Rise of AI Conference 2022 · Berlin · Meta Stage

Challenges of the European AI Ecosystem

Florian Schütz, Vanessa Cann, Joanna Bryson, André Loesekrug-Pietri

At Rise of AI 2022 in Berlin, a panel with Florian Schütz (K.I. Park), Joanna Bryson (Hertie School), André Loesekrug-Pietri (JEDI) and Vanessa Cann (German AI Association) discusses the state of the European AI ecosystem. Schütz opens by arguing that ecosystems are not needed to develop AI technology itself, but are essential to turn technology into real societal impact, since that requires values, regulation, funding, infrastructure, data, talent and users working together. Bryson presents patent and market-capitalisation data from a paper written with a colleague at DG Competition, arguing the EU and China are closer in AI patents and market capitalisation than commonly assumed, and that the US, not Europe, is the outlier. Loesekrug-Pietri describes building JEDI, a foundation modelled on DARPA, and criticises European fragmentation, weak deep-tech scale-up and dependency on foreign infrastructure, citing examples from space, chips and vaccines. Cann outlines Germany's strong AI research base and established companies, but points to weak corporate-startup collaboration, low research-to-product transfer, and underfunded startups as the main obstacles to scaling the ecosystem.

Key takeaways

  • Florian Schütz argues ecosystems are not needed to build AI technology, only to turn it into societal impact.
  • Joanna Bryson's patent and market-cap research finds the EU roughly on par with China in AI, with the US as the real outlier.
  • André Loesekrug-Pietri set up JEDI as a foundation, not a government body, modelled on DARPA, after concluding state-led efforts move too slowly.
  • Loesekrug-Pietri cites Europe's falling cloud market share and reliance on Intel and Chinese solar/battery supply chains as signs of dependency.
  • Vanessa Cann says German AI startups struggle less with quality than with corporate collaboration, research-to-product transfer and investment.

Detailed notes

Why ecosystems matter for impact, not just technology

Florian Schütz, managing director of the newly founded K.I. Park ecosystem, opens by arguing that ecosystems are not required to develop AI technology: a single researcher, startup or large company can build new technology alone. What ecosystems are needed for is turning technology into real impact, for example using AI for future healthcare, mobility or sustainable production, because that requires accounting for societal values, user habits, political regulation and funding, business models, infrastructure, data, capital, talent and skills, and end users in industry and society.

Bryson: patent and market-cap data on the EU, China and the US

Joanna Bryson, professor of ethics and technology at the Hertie School, presents research done with Helena Malikova, then at DG Competition, published as a paper called "the AI Cold War." Using the WIPO international patent database for AI-related categories rather than a narrow list of top platforms, they found the EU and the EEA were roughly on par with China in patents and market capitalisation, while the US far outstripped the rest of the world on both measures, and the rest of the world outside the EU, China and the US combined had more patents and market capitalisation than the EU and China together. An updated analysis by a master's student, using companies with even one patent, shows the EU ahead of China on both measures in 2019, with unusual shifts for Japan and China by 2021. Bryson concludes Europe should not feel as threatened by the US narrative on regulation holding it back, and questions why large firms like Google, Microsoft and Facebook resist disaggregation when HP increased shareholder value by 40 percent after splitting.

Loesekrug-Pietri: building a European DARPA and naming dependencies

André Loesekrug-Pietri describes running JEDI, an initiative built as the European equivalent of DARPA and also the largest deep-tech ecosystem in Europe, set up as a foundation rather than a government body because he concluded government-led efforts are too slow. He lists examples of European dependency and fragmentation: SpaceX had 23 launches last year versus three for Ariane; European cloud market share fell from 30 to 15 percent over five years; the EU is subsidising an Intel chip plant near Berlin despite Intel not yet mastering 5-nanometer chips; 99.7 percent of solar panels and 60 percent of batteries are made in China; and Berlin has the second-highest number of CCTV cameras per inhabitant in Europe, after London. He argues Europe reacts to events (the pandemic, Ukraine) instead of shaping them, that national AI strategies fragment effort across 27 ecosystems, and that Europe should compete on scale rather than ideology. He proposes concrete cross-border projects, for example privacy-respecting facial recognition without centralised databases, batteries without lithium, and rotating civil servants and entrepreneurs between government, academia and startups, and notes the EU is investing 750 billion euros in "Next Generation Europe" without precise KPIs beyond spending targets.

