foreign I think when it comes to when it comes to Europe and Germany sometimes we think we are like not the first runner um but maybe we can change this opinion today because I think Björn Bringmann from our AI Institute at Deloitte has some good news for us right let's go a woman plus Fabian thank you the first good news is I study computer science I have a technical Gadget it's probably gonna fail um because it was technical people do with technical gadgets right so is that forward no somebody has a manual for that one which button do I push to get forward I see the laser pointer and a back button and a stop button at the big oh thank you wonderful so good news I found the big green button and AI in Europe some good news um to bring in the next I think 25 minutes what we have um and thanks Lara for the introduction um I'll take a little bit on the on the story where this is coming from
um I've been here last year I've been in quite some discussions and quite often I'm sitting in discussions where people go like yeah you know if you would just have more money or you know if we would just have more Talent the industry is not really going to use it anyhow it's so complicated and I'm seeing them like yeah this really transpires hope and vision right um kind of Highway to Hell like feeling you sometimes get and I don't think it's that bad so I sat down and I said let's take the good news that feels way more optimistic but at least for me I like to build on things that exist and that get me motivated may they be so small rather than you know standing in front of a fire and somebody saying it's even just getting hotter Once you walk in there so here we go um it's very simple good news there you go one slide and you get 24 minutes back no obviously it's not that right but that's the
feeling you get in these discussions and hence disclaimer quite obviously I don't want you to convince you that we're number one right not in Germany not in Europe but I would like to convince you and have you go out here with this understanding that we're not at the last spot if there's even a ranking but rather the opposite that there's a lot of things going on and I had a chat with uh Veronica earlier today she said in this one month's May there's so many connections happening between different small groups which haven't seen each other before which I hope will really push things even more forward now that disclaimer out of the way we go away from the black slides again because supposedly something positive now at the end this are we number one or not right or are we in the top ten it's a little bit about competitiveness and our our co-founder of our monitor Deloitte brand uh Michael Porter basically wrote down I think 30 years ago a nation's competitiveness depends on
the capacity of the industry too innovate and upgrade so you really need to be able to do that not just to want that and that's pretty much what I'm going to run through now now before we go into you know the nitty-gritty so to speak of lots of examples what we have and none of this is holistic or meant to be complete so if you say oh there's one missing yes great right keep it in mind and share that and they're guaranteed to be many missing oops wrong button there you go um what's the current state I'm very lucky to have the chance of that we interviewed last year and currently again actually uh two and a half thousand people globally on what the state of AI is it's a super long survey you can read it if you like we tried to make it a pleasure to read um we could look at Germany sample size of 150 senior Executives is not huge right um but it's a good number and what we spotted
at the very beginning is we've and I'm not going to go into the details of this Matrix but you can imagine Transformers is the group where you want to be in right and we're 42 that's almost half of these 150 people um that's it we are Transformer our company does a lot of AI stuff and is successful with it that's basically what it means to be in the top right corner you do a lot of AI things lots of different ones NLP computer vision what have you that is pre-generative AI hype so that wasn't explicitly asked um and on the other side it's not just we're doing stuff but we're actually being successful we're reaching a bunch of goals right you know our processes are more efficient we can enter new markets what have you um the global average is I believe 27 percent and when I saw this I thought okay somebody's lying to themselves um because we're way outperforming global average in fact we're number three out of 13.
um the interesting piece here is there are lots of companies out there that are really pushing forward if you want to see and that's actually not an ad for the thing but I can't go into the details right now because I want to talk about something else if you want to see where the Achilles heel is feel free to read the report it's really about the culture so companies seem to have kind of uh jumped over the fact that they have people running around in the company that need to be taken along right but there is quite some interest in adoption and if you want to look look this forward how is this going to change um one last chart from from this um from the survey is globally on average so these 2620 um 94 of them said that AI is really crucial for their business to succeed in the next five years right so that was the the person's gone but the one who said um if you don't use AI you're not
going to there anymore that's that statement of numbers kind of right um funny enough and I have to apologize the the access is cut off at 80 because otherwise it looks really boring um Germany is 87 percent that's a lot that's you know uh basically um nine out of ten um but we're also lost so I think it's still good because hey 90 say it's crucial for our business right so out of these 150 they're like 135 or something let's say we have to do Ai and you can see the other two countries from Europe are basically in the same similar space Francis wide ahead and if you're wondering he just said 13 countries I just picked some here right so there are more um they saw themselves in somewhere there so there's a lot of demand so to speak like pretty much everybody in the industry at least wants to do something there now what do we need to to get this up and running and this is the first slide when where we'll
