Rise of AI Summit 2020 · Berlin · Applied AI Day | Future Space

Roadmapping a Successful AI Journey: From Grassroots to Board Rooms

Christian Guttmann · TietoEVRY

At the Rise of AI Summit 2020, Christian Guttmann, Chief AI Officer at TietoEVRY, draws on almost 20 years working with businesses across four continents to outline what boardrooms and grassroots employees each need for AI adoption to succeed. Structured around eight reflections, or 'ducks,' he argues boards need entrepreneurial, technically literate members, CEOs must personally learn the technology rather than delegate it, and organizations must build trust with employees by framing AI as augmenting tasks rather than replacing jobs. He challenges the assumption that AI always requires massive legacy data, citing the second version of AlphaGo, which learned purely from the rules of the game, and describes a 'second wave' of AI maturity in which purely technical data-science teams gain business, change-management and organizational mandate. Guttmann discusses the scarcity of top AI talent, estimated at roughly 10,000 people worldwide, the risks of choosing the wrong technology partner, and why so many proof-of-concept projects end up in what he calls the 'POC graveyard' instead of scaling into full production.

Key takeaways

  • Christian Guttmann recommends boards include entrepreneurial or technically literate members, since dividend-focused, non-digital boards struggle to accept short-term trade-offs for AI investment.
  • He cites Nokia chairman Risto Siilasmaa, who personally studied machine learning with Andrew Ng at Stanford before advising the Finnish government on AI education.
  • AlphaGo's second version learned Go strategy purely from the rules of the game rather than historical human data, showing AI does not always require massive legacy datasets.
  • Guttmann estimates the global pool of AI leaders able to 'move the needle' at roughly 10,000 people, with Europe a net exporter of that talent to the US and other parts of the world.
  • He recommends measuring 'proof of value' with clear business KPIs rather than stopping at technical proof of concept, to avoid projects ending up in the 'POC graveyard.'

Detailed notes

Boardroom readiness: are your ducks aligned

Guttmann frames his talk around eight reflections on organizational readiness for AI, starting with the boardroom. He argues boards, who are ultimately responsible for setting company direction, need executive or non-executive members who are entrepreneurial or deeply understand AI technology, since boards with a mostly non-digital, dividend-focused background struggle to accept short-term revenue trade-offs for longer-term technology gains.

Connecting grassroots enthusiasm to the boardroom

He describes seeing many strong proof-of-concept AI projects in European and Nordic companies over the past five to six years stall and get buried in what he calls the 'POC cemetery.' Leaders, he says, must stay close to enthusiastic employees running these projects, study their impact, and build a path from prototype to full end-to-end deployment. He also stresses building employee trust in AI systems, citing examples from recruitment, where resume-scanning tools must be fair and transparent with a human still assessing outcomes, and sales, where AI recommendations on which customers to call must still let commission-paid sales staff trust they can hit their targets.

Advice for CEOs: learn the technology directly

Guttmann urges CEOs not to let outsiders determine their company's future, recommending they personally learn machine learning fundamentals. He cites Risto Siilasmaa, chairman of Nokia and CEO of F-Secure, who studied machine learning with Andrew Ng at Stanford, later advised the Finnish government, and contributed to making AI education mandatory in the Finnish parliament and to the globally distributed 'Elements of AI' course. His practical advice is to hire the best AI people available and spend regular time, including informal coffee and lunch conversations, with them to build a tangible feel for what the technology can do.

Data myths and organizational structure

He challenges the assumption that AI always needs large amounts of legacy data, pointing to the second version of AlphaGo, which learned its game strategy from the rules of Go rather than historical human data, and to cases where new data sources, such as newly installed cameras for factory anomaly detection, can be more useful than connecting all existing legacy systems. On organization, he describes a 'second wave' of AI maturity in which companies move beyond pure data-science teams to give AI teams business change capabilities and the mandate to implement end-to-end processes, while avoiding both full decentralization, which risks duplicated and competing AI initiatives, and full centralization, which loses insight from individual business units.