Cann: Germany's research strength versus weak scale-up

Vanessa Cann, managing director of the German AI Association, which represents about 400 AI companies with at least 70 percent of their activity in AI and a German seat, describes Germany's strengths as a strong research base and established corporates and SMEs that became more open to AI during the pandemic. The main challenges she names are that corporates and SMEs struggle to collaborate, too few startups are founded on German research results, and startups struggle to find investors, pushing German AI companies toward quality and "ethics by design" rather than scale due to underfunding. She argues no single actor (politics, academia or industry) is responsible for keeping talent in Europe; building venues where research, product and business people meet is a shared task.

Q&A highlights

Bryson pushes back on Loesekrug-Pietri's framing of European vaccine exports as weak, noting the EU exported half its vaccine supply while keeping half, and questions whether Tesla's market capitalisation reflects real competitive advantage over traditional carmakers. Loesekrug-Pietri responds that market capitalisation, while only one indicator, is self-fulfilling because it lets companies acquire firms and attract talent, and cites COVAX data suggesting the US, not the EU, donated the highest share of vaccines relative to its own use, crediting the US Operation Warp Speed's parallel-funded vaccine projects. On what would most change the ecosystem, Bryson stresses diversity of approaches and engaging with people who want startups to succeed rather than working in isolation; Loesekrug-Pietri argues for concrete cross-border projects over abstract frameworks and rotating people between government, academia and business; and Cann argues for federal-level collaboration around shared "moonshot" projects instead of German states or European countries each working alone.

Quotes

AI strongly depends on ecosystems to develop real impact.

Florian Schütz

I don't think we should be feeling so threatened by America.

Joanna Bryson

Europe should not be in an ideology but it should be the scale that we need for technology.

André Loesekrug-Pietri

Questions answered in this talk

Are the EU and China really far apart in AI development?

According to Joanna Bryson at Rise of AI 2022, patent and market-capitalisation data from the WIPO database shows the EU and China roughly on par with each other, while the US far outstrips both.

Why did André Loesekrug-Pietri set up JEDI as a foundation instead of a government agency?

At Rise of AI 2022, Loesekrug-Pietri explains he concluded government-led initiatives move too slowly, so JEDI, Europe's DARPA-style initiative, was set up as a foundation to act as a common good outside government control.

What are the main obstacles to scaling Germany's AI startups?

According to Vanessa Cann of the German AI Association at Rise of AI 2022, the obstacles are weak collaboration between corporates and SMEs, too few startups founded on research results, and difficulty finding investors.

Mentioned

European AI ecosystem, AI Cold War, digital sovereignty, technology transfer, market capitalisation vs. patents

Keep exploring

More from Florian Schütz

More from Rise of AI Conference 2022

More on Geopolitics & Sovereignty

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript, not edited. · 8,199 words

Show the full transcript

so now we have the panel coming up challenges of the european ai ecosystem probably close the interlink to what bjorn already started us off with um ollie zeissman will be the moderator oh no not only florian florian sorry vanessa khan on stage please joanna bryson andrey lawson pietre and ollie zeissman probably take a seat so thank you for the introduction and a warm welcome from my side a special welcome to the three panelists vanessa andre and joanna i'm really looking forward to discussing the challenges of the european ai ecosystem with you today my name is florian i'm managing director of the previously mentioned kai park an open ai ecosystem that was founded in october of last year and that has the mission to strengthen collaboration within the european ai scene to bring ai application that's engineered in germany and europe and the one that has its opening event on friday that you've been all invited to five minutes ago and if you want the last minute invitation you can contact me in the next break

um to start our panel discussion i would like to show only two slides of mine to give you an impression of my perspective on ecosystems so the first thing i really want to say is we don't need ecosystems to develop ai technologies and this could be quite bad news for someone like me who's paid to build up ecosystems next slide please but there is a but and i don't have the presenter so i can't click to the next slide oh here it is but ai strongly depends on ecosystems to develop real impact and this is why please the next slide yeah so if you have if you if it's only about developing technologies um about the best research results about having a new technology a better chip maybe that really can be done without ecosystems developing technology is possible by a startup by a single person by a researcher by research organization by a large company everyone can develop technologies on their own but what if it's not about developing technologies only but really making

big changes big changes like using ai for the healthcare of the future using ai for the mobility of the future changing the way production is done in a sustainable way these are really the big changes we want to use ai for and therefore you need to have a collaboration within the ecosystem because it's not about the technology only it's not about the products about the services or solutions but you have to take into consideration the societal values you have to take into consideration the habits of users the political regulation maybe the political funding you need to develop some things the business models and the use cases the infrastructure the data the capital the talents the skills that need to develop at the end users in society and in industry too and so this is why ecosystems are very important to bring ai into a really impact and effect so now i got this but i don't know how to use it next slide i try to ah okay and this is my last slide so