say it's probably not complete um we have industry we have Academia we have government those I believe need to really work together because otherwise it's not going to work right and within that you have all these kind of little pieces and elements that kind of need to snap ideally into each other you obviously need adoption because otherwise you have a lot of interesting stuff lying on the Shelf you need the infrastructure because well basically you need the Shelf to put stuff on right like compute or data or anything like this you need a way of awareness it kind of ties in with adoption I guess so people need to know and need to want obviously you need money for a couple of things um patents slash Innovation right is an interesting topic where we're standing some research because you know you want to have more patents if you like if you if you're interested in rankings if you want to move things forward you need research to do that and obviously talent and there might
be other things so what I did was basically just um sat down and told my team go find some good news so they went and brought back a couple of things let's start very simple innovation ah we're so bad at that yeah we're number eight out of I don't know how many but that list is cut off that's way longer right um and actually we're going up so we're since uh since when we entered this list or the top 10 in 2009 we've just been going up we're not in number one right but you can see the Delta too in in fact in this case Switzerland is just what seven percentage points or seven score points it's not like we're number eight that that's a pretty decent spot now I hear saying yabian that's that's patents and innovation in general obviously we you know we build machines there will be Innovations there we probably do something with cars in there and what have you all right fair enough um there's a global AI index um
we're number nine okay we dropped by one number um that's not too bad that's a list of I believe 60 something countries in there right so we're in the literally in the top ten um and in the top uh whatever 14 of what that might be right what's not surprising is that the two popular uh ones are on the very top right no surprise here at the very last column and it's small numbers so I'll read out for you at the very top it's just normed by the United States by 100 right and then you basically go down and Germany is sitting at was at 37 36 so a score of 36. and funny enough the UK on number three is sitting there with a skull 41 rounded so that's just what Five Points difference so it looks like a long way but we're not that far from number three we're reasonably file for number one and number two but we're there usable um and there's a lot coming behind us right foreign so one
more thing where we are um you can go on with these things right I I bumped randomly into this one and thought how funny like I'm I have a hard time finding a child that's actually saying the opposite right so again two different axes were in the leaders group right slightly different sorting maybe now we're number five doesn't matter somewhere up there um I'm pretty sure all of you know this because it has been over the news since it became into existence but the reason why we have microchips is because we have the Dutch and size and Trump because those three together are building the machines the only machines globally that are able to produce these super small hyper efficient chips now the chips themselves are not produced here at the massive degree but the machines you need to produce those chips are completely European right um and that I think is pretty impressive and by the way this shortcut of the story asml which is a Dutch company that's basically building the machines eventually
using parts from from Trump and science um they sent down some point in the past and said we want to figure out how you can make these chips smaller and they just went for it and put a lot of effort in it and at some point they had the Breakthrough and now can build the machines so that was a long path to get there now the other one and I put a tiny question mark in there in terms of building semiconductors here there's an ongoing discussion I think that's fair to call it like this of two pretty big factories from Intel pretty much right around the corner to produce some microchips right here right so there are things going on and obviously there's a chips act where the idea is hey we're consuming about 20 of the microchips globally maybe we should produce that many probably our consumption is going to go up at the meantime but let's hear I'll try playing catch up and there's 45 billion um basically being planned to be spent
on making that happen that's not a small number obviously you can use these chips for anything else not just AI right um what do you do with these chips well you build data centers and compute centers you know the famous ones um I'm not sure if you know those and again that's obviously just a sample right um from the Schwartz group they said we want to build a cloud they put a lot of money behind it behind it and they went and they both stack it is it as big as the other hyperscalers no did the hyperscaler start as big as they are at this moment probably not so that's an interesting start and then around for a year now um Conti I'm pretty sure you all know them they have their own compute Center to actually do AI computation right like all kinds of deep neural networks in there because they needed it so they built it it's there it's commercial it's for them but they do exist right the two on the left
are very recent like basically from last year and Alpha One I guess you've heard enough or already sorry a lot about Jonas and Willis today that's the fastest let's say AI computer that we have in Europe at the moment right and that's being inaugurated somewhere last year so half a year ago so that does sit I think somewhere in it was inaugurated in Berlin it's not right there somewhere on German ground so this does exist and pretty recently um Hessian AI so another let's say ecosystem kind of thing from well Hassan they said we need one that's available for research so they built one that's as far as now currently being extended even um but so that's now there obviously it's not as big as some others might have it but they do exist and I'm just seeing 12 minutes so there's a lot of good news I need to speed up a little bit financing um the European spending is predicted to go up quite a bit I mean this is tripling in four
years that's quite decent right that's a prediction that might be wrong um but you know even if it's off a little bit that's still big numbers and the ones driving this are Germany Spain in the UK mostly right guess what we're one of those three so that's cool then SPRIND our agency for disruptive innovation so to speak just got a little bit liberated over there let's say very bureaucratic corset right sorry able to react faster more flexible and more let's say investment Style on this Market again obviously for all kinds of startups um which which includes AI for startups there were many complications and what you could do let's say in the US but couldn't do here due to all kinds of legislation so the U came up with this I'm not sure that correct name actually but the the startup Nation standard right which contains many things like just stock options that your employers could employees can get stock options right this wasn't so easy now that has moved forward along with a bunch