Talent scarcity and choosing partners

Guttmann cites estimates from the World Economic Forum, the New York Times and Wired putting the global pool of AI leaders who can 'move the needle' at about 10,000 people, translating to roughly five in Sweden, three in Finland and three in Norway, with Europe a net exporter of AI talent to the US and other parts of the world. He advises companies choosing an external AI partner to evaluate whether that partner's people combine deep technical understanding with business and regulatory insight in the same person, rather than treating technical expertise and business translation as separate roles.

Q&A highlights

Asked why boardrooms often lack entrepreneurial roles, Guttmann says companies with more entrepreneurial board and leadership teams are more likely to spot new AI-driven opportunities, while boards focused on executing a mature business tend to favor caution. Asked how leaders manage employee fear of new AI hires, he says introducing uncertainty naturally makes people protective of established, comfortable ways of working, and describes examples of companies deliberately exposing leadership teams to stressful experiences, such as helicopter skiing, to build comfort with uncertainty. On the 'POC graveyard,' he recommends measuring 'proof of value,' with clear KPIs on cost, revenue or operational impact, rather than stopping once a project is technologically feasible, and notes that scaling a working pilot across an entire organization often requires tens of millions of euros that only the boardroom can commit. On talent retention, he says top researchers at large US tech firms can become 'spoiled' because business outcomes are not always the top priority there, whereas European AI teams tend to be more focused on business impact. He also credits the Nordic 'fika' coffee culture and flat organizational hierarchy, including easy access to TietoEVRY's own CEO, as helpful models for fostering curiosity about AI across an organization.

Quotes

No one sells AI, right, you're selling the impact and the business and the value to the organization.

Christian Guttmann

Talent is still scarce, and to put it in numbers, WEF, New York Times and Wired have estimated the global talent pool of real leaders that can move the needle at about 10,000 experts in the world.

Christian Guttmann

Work your way backwards from the value that you want to create, from the value proposition, and see what type of data is necessary.

Christian Guttmann

Questions answered in this talk

Why do so many AI proof-of-concept projects fail to scale?

According to Christian Guttmann at the Rise of AI Summit 2020, projects often stop once they are shown to be technologically feasible instead of being measured as 'proof of value' against business KPIs, and scaling a working pilot across an entire organization typically needs an investment, tens of millions of euros, that only the boardroom can approve.

Does AI always require large amounts of historical data?

According to Christian Guttmann at the Rise of AI Summit 2020, no: the second version of AlphaGo learned its strategy purely from the rules of Go rather than historical game data, and companies can often start with new, targeted data sources, such as newly installed cameras, instead of connecting all their legacy systems.

How scarce is top AI leadership talent globally?

According to Christian Guttmann at the Rise of AI Summit 2020, estimates from the World Economic Forum, the New York Times and Wired put the global pool of AI leaders who can meaningfully move an organization forward at about 10,000 people, with Europe a net exporter of that talent to the US and China.

Mentioned

the second version of AlphaGo, proof of value, POC graveyard, second-wave AI maturity, AI talent war, Elements of AI, entrepreneurial board members

Keep exploring

More from Christian Guttmann

More from Rise of AI Summit 2020

More on Enterprise AI & Adoption

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 6,585 words

Show the full transcript

our first keynote speaker is a man that says of himself i have dedicated my life's work and career to advancing artificial intelligence for societal and economic prosperity he has led r d of hundreds of ai approaches for a quarter century today he is the chief ai officer at thieto every the leading nordic nordic digital surface company please welcome a backbone of the ai community Christian Guttmann thank you for the kind introduction it's my great pleasure to be here in berlin and give the introduction talk on the second day at the rise of ai thank you for the organizers to have such an important event here and my thinking is for this presentation that i will discuss uh some of those insights that i have gathered over the last almost 20 years uh working with different businesses around the world i've worked in four continents with many businesses and manufacturing telecommunications finance and so on and of course you see a lot of you you gain a lot of knowledge and experience with the ceos with

