Rise of AI Conference 2023 · Berlin

How to Create and Grow AI Ecosystems

Tina Klüwer, Alexandra Beckstein, Thomas Neubert, Johannes Otterbach

At Rise of AI 2023 in Berlin, a panel with Tina Klüwer (director of KIEZ, the Berlin universities' AI entrepreneurship center), Alexandra Beckstein (co-founder and CEO of QAI Ventures), Thomas Neubert (founder of the Transatlantic AI eXchange, formerly at Intel) and moderator Johannes Otterbach (VP at Merantix Momentum) discusses how to build and grow AI ecosystems in Europe. Klüwer contrasts the individual, deep-dive culture of academic research with the fast, collaborative but shallower startup ecosystem, and argues both need exchange to succeed. Beckstein describes building a quantum and AI hub in Basel, Switzerland, where her venture fund gives startups corporate-partner projects, mentoring and hardware access, and flags that Europe has only two quantum-focused VC firms and just one fund investing in AI startups from Series C onward. Neubert traces his experience bringing Silicon Valley graphics technology to market and building the Transatlantic AI eXchange from a hobby into a network of over 8,500 followers and 25 events in two years. The panel discusses Europe's market fragmentation, the need to attract and retain talent, the balance between innovation and regulation, and the cultural mindset shift needed for European AI founders to take more risks.

Key takeaways

  • Klüwer says academic ecosystems favor deep individual work while startup ecosystems favor fast, shallower collaboration, but both need exchange to succeed.
  • Beckstein says Europe has only two VC firms investing in pure quantum technology and just one fund investing in AI startups from Series C onward.
  • Neubert built the Transatlantic AI eXchange from a free hobby project into a network of over 8,500 followers and 25 events in two years.
  • Neubert argues Europe will likely never be as unified as the US given its history, so the goal should be maximizing output within its fragmentation.
  • Klüwer argues public discourse focuses too much on AI's risks and too little on its potential, discouraging young founders.

Detailed notes

Academic versus startup ecosystems

Tina Klüwer, who has founded and exited several AI companies and now leads KIEZ, the Berlin universities' AI entrepreneurship network, contrasts academic and startup ecosystems from her own experience straddling both. She says academic work tends to be individual, with small groups digging deep into a topic over years, while startup culture is fast-moving and collaborative but less deep, with people constantly exchanging ideas. She argues that exchange, interaction and feedback from peers are the crucial ingredient both ecosystems need to succeed, and that concrete shared tasks, rather than abstract goals, are the biggest motivator for groups working together.

Venture capital as an ecosystem magnet

Alexandra Beckstein describes how her firm QAI Ventures built a quantum-and-AI hub in Basel, Switzerland, giving startups hardware access to industry. She says that before QAI Ventures had a fund, startups would look around, connect with universities or corporate partners, and leave again; once the fund existed, it became a magnet that keeps startups engaged through global corporate-partner projects, one-to-one mentoring, and free access to quantum and AI hardware. She cites one German startup now going through a five-month investment and mentoring process that has already produced three customers through QAI Ventures' network. She also warns that Europe has only two VC firms investing in pure quantum technology, and only one fund investing in AI startups from Series C onward, which she calls a real problem for raising bigger tickets, alongside regulatory uncertainty and university-held IP rights on startup spinouts.

Building the Transatlantic AI eXchange from a hobby to a network

Thomas Neubert, who moved to Silicon Valley from Germany decades ago and later spent six years at Intel leading AI incubation programs, recalls helping bring 3D graphics workstation technology to the PC market despite no existing software-vendor ecosystem, and says the lesson he has since reapplied is to keep things simple and always answer the question "what's in it for" every party involved, from VC to entrepreneur to channel partner. He describes starting the Transatlantic AI eXchange two years ago as a free hobby project connecting Silicon Valley AI experts with European research institutions, universities, startups and incubation programs, inspired partly by a paper called "AI Made in Germany." It has grown into hybrid events in London, Munich, Berlin and Düsseldorf, with over 8,500 followers and 25 events reaching more than 120 experts, all run for free.

