Rise of AI Conference 2022 · Berlin · Meta Stage

Lessons Learnt from the Nordic AI Ecosystem

Christian Guttmann · Director, Nordic Artificial Intelligence Institute

At Rise of AI 2022 in Berlin, Christian Guttmann, director of the Nordic Artificial Intelligence Institute, former VP Global Head of AI at Tieto, and a researcher at the Karolinska Institute, shares what he has learned working across Sweden, Finland, Denmark and Norway. Citing global AI rankings where Finland and Denmark place in the low teens, he attributes Nordic strengths to near-universal internet coverage, a personal-number system linking private and public data such as healthcare records, and high public trust in data sharing, illustrated by Klarna's payment-risk models, cross-registry healthcare analytics he worked on, and Iceland's national DNA biobank. He describes government-backed structures such as Nordic Innovation Houses and the Nordic Council of Ministers, an engineering-heavy but talent-exporting workforce, early technology adoption, and English used as the default business language from day one. He also notes friction points, including state alcohol monopolies and diverging cloud policies between Sweden and Finland, before surveying large companies and startups applying AI, and closing with recommendations for startups, investors and politicians, including a call for a more ambitious, JFK-style AI vision.

Key takeaways

  • Guttmann attributes Nordic AI strength partly to a personal-number system linking private and public data, including full healthcare records, across each country.
  • He cites Klarna's use of hundreds of data points to predict bill-payment likelihood and Iceland's national DNA biobank as examples of high public trust in data sharing.
  • He contrasts Sweden's reluctance to use non-EU cloud providers, which limits AI deployment, with Finland's broader adoption, including at Helsinki University Hospital covering a third of the population.
  • He describes H&M's "Fountainhead" approach of democratizing AI access to hundreds of thousands of employees because it could not hire enough AI specialists.
  • He argues European and Nordic AI strategies lack an ambitious, JFK-style moonshot vision and calls on politicians to take bigger risks to attract talent.

Detailed notes

Rankings and the Nordic starting point

Guttmann opens by noting he arrived without his luggage or laptop charger, so the talk would be delivered largely without slides. He references the Global AI Index, where Finland ranks 11th and Denmark 12th, with Sweden and Norway around 18th and 19th, measured on factors like talent, access and infrastructure readiness. He also cites per-capita unicorn rankings where Sweden trails only California, pointing to Spotify, King and Klarna, as well as Minecraft and Angry Birds as billion-dollar Nordic successes, and notes strong results on a global AI government-readiness index from Oxford, speculating that long winters may partly explain the region's engineering-driven innovation culture.

Infrastructure, data culture and the personal number

Guttmann highlights near-complete internet and mobile coverage across the Nordics, roughly 80% high-speed penetration even in rural areas, contrasting this with disruptions he experienced in Germany, and argues reliable connectivity is a basic requirement for AI applications such as self-driving cars. He points to each country's personal number system, linked through BankID or Norway's Altinn, which connects an individual's private and public services, including a full healthcare record, as a foundation for AI. He gives two examples: Klarna's use of hundreds of data points per individual to predict the likelihood someone will pay a bill, and a healthcare project he worked on that combined multiple quality registries to enable value-based reimbursement, tracking which treatments and hospitals produce which outcomes at what cost, work he says would not have been possible without the personal number. He also cites Iceland's population-wide DNA biobank, noting an app that lets people check genetic relatedness to a potential partner in bars.

Government support, talent and market structure

Guttmann describes Nordic government-backed structures such as Nordic Innovation Houses in Silicon Valley, New York, Hong Kong and Singapore, which help startups land and grow abroad, and the Nordic Council of Ministers, which enables countries to collaborate at a scale a single small country could not achieve alone. He notes the region is engineering-heavy with comparatively less sales and business focus, reflected in companies like Ericsson and Nokia, but that the Nordics remain net exporters of AI and data science talent, similar to the rest of Europe. He points to early technology adoption, including Tesla's roughly one-third market share in Norway, and contrasts Nordic startups, which use English as their primary language from the outset because small home markets like Finland's five million people cannot support a global company alone, with German companies that often expand abroad still using German.