today i want to talk with you about the european ai ecosystem i want to talk about the characteristics of our government society academia and industry ecosystem what makes us in europe and maybe also in germany so special and so unique and if it's everything a challenge or if there are also opportunities so and for the first thing i would like to ask you three to introduce yourself again and um your perspective on the european ai ecosystem right so quickly through the three of us introduced yes or do we do our perspective so i would like you to introduce yourself again to the audience and then give your perspective on the ai ecosystem right now all right okay sorry okay uh hello my name is joanna bryson i'm professor of ethics and technology at the herdy school but i have also been a developer like you i've worked in startups and i've worked in relatively large corporations and i also was a computer science professor i have a phd in ai from mit um so and

i wanna and i'm here i'm in germany and i wanna say i mean just the people i met last night i'm sorry i wasn't here this morning i actually am supposed to be in japan this week but instead that all got made online because of covid so i'm attending another meeting in the mornings but anyway so many people here are showing that there is a vital ai innovative ai infrastructure in berlin in europe and so actually i wanted to really quickly uh show some slides that sort of contradicted some of the narratives that we've been hearing about the the the cold war and the race about ai could i have my slides please and i had this over to you maybe you know how to use it i i hope so the big green button right is that no i can't have my slides no i think that that's a no okay so i can't get my slides i don't know what's going on all right um okay why don't i hand it on is

this going to change later maybe i'll just pass it on and then we can come back to this well okay they disappeared or you don't that you don't have the pdf you don't know what happened okay they just told me they did have them so i'm very confused sorry i asked whether they had them okay so the um let's see i have my laptop can i connect it the uh i actually published a paper last year called the ai cold war with helena malikova from the director general of competition and a lot of people were circulating this uh this meme of where you saw the top 20 platforms in the world um and uh most of them were in china by which they met asia actually japan and korea who compete with china and the united states and so those are the two big clusters and then there's little tiny cluster which is you know europe and then maybe even smaller cluster that's africa right and so i was like well wait a minute i

thought that market concentration was a bad thing why are we only looking at the top 20 why don't we look at the entire digital ecosystem and she said well what even is a platform how is this objective i want to know everybody who's doing ai so what we did was we looked at the wipo the international ip database for everyone who is doing in a particular category that related to model based you know a you know intelligent systems and in that catalog we found that actually china and the eu and the eea actually were not that different from each other they were actually more or less on par um but the other two pieces of news was that the us far outstripped the entire rest of the world on both the number of patents they published and also on the amount of market capital uh capitalization aggregated across every company that had put out at least two patents okay and then so that was one piece so there was not a binary cold war it

wasn't that the eu was in danger of throwing you know all of the ai into china but secondly the rest of the world not counting china or the eu or the usa actually had more than the eu and china combined okay both in market capitalization and in ip so that was the paper we published last year this year i've had a master's student look at more years and also go into more detail so she looked at even oh those are my slides okay so that's the the disinformation one i told you about right and here's the uh so now this is log log scale okay we all know this from covid now we get logs right so what you notice is not only that ip and market capitalization are more or less independent of each other but also that some companies we know are innovative like apple don't choose to use ip to defend their innovations at least not using patents i should say to defend their innovations and also some companies that are highly

innovative don't seem to choose to go for highly leveraged market capitalization strategies so these are both strategies corporations take and so these measures aren't perfect but still here's the the complete version um so summing those up that's the sum i just described to you now this was like i said we were doing this sort of nights and weekends so helena only looked at companies that had at least two paintings so this is what vipka did this is from the year before and now you see the eu is already doing even better um if you look at every every company that had even one patent right and now she's also highlighted japan something weird is happening with japan watch this okay here's the year that we had done so you see that in 2019 actually the eu is ahead of china both in market capitalization and an ip now this is what happened in 2021 okay so something weird is going on with patents and china and japan are in some weird compute about this the

eu is still growing this is still overall growth by the eu and we know something weird is happening with market capitalization what happened over covet for these large tech companies right so i i it's pretty weird to try to make a claim with a with a measures i'm telling you to suspect both of them but at least i hope you understand a lot is happening and the digital is an enormous a leveler look at the again look at the rest of the world a lot of people are finding ways to innovate and come in so i don't think we should be feeling so threatened by america i don't think we should believe the libertarian statements that america is saying about oh your regulation is slowing you down or holding you back um i don't think we're doing too badly there and we have a good quality of life and maybe it's not a great thing to have giant market capitalization companies in your in your in your country um like i said it doesn't seem