Fragmentation, talent retention and raising bigger funds

The panel discusses why Europe's fragmented national, language and regulatory borders slow ecosystem building compared with the United States' single government, language and huge capital base. Klüwer says Europe must stop losing researchers who leave to continue their work elsewhere and needs to attract and retain both young and experienced talent. Neubert argues Europe will likely never be as unified as the United States given a thousand years of separate history, so the practical question is how to maximize output within that fragmented environment; he also praises the energy he now sees in Berlin's incubators, comparing it to Silicon Valley 10 to 15 years ago, and cites a forecast of 27 percent annual growth in the generative AI market over the next decade as reason to attract more capital.

Sovereignty, regulation and the risk-versus-potential debate

On European technological sovereignty and AI regulation, Klüwer argues an ecosystem should represent all its stakeholders' perspectives, including startups, universities and large enterprises, and bring those views to decision makers, while warning against staying siloed in national "gardens" instead of collaborating globally. Neubert says he has shifted his own view after attending sessions at the European Commission's new San Francisco office, and now believes Europe's value-driven, privacy-focused approach to regulation is well positioned to set a global standard, noting that historically it was European regulators, not American ones, who fined Microsoft and Google for misbehavior. Klüwer argues public discourse focuses too heavily on AI's risks and too little on its potential, and calls for more visible role models and a stronger culture of tolerating failure to encourage young European founders.

Q&A highlights

Asked where Europe's entrepreneurial mindset shift is happening fastest, Neubert says he cannot yet point to a specific unicorn but describes the spirit and energy he now sees in incubators such as Merantix's AI campus in Berlin as comparable to Silicon Valley years ago, while cautioning that the capital infrastructure to take startups to the next funding round is still missing. Closing on what each panelist wants to see in the next 12 months, Klüwer expects more applications built on foundation and large language models; Neubert hopes for a shared Western AI regulatory framework and five to ten new European AI unicorns; and Beckstein wants to see deeper two-way convergence between AI and quantum computing.

Quotes

If you keep it simple, you have to simply answer the question: what's in it for?

Thomas Neubert

There is only one fund that invests from Series C on in Europe into AI startups, and I think this is a real problem.

Alexandra Beckstein

I'm getting asked a lot about the risks of AI, and I almost never get asked about the potential of AI.

Tina Klüwer

Questions answered in this talk

How many VC funds invest in AI startups from Series C onward in Europe?

According to Alexandra Beckstein at Rise of AI 2023, only one fund in Europe invests in AI startups from Series C onward, which she calls a real problem for raising larger funding rounds.

What makes a healthy startup and academic ecosystem, according to Tina Klüwer?

According to Tina Klüwer at Rise of AI 2023, both academic and startup ecosystems need constant exchange, interaction and feedback among peers, even though academic work tends to be individual and deep while startup work is fast and collaborative but shallower.

Why is Europe's AI ecosystem more fragmented than that of the United States?

According to Thomas Neubert at Rise of AI 2023, Europe lacks the single government, single language and unified capital base the US has, and instead has separate national, cultural and legal systems built over a thousand years of history, which he doubts will fully unify.

Mentioned

AI ecosystem, technological sovereignty, AI regulation, venture capital, quantum computing, foundation models, large language models

Keep exploring

More from Tina Klüwer

More from Rise of AI Conference 2023

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 7,196 words

Show the full transcript

foreign panel session uh on the topic of how to create and grow AI ecosystems so maybe to frame the conversation a little bit and to to get started um what I'm very excited about that latest with the release of jet gbt AI has actually made it to dinner table conversations so um that's something new like everybody in the room knows that AIA has been around at least 10 years with the image moment but we have never really discussed it image that was like a really big release and since then uh the big companies like Amazon Google Apple Facebook they really have driven forward um the development and Adoption of AI and of course we all know that it happened in the valley they built a very high capacity really talented pool of of people that are educated in the valley staying in the valley ready to build and productionize AI system it's a really really healthy ecosystem and with the question of like how um that ecosystem is very very rich and and uh fruitful

we have seen now recently a Cambrian explosion of AI systems in in that system making this ecosystem even richer and even faster and even more accelerating and I want to discuss with uh my fellow panelists here how we actually address the challenges in in the European ecosystem where we are significantly uh much smaller and how we create a healthy and Innovative ecosystem here in Europe so with me are first of all uh dratina Glover she is the director of Keats which is the center for AI entrepreneurship a network for startup Services of the Berlin universities in the Charité she has founded several AI companies already has also brought them to successful exits so it has a lot of experience in this and also as an advisor on many councils such as the Technologies for entity Council of the German Federal minister of Education and Research as well as the young digital economy of the Federal Ministry of economy and climate action next uh to write off me is Alexandra beckstein she's the CEO and co-founder

