to fly but i cannot even walk and
then you may just hand it further to the next one thank you okay so yeah my name is christian goodman um i will also be speaking at 4pm on the nordic air ecosystem and i'm particularly interested in how we tackle this as europeans you mentioned it before there are certain advantages for example in the nordic countries it's colder so there's for example big data centers that are built there now because you can save energy there's north world a big battery company got a couple of billion dollars investment and so on but i'm also a little bit split you know as we become uh as we give certain parts of europe and the world a certain dominance you know it's not always better like uh i don't know the best example i could come up with is tomatoes right if they are all made in certain countries in spain and so on they're actually not always high level quality i'm a bit of a food nerd uh following a bit of fabian's views earlier but you
know like i'm a bit split about this way of working together i think we need to and i think that makes us stronger but it also you have these long-term effects you know what is uh the best way of finding the the balance between this european approach so i just wonder if you could elaborate a little bit on that topic if that makes sense so um absolutely it's to be honest for sure it's it's not easy as you said um i brought up the the example with as you said power supply and all that stuff which might be better there um we all talk about sharing data and healthcare data i'm not sure there are countries like a bit of east difficult government not sure if i really want to have my health record or whatever data's there so for sure it's a give and take but in the end i guess it's still possible or there's one difference to maybe the tomato example what we are mainly talking here is data so and it's
relatively easy to do it decentralized and still somehow in control i mean with tomatoes if you you know if they are in the market they're in the market but for some stuff to really collaborate and for some stuff maybe don't so if i would be somebody from estonia i wouldn't probably wait for the german eid to go online to then join us i would just use my working eid since the last 20 years so this might maybe not be the case but for different stuff manufacturing whatever they will and that's again picking up on on the hype topic of serenity serenity cannot be that every country does everything on its own so it never was like that but really to see where to collaborate with unfortunately we'd now talk about collaborating in military which obviously makes sense and it might if it comes to research and curing cancer i guess probably everybody would give the data if it really comes to the healthcare system and really getting treatment i guess people would be more defensive
because like if you're from the nordics you would probably join the spanish system for um so long answer because there will not be one easy thing to take but the advantage i really deeply believe in this we are talking data and this is manageable decentral and still with some control and audit locks and you even can basically stop um corporations or whatever really easy to go on sharing data and that stuff so that's my hope and that's at least how i try to tackle it but there still remain problems so some countries be more open about genetic engineering for example others don't so you might not like it i'm personally a fan of it so um that we can take about the tomato discussion than offline can i add just a quick thing because we only we talk about europe we always try to kind of create a home again homogenous kind of environment which we are not will never be and also the data shows it's confirmed that actually the environment uh within like
different countries have different level of innovation degree and it is that can be kind of led back to the environment and the call like the colder the country the the higher the innovation because you had to like that just that that's a fact right because you had to start building houses and you had to you know understand the agriculture better and that you're so it will never be different in germany or it's never going to be like in sweden and it's also not going to be like in spain but i think the good thing is a data i totally agree but also we have all this strength i think we should kind of define that and understand it embrace that and see how we can learn from each other never seen that happening but maybe that is something in future to kind of strive for and say like look why is this country a or this region strong here and is it applicable to others maybe not and why not and i think it that
is in context of technology and development and innovation and politics and all of this stuff as we in european union that would be great dialogue to lead in the end it's diversity i guess what we're trying to push into the companies we have it on like on a european side but we're not living up to it fully and that's probably the problem here do you want to add something no i just wanted to round this up because i think also in the beginning you mario said that we need to have uh regulations um on a european level and i totally agree with that and it comes back to that and maybe also some some self-criticism uh from from my end i'm swiss and swiss people always think they're the best and and we do everything in the best way in switzerland and we can do it without the we can do it without anyone else and the reason why i'm here in germany and also why i've been here for the for the last four
years actually because i love this this this mindset that we have here is basically we're part of of this big thing of we're part of of of europe let's move something together and and and sometimes um it's easy to forget about that and forget about um this is this mission and um yeah maybe if sometimes we believe and that things are actually sometimes a little bit more complex than that they are maybe we can also think of that again and actually uh come back to our motivation that we want to do something um together and and and in a collective way thank you i think we have time for a few more questions that's okay it says something else there is a red sign in front of us but fabian is like yeah yeah you see you have to break rules just don't believe the system design thank you for thank you very much for uh the great panel and i want to circle back to the detention whoops between curiosity and also risk and
regulation so what can we do or what would be your suggestion to let's say all these large corporations out there that have all these curious young minds there to wet their appetite and their curiosity to like inspire a little bit more entrepreneurship in these large corporations using ai to maybe heal the world so i'm now to advise the the big corporates i mean on the one hand side having worked for big corporates i mean these are the big names you're you're a facilitator it's easier to speak to the regulator but often like the real disruption then comes out of the startups so um being being purely open i mean it's a chain and you're an important part in the middle and as sad as it is i mean if whatever bmw comes up to the government wants to say something they might get an appointment faster than a blockchain startup trying to do whatever on a blockchain so um therefore i guess you have the role of kind of a mediator between these worlds even