to help you that much with ip but we should realize i think that the main point is that that we're in a situation that's highly highly dynamic and that the whole world has opportunities as well as us thank you and so from from your point of view we are not as bad as we thought and heard why do you think um don't we know that why do you think do we always focus on what we are bad at and not talking about what we are good at i i well there's a there's sort of a celebrity aspect to this so when we do have these really large companies i mean there's a real question hp who i notice is one of our hosts but that's not why i bring this up hp increased their value to stakeholders by 40 percent when they desegregated why is it that google and microsoft and facebook are so reluctant to disaggregate they would also increase value everyone you know everyone at youtube is dying to get the segregated out

of google right they think that their stocks are going to go through the roof so why why is this resistance but i think part of it is that you get the celebrity status you get invited to the table you get on television and and people talk about you and i think we don't notice this incredibly vital ecosystem around us and what bothers me about that i think in a way who cares it's almost like two different levels if we're creating that's great but then people start trying to disrupt what makes you know europe attractive and so that's what i'm worried about thank you joanna and now i would like you andre to introduce your perspective on our european ai ecosystem yes hello everybody so uh the good news is i was instructed not to have any slides so there won't be any slides and there are no slides back there at the moderator what i'm what i'm doing is we are building up the equivalent of the of of of darpa in the us that

was so eloquently presented this morning by uh hans oscar wright so an initiative an agency for disruptive innovation in order for europe for germany for france for europe to lead again in in this technological century that we're experiencing and why do we think it's important because we've realized that tech is not just an economic topic but it's at the center of the way political opinions are created at the way our societies are structured the way our health care situations are assorted or crisis are sorted out and the second thing we do in order to do that we run the largest deep tech ecosystem in europe that helps us anticipate and ask the right questions because too often and here i'm going to have a little segue to the question on why do we permanently think that we are bad because we are i mean just give you a few numbers last year i'm going to expand that on on technology and not just on ai 23 launches of spacex three of ariane the cloud market

share went down from 30 to 15 percent in five years during the five years of the macron presidency but that's a total coincidence um we are relying on intel to build the latest semiconductor uh uh plant uh 10 miles from here so we are basically subsidizing with eu money your money uh the fact that intel which does not know how to do five nanometer chips uh to do them and we have no clue that they will succeed i think it's a huge bet with our uh with our money that that has the the feeling that it's so and why i'm despite everything i say optimistic is because that's the beauty of tech uh i don't know i think it's live streamed for those who are using zoom zoom they don't exist 2016.

and today it's worth three times the value of all the airlines uh in the world because tesla is going to crush probably continue to crush the the traditional automakers and it's worth twice the total market cap of all the automakers in the world so the beauty of tech is that you can reshuffle the cards but for that you need to project anticipate and that's where i get interested in ai to answer your question because ai it's all about that it's about the capacity to in this in this fog we speak about fog of war right now with ukraine but in this fog of information with this incredible amount i could use a log scale too amount of information that we're receiving every day which probably explains also why a lot of people feel disenfranchised in our societies we need to understand what are the trends so it's not the the ultimate weapon but it could allow us and if on top of that the europeans could use the diversity maybe that's my idealistic heart the

diversity of our countries to to feed into this model the diversity of what europe is about and that we listen a little bit more to the baltic states where they talk to us about russia that we listen a little bit more about the the southern state when they talk about africa when we listen a little bit more about the the the the nordic countries when they talk about education like bjorn just uh alluded because what he said about the finn on ai is exactly the same thing happening on on training of the young kids on disinformation you know develop critical thinking these are all european values how do we transform them and leverage them in our uh in this technological century and i think it's a beautiful european project last but not least we've come to the conclusion that it's a political project frankly speaking i hope super mario marion brandenburg who was there before will save us all but for the moment i'm going to be very blunt the the political class has driven

us into a fragmented world i mean we saw the 27 a.i ecosystems and then you hear these words in the bundestag saying abaddan fintenbeer to franchise that means and then let's do our strategy and then we'll try to find the connection that's complete bs because once you have a national strategy it's incredibly difficult to then because you will have a president for the and the commission and everybody has this little turf and it's impossible to build something at scale so that's why i command what vanessa and others are doing because you try to build these large european models immediately at european scale so europe should not be in an ideology but it should be the scale that we need for for technology so that's just in a nutshell okay and i hope to have a real discussion between us thank you andre um my question would be so we germans tend to really admire the darpa model looking at the us sometimes looking to israel and thinking oh this is how radical innovation works um