the leadership with the company with many projects that happen within the organization and also with the board so my my feeling is and my uh ambition with this talks to really share some of those insights the talk is also dedicated a little bit towards the leadership the ceos the startup owners the entrepreneurs those and organizations that are responsible for scaling ai for scaling the business of ai and i think that is a very important topic because of course the leadership needs to also understand where the boat is going and finally i think before we start off really i go um into detail uh on the issue of this duality between new technologies new disruptive fundamental technologies such as ai but of course also many related ones like 5g and iot and the existing business so your cash card existing business that some companies have been building up for decades maybe 50 or 100 100 years so with that started uh the talk is really from grassroots to boardrooms and i would like to start suggesting

the question are all your ducks aligned i guess most of you are familiar with the saying it means well how ready are you how prepared are you for this challenge to come and i would like to discuss about eight ducks eight eight reflections uh that i believe are important when you look at the spectrum of these grassroots movements that employees have that start to investigate and execute ai projects as well as boardrooms the owners of the company how do they see the future of the company it's all about how ready you are so in this new era of ai is really revolutionary questions that are important to um to reflect on uh there will be a smurgos board of different topics uh that we will discuss i believe we have a good amount of time for question and answer so please feel involved as mentioned earlier ask questions we're very happy to reflect on them i think we leave plenty of time and i would also like to say that those eight topics that are

coming it's very customer centric and very value-centric so what type of value propositions can you detect and can you elaborate on so that is at the core of this entire presentation really so let us start let us start with the boardroom so i mentioned grassroots to boardrooms and um as many of you know the boardrooms and the boards of companies are those that are usually the owners they're really sitting and steering how the company is moving forward and the responsibility for boardrooms becomes even bigger in times of massive change right so how how can you represent the interests of the owners of this company uh in the in the best possible way choose the right executive team in order to achieve those types of targets and be aware of what the company will become in the future so um then of course in those boardrooms one important aspect is how how is that knowledge in in the in the bottoms around new technologies is an entrepreneurial attitude do you have commitments and obligations to owners

which have let's say a much more dividend focus or are you able to are you able to actually start changing your outlook and perhaps have less and accept to have less revenue for some time in order to gain higher traction and more market lead in the future so this is a very important part i have been interacting with many boards and i understand that the setup of these boards is quite different that the tasks that they have are quite wide ranged in some cases it's really less risk and and the boardroom uh members board members are having a certain background which is non-digital non-data and i would always strongly encourage to actively think about executive or non-executive board members that are entrepreneurs or that know the ai technology very very deeply that's a very important aspect so that's the boardrooms then of course again looking from a ceo perspective from a leadership perspective it is so important to cherish the um the enthusiasm and the entrepreneurship of your employees uh i've seen many projects over

the last couple of years maybe five to six years in european nordic companies where you see excellent pocs proof of concepts first prototypes pilots they go really well and you see outcomes but then they often stop they they are buried in the poc cemetery which is full uh in europe right so we need less of those short-term projects but more of these long-term projects but how do you get there well one one aspect is that you you as a leader need to understand you need to connect these grassroots movements these grassroots projects and start seeing how they developed what impact they have on the organization study them carefully and understand how you can make a full value change in your organization so be close to these enthusiastic employees they are it's a very precious pressure precious resource which you would really like to foster and use as good examples across the organization and then of course focus on how you can get those povs to full-scale end-to-end solutions in your organization on the other scale

i've also seen a lot and particularly in europe we heard a lot of those discussions yesterday also from a german perspective that the there's of course many employees also unions as a certain angst the german angst the fear that you know this new technology would uh essentially introduce challenges into the organization take away jobs make life hard and difficult and of course that is a topic which is very important and we have been involved in several projects where you need to focus a lot on building that trust into these ai systems starting to see that it is not about replacing jobs but it is about replacing certain tasks which are executed within a certain job replacing them or augmenting them and looking uh from a perspective uh that it is a combined effort between the human and the ai system in order to really create value so having augmented uh augmented value sets and then of course when you're introducing ai for employees to use they need to trust the outcomes of these uh of