of Kai Ventures a company focused on building ecosystems in the quantum and AI space so I'm super excited to have also some Quantum here on the panel she has also worked for a lot of startups so it brings a lot of expertise in these very young early stage ventures in here and worked in the sector of renewable energies and published a book on how to be successful in shaping the future last but not least is also Thomas Neubert with me he's a Syria entrepreneur with a lot of expertise in building and evangelizing new Innovations and markets he's the founder of the transatlantic exchange and also the founder of wow Dow a block-based AI ecosystem and has done a lot of long list of experiences working for various different companies on both sides of the aisle too long to actually mention all of them we might get into some of them so welcome everyone so to kick it off maybe I'll start with you Tina as a core member of Keith you're typically dealing with two

ecosystems right like you're dealing with the academic ecosystem and also the startup ecosystem and to kick us off like what's your experience or your impression of a healthy ecosystem what are current characteristics that are typical uncommon in all of these ecosystems that are healthy visual intelligence and then I found at a company I dived into the whole startup ecosystem and now I'm bringing it all together and I think they differ quite a lot actually yeah so the academic ecosystem is quite different from the startup ecosystem from my perspective and it felt totally different to work in both there are some common things but in Academia you usually are more much more on your individual work yeah so there's a lot happening that you do by yourself and even if you work in a team or develop something together there's always this individual component to it and on the other hand in the startup ecosystem there's a lot of collaboration and things go super fast and people talk to each other and exchange a lot of

ideas but you don't go so deep yeah so in research you have the ability or the scalability to to come together in small groups and dig really deep into a topic right and you stay with that topic for some years this is what research actually is for right so that you get some new insights if you stay with us with this topic and you can elaborate on it on the other hand I think what both ecosystems need to be successful is exchange yeah so if there's no exchange if you don't interact if you don't express your ideas if you don't get feedback from your peers if you don't work together on a certain task then there's no success for nobody right so I think that's a actually The crucial thing about those ecosystems and it's always helpful if you work together yeah like concrete work it's not like something abstract if you have groups shaping around a certain task and then everybody does whatever they can to bring this task to success that's always a

big motivator thank you very much for that um maybe drawing on that like because we want to Foster transfer from uh academic research into Ventures itself um maybe for you Alexandra um how does venture capital actually support this like how can we leverage Venture and what role does it play in actually making this transition happen and creating and bringing these ecosystems together so out of my experience venture capital is a crucial part when it comes to building ecosystems we try it without actually what we do is we build a Quantum ecosystem within a Quantum Hub that we built in Basel in Switzerland giving access Hardware access to the industry and startups are crucial for us to come into this ecosystem and startups before we had a venture fund startup they came they had a look what we do they found it quite interesting they connected maybe with the universities or with some corporate Partners but then they left again since we have this fund everything is different so it's really a big magnet for Global

startups it's a magnet but it's not the course why they stay so they they get get attracted by the venture capital um and what we do is as soon as we invest we want the startups to stay with us so it means we give them projects with our corporate partners that can be also globally we give them a coaching individual coaching one-to-one mentoring um we give them free access to Quantum and AI hardware and services around so they can leverage their knowledge and their technology and this is what uh what Venture Capital allows us to do so I think for me venture capital is the is a very crucial part out of experience I can say it's the most crucial part for us when it comes to building ecosystem a very nice example what I have is or what we want to reach is one startup they approach that they actually from Germany um they approached us uh with a for for venture capital and what they will get now is we will invest in

them we are now in the process of investing they will have a mentoring they will stay with us five months and the most important for me is they already found three customers over our Network which which whom they will work now they will start projects now very Advanced very good projects and yeah this is actually what we do and what Venture Capital makes um possible so um moving on to uh to Thomas from from here on uh you've seen many many ecosystems you have also built many many ecosystems from your experience like what does it take like can you give some examples like how do you really get an ecosystem off and ground and scale it it's a good question um so first of all being German raced born in Germany I moved to Silicon Valley 32 years ago and in my first job in Silicon Valley I had the honor to work with somebody in the 3D graphic art industry at the time now I'm aging myself and that person had an incredible talent

