Rise of AI Conference 2019 · Berlin

Living in the Post-AI World

Charles-Edouard Bouée · CEO, Roland Berger

At Rise of AI 2019 in Berlin, Charles-Edouard Bouee, CEO of Roland Berger, revisits his 2018 thesis and reports on where AI actually stands a year later. He recaps "portable AI," a personal cloud he compares to Jiminy Cricket and to Joy from Blade Runner 2049, arguing that GAFAM and the Chinese BAT platforms are on the last stretch of their exponential growth because portable AI will eventually replace their revenue sources, while traditional companies fighting digital leaders, startups, platforms and their own IT systems have more future than they think. He says progress has been slower than he expected: every client mentions AI on earnings calls, but few actually use it, and GAFA companies mostly apply basic machine learning to harvest existing data, such as Amazon optimizing warehouse robots and server uptime, rather than building genuinely advanced AI. He argues GDPR benefits Europe by protecting the personal-cloud data that portable AI will need, and gives companies practical advice: start small, focus on real business problems, and treat cloud computing skeptically, since he estimates 95 percent of it is storage rather than processing. He closes with predictions for 2029, picturing AI as everything, everywhere, for everyone.

Key takeaways

  • Bouee says traditional companies have more future than expected once portable AI helps them fight digital leaders and platforms.
  • He says GAFA companies mostly harvest existing data with basic machine learning rather than build advanced AI.
  • He argues GDPR benefits Europe by protecting the personal-cloud data future portable AI systems will need.
  • He estimates 95 percent of cloud computing is data storage rather than actual data processing.
  • He predicts AI in 2029 will be everything, everywhere, for everyone, reshaping every industry like the internet did.

Detailed notes

Recap: portable AI and human augmented intelligence

Bouee recaps three points from his 2018 talk: portable AI, a personal cloud he illustrates with Jiminy Cricket and Joy from Blade Runner 2049, will be the next big thing and will replace today's platform winners the way earlier ten-year cycles replaced IBM and mobile phones; GAFAM and China's BAT platforms are on the last part of their exponential curve because portable AI will wipe out their current revenue sources; and traditional companies, besieged by digital leaders, startups, platforms and their own legacy IT systems, have more future than they think once positive AI lets them fight back. He also recaps his idea of human augmented intelligence (HAI), arguing humans are coming back into the picture and citing consulting as a profession that will persist.

Why AI adoption is slower than expected

Bouee reports that a year on, the field is moving more slowly than he expected: every client now mentions AI on earnings calls because analysts punish companies that do not, yet very few companies actually use it. He argues that what GAFA companies present as advanced AI is mostly basic machine learning and deep learning applied to harvesting data already collected from users, for example Amazon optimizing a warehouse of 5,000 robots, its logistics chain and server uptime rather than predicting the future. On data protection, he takes the opposite view from Kai-Fu Lee, arguing GDPR is good for Europe because it protects the personal-cloud data that portable AI will depend on in ten years.

Practical advice for traditional companies and startups

Bouee tells traditional companies to "learn to walk, drive, fly" before expecting to "go to the moon," and tells startups to sell clients concrete machine learning and deep learning applications on existing data rather than promises about huge data lakes, noting that he estimates 95 percent of cloud computing is data storage, not processing. He names healthcare, fintech and education as the industries with the most near-term potential because of high transaction costs and volume, citing France as home to two of the world's five best healthcare databases. His golden rules: proofs of concept are easy to sell but production is hard to maintain, so ask what business problem needs solving before proposing AI, favor business-driven innovation, take baby steps, and think about the data first.