these um systems and i could give several examples maybe just two uh you know it is about we talked to recruitment organizations and when you are starting to look at scanning resumes and starting to match them to potential job applications or job offers from companies then of course you want to be very aware that these scans detect and make these types of assessments of what that resume contains in terms of qualities and characteristics is done in a fair and transparent session fashion and at the same time also understand that these job placements which are today manually assessed just as the resumes are assessed are uh when you're assessing whether they are correct complete appropriately written and so on that you actually do that also in a fair and complete manner so a human um is still involved in employees still involved to assess whether these or to decide whether these resume assessments are correct and complete but then you also need to trust the outcomes of these automation and ai systems right so that is

that is something that you would really like to highlight at the same time you have situations and we have been increasingly talking to sales departments at organizations that for example manufacturing companies and finance companies where when you are starting to use ai to predict which customers are more likely to buy your product and services in the future and you recommend that to your sales force to your sales representatives and they are paid based on commission right so and they have their way of being successful in the past which is perhaps based on manual assessments and discussions they had with customers and so on but now you have an ai system making recommendations on whom to call then of course you would like to be very you need to trust you need to build that trust you need to see that you can still achieve uh the outcomes that you set yourself to achieve by the end of the year and so these are all new processes that need to be included in the um in

these organizations and these sales organizations so the employees are your driving force in your organization to really transform and adopt this technology you're the ceo i mentioned before the talk is a bit geared towards ceo's leaders and entrepreneurs in the organization so what does that mean i see a huge interest and curiosity when it comes to this technology as i'm speaking to ceos and cfos and ctos in large organizations and also smaller organizations and what is though let's say missing is a bit this feeling of what's the art of the possible right so it's actually quite hard to assess how your company needs to be restructured how you will play in a in quite a different market without having some understanding of what that technology can do and i really like to give often this nice example as i have also met a fine colleague in finland um risto silas ma i'm sure he would be happy for me to mention him because he is the chairman of nokia and ceo of f-secure nokia i

guess most of most of the audience know nokia and so he decided to really go back to the bench and learn machine learning and ai went to to my colleague andrew nung in to stanford and actually learn what these algorithms can do to get a tangible real feeling of of what it does and so in fact as a result of those insights not only um was he able to make a much proper assessment of where the company would be going but also there was a lot of advice given to governments and other entities in order to learn more about ai so one result was the finnish parliament is now learning ai and that is obligatory mandatory now in in finland that everyone in the parliament actually has an understanding of what ai is also in part the elements of ai course that comes from finland which has now been broadly distributed across the world is in part related to this initiative so i can only highly recommend for leadership and executive members to learn more

about the technology so don't let outsiders determine your future obviously you are responsible for the core product and core services that your company is is building i will in fact mention something about this later regarding partnership but it is very important that you on the driving seat and you have this knowledge in order to make decisions uh for your strategy in your company and then i would actually from a practical point of view i would recommend that you hire the best the best ai people and experts that you can get your hands on and have as many place these people next to your desk and have as many coffees with them and lunch breaks as you can possibly have to get a tangible feeling about what is possible in terms of applying ai and data technology and in fact other disruptive technologies that are now on the horizon so that's a very practical advice because otherwise it tends to be a discussion topic that that's happening at the end of the day or at the

end of the week or end of the month rather than being the core of where you should be focusing in order to re-situate your organization and you will become much more knowledgeable insightful and have much more mature discussions also with the rest of the organization and the board so um we had a lot of discussions and of course ai is a lot about the technology and the data and the and then of course there's a bit of the sphere how complex it really is um and i can highlight just the idea that it is true that in some cases in many cases the ai that we have today and one subpart of ai's machine learning requires a lot of data so many of you are aware that we talk about supervised learning for example uh neural networks that we that require a lot of data in order to learn but that is not the only way how to create value so you can certainly build ai without having massive amounts of data so that is