if it's a super unsexy role to be honest this is the role i do at the moment in the political system as well coming out of the tech sphere and now being there but sometimes it's really just about translating they actually want to do the same but in a startup on the tech side they just create tech and framework and whatever use fixing whatever micro problems and on the other side um there are papers produced trying to we have to regain power over data and on the other side you have something like whatever the ocean protocol really giving you power over data but the middle layer is absolutely missing and it's obviously not the bundesliga to execute then it's maybe fauvei or whomever to take it to prove it to show it and then that's the adoption into the political mainstream world so you're a translator and a bridge even if you might don't want it to be that's just my my honest answer so um carson house actually mario before said that now we
have become addicted to chinese solar panels um there is a big risk that we also get addicted to chinese ai auto american ai and so currently our niche in the market seems to be that we do ethical er ai but how do we ensure that ethical ai is so important for the world when we are so far behind in other ai fields and we don't catch up um how do we ensure uh that that we that our ai our ethics will still play a role um when our technology does not yeah i mean i said it maybe in a not very politically uh correct way with the addiction but but it's there is some truth to it and and i always as well brought that up so we can not only be the guys selling ethics so we have to prove that there are products and things which are better if we do it our way so and it's probably not aiming for the new google or whatever but just to give you an example
so skype is i think 17 years old or something almost 20 years and we now cheer at each other that we can do webex sessions so like after 20 years we are able to do it and we talk about a corona boost so if carl benz would be the guy who is able to drive the car 20 years after somebody has invented it it would look totally differently here so if we are the ethical and if whatever work-life balance or the high mart or something is so important like where is our meeting tool which just switches off and they go play with your kid or does something what we value um like tariff whatever we we stand for where is it in some tools you have to bring up an spd example we have friends now um therefore no honestly to come up come up with such things which we really believe on and it must not be the new amazon the new whatever we had the middle stand or we had still have the
middlestone before and i love this country because i live in greenland falls really in the middle of nowhere but riesling is growing there i would never ever leave this spot but i could work for sap because it's close it's a mega company in the middle of nowhere of waldorf so this is how i want this country to be and remain i don't want to move to berlin sorry berlin it's cool here but i don't want to and that gives the opportunity to really come up with these things we not foster to live in mega cities whatever trends so come up with the stuff we value with our tool whatever it will be and wherever ai is in that tool remembering the fridge example and i think this is what we can sell to the world um but there is um there's a bit of catch-up to do no okay zil kahan i'm a tech journalist um my question would be coming back to a point that daria was uttering earlier it was the fact that
actually we are not in control but um technological advances uh is is happening and the disruption is actually upcoming and approaching and to me it always seems looking into the highs of foramen how people react whenever we report or try to report an ai artificial intelligence people react with fear not trust but fear they seem to be quite averse and skeptical towards all these quickly happening revolutions right now and i do not want that to happen so there's a reluctance and i have the sense that in germany a lot of people are opposed in a way or skeptical so how do you actually tackle that psychological and societal uh issue which is not yet solved yeah i think you are a big solution to this trying to that's why i sneaked in here yeah no no you as a representative of course of journalists i think journalism has to be like is a core pillar of our society and has to get away from being sensation clickbait driven because fear sells better so and i
think we have to redefine the narrative and that's one of the reasons why i i co-founded the 109 community which is led by former team of wire germany and then it's all about optimism and and kind of in the deep dives in in in topics trying not to say like you know robots are coming and killing you so i think you are a part of the solution and i'm happy that you're asking this question so i thank you for for your contribution i can may add to this because this kind of expertise i do i give talks about how can we get people from fearing the future into enjoying and welcoming the future and it's all about we said earlier the mindset and even how to think about the future in school we have history and we learn everything about the past but no one tells us how to actually think about the future and there are three myths that we all to bring up which is first the future is actually not existing because
it's in multipliers it's the futures so we still have to um explore them all in order to instead to predict them then it's actually more a space to create in a timeline but if you think about the future we still think about a dot or like a line or a road map and i would encourage people to open that up and to think about the bigger space that can create and the last part is that people believe that the future is already written and it feels like we are on this wide river and we may can steal left or right but it pushes us into one direction and this can be replaced by being a captain of a sailing boat on the big ocean so there are storms that keep you away from your destination you have to do detour but it's about your skills how to steer the boat to bring it back to the safe haven so it's all about how we learn to deal with the complexity of the future and not
see it as fear but as chances as the action that we can do today are still influencing that and it encourages us to think positively more in the future so we can also see the pathways leading into that and yeah i think with that we can uh close the panel i thank you all for here and i think there's now lunch for you and thank of course to all three of you for sharing your opinions thanks for your moderation you