Predictions for 2029

Bouee predicts AI in 2029 will be defined by three E's: everything, everywhere, for everyone, touching every industry the way the internet did in the 1990s. He illustrates this with existing products: Predictive, which estimates the odds of winning a legal case; Detective, software that compiles a full briefing on people before a meeting; Neo, which recommends who to team up with on a project; and Netflix, where he says algorithms acting as artificial clients now shape what gets produced. He also cites Google Duplex, a movie script he says was built with Watson from a corpus of science-fiction films, which qualified for Writers Guild of America royalties, and the AI-powered website builder The Grid. He demonstrates the WT2 earphone translator, a device from a Chinese company inspired by the film Wandering Earth by Liu Cixin, that translates spoken conversation in real time across more than 20 languages.

Quotes

First, learn to walk, drive, fly, and then maybe I can bring you to the moon. There's no magic.

Charles-Edouard Bouee

If it's written in Python, it's machine learning. If it's written in PowerPoint, it's probably AI.

Charles-Edouard Bouee

Questions answered in this talk

What is "portable AI"?

According to Charles-Edouard Bouee at Rise of AI 2019, portable AI is a personal cloud, comparable to Jiminy Cricket or Joy from Blade Runner 2049, that he expects to eventually replace the revenue sources of today's platform companies.

Is GDPR good or bad for Europe's AI future?

According to Charles-Edouard Bouee at Rise of AI 2019, GDPR is good for Europe, unlike the view held by Kai-Fu Lee, because in the coming personal-cloud era it will protect the data that portable AI systems need.

How much of cloud computing is actual data processing rather than storage?

According to Charles-Edouard Bouee at Rise of AI 2019, about 95 percent of the cloud is used for storing data, with only the remaining share used for deep learning and machine learning processing on demand.

Mentioned

a"": ""According to Charles-Edouard Bouee at Rise of AI 2019

Keep exploring

More from Rise of AI Conference 2019

More on AGI & Future of Intelligence

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 3,343 words

Show the full transcript

Very happy to be with you today. As you know, uh last year and I'm very happy that we changed the Is it working? Yes. Last year was my birthday, so on the 17th. So, I'm happy that we changed the date to the 16th, so I'm coming back. Otherwise, I don't come back. It was the first time and last time I was making a speech on my birthday. Um but today I want to share with you some ideas, flashback on last year. So, last year what we discussed is first is portable AI. That it will be the next big thing. Because and I will not go over it. I can go over it offline. Because we had three waves and now we are entering a wave where artificial intelligence and portable AI will replace uh the winners of today.

It's been cycles of 10 years. 10 years with IBM. You know, 10 years with the portable phones, 10 years with the platform, and the days are counted. What is portable AI? I'll go fast because I explained last year. Portable AI is uh a personal uh cloud. It's uh something that is looking like That's why you I'm using very simple image. Jiminy Cricket for you Those of you who are more in the '40s, 1940s, not 2040s. And uh Blade Runner 2049, Joy. And the implication is and this is the second point is from last year that the GAFAM, the BAT, the uh FAMGA, whatever you call them, uh are on their last part of the exponential curve.

Because the all their sources of revenue will be wiped out by the portable AI. The third point we discussed last year is that traditional companies and I hope some of them are in this room, some of them at least on the sponsor group uh have more future than they think. Because today, and this is our clients, they are surrounded by four enemies. Digital leaders, startups, platforms, and their own IT systems, which is uh endearing them from uh change. And tomorrow with positive AI, they will be able to uh fight this uh challenges. By the way, a small indication and then as you know, I'm traveling the world, I'm spending my time mostly in a plane.

Um the cost of acquiring client online has become more expensive in China than acquiring client offline. Because the little screen that you have in your pocket is totally fully full. There's no more space to acquire you. And this therefore the prices are going up. And if they have already acquired you, they don't need someone else to acquire you. And that's why people are shifting and people are thinking that the BAT are moving offline because they are, you know, smart or whatever. It's just not smart, it's just cheaper. I think if you holding some of these assets, don't sell them cheap because they need them dearly. Last flashback and uh it's quite important just before I get into my main part is the new era of human augmented intelligence because the title of my master um speech last year was moving from AI to HAI.