of other things so there's a lot Happening Here Right In financing and again these are just samples if you dig further you will find other billions right Talent it's a bit of an outdated number of the 6.1 million um but that's the number of professional developers in Europe if you want to build AI you may need more specialized Developers but I'm pretty sure they're a subset of this is roughly at scale with the developers that exist in the US so the per person developers so to speak in the US and in Europe roughly the same right that's not too bad um from the last decade of unicorns in Europe we have around 700 people that graduated from those unicorns so not just the founders obviously because that would mean we had several unicorns but the people that have been working there they know how to grow and run a big startup right they know how to do an IPO and stuff like that we have 700 of them by now at least um 10 years
ago there was maybe a two-digit number so there's a lot of power another number I was quite surprised to find is the what's the thing called The Deep Tech Talent initiative from the European Institute of innovation technology obviously complicated name right but the interesting thing is they want to train half a million Europeans in deep Tech right the alpha million is not huge but it's quite a decent number so again there's there's a lot going on on the talent side research and ecosystems and I feel really like I'm just going down the long lists right it could be a lot longer but that's the idea right you should be like oh God it's more and more when will you stop that's the idea right there's a lot The Innovation Park um that's again pretty much the schwarzkopper right they decided I believe to build this it doesn't look like that the ant but it's supposed to look like that in 2027 and they have a bunch of stages so we don't have to wait till
2027 there are things happening right now um with we have some folks from the from applied AI here that's already existing for a while that's a huge ecosystem right they're connecting all kinds of people that does exist it's work running really well we have for the kai Park here in Berlin where we as Deloitte kind of also went in right this is growing quite a bit there are lots of discussions happening um there's a cyber Valley yeah around Tübingen like it's it's already actually quite famous for being the Cyber belly and probably even Europe right there's a lot going on there are a lot of researchers there there's it's not a Silicon Valley yet right um but maybe we also don't have to copy everything right so this is doing very well um we have I'm going to go counterclockwise now buy it I've just been sitting next to the to the one who's running this this might be a small piece but when he said we gonna make the data available in a machine
readable form I said wow finally cool um so they're going for this and this is going to happen in the next couple of weeks right that there will be accessible uh information easily accessible like you might see in the US quite a bit there's hnai which I just mentioned which is still pretty fresh bringing research and Industry together in in hessen and slightly off here but I wouldn't know where else to foot it put it stable effusion one of the most famous generative AI image models right that's from the University of Munich from a guy that happens to share first names but um so that's that's World standard right so there's a lot of this going on just short sample of status of innovation you will have seen those right but there are many more let me just pick um you've seen alif Alpha for sure the bunch of others um I'm not sure who of you knows the one on the bottom right I'm pretty sure people all of us are using um and
I have no idea how to pronounce it lion right they basically curated one of the image data sets which is used for all these image Learning Systems right that's that's huge like everybody's using this they it's sitting somewhere in Germany this data set and the people kind of making sure that works also um so they obviously have connections to other places as well but that's that's where it's coming from um coming to adoption and that's basically the personal story here one is um a reason bitcom study said that roughly half is it right half of the companies of 2000 people or more so they're very few companies with less than 2 000 people I guess what in Germany that's entirely true sorry I'll take that back but how of the you know reasonably sized companies um do use AI in one way or the other that's a lot that's what I would call adoption it's not a hundred percent but it's a very good step towards hundred percent and the below is just a color
arranged list of our top companies in Germany right um I have so many people reaching out since basic beginning of the Year from all kinds of companies saying like we understood we want to do AI where do we start right so there's a lot of Interest being triggered right now because obviously there was a trigger point with uh end of end of last year and everybody been playing around with the famous chatbot um and many of the folks woke up and finally reach out they reach out with completely different questions and think it's going to be solved by a chatbot but that doesn't matter so you can easily kind of reel them in and say like interesting idea let's go over here there's a good solution for you right um but many have been waking up and many are coming with the interesting questions and overcome the fear and have seen what can be done and I think that's the most interesting part that I currently see is everybody can use it and everybody is
impressed some are a little bit scared some are a bit too optimistic but certainly everybody's impressed and gets the first idea as to what AI is actually able to do it's not like only somewhere behind the scenes doing its magic but can actually feel the magic and that has been hard to convene for a long time and we can really see the the effect right now when literally from all over the place industry reaches out and wants to start or improve or change or what have you um and then that one um and it's funny because quite a while ago and and I think in in the way I agree with the sentiment in the room I would say right there's a lot that could be broken with this but at the same time pretty much right now in the last weeks there was an outcry for maybe we need more regulation right so I purposefully didn't not in the talk but not at all deep dive into this topic because I have colleagues that