we are getting the results we're seeing the results and sometimes we say yeah but that's not how we germans do things that's not how we are is that different if you put it to an european level so is the european collaborative ecosystem mentality okay for something like darpa yes i i personally am very much against this tendency of thinking yes but we are not risk takers you saw the number of germans and i could add the number of french who got darpa it's not just sebastian troon for waymo and others that suddenly you just need to build these freighters but we have all these politicians and sorry it's not an anti-political speech that i'm doing but we are citizen we need a civil society to step in and say you cannot miss merkel but mr schultz is saying the same say deep fakes is a big danger that was a regular seminar in meseburg 2018 and then when we come up and say look facebook are the only ones who do put real money into

deep fake detection and we don't want facebook becoming the uh the ministry of truth like in 1984 we will do that with a couple of researchers in theo munchen and in in in in in cardiff and in in paris and uh put put a million at work oh no no that's too complicated so this i mean talk to rafael laguna i i personally came to the conclusion that it's hopeless to start with the government initiative so that's why jedi a year and a half ago we decided to set it up as a foundation because we think it needs to be common good it but it needs to be outside i mean you can hope to change governments but let's first focus on what is really important for us is to lead to make sure our values are embedded in the technology uh that's why this is why i gave you all these numbers to show you that people talk about sovereignty technology leadership embedding our values but in practical details do you know which is

the city which uses the most cctv in cameras and face recognition in uh in europe london london but do you know which is the second city in terms of number of cameras to the number of inhabitants it's berlin it's your nice city of berlin so we all think we love privacy we are against authoritarianism and civilian state this is because we are not leading so we are more and more i mean look at the pandemic we are reactive look at ukraine we are reactive we are faster than before in europe but we are shaped by what is happening outside that's why this obsession about china and the us if we shape the future if we invent the technologies of the future and not just the technologies suddenly we we take back control sorry for this reference to the to brexit but i think taking back control for citizen is it's a political project so i think it's our role to say okay if we want that then we really want to put our work our

means our money our efforts where our words are we're a little bit too much talkers the real talkers are not in the california they are in paris berlin and especially in brussels okay so joanna wants to ask a question to you well yeah i well i was i i have a question to ask but i first have to say i do not know the sense in which we were lagging on uh on covid so like there were two countries the us and uk who never exported any of their vaccine and then there was like two countries that exported all of their vaccine and didn't protect their own people india and china and then there was the eu who exported half their vaccine and kept half their vaccine and germany could have gone first but they said no we want to keep the union together and so we were all sort of matched for a long time until we got to a certain level vaccination before we spread it i think we we showed incredible power

and leadership and we benefited the rest of the world we we sold a bunch of the vaccine we exported but we also donated a bunch of it i think we are in a leading position right now i agree with you on the diversity part i think it is really important that and that is part of how we achieve things and is also part of what makes us slow and i've heard you know i've heard the commission pitch us that way to africa they said if you have an emergency go to china they can operate faster than we can but if you want a lasting solution that's going to last because it will benefit your people and you then come to us because we're really good at crafting those kinds of things and i think airbus is a fantastic example of that it was slow it was insane and now it's the best and where would we be given the problems boeing has if we didn't also have airbus so the question i was going to

ask though and i honestly am exposing myself here i don't know this but in what sense is tesla crushing their competition except this really weird metric of market capitalization i don't see that many teslas around but maybe i'm not aware that they're being sold at a higher rate than traditional cars okay my lens is completely focused on technology and it's as previous speaker showed it it's only a very small part so at the contrary i believe that this political driven technology policy and it's over uh simplified that you see in in some asian countries and this technology for technology ideology that you see sometimes in the on the west coast i think the europeans have probably a very interesting angle tech for a certain purpose so i'm only talking about the technology part well just on tesla uh yes you're completely right market cap is only one indicator but unfortunately it's a self-fulfilling prophecy because when you have a market cap you can acquire companies you attract a lot of the best talent and we

saw that at work with the big tech platforms i agree a lot of people don't want any more to work for the googles the microsoft but we should be careful because these guys are smart when you see currently how microsoft and apple is riding the privacy wave that we invented you know it reminds me of we invented 40 years ago the the sustainable uh you know consciousness with the green movement etc today 99.7 of solar panels are built in china and already 60 of our batteries so it's great to to have the right vision it's better to implement it and that's where i see and and on the vaccine you're right and wrong if i may say at the same time you're totally right on the fact that the eu but brother on that one is i think not totally fair because he says uh we are the biggest exporters so we sell our vaccines but when you look at kovacs numbers kovacs is the uh is the and for those interested follow our twitter