Human augmented intelligence. And I think we have all to get ready that humans are back, which I think is good good news. Uh which I will ask Fabian, thanks for inviting me again to put some special stage on humans. I think we should have a special human section uh not only on AI. And that means that in the world of tomorrow we will have this human augmented intelligence. I was with a journalist this morning asking me about consultant. I believe that consultant is the second oldest profession and will be be there for quite a while. So, now where are we? The problem is, and you can see on this mirror, we don't know where we are.

What is sure is disruption is coming on artificial intelligence and I I wanted to report to you where we stand because we are we are I'm sure that in the long term something will happen. But if when I report to you, I think that the problem we have is that we are still slow. And I think the people in this audience and also the people in this conference are all pushing AI. And as a strategist, as a author of books and researcher and working with clients, I have to say that we are not moving fast, huh. There's a lot of hype, as you know. Companies are pushing back and I think this is a first point you should know, which is everybody is talking about AI in the earning calls.

I don't have any single clients who's not talking about artificial intelligence in their earning calls. Because if they don't talk, the analysts say, "You're you're old company, you lost." But if you look at how many companies are really using AI, very very little. So, we are really backwards and not moving as fast as I was expecting last year. And I'm really hoping because, you know, at the time I was making my speech, the cryptocurrencies, the ICO were on the hype. And you see what it is now and I'm seriously hoping that even though I believe and I will show you in a few minutes in the long term of AI that we're not going to crash like the Bitcoin bubble.

The other thing is everybody is talking about AI portable AI, but if you look at what the startups are doing is piecemeal work. And I come back to the GAFA, what they're doing is not portable AI, it's not advanced AI, it's mostly machine learning and deep learning harvesting the data they have taken from us. Voice recognition will be the next big thing. I I finished my keynote with this topic, which I think is very important. On data protection and GDPR, even though Kai-Fu Lee could not come today, he's in in Paris and I will see him tomorrow and he is a big advocate that GDPR is dangerous for Europe. To the contrary, I believe and if you you read the slide on the portable AI that GDPR is good for Europe because in 10 years everyone will have a personal cloud that protects your data.

And GDPR will be the key and this is something we need to work on. So, if you look at the GAFA, they're just doing basic work. You know, they are displaying very strong KPIs, so they're not dead yet. But what they're doing is basically harvesting with machine learning basic basic algorithm. If you think about Amazon, we always think, "Okay, they are incredibly smart and they they are trying to predict the future." No. They're just looking at a warehouse with 5,000 robots and they're just optimizing it. They're looking at the logistic channel and they're just optimizing it. They're looking at uptime of their server because when you're clicking, they want you to buy and if the server is down, you're not buying.

So, basically, while we think these players are kind of building the future and of course there's a Google X and there's some research, they are only harvesting the present. And that's something that traditional companies should know. Market cap are going up. As I told you, the next trillion-dollar company and I know that they touched the trillion, I was a bit annoyed, but they went back down. Uh next trillion-dollar company will be an AI company, which we don't know yet. Traditional firms, as I said, they need to use basic tools. You know, when we meet clients, they ask me, "Okay, how can I go to the moon?" I said, "First, learn to walk, drive, fly and then I maybe I can bring you to the moon.

There's no magic. I think the startup in this room should be very careful. Don't come to clients and sell them an incredible story. Just sell them machine learning, deep learning application on their existing data. Don't talk to them about the big data lake of terabyte of data or even more. I mean, you have to know we are talking about the cloud, but 95% of the cloud is storing data. It's not processing data. And the trend is even more. And the 5% which is left and available is mostly deep learning, machine learning on demand through cloud computing. The industry, and I was asked this morning, what are the industry with the most potential? Of course, in the short run, this is where you have high cost of transaction and high volume.