Monopolies and diverging cloud policies

Guttmann notes state alcohol monopolies in Sweden, Finland and Norway, joking that some call Sweden "more communist than North Korea" in this respect, while observing that centralized purchasing makes Sweden's state retailer, Systembolaget, buying wine for ten million people, the largest wine purchaser in the world at high quality and affordable prices. He also contrasts cloud policy: Sweden's public sector largely avoids non-EU cloud providers, citing Schrems-related legal concerns, forcing reliance on on-premises AI infrastructure, while Finland has taken American cloud providers further, including in a project covering roughly a third of Finland's population through Helsinki University Hospital, where he says far more AI technology could be implemented than was possible under Sweden's more restrictive approach.

Large companies and rising startups

Guttmann surveys established companies applying AI: H&M pursuing a horizontal "Fountainhead" approach to democratize AI access across hundreds of thousands of employees rather than relying solely on scarce AI specialists; Ericsson using AI extensively to make 4G, 5G and 6G networks effective; Novo Nordisk focusing on drug discovery, including growing investment in antibiotics, though he notes the antibiotic Halicin, which he says was only discoverable using deep learning, was developed by another, unnamed company rather than Novo Nordisk; and Equinor operating a fully autonomous oil platform in the Atlantic, alongside Norway's aim, as a country, to become oil-and-gas neutral. Among startups, he cites Silo AI from Finland, which he calls the largest European AI lab with about 150 AI and machine learning PhDs and 100% growth; a Danish company recognized by Brussels among Europe's top AI firms for AI that listens to emergency calls to improve response accuracy; Sidekick Health from Iceland, which recently raised about 55 million euros for patient consultation support; and Depict AI, founded by teenage CEO Oliver, who raised about 40 million dollars to provide Amazon-style recommendations for e-commerce sites.

Recommendations

Guttmann closes with recommendations for three audiences. Startups, wherever based, should ask whether their home market is really the best beachhead market given local culture and infrastructure, rather than assuming their home city is automatically the right starting point. Investors should understand the competitive landscape they are entering. Politicians, he argues, often treat national AI strategies, frequently drafted by consultancies rather than by politicians themselves, as a way to appear active without taking real positions; what is missing, in the Nordics and across Europe, is an ambitious, JFK-style moonshot vision for AI, comparable to committing to a moon landing before the technology existed, which he argues would attract talent and give AI efforts real purpose.

Quotes

What I'm missing in the entire European system, and that's the same also in the Nordic countries, is a strong vision, a JFK-like vision of how to use AI to do big things.

Christian Guttmann

Questions answered in this talk

Why is the personal number system important for AI in the Nordic countries?

According to Christian Guttmann at Rise of AI 2022, the personal number, linked through systems like BankID or Altinn, connects an individual's private and public services, including a complete healthcare record, into one accessible identity, which enabled projects such as cross-registry healthcare analytics and Klarna's payment-risk models.

Why does Sweden use less cloud infrastructure for AI than Finland?

Christian Guttmann explained at Rise of AI 2022 that Sweden's public sector largely avoids non-EU cloud providers due to Schrems-related legal concerns, relying instead on on-premises solutions, while Finland has adopted American cloud providers more broadly, including in a Helsinki University Hospital project covering about a third of Finland's population.

What recommendation does Christian Guttmann give to AI startups about choosing a home market?

At Rise of AI 2022, Guttmann advised startups to ask whether their home city or country is really the best beachhead market given local culture and infrastructure, rather than assuming the place they happen to be based is automatically the right starting point.

Mentioned

Global AI Index, personal number system, value-based reimbursement, cloud sovereignty, AI democratization

Keep exploring

More from Christian Guttmann

More from Rise of AI Conference 2022

More on Enterprise AI & Adoption

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 4,560 words

Show the full transcript

our next speaker is dr Christian Guttmann he's a multinational ai specialist and he's dedicated his work and life for advancing artificial intelligence so ai for society and also for economic prosperity founded an institute in the nordics and this is also what he will be talking about lessons learned from the nordic ai ecosystem what works and what doesn't work and probably a good follow-up to the conversation and the panel we had a few minutes ago thanks thanks for um being with us christian and i think you have a you have a kind of a difficulty experienced something yesterday yes that's true i arrived a couple of days ago in fact and i experienced a very non-digitized non-intelligent interruption in terms of my luggage not arriving so i have been essentially luggage free and and uh notebook charger free for the last five days meaning that um there won't be many slides you will have a a natural authentic impromptu presentation by me today so enjoy okay so this will be free speech and free flow speech