to build an ecosystem that didn't exist at all so think of it as there was then this is now 25 27 years ago there was silicon Graphics I don't know if somebody remembers that company and there was the workstation industry and then there was the PC industry they're two different Industries and this particular person um with myself introduced the technology to bring the whole super expensive workstation industry down to a Windows workstation PC for a fraction of the cost now that was a technical physical Revolution but there was no customer no isv an independent software vendor industry so how do you convince these people who are developing super expensive software for an industry that are making a lot of margins the movie industry and whatever and here comes this small company we had a graphic card we went to Microsoft we teamed up with them and how do you convince you know the the the new development Community to adopt this new thing where there was no Revenue no customers no Channel Partners no nothing

and the biggest thing that I learned during the time and I'm replicated it multiple times over is keep it simple keep it as simple as possible make it explainable and I live by actually I would say two things the first is I don't know if anybody knows or you know knows the the movie Field of Dreams with Kevin Costner and I love that saying if you will build they will come and it's actually it's it's really true and the other one is if you keep it simple you have to simply answer the question what's in it for question mark and the question mark is every entity involved in an ecosystem what's in it for the VC what's in it for the entrepreneur what's in it for the channel partner for the developer for the customer for the user if you can answer the question what's in it for question mark it's actually fairly easy to build an ecosystem so two years ago I had the opportunity to build a new ecosystem which is now for

me at least called the transatlantic AI exchange it started as a hobby I was until eight weeks ago I was with Intel I was a general manager at Intel around AI for incubation programs within Intel so I was there for six years this thing which is now as of eight weeks ago a full-time job because since jet gbt everybody seems to be an expert and everybody's talking about AI talking about timing you know if you build they will come yay um but but my point is when I started this I didn't have really a vision in specifically where I would be two years later like here on stage talking at this conference about Ai and we just went through the ChatGPT it was more about where's the need where's the value creation and how do you build an ecosystem around Ai and the trigger for me at the time was this paper that some of you actually know I didn't know at the time it was this paper called AI made in Germany and I

was like you know what we tried for 30 years to convince the Europeans to just kick the gear in startup and mindset and everything else so at the time I was like I want to connect the AI experts in Silicon Valley and connect them with the knowledgeable base of AI research institutions universities startups incubation programs and so on so I started to create an online a dating system is the wrong word um a web session on a monthly basis which has now grown into hybrid events in London in Munich in Berlin now I'm doing it in Dusseldorf and then back in Palo Alto and the ecosystem has grown literally within two years or less from zero to over eight and a half thousand followers 25 events with over 120 plus people who are really deeply experts and they have done it for free nobody has ever charged for any of my sessions and everything please go to transatlantic AI exchange all the sessions are for free there are sessions about Quantum Computing trustworthy AI incubation

programs and what have you so I keep it simple what's in it for a question mark if you can answer it pretty good I I would like to answer and there was one phrase that resonated with me is uh if you build it they will come right so maybe piggybacking off of that um you've seen it with Hardware Investments Quantum knows it and AI knows it as well it's like this is our very very cost costly measures to build it's really um Capital intensive and we also know the the the the German and the European Tech VC world is comparatively small to say in the US and Asia Pacific the problem is also they have there are more they have more capital and they're faster they have they're accelerating they're doing a lot of stuff so my question is maybe how can we first of all to Tina how can we catch up like why should we not give up like what is another what is illness for us well yeah I think that's a

tough question right um of course I hope that you will keep up um but we need to be realistic right so we are comparatively Small industry and we also in Europe have a fragmentation of countries nationalities and language borders so that's something that we always have to keep in mind but still there's hope in us for I'm hoping for us I think because we have also a lot of interesting findings and a lot of interesting people yeah so mostly it's about people I think we have interesting researchers for example here but usually what happens quite frequently is still that they decide to leave the country to continue their work somewhere else and I think this is something that we need to stop so we need to be attractive to those hats to those talents um because this is actually what will shape the future yeah so we need those young and also experience people to come together here and I think also what you said I agree with all of it but I just want