So, you can see health care, fintech, education. By the way, the best database of on health care is in France. Two of the best database in the world are in France out of the top five. So, we European have very structured data, of course, which we need to protect, which will allow us to harvest. Last but not least, a couple of golden rules. It's very easy to prototype, so it's very easy for a startup to sell a POC. It's almost impossible to maintain production. So, please reach out to us with our Terra NiMata platform because we are doing the bridge between you startup and the big clients. Favor business-driven innovation. You know, I was with two AI specialists.

We had the executive committee aboard of a large docs company, and they were asking about AI. So, we did an alpha day, and then the board members said, "Okay, but what can we do with AI?" And then this AI specialist said, "First, ask the problem you want to solve." Ask the problem you want to solve instead of thinking there's a magicians from this room coming, and then they will they will bring some crazy stuff. AI is market inside before action. Baby steps. And last but not least, think about the data. So, having said this, what is the future holding for us and I want to put you a bit forward, fast forward, in 2029. So, the future you know, sci-fi, and I'm a big sci-fi fan.

Remember last year at my conclusion. They invented the credit card in 1888, they invented the automatic door in 1899, the voicemail in 1924. So, sci-fi is a predictive of the future. I mean, some of you have seen this movie. This is a robot taxi. We in 1990. Sci-fi Logan's Run, so this is for the older one. I was a kid at that time. Smartphone. Voice assistant. And then after sci-fi you have the military. And then I made the point quickly last year. CALO became Siri. 2003. The US Army changed the military doctrine in 2004. Who knows in this room light footprint? Raise your hand. Okay, you read my book, maybe. Uh in 1995 the US Army War College, 1995.

At that time we had these big phones and we had America Online merging with Time Warner before they collapsed. The US Army War College worked on the new wars. And they say what's going to be the new wars? And they say it's going to be VUCA, volatile, actually it was violent, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous. And they they worked for 9 years on what is the measure you need to take to win these wars. And in '04 they invented the doctrine called light footprint. And this replaced shock and awe. And that from that day, you can date it, '04 was the announcement, they started the CALO and the grand challenge on the automatic car and the drones and everything else.

So, what will be AI in 2029? It will be what I call the E3 or the three E's. Everything, everywhere, for everyone. So, when people asking me, "Which industry you're going to be challenged?" Every single industry. Think about yourself as back in the '90s on the internet. So, where some people in reality are making more money from doing websites, machine learning, than them from doing crazy platforms. And what we're going to see is that it's going to go all over the world and everywhere. That we will be to we will be able to have this not only this possible AI, but this capability of all over the world. And if I give you some examples, what if you could really predict the future?

And some of you have seen this movie, where he's predicting the future. So, you're going to say 2029, "Okay, it's nice. It's bullshit." But today there are companies, that's why I wanted to give you the examples. A company called Predictive. I'm not saying this is the best you should invest, but Predictive can tell you if a legal action will work, if you will win, using artificial intelligence to predict your chances. So, next time you're doing a lawsuit, at least you can try this software. What's on the UI take and predict also the fashion trend, to see what will be the trend of tomorrow. And that's in 2019. This is today. So, people are starting to predict the future.

What if an AI could brief you about a third party? You all going to meetings. I'm going to meeting. Look at her. She's about to arrive in the meeting, and she's getting the full briefing. You're going to tell me again, "It's sci-fi, Mr. Boye. You're crazy." But Detective, who knows Detective in this room? Raise your hand. Detective is a software that allows you to give you a detailed briefing on your next meeting. Because it will search on the internet all the information and gather it into a file that allows you to prepare your meeting effectively. I mean, it's good for your business. Neo is a software that allows you to determine who are the best people to team up with you on a project.

And I know that on startups, you're okay looking you're calling your friends. But, there are some ways that you can be briefed and be more efficient using artificial intelligence. And this is really the next wave. What if your clients were AI? I mean, you've seen this movie. Netflix, I mean, I'm not going to ask you who knows Netflix. Where's your hand? Okay. Uh Netflix is saying that most of its clients are artificial intelligence. Because we can basically the client of Netflix are algorithm deciding what to sell to the clients. Based on the needs. So, at the end of the day, it's not the client who are shaping the Netflix. The clients are artificially intelligence shaping the needs of production for Netflix.