exactly excellent so thank you welcome to my talk and i think i start off by opening my iphone and starting to look at the different notes that i made just a couple of words about myself i have been working with ai for a very long time 25 years almost i did my phd in this area became academically active but then started working for large corporations around the world you juliet pekka the british telecom and also tiato every one of my recent big gigs where i was have been the vice president global head of ai one of the largest i.t companies here in europe and i'm also the director of the nordic artificial intelligence institute one of the one one of the think tanks in europe when it comes to ai and i'm also at the karolinska institute still which is a medical university in the nordics so that's a little bit my background i focus a lot on helping the ecosystem in europe to become strong and that means in practice i'm a mentor advisor

board member of startups i'm helping holdings family holdings vc funds to do due diligence and make smart investment decisions and also help ceos of established companies and leadership and establish companies and government in the government sector to start uh and to to properly set up frameworks that work for these types of companies so that's my activities and that's the activities of the nordic artificial intelligence institute what i will try to do here since i live in stockholm i have several nationalities but currently i'm living in stockholm in sweden i travel a lot to helsinki and oslo and copenhagen to talk to startups to talk to companies and to customers and i will give an overview as to what happens in the nordics and also what works and what doesn't so certain highlights that i have experienced there and maybe just to contextualize and start a little bit there are plenty of rankings out there to to media for example some of you might be familiar it's a global ai index of countries and the nordic

countries are doing relatively well they are not very much on the very top of the scale but finland for example is on place 11 and denmark on 12 and then sweden and norway on 1819 something like that and the type of measures that they have is like talent access infrastructure how ready these countries are and i will i wanted to reflect on some of the strength of the nordic countries what works particularly well maybe also what some of these rankings do not fully reflect in my opinion and see if there's something that helps startups investors and ecosystem builders to be aware what is around you whether it's in germany or in the nordic countries on any other country it's so important that you are aware what opportunities and what support you can gain what that you can get and also seeing the limitations of the culture the infrastructure and the support system in order to be successful essentially i also wanted to note there's a couple of other rankings out there so per capita um

sweden actually ranks only second to california in terms of its um unicorn startups such as spotify king klana and also if you look a bit wider you have minecraft and angry birds these are all billion dollar companies which have been very successful and come from the nordic countries there is a global ai index for talent there's a global global ai governmental readiness index by oxford research and the nordic countries actually do quite well as was alluded to before in another panel it could be several reasons as to why the nordics have been a bit advanced when it comes to innovation could be the cold weather and the long winters and being innovative when it comes to housing but it could also just be the long winters and being spending a lot of time indoors and you know thinking about big problems from an engineering perspective so um and the overview and you see this here also is essentially that i will speak about the strengths and weaknesses give some examples of big traditional companies that

are utilizing ai in the nordic countries and how they do that and then focus a little bit on the on some startups which i believe are becoming very successful and really start to outperform others in the in the system and then yeah a couple of perspectives and recommendations if you like from from this perspective so um let's start with a few um special uh features of sweden and denmark and finland and and so on maybe also to make everyone aware each of these countries is very unique these are not they are not very homogeneous countries for example each of them have of course their own language they have their fully autonomous the structures and the ai strategies for example were lodged at completely different paces and times finland being the first in the eu for example norway being the last in terms of having an ai strategy national ai strategy in place and uh and also each of these countries have completely different industry sectors which they focus on traditionally with um with uh sweden

having telecommunication ericsson talia very successful you have denmark with novo nordisk and live tech not a lot of focus there particularly now a lot of investments into antibiotics halley scene was one of those trucks that not no no no disc developed but another company so it's um it's starting to really pick up in the pharma space equinoir is a it's a huge oil and gas company in norway they have developed a fully autonomous oil platform in the in the atlantic and at the same time also aim as a country to become completely oil and gas neutral and free so there's a couple of uh how to say focus areas where each country is sort of shining and therefore each of them also have quite a different starting point what i do reflect on now is like a bit the infrastructure the culture and the support systems in the next couple of minutes um and as i started saying and it's a bit of an example it does um i would say surprise me when i