worth noting the goal alphago success that we had a couple of years ago in fact the ai system there was not built on legacy data the one that the first one the first alphago was it was the wisdom of all humans ever played that ever played gold but the second version that was superior actually learned learned its moves and its game behavior from the rules of the game so it was actually not based on a lot of data and that is worth noting that a couple of those examples another one is which holds organizations back they believe that ah we need to look at all the legacy data that we have that we have collected over the last 10 20 30 years and that's certainly not always true either it was mentioned yesterday when it comes to external data so the usefulness of external data adding it to the data that you already have in your system can vastly improve the power of the ai system that you're using for predictive maintenance let's say or

for many other topics and secondly think about creating new data sources so there is if you're in a factory and you start making predictions or um i want to assess anomalies in the factory process uh you can install cameras we heard yesterday very interesting talk about also how camera data is perhaps one of the biggest sources of ai in terms of data but you can install them today and collect that data and then use that data in order to do this anomaly detection forward for that you do not necessarily need a massive data strategy as to how you handle your legacy systems so work your way backwards from the value that you want to create from the value proposition and see what type of data is necessary uh in the most minimal case to start off with in order to unleash that value it is not always necessary to boil the ocean and try to connect all data sources that you have in your organization although of course in the long run if you really

want to play the long haul then of course it is useful to make a very uh decent full scale investment in order to have all your data connected okay so organizational changes what i've been seeing a lot and i think many are familiar with that notion that over the last couple of years maybe last five four five years that's where it started that businesses have started to build up ai and data teams in in organizations right so many ceos and leaders and board members and key employees went over to silicon valley and to shankston to get the inspiration and there were a lot of there was a lot of travel and um to see how how did the guys in the us and china succeed of course that is not enterprise ai it is consumer ai and that that era of these types of visits have gone down but and this first wave that we have experienced in europe and building ai teams is now also coming to a next level because there is an

understanding and a learning that these pure ai data teams that only consist of data science experts which you absolutely need it's very important but you you also need to have those people that understand the business integrated into the rest of the organization have responsibility to do an end-to-end process implementation in your organization and also understand what the business impact is to the market also have the mandate to actually change the organization right so those types of things are now moving into what i would call a second wave ai maturity right so more and more companies start realizing well of course we need the data scientists and the ai scientists and that is very important but on top of that we need to give them the more capabilities business change capabilities transformational activities and the mandate to make fundamental changes in the organization of course hand in hand with other stakeholders and with the ceo but that is very very important so i see in fact also and the second wave to be very careful about

defragmenting your ai approaches so i'm looking often at the two extremes which don't work if you have if you defragment and start distributing the ai initiatives across the organization and you don't connect them with each other you have big risks of having parallel agendas which compete you have big risks and reinventing the wheel it is not necessary that different service lines and verticals are all reinventing their uh reinventing their for example ai transparency agendas and algorithms that can be reused across the organization so you you're not this is not recommendable to fully defragment and decentralize your entire uh ai efforts right on the other hand it is also not advisable to completely central centralize your ai approach uh because you will be needing the insights that that reside and exist in the individual business teams service lines in the country teams and the verticals and that knowledge there uh is of course absolutely important in order to create value propositions around the technology of ai so so be quite mindful about the building building an

organization that effectively adopts and translates these ai and data science technologies into business impact and value yes i could certainly go on on this topic but maybe we have a chance in the question and answers section so very important also which i'm seeing is still a big trouble uh let's say it's still a big issue for us here in europe is you need to find the ai talent and how do you keep and retain that talent right so it is still so that for uh a big implementation of a big change and this big business impact in your organization uh you still need kick-ass talent you need the best of the best in your organization uh in order to really make a change so there is a it's a huge competition and finding that talent attracting that talent europe overall is a nato exporter of ai talent to the valley to the us to many parts of the of the world and it is a matter of how to attract and also retain that talent