to add the aspect of people as well so from my experience um if you have this what is in for me that's the absolutely the fundament of it but then you also need the right people to build it up and if you find those seed of teams that will continue and support your work then you have a good chance and I think this is what we need to strengthen here and we need to strengthen the player that we have so that they don't decide to leave us and may I can add to that I have to I really have to complement what is going on at the moment in Germany many people in Silicon Valley particularly the German community and the veterans we were trying to pitch to the Germans you know mindset Everybody Knows by now Silicon Valley is not a place it's a mindset and I don't go into the details why but it is what it is I have never seen in 30 years so much progress with the younger generation of

startups particularly in the AI space now I hope this will continue and I hope that at least with everybody that I'm talking with they have the right mindset but the structure is still not there it's still slow it's still bureaucracy and paperwork and all of that stuff but in general the last two years amazing what Germany is doing right now in in regards to startups and Entrepreneurship so heads up all right that that's a really good point thank you so much and uh breaking uh uh uh bearing the torch for the for the German ecosystem so um I'm looking forward and I hope that you're right and that we keep the momentum going um the um to keep the momentum going of course we also need a lot of capital right um Alexandra how can we create a uh an ecosystem for the VCS where we can actually write bigger tickets right I have a lot of friends that want to to start actually uh building very complicated very Capital intensive products they can content

here like they go to U.S companies or give to Asia Pacific and to get the tickets correct so in in Quantum Quantum technology I know we have only two VCS VC firms in whole Europe that invest in pure Quantum we are one of them and we are new so there was all the way all the years only one Quantum fund in AI we have 14 funds that in invest in AI early stage until series A for the later stage startups we only have one fund there is only one fund that invests from series C on in Europe into AI startups and I think this is a real problem if you ask me how we can raise bigger funds there that's a good question I don't know we just have to try I think there is some challenges also we might face so for the investors maybe in Europe it um we have to we have to be clear about regulations this is a risk if the investor doesn't if there is no regulations but the

regulations are about to come so we're a bit hesitating and the second a second topic also for us is IP rights a lot of the startups come as a spinner from University and the patterns and the IEP are very often still with the university and they are not free with the startup this is also what we often see in Europe and I don't think this is so much the case in the US I think there is a huge difference maybe this would help to raise then bigger funds and to invest bigger tickets but I don't have an answer to this question how to how to actually raise bigger funds but I know we have to do it yeah but um it's it's uh for me um puzzling sometimes that we are talking about for example you said the German ecosystem or then the the French ecosystem or the Nordic ecosystem of course you you mentioned a very like very Splinter we have like cultural boundaries we have language boundaries why don't we try to uh

pull them better right like the whole European market is actually as big as the North American market like what's the challenge here that's a cultural question in my opinion honestly if I compare to the United States when I moved to the United States I made a joke but I actually meant it the United States in general is actually pretty inefficient there's a lot of problems in the United States don't get me wrong but there's one advantage that they have from east coast to West Coast massive amount of people massive amount of capital but they have one government one language and then some Regional stuff you can get away with a lot of mistakes if you have that giant engine behind you now you come over to Europe and yes you can say you know we all want Europe we are we like to be one Europe and I think we got there for the last 20 30 years but the reality is there's the French they are the Italians they are the Germans and then

within Germany there are the northern part then there is the western part and then there's Berlin and there's mule it's it's fragmented I actually don't believe that there will ever be a a Europe as unified as the United States but that's not a negative I don't want to be negative at all it's a fact of life it's a fact of a thousand years of a history that United States doesn't have so I think the question is more how do we maximize the output of the environment that we are in yes we can do it a little bit better but the fragmentation is there and I do not believe that it will go away anytime soon and it's also not about not just about a mindset right there are legal issues tax issues yeah if you cross the the Border there are different ways to handle things yeah so and you have to always if you add a new country to you want to sell to your product to you have to deal with that yeah

always you have to find again the way to do this in this country um I think I mean it can be done but it just takes a lot of resources thank you um maybe uh in another questions around this topic uh uh for the panelists also um what advice should we actually give to Young Founders in in this fragmented space right like you you're facing really challenging uh regulations which is the next topic that we're that we're getting into but like you're also facing uh a very fragmented Market you're facing uh problematic problems at scaling these these systems because you really have to jump the regulatory um fragmented Market uh really early you have small ticket sizes you have uh all these kind of channels like what's the advice that you would give to to Young founders think big don't give up don't think Regional try to collaborate yes yeah okay so collaboration we have I think big and don't give up okay that's that's a good grip um I like that maybe coming to