uh feed little advertising because we do every month actually the the country that gives the most vaccines in proportion of what they use themselves is the us by far and china is totally fake they announced 3 billion of donations and they gave i don't remember the name now but a couple percentage on that i think the europe is at 50 percent of what they promised and i think the the us is almost at par that means they used 600 million doses and i think they gave 600 million doses and i don't think it's because they are more humanistic than us because they just realize that if there's a variant in brazil or in south africa it will has hit us back we saw that happening what i just want to say is that you know we have to think i know it hurts me too donald trump and his administration because why are we do we have vaccines in 11 months because there was an operation called warp speed which was managed by i happen

to have him as a friend a former darpa program manager colonel matt hepburn you don't know this guy but he was running this program between march and november 2020 where the us put 18 billion in 10 different projects two of them beard food jensen and johnson and modena yes in parallel streams we had bayern tech here in germany which is a great success for us and yeah absolutely and and so um i think this this approach of saying let's test several things we know we are going to fail on something let's trust research let's only aim for excellence this is something we need to change i mean do you know we are going to invest and i'm finishing on that we're about to invest 750 billion euro in europe for the so-called next generation europe ursula vanderlian is speaking about that monday uh noon midday and and evening and it's great but we focus on the money no has ever somebody heard about precise kpis what do we want to achieve the only kpi is

30 needs to go in digital 25 in in green or the opposite but we all know then you can basically justify any kind of project a lot of this money will be wasted we need to make sure we use that money it's in a it's an exceptional historical moment so this is what we are pushing for and that's where i think these european ecosystems can really bring ideas bring their energy and probably also reconcile a little bit people with their with their political leadership thanks andre i hope you remember all to aim for excellence now i would like to ask vanessa to introduce you and your perspective on our ai ecosystem and if we can compete with the rest of the world sure thanks florian and let me first say it's great to be here again on this big family reunion called rise for ai after two years it's great to see you all live and in rio and yeah so my name is vanessa ken i'm the managing director of the german ai association

bonus for bandwidth 400 ai companies so they're all focused on ai 70 of their activity have to be in the field of ai they all have their seat in germany and we're pushing very much i think in a similar direction as jedi is kind of towards a digital sovereign european union because we see it as a big trouble that we're becoming more and more dependent in the european union on global players and i think i know the header is kind of challenges of the european ai ecosystem and that's very german i think they're focusing on the challenges but let me maybe first start uh with the strengths because i think we have so much and i think this like this whole room already shows the the major strength of the ai ecosystem so i think we have this this growing ecosystem right now uh built around a very very strong research pillar and uh the research from germany from frankfurt i know some of you i hear is really renown across the world and many

many are citing these researchers from germany so we're very strong when it comes to research and i think that's one thing we can really be proud of and what we can build on the other really big strength that we have is we have these major established companies and smes all across germany especially in the pandemic they've become more and more open towards ai are looking towards ai and new technologies to become a main driver in the in the future also and i think and that's where we can kind of build on and now kind of let me come to the challenges kind of because i know this is also the topic of today and of course also one of the main things we discussed as the german ai association when i speak to all of our ai companies in in the association they all tell me well we have all of these established companies but still we have big troubles working together with corporates who have big troubles working together as with smes so what

we have to foster i think we have to step away from this theory of ai that everyone has heard ai is a big topic it's a future future topic but to really work on the use cases and how we can transport what ai really means for a company how they can embed um ai and i think that's that's one thing we really have to work on right now as an ecosystem on how we can explain ai and and make it real for people that aren't really too deep in the topic and and once you want to use ai and one other thing is of course when you look at research and but the numbers of kind of what we transfer into products it's still very the numbers aren't and big so i think depending on on the research we have here we still have too few startups for example being established on these research results and we really have to push for the wood as an ecosystem to to help researchers gain this mindset and

see their business models behind their research results i think that's that's one thing we really have to aim for too to kind of how how we can um yeah how we can establish services and products um and um yeah and then maybe also like the last thing and i know that's been in the press uh a lot these recent days is kind of uh the issue of investment so if you ask a lot of ai startups they will say we're looking for investment we don't know how to find vcs that can help us and and can finance us and i think we will become very cautious of how to invest i think we have the strength in in germany in the european union in general that we focus a lot on quality because of the lack of investment so we're focusing a lot on how to build really really good products that have like ethics by design or value by design for example implemented already so i think that that's a major strength but we

really have to see how we can scale these companies now and that we we need investment for so um so i think yeah be kind of proud of the ecosystem and go out and say hey we have this high quality we're just mainly underfunded and we our companies don't know how to work with uh clients and i think that's what we as an ecosystem should push for kind of explaining how uh companies how how also um yeah vcs can invest in ai thanks vanessa one thing i really would like to hear your answer on this um who is responsible to ensure that the brightest miles thought leaders decide to found research and stay in the european union so who's responsibly responsible for that is it the politics is it the academic sector is it maybe industry or society i think we all are that's what makes what makes it also difficult and why we have this discussion kind of going on um is i think there's not one person responsible and there's not one thing