right how can we keep that talent in in europe um uh many of our fellow uh you know areas and countries innovation countries like silicon valley shengsen we had a big discussions around moonshot projects uh projects that really make a difference and move the needle that is attracting top talent in the world right so there's many examples in the us and that is certainly one attracting point and you will be competing if you're a european company and a european ceo and european entrepreneur let's say and a leader you're competing with those companies in the us in in china so you need to be quite innovative as to what you bring to the table to this talent in order to really keep them keep them here yes and of course highlighting something that i often say but i think it is still very clear and obvious that talent is still scarce and to put it in numbers wef new york times uh wired have estimated the global talent pool of real leaders that can move the

needle at about 10 000 uh experts in the world right so in in the nordic countries i often break that down statistically that that means we have about five in sweden three in finland and about three in norway right that is what you are mapping it down to so there is a big uh challenge in having this type of talent and keeping that talent and as i mentioned earlier we have via net to exporters so it's actually less than those numbers that we're actually having right and this is not of course uh many experts and talents that have learned how machine learning works and how you can apply it but also starting to see the bigger picture you know business having a business understanding working with governments seeing the regulatory frameworks and how you how you're actually creating an ecosystem around the around the technology um and then of course it is more and more let's say it is it is an increased trend that you as an organization if you're a manufacturer or a

finance organization or a recruitment agency or you work in tourism that you need to find a qualified partner a partner that you can rely on and it is a partner where you will see that you can speed up your your innovation that you can speed up the adoption of ai but i've seen many unfortunate cases where you due to the early days of this technology and less knowledge as to how this actually translates that partner choices have been sub-optimal let's put it this way and one one advice that i give here is as you're evaluating your partner look closely as to what talent they really have on their side whom have they employed in order to make this partnership happening and it is then not enough just to have someone that is a technological uh knowledgeable figure so having let's say a phd and you know many years of scientific experience in this field but you also need someone that has a very deep business inside so how do you translate this technology into business

environments what is the impact that is in this organization does this person have an entrepreneurial background for example how much business has been has been translated so you need someone that understands the mathematics the algorithms in depth and that same person i i say that clearly you don't need two separate persons at this point you need the same person that has the ability to also understand the the business impact and ideally also one that understand the regulatory environment and the government environment let's say the state environment in which you are performing those ai uh projects and how you're turning into more ai first company yeah finally i mean i will reflect briefly and then we can probably take it to the q a session is uh now we start becoming ready towards building a roadmap and a strategy for ai putting it all together i mentioned earlier that having a full strategy of ai considers some of the aspects i mentioned before and there's so many more aspects that i couldn't discuss in this talk

but please reach out to ask more questions i'm thinking of course of value propositions how do you technology no one sells ai right you're selling the impact and the business and the value to the organization need to be pretty clear uh as a as a company as the owner of the company and as the ceo of the company in which market you want to compete in in two or three years time where have you found your niche how do you want to change your organization and what capabilities do you need to successfully arrive there choosing the partners attracting the talent and knowing what type of products and services you're going to you're going to offer to the market that is the comment on strategy and this is pretty much the last slide summarizing all the different uh ducks you know the the different reflections that i've shared with you and um i leave this last slide where it is and i'm looking forward to many great questions and a good dialogue thank you thank you

very much christian we already have one question from the audience i want to encourage you to ask more so the other daniel welcome back asked the question yesterday was shown that corporates usually don't have entrepreneurs or an innovation focused role in company leadership in your experience is there a different development on how that innovation is evolving in those companies yes i mean you can say that in the we will see in the short and midterm that the companies that are applying ai and have a certain risk appetite when it comes to these new disruptive technologies will will be different to those that don't right so you of course there's always a higher risk doing new things but the chances for you to prevail in this market is of course higher and um i think i can this is of course not necessarily empirically completely studied although i'm sure there's a lot of there is actually a lot of evidence and i think i've read a couple of research papers on that but if you have