Of course, you have Google Duplex which which you know, which the demo was done last year. And I come back to this on natural language because I believe this is the next next big thing. What if unless you know, we all dream of sleeping and something is doing the work for us. What if in 2029, the artificial intelligence is doing the deliverable for us? You guys say again, this is Mr. Way, you're dreaming. But, in 2019, we have of course this maybe you've heard about this uh movie script. Have you Have you watched this movie that was built by Watson and some crazy people. Yes. I mean, basically they they've given the computer all the movies sci-fi movie which worked the best in history of humans and it compiled into a script which by the way made it to the Writers Guild of America because it was a it's a movie.

So, he has royalties. But, I would encourage you to watch the movie because you will find every single sentence of all the famous movie like I'll come back, you know, beam beam beam me beam me up. But, then it makes no sense because at this stage it's not completely accurate. The grid is if you want to build a website is an AI-powered system that allows you to automatically build a website given your requirements and objectives totally automated with artificial intelligence. So, having said this, where do we stand? And I want to show you something. Have you ever seen this? This is a voice recognition machine which allows you with two pods two people, two ears, and and just a phone in the middle to take the voice into text, translate automatically, and get to the other pod.

It's a slow machine. This is number 1,000. It's produced by a Chinese company. By the way, and I wanted to share with you. This is coming from a movie. Who has been hearing about Wandering Earth? Raise your hand. Are we sure you're in the AI conference? Where's Fabian? Fabian, you need to check the people coming next time. More seriously, this is a movie which was released in February in China by a very famous writer which is called Liu Cixin. Uh, will not tell you about the story, you can Google. But basically in the system, in the movie they're using this translation machine and I want to show you the demo. It's still a prototype, but I want to give you a feeling of what the future could be.

In today's world, there should be nothing that holds us back. That is why we created the WT2 translator. We aim to break down the communication barrier and our goal to inspire, empower, and connect. Using a simple, intuitive design, we built the first translator in the world to connect two earphones to just one app. The WT2 comes in a streamlined charging case, it wakes up and pairs automatically, making it ready at a moment's notice. Just peel, share, and start speaking. The WT2 has access to over 20 languages. With ask mode, you can ask anyone a quick question. Manual mode is built for busy, complex environments. And auto mode is for natural, hands-free conversation. Keeping in mind that communication is more than words.

It's expression, eye contact, and body language. The WT2 is built for sharing. Because across the world, we are meant to be connected. Okay. I I have no share in this company. Just to be clear. But I think this is If you think about us as European, our biggest challenge is the languages. I end up doing a speech in English today. By the way, I wanted to do the demo with Timekettle, but they are in Paris for Vivatech, so we had to organize, but I hope next year we can do a demo. And you will be totally impressed because you know, in real time you get on the screen, I can speak in French, it gets into Chinese, English, and so on.

So, the conclusion, whatever you are and I'm on time, your vision of the future is after this keynote and I told you last year that you knew your brain has changed in the last 20 minutes. Fortunately or unfortunately, but it changed. So, whether you think like Jeff Bezos that um we're going to move into a amazing renaissance. Whether you think that um the difference between machine learning and AI is very simple. If it's written in Python, it's machine learning. If it's written in PowerPoint, it's probably AI. I think you should take this very seriously. And last but not least, and this is back to the old time from Andre Maurois, machines treat badly those we don't like them.

So, we need to make sure we own the future and we manage this machine. And as a last slide, one more. I reported to you that after 1 year I'm very disappointed of the work we did together as a community of AI. So, I'm encouraging all of us that in this AI bright future, we have to work together to deserve it and to build a very strong European ecosystem. Thank you.

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.