uh to the other topic which I already teased about um regulations right we hear about two different things we have about increasing Europe's technological sovereignty and regulating AI um so there are two key Concepts that are gonna shape the future of the European Texas the number it's not only the Germans like all of Europe because it's uh discussed at a European level um what role does does our ecosystem have to play here like where should we go uh what's the importance like from the VC side from like uh connecting people from like the transatlantic perspective how what is the role that we have to play and what is crucial for us to get right well as an ecosystem I think we need to be the mirror of all the different aspects and positions that are to be yeah keep kept in mind in that discussion um and I think I personally see the regulation um as something that is really like more like a threat to the AI industry than as a win just the

man in the way it is just now and I think what else what we can do about it is just to always make clear where we see the problems yeah so what are the issues that we see from our perspectives and if you have a ecosystem then you should have a lot of different players included there so for example startups or universities or industry and bigger Enterprises and they all do have a different perspective on regulation and I think it's important as an ecosystem also to bring those together and maybe frame it document it and bring it to the decision makers yeah so that there's every voice can be heard maybe what I experience I'm German but I work in Switzerland and in Switzerland we're totally out of these regulations um and we are very small country and we have to open up our ecosystem it's not worth anything without the global approach and I think this is also an approach what I see here now there is a lot of nationalism regionalism regionalistic thinking

maybe but if Germany or if we hear really or Europe wants to want to be a leader in ethical ai ai for good or whatever AI for impact or whatever you want to call it you have to know what the others are doing we have to try to collaborate to then also find by collaborating a common understanding in what we really want to reach and I think this is this is the key try to open up to collaborate and not to yeah to to just Garden in your to to do gardening in your own small garden it's a global development you cannot stop it you have to develop together that's my my experience also maybe that's a good good point to just try to get you a little bit to argue about this because like on one hand you say like collaborate right like we want to collaborate we have to do collaboration in order to have ecosystems on the other side um uh Thomas is involved in like trying to bridge gaps between uh

the transatlantic with translating collaboration so we're talking about sovereignty which is de facto saying like we don't want to collaborate what we would do want to collaborate but like a very controlled fashion right so where do we draw the boundaries for that well one thing is you we have to collaborate right I mean if you want to access a really big big Market all at once then you need to collaborate and tap into the ecosystem that is available to you in in North America in general when it comes to the regulations even I have to say I I pretty much changed my mind a few months ago uh people who know me for a long time for me regulations and stuff was almost like don't bother me I'm going for the opportunity I'm going for the technology I'm going for the use cases I want to build something the rest we will worry about it later that for me is not the case anymore I have to admit the reason is when I witness at

the moment what's going on on the European level and the European commission finally after two and a half years of begging they opened their first office in San Francisco they never had a representative there so every few weeks over the last few months they have sessions and normally the sessions in their office is primarily about regulations and the podium discussion and I went every single time I showed up physically and I am now convinced that the Europeans with their mindset value driven honestly data center I mean data privacy and stuff like that it is something that is of most urgency that needs to be addressed and we should do it better than when the internet was invented because we missed an opportunity to put some basic regulations in place and if you look at the last 20 years who find Microsoft or Google for misbehavior it wasn't the Americans it was the Europeans rightly so we in America we could care less we just have a different mindset right it's more capitalism and money and

return on investment here it's different what I have seen over the last few months very impressively is the Europeans are putting a stake in the ground now it's not perfect we heard this this morning unfortunately there's too much effort on all the stuff that is not working and things needs to be finalized and paperwork and stuff I think the balance is the right thing to do don't discuss things to death and the opportunity is gone because somebody will be faster but I do believe that the Europeans have the right and they are very well positioned right now to put fundamental AI regulations in place and force it in in a respectful way onto the Americans and anybody else if it's based on the value system that Europe has and I think even the Americans have recognized that once still but still the Europeans don't have the big cloud providers right I know yeah well you have to try yeah um the one of the things that of course with your regulations coming like that uh