you have to do that will change everything so i think it's it's all down to all of us it's it's down to building ecosystems your question was in the beginning kind of do we need ecosystems yes we definitely need ecosystems we need places where everyone meets how where research can meet uh kind of the the the server side the product side and can learn from each other so we have to kind of engage into this dialogue be open towards new ideas and i think if we if we if we engage and if we can really show how we use these strengths of good research of good of established companies that that need ai to kind of stand up in the future then i think we can really be strong in the european union and you can see this i think through the last couple of years that more and more people are coming back because they see what vibe is kind of growing in the european union and how many yeah inspiring people are here

and how much can really be done for society for climate and and kind of value by design ethics by design as as part of the product and i think that's really a part of our yeah core usp in the european union that makes lots of people come back and and really decide hey the european union is where i want to stay and build my company yeah just to build one one word on what nasa says uh it's this word i would like to float this word of interdisciplinarity because today the biggest breakthroughs are coming from the conjunction between different fields and if you think again about my example on space but automotive is the same thing i know nvidia i don't want to make too much advertising for you guys is it a hardware company is it a software company is tesla an automotive company or software company is spacex a pure rocket we have too much the tendency in europe to think in silos for example in france i'm trying to remove the word

filiere which really means the industry branches because increasingly if you are again to your log scale if you are linear in your approach you are not seizing what indeed everybody knows as a word this exponential word and that's where the opportunity is because where do you find this interdisciplinarity and this diversity that we have in europe so that's why i'm also like you're very optimistic but that's why we need these bridges and these dysphora and these these uh these these approaches which are difficult i mean i used to be on the board of a danish company before me they were only 60 year old danish man i love denmark it's a company called bno bang olufsen that you probably all know i was the diversity i don't look like diversity really but the fact that there was suddenly a french german not speaking danish and that was 20 years younger or 30 years younger at that time that was already a huge change but but people who say diversity easy are completely wrong it's much

easier because you go drink a beer with people that look like you like you it's much less you speak different languages already between ai and computer science or between ai and hardware people speak different languages but if you get that together the power of creation of innovation is amazing i want to find out if there's a conflict between you or if not if i can make up some um you talked about technology transfer within an ecosystem and that ecosystems are very important for tech transfer so the collaboration between science society industry and politics for tech transfer but isn't that a contradiction to every kind of darpa model so doesn't every darpa like model say what we need is a lot of funding a lot of freedom and the brightest minds of applied research this has nothing to do with an ecosystem or technology transfer or maybe technology transfers done afterwards after the the technology is developed within the applied research okay could i uh yeah well i i just wanted to say something about back

to this uh whose responsibility is it to keep people in europe um i think i i agree it's everybody's but also i don't think it should be a goal that everyone stays in europe my grading is great at the the goal as was mentioned before is that more people are coming here than are leaving um so that would be great and i do think that we are doing that through getting the message out about quality of life and unfortunately that's partly by some of our competitors driving their own quality of life into the ground um but but anyway we as we uh that's part of the reason i think it's important to be positive and to say because the people who come here often they don't come here by choice maybe like because of a partner or something and then all of a sudden they go oh wow i don't have to worry about healthcare you know i don't have to uh you know i just the quality of life is better and i can

get things done and it's it's not what i had been told before it's not that hard to get a company going so i i think there's there's some snowballing about that happening here now on the other hand definitely some people uh when they go out to make their fortune or seek their fortune just like you know they could go into bitcoin or they could move to california and and i think we are seeing a lot of ambitious people going where the gold rush is under regulated gold rush and i do think we need to worry about some of these companies are becoming you know they have transnational talent they have transnational data they have transnational infrastructure which they did build themselves but i think they're becoming something like transnational utilities and we need to make sure that not necessarily the people but at least some of the revenue is being fairly and justly invested back into the places that provided the education and uh you know the and the data and everything else that helped

them become what they were so this is another reason that we need to work well with uh our government to make sure that and that the government you know it's we're fortunate to live in the eu well i chose to come here because of the strength because i think it is a really good way to integrate uh national strengths together um but therefore that that's able to compete and and negotiate at this level where and we are we're negotiating at the level including that the united states government is not entirely sure how to get tax money out of those guys either so we're actually cl cooperating with the us as well as with the rest of the world and trying to redesign that at a transnational level so i just wanted to mention that on another piece so as we are already running out of time i would like to ask one last question to you all um we heard a lot of things that are good in our european ai ecosystem we heard a