a more entrepreneurial board team and leadership team you're starting to consider your business in quite a different way you're starting to look at opportunities but if you're if your leadership team and board team consists a lot of uh let's say those that understand how standard business the mature business is executed which is very important like when you bring your startup organization as hans pointed out yesterday to scale stage and it becomes mature you need people that execute you need trans uh you need transactional leaders you don't need transformational leaders you need people that just execute and those tend to be in the boardrooms of the established businesses today right so so yes when it comes to revolutionary and new trend transformational technologies as ai is you will almost certainly benefit from having an executive or non-executive board member that is an entrepreneur ideally several so i see the tendency we will of course with ai we still sort of in the beginning of that in the enterprise domain but over the years i'm i'm almost

certain that you will find that companies that have two or three entrepreneurs that are rocking the boat you know right they're saying hey we need to do it differently uh we'll have a much better chance of prevailing that's very interesting and last time i checked most of the board members and cxos were human and since since humans always have to deal with feelings like fear and maybe rivalry what's going on when there are suddenly a lot of i would say new people on the playground that do things differently are maybe admired now these are the new guys we we got in to do the great new wonderful thing of ai what happens uh from a human perspective how are the dynamics yeah exactly it's true i mean people are how to say um some feel comfortable uh in in really looking at the cash cows of the organization and and and optimizing those right and that brings a lot of comfort and if as you introducing variables of uncertainty you will start seeing people you

know getting a bit nervous on the seats um so uh yes so if your question is how do you deal with fear i mean now remember and i think it is still partly a let's say a method in in boardrooms and leadership teams that you are taking out your leadership team to particular organ uh events right to really stretch them to make them feel fear right to make it part you know like no exaggerate but i know one example where they pretty much just went with a helicopter in a mountain pretty much pushed them out of the out of the uh out of the um helicopter skiing down right so it's you need to be experiencing this feeling of uh there is many uncertain environments you need to take uh you need to take a chance and things will be will be good at the other end so uh i think this is a very important exercise right um thank you let's talk a little bit about the uh the proof of concept graveyard you

call it i think that was that that's a picture that uh that just doesn't fade after even after your tour so why do you think there are so many proofs of concept in the graveyard because the idea of course is you have a proof of concept right um then you explore the market and if the market is there for it you immediately go for it and this doesn't seem to happen is that another fear thing or what is it yeah yeah i think there's a couple of factors so first what my team is doing and what i'm often encouraging and also encourage the customers in the ecosystem to think about i think not of proof of concepts but a proof of values so that when you're engaging and you're doing a particular project and you're investigating whether this technology makes a difference then don't just focus on it being is it technologically feasible which is important but also does it create value so measure the outcome define the kpis what difference does it make to

the organization from a business perspective does it reduce cost uh you know does it increase revenue what difference does it make to the operational model so keep a lot of focus on that i've seen so many projects where the first thought is how we do poc because everyone knows what a poc is uh you know and and that is sort of the the end of that part the second variable is it's often a bit of an easy choice right because you say look i put a few million on the side i give them some for some people to play with you know i mentioned earlier the employees enthusiastic employees that get that think luckily they get the few million and they can play and they can show it's a wellness program or appreciation program for employees almost almost yeah yeah so i'm exaggerating of course a bit but then they they they get those millions but there's really no follow-up plan right now and and it is also worth noting that even if you show

this pov at the end right you need to scale the scale and deploy it so let's say it works for two shops in a in an organization well how do you scale it to 10 000 shops right across europe if you know if that's and so and that requires much more investment and that's what i mentioned earlier connect the grassroot movements to the boardroom because they need to understand aha this pov has worked now these guys need 50 million euro maybe 100 million euro in order to scale that where is that coming from even the ceo cannot just just you know take it out of his pocket and say yes this has probably has to do with the other idea you introduced like the art of the possible not only possible to get the product to make the product but to get it out and to roll it out maybe globally or europe-wide right this should be probably considered early and you could argue that i mean the scaling and deploying that's almost a bit