do that very well um but the fact that we have already a headset of two years in terms of experience and what you know how to discuss this topic I think is also a very interesting point here now as far as I know it's going to be voted tomorrow so the last part of the left slide on the left part is kind of slightly outdated but um that that will be very interesting Journey as well so lots of things that happen here in this range and I'm not very proud of that slide um and I think I've found part of the answer today already but okay that's all good but is that a classical case of too little too late or are we just you know having trouble with the fact that Europe happens to be more fragmented than you know China and the US for example where things are easier to reach because it's more concentrated or because the country is just more homogeneous you know it's it's a few places are as heterogeneous
as Europe I guess at that scale so is there a need for just simply to do these people talk to each other do all these people on those slides kind of know each other or at least know that they exist I kind of doubt that um then there's the other question about the money and I had to put it on here obviously we do have and it's quite awfully quoted right we have CERN in Europe that's sitting somewhere at the corner of Switzerland and France um and roughly the European countries involved in that plus there is some money coming from I believe Japan and the us as well but the operation costs of this one is roughly a billion euro per year roughly that's quite a lot and um I think we wouldn't necessarily need the same number for AI but in a way I think that's the easiest argument why that number is possible right especially if you spread it out over more countries but for that there would need to be one sink
so to speak to put the money on rather than spraying out in many different parts and I'm not sure if one of the two is a better solution but what I really have the feeling is and I guess you got that at the beginning I have the feeling we like a little bit of optimism and I would really hope uh that because at slide number three you said oh he doesn't stop um we get a little bit more optimism in the room because this was all a sample I'm pretty sure I could make the talk five hours long listing more examples obviously the message wouldn't change and the only thing that would happen is you would get bored I guess so with that being said there's a lot of good news um we're maybe not that good at marketing them and maybe not that good at talking about them and as I said at the beginning this may it seems that many actually getting together but we should kind of not just sit and watch
but go and push thank you wow so much optimism in the room um yeah I really like to see that we are at Place eight when it comes to Innovation index in Europe that's I didn't know about that but I would like to ask you also maybe we can do it again like before and to become active and what do you see as the greatest developing fields for us um in the comp competition in Europe any idea we heard optimism yes to work together it's all not not to compete so to speak yes activities against the fear that is interesting and I think it's also I mean why do you fear something because I mean I can talk for myself when you don't understand it and I think we also need to educate a bit more in this field so don't fear it has there anyone in a good address to to educate a bit more to learn more about AI I got this question last year so the the answer I had last year
is that from Finland there's one um a very good program that's available in all languages I'm not sure if it's suitable for every Target group so to speak but you hi thank you so elements of AI this is the one exactly you were suggesting uh it's definitely made for the public so it can be understood by anybody okay just on a funny note I was going to recommend my own book okay so what was the elements elements of AI okay so this is a education plan form okay because this is from the University of Helsinki it's available online it's for free it's okay it has been translated so it's from University of Helsinki I just repeat because this question came also from the Q a from online okay another field of development yeah yes talk a bit more about success stories yes okay so success stories yeah yes yeah I think your success stories and use cases also to make it more tangible what do you see maybe in another field I feel good I
don't know but I think it's it's like non-compete right or you know joining forces and probably push joining forces um and and make it more aware I mean that's that's a one funny thing I guess everybody in the room roughly agrees on all of these topics but we're like What 200 and then another couple of thousand ten thousand on the video stream great everybody welcome how many million in Europe there's a lot of people which are not in the room so they need to be kind of uh integrated in this right so that's the really um and I think sharing good good stories right like taking away the fear um not competing and probably reading some books about it um you know you don't have to um don't have to go online and click through the course you know some people and that's what I meant with the maybe it's not the right for each audience maybe somebody wants to read a story about it which is not Terminator right yeah we had another idea
here in this role um I think part of the password is also a really good go-to Market strategies because I have no doubt that we're very good with Innovation and products yeah but why are the Americans so great at actually getting traction for their Innovation I think they have a really very good blueprints on how to aggressively bring Innovation to Market and gain market share and I think this is what I observe in Germany in particular is that we don't think about getting traction and buying market share aggressively enough sometimes and this is where I lack behind yeah simple and good step-by-step plan to go to market who has this blueprint do we have it no no I mean so gross Frameworks already exists they're very well known and I think we're just not used to really aggressively yeah it's a mindset thing right so it's a lot of this if the mindset I think is the hardest to change right yeah and and that's part of the mindset that's yeah so we are optimistic
but there's still something some more to do thank you for all your ideas thank you Bjorn for your great talk thank you thank you so much