lot of things where we are bad at what if we want to change something if we want to have more revenue if we want to be more aligned to european well used if we want to have the brightest minds in europe so if we want to change anything in any of these sectors how do we do it is it by consulting politics is it by making up smaller ecosystems that lead by example what is the way to change the way the european ai ecosystem works okay so one one we'll just do around uh so i'll do it quickly in like two minutes and give up um i think it's really important again this diversity so i think it's wonderful that you can approach all these different strategies not the same person but the corporations should absolutely be investing the time it requires to make sure their governments are informed but don't hesitate to move to another country including another european country if that's where you can get your business model bootstrapped first you know and

there is a lot of that there is cycling between the different places they have maybe cheaper great programming labor then versus somewhere where the higher rule of law that you might go when you're growing your company so i think it's important that we have all these different sandboxes including the different german states are trying different things so i think there's a diversity of approaches but the main thing is is don't just think you can you know at some point you're doing the programming all night i get it but it really is important to engage somewhere you know to make sure that you aren't just complaining to yourself but that you're actually getting your information because there's a lot of people who are paid to help you and they want to they want to succeed they want you to succeed everybody succeeds it is not a zero-sum game so absolutely try to figure out a good amount of time to spend engaging in communication with the people who could be helping things i i would have

one word which is projects i think we are way too on that one we are way too french in europe we're always trying to find the big framework that will apply to everything i think that's it's projects which get people together and let's remember the eu was founded on very concrete projects of putting coal and steel together i think we need to go back there some of the discussions that you hear and again that's going to be a bit anti-brussels stance in brussels are so theoretical frankly speaking good luck to those who will categorize high risk medium risk and small risk and who has the capacity to judge that and who will do it smartly enough that every three months it's updated because technology is going too so fast so common projects and we have so many can we do face recognition come back to my cctv example uh without centralized database that would be an interesting project where on one side you do biometry on the other side you are respectful can you do

really fair ai can you do batteries without lithium i mean we are jumping from one dependency to russia to another dependency to australia and think about the wound mills that include 98 of rare earth from china i mean this lack of foresight is incredible but on the other side if you put very concrete projects and say only excellence counts then suddenly you have the best brains from europe but also the others they will rush back and and i think just one word on what joanna said on this back and forth i think we live that's why it's really a political project is we we need to have these passage from research to academia to business and politics the other day i looked at all the director generals and for those who know the brussels bubbled you know the director general much more powerful than the commissioner himself have now 25 years of age in the commission that explains everything we need to have these guys go out to a startup for two years or to

academia for some year to just understand and we as as entrepreneurs we also need to go sometimes in politics to realize that it's not as easy so these back and forth these would be two very concrete projects where we can move it forward thanks andre yeah so i i think i i agree to that point with andre that i think products are really important i said that earlier like we have to work along of use cases and not see ai to theoretical and i think especially smes and corporates they get very lost because when i speak to them they usually say okay we're still working on our ai strategy and then two years later they say the same thing so it's nothing really changes and i think the problem is that they see it as a two big big thing and they just have to start so i think the the challenge is really seeing one point seeing one project and seeing okay this is a use case that could help us okay let's get

going and let's learn in the process so i think that that's one one way of definitely putting it i think definitely to to add to this is kind of the federal um yeah cultural setting of the european union and also germany is of course challenging because it it it works that way that we kind of have these small communities and all are kind of in their little bubble and no one can really communicate so i think setting on collaboration and also from a state perspective not really on this um how would you put it in english that in in german it's like gis khan principe so you're kind of setting on on and doing everything a little bit but nothing really so i think we have to set our minds to like this bigger moonshot project of working on like bigger projects as a society where we collaborate i guess on a federal level because we won't get around that france and germany and and all our baltic friends and so on they they all

want to have part of the cake so we can't say okay everything i will happen in germany and you you're happy to join but come here that won't work so i think we will have to think it on a federal perspective but in germany the setup is often that we see each other too much of um like um yeah as counterparts instead of working together so i think we really have to share our ideas and see how we can work together on like a bigger picture and work towards a moonshot project so that we really have something of our own in in the european union thank you very much thanks vanessa thanks andre and thanks jana for being our panelists and thanks to fabian and veronica for making the rise of ai 22 possible this year you

Rise of AI 2027 · Berlin · May 2027

Be in the room for the next one.

Ten years of talks started as conversations in one curated room in Berlin. The next edition brings 300 selected leaders together in May 2027.