come to germany is i don't want to make it sound like a complaint also but it's still when it comes to coverage which is such a strong uh a feature in the nordic countries in terms of internet access uh mobile phone access it's i have never experienced the disruption really i can say in the nordic stockholm housing when i drive to the country there is a hundred percent coverage and the penetration access to internet is it's 80 for for high-speed internet access so there were several situations where i'm essentially stranded with having no internet access here or where if i take a train uh i'm unable to have an ms teams or a zoom call or something right so it's a lot of disruption and i i would say that this is um almost a basic requirement for certain ai applications to function right i mean self-driving cars of course can be completely self-driving but one one use case is of course having 5g 6g networks in order for them to be fully connected so

that's one and i was since my luggage got lost since saturday so if lufthansa is listening um i got the first part being digitized and i knew where my luggage was but then it was handed over to korea and it's still now it's completely i have no idea where it is and for days i have been trying to find out where it even is so uh i they are nordic airlines which have a complete end-to-end process when luggage is actually lost just as a side note right so i feel there's a couple of very practical things that i recently experienced where we could all do a little bit better and of course there are always good reasons as to why that's not the case but just some some examples in terms of infrastructure if you continue on that level so again you know 5g internet access extremely good means a lot to the um to also startups to position themselves to be aware what would work in your in your country in the environment that

you're in another example is it's a very highly digitized public market in the nordics so there is something called the personal number in every nordic country are there any has anyone lived in the nordic countries so ask me okay so then you're not familiar with this concept perhaps but the personal number which each of us have allows us to connect any service whether it's a private one or public service so it's internet account your healthcare journal so i can see my all my visits at doctors across the country diagnoses vaccinations you name it and it's all going through one so-called bank id or in fact other you know norway and the others they have something called altin and remit so that's essentially one access to all the data and what that enables to give you one specific or two specific examples for data driven slash ai driven initiatives is one is clanner some of you might be familiar with klanner they have essentially been very successful in collecting hundreds of data points of individuals in

order to predict the likelihood for individuals to pay the bill online so it's you can look into this but it's essentially one of those unicorns that have existed from the nordics it essentially allows you to collect uh data about individuals another one is when i actually decided to come to europe i worked for a company where we had a very unique opportunity to connect data points from many different healthcare registries and it allowed us allowed us to do something referred to as value-based reimbursement in the healthcare system so what's currently unknown in almost any healthcare system is what action what remedy produces which type of effect in a patient and how much does it cost and we had the opportunity to connect many different quality registries meaning information that's collected about let's say cancer patients uh and seeing what actions have been taken and then start making predictions about how effective the treatments are and how effective certain hospitals are so this has been published and recorded really well there are also issues with this

approach if i may say but it is it would wouldn't have been possible if he didn't wouldn't have if he wouldn't have had the personal number right because there's sort of one central piece of information that allows to connect everything and um it is often used as a proof point in other countries now in order to show that it's actually possible to make calculations that of high relevancy so that's one example another one is um that this data quality as i mentioned before in these registries um and the data sharing acceptance by the population is is very high an example in iceland many of you know that perhaps that the entire icelandic population has been dna samples so there is a biobank and maybe one slightly amusing anecdote is that the icelandic people use it in bars now there's an app that allows you to estimate how closely related you are from a genetic point of view within with your potential mate so it can give you advice as to whether or not you should

proceed you know with your with your engagement but um these sort of this sort of type of quality information about health care is the highest in the world uh the information that's collected allows for very precise uh predictions another one is that there are many uh emerging and government initiatives i listened to another talk just before as to how german startups and german companies are encouraged to expand into other countries the nordic countries work together having structures like the nordic innovation house which is located in the valley in new york and hong kong and singapore and all the nordic governments put in a certain investment in order to make it easy for these startups to land and succeed in these countries when i had my startup a good while ago it allowed me to speak to angel investors to vc funds i was visiting the google and and facebook headquarters to understand where they are what type of initiatives they have and how closely related they are to my sort of startup and whom i