it's it's a topic that is regularly discussed uh in in with my friend Sergo is in this in the US as well as here in Europe is that when we're talking about um regulations and we're talking about uh these these kind of effects uh that regulations have it's not only like actually um potentially stifling Innovation and say potentially because it's like not necessarily true um or being like a a showstopper to certain um types of system but there's also a secondary effect by discouraging people to actually try right like if you're really coming out of University or coming out of high school and you're really excited of building a piece of technology and then you start looking at the press and you're starting looking in like different types of political debates and people are always talking about like we have to regulate here we have to mitigate this we have to do this like if I were 20 that would really discourage me to build something how can we actually make this discourse into something

positive so that that we avoid uh um either pushing people out of of Europe to Foster The Brain Drain or even like uh stop them from being discouraged and not trying at all I think it's about the potential right so but this is something that we definitely need to in Europe Embrace a little bit better from my perspective so that we also talk at the same time then we talk about risk we talk about the potential and I'm getting asked a lot about the risks of AI but I almost never get asked about the potential of AI right sometimes someone asked me can you name just one example of something you can do with AI that's actually good yeah and the question itself also expresses the mindset I would say yeah so there's a lot of talking about the risks and not so much about potential and I think even if we make it more concrete and talk about the things that we already have yeah so very day-to-day things we use we used to

we have in our smartphones we have already built on AI and nobody actually cares yeah so and nobody also would ever want that to go away again because it's very convenient actually to have it yeah and also there maybe is not a risk included but we don't talk about those things yeah we always talk about the more General risks the more General broader questions of an artificial intelligence that sounds more like an entity that's similar to humans and I think that's what we need to change we need to have a different way of discussion agreed and I I would I like to compare it to a joke that I have been telling and sharing for 25 years there's always opportunities and there's always risk on anything it doesn't matter what right so you have to accept that but the fact is a German entrepreneur wants to pitch the idea to a VC two VCS sitting there someone in Silicon Valley and a German BC or european BC doesn't matter the entrepreneur gives the pitch and

then there are two responses the American VC says no sorry the German BCS or the European says why the Americans he says why not that little joke there's so much truth in the fundamental mindset of the culture that's one of the problems that we have if we balance that opportunity versus risk we will be in good shape but what we have seen 25 years ago in the internet boom in the social media 10 years later and the cloud service providers is always we here talking about the wise the problems the you know the negatives and the United States like let's do it look at Facebook Google I mean there's a reason why these companies are over there not saying it's all perfect but it is fundamental a mind shift that needs to take place which is already doing it but it's not fast enough and it's not aggressive enough yeah I mean when we talk about encouraging in general encouraging startups to to found them that they don't that they should not be afraid of

regulations and so on so I I also like to talk a lot about Role Models so what I think is we should also create a more playful uh uh surrounding for startups to actually try out we also we don't have a culture of failure so like regulations maybe would you just a picture is that the startup could be stopped by regulation and this is also in our culture to not even try and I think this is also a cultural problem what we have to what we have to tackle by creating Role Models by showing more startup Founders by bringing maybe serial Founders together with young startups in the universities having another education on this we don't have this founding culture I think this is also what we have to work on hmm so with that being a set I dominated the the debate right now with all of my questions but I'm sure that the audience has a lot of interesting questions to this panel so uh please it's all said no questions okay so

now I'm not sure that was the first one either but I was curious I agree there's a certain mind shift that needs to take place and um you mentioned it's happening uh could you maybe put a bit of a light on where it's happening uh and where it's happening fastest in terms of more individuals more investors more company having a more risk open uh mindset that comes closer to perhaps the the American globally known entrepreneurial mindset right of taking more risks and so on so I wonder where whether a good examples Best in Class examples of Europeans that take that Leap Forward right like in for the lack of a better example you know and I'm not saying I'm a fan or anything of that sort but an Elon Musk or Steve Jobs type personalized it would be maybe yeah so I wouldn't not necessarily look around and trying you know an equivalent to Elon Musk in in Germany and I'm glad I wouldn't found an Elon Musk in Germany to be honest with you

yeah exactly but I I give you an example and I'm I'm sticking a little bit more within the AI space when I had the idea to to do this bridge building between the two you know Silicon Valley and Germany I was not involved for many for six years when I was at Intel I had one business trip to Germany to talk about virtual reality augmented reality 3D perceptual Computing AI I was 15 times in China there was nothing going on here in Europe or in Germany on these topics including robotics to some extent robotics so here I'm coming over pretty fresh open-minded for AI and I have to say the examples that I have is uh on Monday I had an event together with other partners here in in Berlin at the marantix AI campus at the same time I have very good friends who helped me kick-start transatlantic AI exchanger sitting right here recognize their petos over there from AI handberg the when I go into a mirantic's office or AI campus or anybody