more standard in some sense because you need to at least on one level because you need to start thinking about what type of business logistics do you need to consider uh what type of processes in the big process map do you need to change and so on what business processes will be impacted but you know there is analysis and methods for that then of course yeah ai comes with different challenges right um do you see a problem there together with the idea of the war of talents i mean of course you want to recruit incredibly talented people and maybe you get them and they have this great proof of concept but they are never put out into the real world and then they might just as well leave and go to apple or google or wherever they're going is that a phenomenon that you that you see or a danger that you see yes of course and i would even say now i want to be a bit careful but because i have a lot

of colleagues and friends that also work at the big american organizations right right uh at uh you know google facebook and many others but it is i think it is fair to state that when it comes to the maturity and the exposure of that talent and unspeak data people that know the algorithms fantastically well um they they can sometimes be a little bit spoiled because the googles the facebook the amazons have so much money they're reinvesting that money right now and the business business value the business outcomes are not always the highest priority right so you can very easily create 200 300 people project right with top researchers and top uh scientists where the outcome is not critical to the organization that is not a luxury that many european companies have and i would almost say that as we are succeeding here we become much more how to say uh battle proven right because i would still say that you know the 20 30 40 people that we have in big organizations in europe that

are leading these initiatives need to think more about this business impact and i think they are more prepared in this enterprise ai era forward to really uh really be let's say more competitive right i would like to talk about one aspect that you briefly mentioned almost as a tangent you said drink a lot of coffee yeah and of course i know you live in you live in stockholm i know that in in sweden there is this fica tradition like drinking hour-long coffees in the morning in the afternoon with everybody in the company which to germans is a nightmare like so much productivity right left at the coffee table and i you talked about your finnish friend who just said i'm gonna learn something although he's running a company i mean a luxury probably many ceos in germany would take for a day but not for a month or a couple of weeks a year do you see a different mentality there is there something we can learn from the nordic countries yeah i think everyone

i mean and i'm looking even at myself as a person you know i've been living in many places in the world and i tend to i tend to think and i hope that i'm sort of picking picking certain positive aspects and characteristics from certain cultures right to collect it together and yes i think there's something to be learned from the nordics um i think one aspect and that's also one that a tiered to every as a company and the nordic ai is to put very boldly on the map set we have a lot of respect for the individual uh and we have a lot of respect we really consider there is very little hierarchy right and i would say in part it encourages not only a nominally flat hierarchy but a really flat hierarchy very quite yeah yeah you can call our ceo right almost any time you know and then and then have discussions and he's very engaged just to take one example but i think you find that in many uh nordic companies

you know so i think and then and then the fika culture is but i think i would say is particularly strong in sweden right the finns are not yes they also drink a lot of coffee may actually more they drink other things right they drink i don't know yeah but but of course look i mean this um there is benefit in having meetings which we now have much less uh due to corona of course uh and it depends probably a little bit what the nature of these meetings are specifically to the ceo i mean it was a bit tongue-in-cheek common right you don't have to obviously sit all the time have coffee right but sit close to the people that know this technology and um at least me and some of the people that i know the curiosity sparks these interests and saying hey you know what what here is a business problem that i'm seeing all the time you know i cannot predict why the sales unit in the netherlands not performing well right

and so the the ai person the experts on the side can uh this is not very very tangible but you know can certainly give you insights as to what's possible and what isn't you know they say well can't we just take all the data and then make a prediction they give you a bit of an assessment i think that is a good sparring session you know a good session of you getting deeper inside hands-on right so thank you very much for your insights i will have a coffee with you any day you want thank you good morning welcome thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.