should be working together with so um there's also the nordic council of ministries a collaboration among these countries which allow essentially uh for much more scale which is i think a very important aspect there was this panel before where we discussed with was mario brandenburg and several others discussing how we should have a european approach essentially and i think it is very important i think the nordic countries have a pretty unique model as to how they work together with each other it's also worth noting the nordic countries are very engineering heavy so they are sometimes it's a bit joked that they are yeah they are very engineering heavy and not focusing so much on the applications we will find far more engineering companies with less business case and sales driven um with a sales driven attitude and they are actually then starting to um and you will see and you see this also in companies like erickson and nokia and so on so that means that when it comes to ai competencies we're actually doing

relatively way well as a basis uh in our in our ecosystem however just like the rest of europe we are net to exporters of ai and data science talent currently so we are not able uh to keep some of the best talent in in europe that's still that's still the case uh also worth mentioning the nordic countries tend to be early adopters you know obviously with mobile phones uh very high adoption early on no surprise with nokia and and ericsson tesla is bought in norway is the primary market 11 of the overall global market is norway so norwegians every third car is a tesla there and so there's a lot of openness partly also driven by the government another thing that i noticed and it was mentioned before which is interesting to see in contrast to the german approach it needed to be said in the other room that when german companies expand to other countries that early on it shouldn't be it shouldn't be german as the uh the language of the company or

the contracts that you're signing i don't know if some of you were in that other room but this is almost a given for nordic countries so they know that finland isn't big enough uh with five million uh people to essentially become a global company right so you need to be from the beginning i don't know any startup that i have been supporting and mentoring or have been in the board that doesn't use english as a primary language and then of course you have a very high proficiency in the in the countries right so nothing is uh translated as it is in germany and i mention all these things because they matter a lot for talent attraction for startups and for ai talent and also for um for expansion so it's it's some of the very strong drivers i would say uh and the last thing or yeah one of the things that i would mention is also industry monopolies so they're still so i forg hopefully my swedish and my nordic fellows will forgive me

here but some say said and i didn't say that that sweden is sometimes more communist than north korea in certain ways and the reason why they say that is that there are certain monopolies that don't exist elsewhere so there is um the alcohol alcohol is for example only distributed to a company called a steamboat and it's a it's a government-owned central entity uh the same in finland alcoholic i think they're called and then monopole it in norway so they don't even hide the fact that there's only one government entity that buys all the wine and the spirits and distributes it to the people so there are certain monopolies in the nordic countries for the better for the worse it means in practice that wine is actually quite affordable and extremely high quality because sustainable luggage as an example is the highest purchaser of wine in the world because they're buying wine for 10 million people right so so there's a couple of very interesting things so i can probably mention more examples if you're interested

just approach me but i would like to switch to um to some and maybe i mentioned also one or two challenges so i i i hope i was balanced so i will want to be balanced essentially uh for example one thing is that sweden as opposed to finland for example is not opening their arms the public sector is not opening their arms to cloud providers that are coming from outside the eu which means essentially there's not many left right that you can use and so in practice it means there's a lot of on-prem solutions for ai services um finland the has taken a different route they have been uh using cloud providers and it's one of my projects that i worked on in finland where one-third of the finnish population is supported through helsinki university hospitals and they're actually using american cloud providers and we were able to implement far more ai technology in this framework than we were able to do in sweden in fact in sweden we weren't able to do that at

all because they are very close now through shrams and and many other other aspects so there's a lot of how to say yeah resistance that's maybe a good work word so yes and i might just mention a couple of companies as i alluded to before i go through them relatively quick and will highlight also their cultural background and how that played a role some and i will mention the big companies that many of you know like hewlett h m hennes and maurits the heads of ais and those responsible for ai in these nordic countries we're actually quite well connected we have many meetings and talk about the latest let's say and um if i just mention h m without making any i would say like uh you know like advertisement but they are using um as part of the founders approach a democratization of ai whereby they want as many people in the company hundreds of thousands of employees worldwide uh to use ai and the and the technologies and the capabilities of of ai