else how Bron Munich wherever this incubation facilities and the spirits of these younger entrepreneurs I have not seen that 10 years ago or 15 or 20 years ago so I couldn't tell you right now like a specific startup company who already is shining and is a unicorn over the last two years but it's yeah last two years but it's more if I and I love working with startups if I go into this incubator accelerated programs facilities the feel the way it actually physically looks it's like Silicon Valley 10 years ago 15 years ago maybe it's like a little bit lagging behind but the spirit and the energy and this positivity it's inspiring it's it's it's it's just awesome so if we can maintain that and even encourage a little even further and let's not goggle them up with you know government rule regulations and paperwork and stuff like that um I think you will see that there will be a massive amount of of startup companies maturing into an a round into a b round

into an MVP product in a year two to three years from now and I hope it keeps going but I'm I'm positive where I see a little bit of an issue is what we discussed before is that the amount of capital that's required to get them to that next level or even one level up that I'm concerned about that that that infrastructure that ecosystem backbone just doesn't exist at the moment but maybe it's also to build it then they come because now the market of generative AI it will raise I read in the next 10 years every year 27 percent so this is quite huge and I think with this Market opportunity maybe the VCS and the more money comes to invest in then there are probably plenty people in this room that need to convince the rich people in Germany who are normally more conservative put the money not in you know housing or whatever put them into an AI ecosystem startups that's what I would do foreign I think I saw one back

there as well but no um I actually don't have a question but I feel the need of um actually trying to change or do something or act and I think um what actually is still is is kind of because you mentioned the Mind shift and I think in Germany especially we have not really changed the mind yet I mean that means like for instance not drinking coffee up to like tomorrow stop it for like six seven months just stop stop never ever touch the coffee again and then you start really changing your mind and I think um that's what we have to do with the AI environment because around the globe like there are different mindsets in the globe like America or Africa India I just went to the UK last year and talked to Indian people and they are so fast and quick especially in the supply chain and uh in Germany we we discussed AI right now but it's already here so and now we are changing and trying to adapt but we

have to be adaptability right now and that's what I think um at least when I talk to people they still feel comfortable they fear the uh yeah I think you have to be uncomfortable to become comfortable and to work together that's true that's true the only constant in life is that nothing is constant period it's fact of life so we are unfortunately running out of time now but maybe uh in a as a final question maybe in like one or two sentences um rise of AI is happening each year the space is Extreme moving extremely fast what are you looking forward uh in the next 12 months like what do you want to actually see happening in the next 12 months and and have accomplished when you're coming back to Rice 2024.

sure I would like to see and I'm pretty sure we will see that many more interesting applications because just now we have a different way of putting more and easily and faster applications based on foundational models and we can already see that for us for example in kids we have new startup teams applying that use large language models as a fundament and then just build the application on that and of course that goes ways faster than just than training own models and I think what we will see is a lot of new applications popping up around this and building an ecosystem actually around those technologies that are now available and I'm pretty much looking forward to see all of those new Innovative applications Thomas in 12 months I think the first thing is I would love to see that based on the European leadership there's going to be an AI semi-global Western World framework of regulations that is acceptable for both sides that would be one and then the second is parallel to that effort

which I know is is huge is I would like to come back in a year if I'm being invited and I want to see a massive amount of startups having risen to the surface where the Europeans or the German ecosystem can say look in the last 12 months we have built pick a number five to ten new unicorns with an AI and then balancing that with the regulations act and then we're just Off to the Races right yeah what should I say I would like to see more connection of AI and Quantum and this in both sides so what we see now is we have a lot of AI use cases that will be leveraged with Quantum Computing if as soon as Quantum Computing is ready to to to work but also on the other side we see now the other way that the AI helps Quantum to leverage and this is a very interesting development and I think one year is quite a good time span where we will have a lot of development

and hopefully we will hear something about it next year all right great um thank you so much thank you so much to to you all let's give our fellas a round of applause and yeah okay so your

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.