essentially in the company and this comes from the same culture of democratizing fashion uh and one of the twists is that they realized early on that there's far too little talent for all the projects they have strategically laid out to achieve they're focusing a lot of time to value having use cases implemented as fast as possible and they realize they just cannot hire enough people they have very very aggressive hiring targets to have ai scientists and data scientists hired but what they did instead is they started having a horizontal approach and an approach with which they called fountainhead meaning that you have basic capabilities and you can start enabling anyone in the company to use these types of capabilities um ericsson very well known there's essentially really ericsson huawei who are providing the new networks like 4g 5g 6g and so on huge efforts made if you go to the ericsson website you see a tremendous amount of ai use cases which are used to make 5g networks very effective without ai there won't be

any 5g or 6g in an effective effective terms i mentioned novo nordisk already before in denmark focusing as a big company on drug discovery i spoke at the royal society of medicine in london before and that was the first time holly scene was discovered an antibiotic drug and that would have only been possible using deep learning so companies like novo nordisk and astrazeneca are starting to see what opportunities there are hiring top people and looking essentially into into this and into these opportunities and equino i mentioned earlier uh i just want to mention a couple of startups too which are many of you know the successful ones like spotify and uh minecraft and so on the ones that are now on the horizon um are silo.ai it's a company from finland it's the largest european ai lab with about 150 phd phds in ai machine learning that are helping companies to to scale establish companies to scale and they're doing really well have they have 100 growth um in the system and they also have

a pretty unique history as to how they were supported by finland and how they have been uh have been growing then there's a company from denmark doing really well in patient consultation they have also received a lot of recognition from brussels as being one of the european ai companies that are i think they're in the top 10 or one of the one of the best companies that we have in europe and they are focusing among other things on phone calls and emergency services so an ai is listening to the emergency calls that you are performing and they are used for example in sweden and other places in the in the world and overhearing what you say and capture the same information than the human operator and essentially enhances the overall accuracy of what has been discussed then there's sidekick health from from iceland they just receive 55 million euro something of that sort in order to become better in helping patients in their consultations and there's also depict ai on their their tagline by by

oliver who's a ceo and he's about i think 17 or 18 now that he got about 40 million dollars now is to have amazon lying recommendations for any e-commerce website so i think these are some of these companies that are doing quite well and some of the reasons why they do well is they focus a lot on ease of implementation and integration of their of their software uh happy to go into it more but i would like to conclude and i'm not sure if the time is completely accurate that we have here with a couple of recommendations or some reflections so all the things that i mentioned now um i believe that these things are relevant for startups any startup whether one is starting in munich in paris and amsterdam berlin or in or in the nordic countries be aware of your ecosystem is the market in which you're operating really your best beachhead market so in other words is that your best starting market given the cultural and the infrastructural conditions right so it's

very important it doesn't mean because you are in berlin that's the best starting point or in stockholm for that matter and also the same for investors of course how how should you invest are you fully aware of the competition that exists and in terms of politicians that could be a good ending note i have been discussing a lot with the nordic ministers and also with other ministers in the baltics and in europe as to how these ai strategies should be utilized and as i have been speaking to them advising them discussing with them online also what should be what should be implemented these ai strategies as interesting as they are and as many of us are essentially aware i feel they are a little bit of a hiding um hiding point for politicians not to be too critical but they are often not prepared by the politicians themselves or their teams but you have consultancy companies collecting this information what i'm missing in the entire european system and that's the same also in the nordic

countries is a strong vision a jfk like a vision of how to use ai to do big things like curing cancer or doing something else jfk 50 years ago said hey we shoot the man to the moon and bring him back alive and that is the vision statement where you're leaning forward you're taking a risk you don't even have the technology available but what it does it brings together people it brings together the mindset it brings together the the talent talent will become attracted again to these moonshot projects they have purpose and becoming part of these uh events and i think that this is a very important part of being a politician so i have indeed challenged kindly challenged um nordic economy ministers to become a bit more vocal and stronger and taking a bigger risk because i believe it is their job to create this framework which is attractive for startups and for talent so if you like to be in in contact with us you can reach us on this email visit the

website and i'm happy to support startups um and also vc funds investors that's one of the things that we are doing so voila i'm over christianity yeah really impressed he did that all in free speech and actually you prepared some slice didn't you i did yeah yeah yeah yeah well done thank you thank you congratulations thank you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.